Special education is specifically designed to provide quality instruction, support, and services to all students with disabilities to aid their unique learning needs. Since the 1970s, there has been a consistent overrepresentation of minority groups, particularly African Americans, in these special education programs (Artiles, 1994). Many academic studies in the present focus on identifying the issue of overrepresentation in special education and addressing the related factors that lead to it, but very rarely do they focus on how certain resources, like children’s books, can impact children in special education. Nelson Beats the Odds is the first children’s book of its kind created to directly reach out to help African American students diagnosed …show more content…
In the first section of the paper, I examine the overrepresentation of black disabled students in special education programs in order to discuss how race intersects with disability and how negative cultural stereotypes are reinforced. In the second section, I discuss the issues with the language used to describe disability and language has a bigger negative consequence on black disabled students than white disabled student. In the last section, I investigate the negative consequences of using an overcoming narrative to inspire students in special education. With this critique, I hope to add to the conversation of overrepresentation in disability studies by examining how a popular well-known children’s graphic novel meant to inspire minority students adds to the problem of stigmatization and overcoming disability …show more content…
The intersection of racialization and disability can be examined through a different cultural lens, besides teacher-student cultural miscommunication, that includes influences of poverty and society. Nelson Beats the Odds is a personal reflection of Sidney’s experiences as a black disabled student in special education. The tiny town of Tappahannock, Virginia, where Sidney went to school and where the context of Nelson’s story takes place, has a demographic of 48.82% African American and a poverty level 31.6% (U.S. Census Bureau, 2015). This means about half of population are black and about a third of the residents live in poverty in Tappahannock. Poverty among African Americans is an important risk factor that contributes to their diagnosis of disabilities like ADHD (Basch, 2011). The author Sidney, like Nelson, was given the label of ADHD and placed into special education until he graduated from high school (Sidney, 2015). African American students living in poverty may prioritize other things that are familiar to them, such as pop culture activities like basketball and music, instead of school as quick routes to success and opportunity outside of poverty. In the book, Nelson was described as “inattentive and disinterested in class” and
Even though I have had these disadvantages and probably many others, I am not going to let it stop me from being successful. I have made it this far so I can’t stop now. In this paper, I talked about my social location and identity, my life experiences and my privileges and disadvantages. The point of this paper is to allow me to reflect on who I am and at this point I think that I am a motivated, hardworking, young African American woman with a bright future ahead of
“If it were that easy to reroute peoples’ life path, we should be doing it all the time for everyone” (Alexander) Alexander and Entwisle considers his students as, “urban disadvantaged”. He knew that keeping track of them was going to be one of the hardest thing. By the fifth grade, the children had scattered into the city’s 105 public elementary schools. They kept track of the students by their report cards and semiannual and then yearly interviews through high schools. Alexander and Entwisle wrote over 20 articles about each findings and the students.
When it comes to poverty and education, many children face difficult situations. In the book “See you when we get there” by Gregory Michie discusses about teaching minority students who struggle with poverty, violence, and crime. He built relationships with his students, helping the urban Chicago school system. He received positive reviews. For instance, Michie described an accurate urban school experience and allowed the students to have a voice.
The video “Tale of Two Schools: Race and Education on Long Island” presents David and Owen, two African-American students with similar backgrounds and grades who attend two different high schools in separate districts that have drastically different access to resources, community support, income, etc. Wyandanch Memorial High School is located in a poor district, while South Side High School is located in Rockville Center which is a more affluent and diverse district. The effects of the districts having varying levels of access to quality resources and diversity is exemplified throughout the video with regards to the way the students interact with each other, their grades, and their careers after high school. The lack of resources of Wyandanch
In “The School of Failure”, author D. Watkins gives an address to the problem of disparities in black education. Watkins grew up in Baltimore, a city with extensive problems within the school system. We begin the story by looking at his 13 year old nephew Butta, who is currently enrolled in a Baltimore middle school. Butta spends his day in a room with about 30-35 other kids, run by a sub where they can do anything they want. He is not receiving an education, along with countless other children in Baltimore.
Structural barriers consist of such material actions as violence or segregation; contrariwise, expressive barriers are related to beliefs and stereotypes (p. 158). According to Ogbu and Simmons, the barriers affect school performance, yet the abused minorities are not helpless victims (p. 158); the story of Cedric’s success clearly proves the
As teachers we need to learn to advocate for our students and reassure our students are getting the right education that challenged, but also allows them to succeed. No child should be misrepresented because of race or color or even gender because every child should be given an equal chance to learn in the appropriate environment. “The inaccurate placement of minority students in special education programs can take various forms including overrepresentation, underrepresentation, and misidentification” (Guiberson; 2009). As we review what each of these terms mean we can see how many students can fall under these sections if not properly assessed or tested towards their strengths rather than towards a general test. First, overrepresentation is an occurrence of minority students in special education programs is greater than the school population as a whole.
Historically, certain racial groups have faced systemic discrimination in education, which has resulted in unequal access to resources and opportunities. For example, Black and Hispanic students are more likely to attend underfunded schools and they also face higher rates of disciplinary actions, such as suspensions and expulsions, which can negatively impact their academic progress and mental health. For example in “Pigeons” by Eileen Pollack she states “Pablo Rodriguez, whose parents were migrant farmers and who, in sixth grade could barely read or write or the Buck Brothers, Phil and Gregory, who seemed to get punished for no other reason than being a large and male and black”(Pollack 118). This statement shows how big of a role being born into a certain race impacts the educational opportunities a child can receive in life. As Well as the discrimination a student can face by just being a different race in the text the Buck brothers were seemingly just punished because they were and had different color skin for the rest of the students and this is seen today in school systems where students are mistreated just by how they look.
My homemade education gave me, with every additional book that I read, a little bit more sensitivity to the deafness, dumbness, and blindness that was afflicting the black race in America” (p. 196). Some people in some instances would blame the child or the way the child is brought up for the way they perform in
Jones’ short story challenges the status quo in multiple ways. The status quo during this era was African American education. Throughout the short story we learn the mother did not get an education, for example: the mother says “I can’t read it. I don’t know how to read or
Author Richard Grant describes these situations as “a problem from hell” when visiting some of the most rural and poor places in Mississippi. Education is a major obstacle that many students encounter when struggling to escape from Mississippi’s never-ending problems. As a result, the Delta has a consistently high rate of high school dropouts or failures. In addition to deficient school systems, “ The South is home to the most children living below 50% of the poverty line” which supports the idea that children living in unstable environments are enveloped with poverty (Hughes). The Delta has developed into an underprivileged community where “24% of Southern students attended school in districts in which extreme child poverty rates dipped below 5%” (Hughes).
Most of the children in Little’s AP class has a dark background. For example, coming from a childhood full violence or sexual abuse. But even that kind of obstacle shouldn’t stop you from succeeding in getting an education. Through the book, “And Still We Rise: The Trials and Triumphs of Twelve Gifted Inner-City Students” Corwin has showed the audience that no matter where you are or where you are from, you can always succeed in
Vonnie McLoyd discusses in the book Child Development that black families are more likely to face poverty in America and the effects that poverty has on those children. McLoyd states that children that have faced poverty in their lives can have “impaired socioemotional functioning” (McLoyd 311). As a result from job loss creating parental stress, parents often become
This essay seeks to examine modern day manifestations of both racism and classism within a school setting. As investigation has shown, racial, ethnic, cultural, and socioeconomic discrimination may lead to negative mental health effects. This is alarming as such discrimination continues to linger among school systems ranging from elementary aged students all the way to college aged students. This essay also evaluates several methods of diminishing racial injustices outlined by various authors. It is in the hands of our current school administrators, teachers, and lastly students, to enact real change in hopes of achieving true racial equality.
Prose Poetry Analysis The article ‘Working toward special ed inclusion, equity’ was written by Chris Henry. This article is written as an interview with Summer and Caleb, two students with special-needs. This interview took place in Kitsap Sun School District in Washington and was published March 17, 2016. In this article, it conveys a sense of hope for children with special needs that are in the public school system. The tone throughout this article is bliss and optimism for how the future of special-needs students within the classroom will improve.