The Problem
A research problem is an area of concern where there is a gap in the knowledge base needed for practice (Burns & Grove, 2011). The problem is identified clearly in the introduction section mentioned in last paragraph (p. 712). The problem is researchable as there was limited study on psychosocial wellbeing of childhood cancer survivor in New Zealand and researcher could easily collect and analyzed the data as cancer survivor are available in New Zealand. The problem is significant to nursing profession. According to Burns & Groves (2012)” the significance of research problem indicated the importance of the problem to nursing and health care and to the health of individuals, families and communities”. The researchers did not mention
…show more content…
712) and clearly identified the plan of researchers they wanted to describe self-reported psychosocial wellbeing in adolescent childhood cancer survivors aged between 12 and 18 years and to compare this with a control group of their peers. But the researchers have missed to mention the setting where the study has been conducted. According to Burns & Grove (2007, p100) the purpose of research identify the variables, population and setting of study. The study does not explicitly indicate any research questions or hypothesis for the research. However, it could be inferred from the problem statement which is given at the end of the “Introduction” section (p.712). Neither the conceptual nor the operational definitions of the variables are shared by the researchers. Terms that could be defined by the researchers include; psychosocial wellbeing, adolescent, CCS, anxiety, depression, emotional wellbeing, and behavioral difficulty. The adolescent age is used as operational variable; according to WHO adolescent age is 10-19years.
Study design
The study design is non-interventional case control study design, since it has clearly mentioned under heading of “Design” (p. 712). According to Polit and Beck (2011) case-control design is a non-experimental research design involving the comparison of a “case” (i.e., a person with the condition under scrutiny, such as childhood cancer survivor) and a matched control (a similar
…show more content…
“Procedure” and also shared in the design section. The procedure is appropriate to the study considering the inclusion criteria of the participants. However, no detail of the data collection process is given. The researchers have required two approvals from two ethical committees and ensure the protection of human rights through verbal consent. The questionnaires were with no name of the participants and codes were used during the data collection. Head phones were provided for the participants to ensure privacy and appropriate facilitation was granted. The limitation of the study is highlighted under heading of strengths and limitations of the study (p.717) and clearly explained. The use of self-reported way of data collection and the small sample size were the main limitations of the study. Furthermore, some age groups and some of the participants were excluded from the study due to some physical and cognitive inability which is considered another limitation for this study. The study could easily be replicated in other contexts. Assumptions are statements that are taken for granted or are considered through even though they have not been scientifically tested. Since assumptions influence the development and implementation of research process. Therefore, recognition of assumption by researcher is strength. (Burns and Grove, 2011).The researchers did not identify assumptions for their
The target respondents were invited to complete the questionnaire and directed them to a brief explanation of the research. If a respondent volunteered to participate they were able to read the instructions and complete the questionnaire online from any internet-connected device. Contact details of the researcher were also provided in the initial description of the form should the respondent have any enquiry regarding the questionnaire. Data were collected on 23rd December 2015 from 8 a.m. until 8 a.am 24th December 2015. The length of time for data collection was considered ideal as it allowed a sufficient amount of time for interested respondent to participate in the study.
The details of the study included literature review, purpose, method, data analysis, results, discussion, limitations, nursing implications, recommendations for future research and conclusion. The results were clearly presented. Study limitations were identified. The conclusion was based on study results. This review was of good quality.
Qualitative Critique Discussion I will be comparing and contrasting two qualitative studies: (1) an ethnographic study that examined the care and management of women experiencing early miscarriage in a hospital (Murphy & Philpin, 2010); and (2) a phenomenological study focused on the emotional needs of dying patients (Law, 2009). Ethnographers describe and interpret cultural behavior. They collect, describe, categorize, and analyze data. Their goal is to identify patterns in the behavior and thoughts of participants.
First, a brief summary of the study, including the background, objectives, methods, intervention, findings, and conclusion will be posted in an online nursing forum (INC, 2012). Next, a formal research report with all relevant information listed above, literature review, and evaluation tools used during the study will be presented to the local chapter of the American Nurses Association (ANA). The ANA can assist with disseminating the findings to other members within the organization (INC,
Discussion Board: Unit 9/Topic 1 Britton Lerch Due Date: October 17, 2015 Kaplan University MN502: Theoretical Foundations of Advanced Nursing Dr. Phelps My personal values and beliefs on nursing, health, environment, and patient care delivery is that they all affect each other. It is great that within our technology advanced society we have the ability to communicate globally and to develop theoretical works among many nursing scholars from around the globe to collaborate about the development of nursing science (Alligood, 2014). A big part of nursing involves education and transitions by guiding patients and family members with ongoing supports.
Journal Of Nursing Practice Applications & Reviews Of Research, 4(1), 6.
Consequently, the problem in the professional nursing practice, that is of interest, is the need
Nursing research is providing evidence used to support nursing practices, generate new knowledge, and promote evidenced-based nursing practice, ensure credibility of nursing profession, provide accountability for nursing practice and document effectiveness of nursing care. Nursing research also focuses on the understanding and relieving of the symptoms
INTRODUCTION: This contextual project consists of 10 concept from the block 1 study with the title “Research and Nursing Research”. The meaning of each concept will be clarified, critically analyzed and applied to social context, personal life and current professional life. The usefulness of the concept to the current world will also be explained.
Qualitative Research Appraisal Mounica Soma Texas State University Completed in partial fulfillment of the requirements for HA 5301: Healthcare Administration Research Methods October, 2015 Introduction: The article titled “Family Physicians’ Perceptions on How They Deliver Cost-Effective Care” presented a study on the effects of family physician availability on healthcare costs and outcomes. Primary care family physicians play an important role in the provision of comprehensive, integrated, accessible healthcare services that satisfy the needs of patients (WHO, 2003). A review of Starfield et al (2005) has shown that health is better in areas with more primary care physicians, people
Nursing research is an integral part of the scientific enterprise of improving the nation 's health. The growing body of nursing research provides a scientific basis for patient care and should be regularly used by the nation 's 2.5 million nurses. Most studies concern health behaviors, symptom management, and the improvement of patients ' and families ' experiences with illness, treatment, and disease prevention. Research
In the Journal of Advanced Nursing article, Whither Nursing Models? The value of nursing theory in the context of evidence-based practice and multidisciplinary health care, author Niall McCrae (2011) discussed key points related to the utilization of nursing models in modern-day clinical practice. With so many advances made since Nightingale times, some argue that evidence-based research and practice should trump the ideas of theorists before them. McCrae cited sources that illustrate a volley of opinions on the topic: are nursing theories essential or are they matters of the past? Upon evaluation of this article, it is evident to the reader that, although they can seem outdated, nursing theories cannot completely be removed from practice as
The nursing profession revolves around evidenced based practice, and even if I do not go on to do research, possessing the ability to read and review research that has been conducted will continue to develop skills which will help me identify bias, statistics, misleading information and conclusions drawn by the researchers. In so doing I can make my own determinations on the validity of the research and ask the appropriate follow up questions to seek better understanding of evidence based
The literature review gives justified information for the need of conducting the research. Apart from the introduction, there is no other information concerning the research title that could offer detailed information (Chaliha et a., 2001). Despite giving the justified information in the introduction section the paper should have had the literature review section, thus it did not follow the due steps and format of a research paper. The methodology part follows after the introduction and it discloses the methods used, the design, the people included in the study and how the data was sampled and examined. However, the reasons for choosing the design in the research were not
For this research, Quantitative study was used as it involved deduction. Hypotheses was formulated; the dependent and independent variables were identified which assisted in measurements of objectives. Data was collected by using close-ended questionnaires. 5.1 Research paradigm According to the requirements of research question, it was decided that it would be appropriate to choose the positivism approach as the philosophical assumption and research paradigm for the study.