Parfit's Theory Of Argumentative
Introduction It seems conceivable for an individual to go through “fission”. Maybe half of an individual’s brain can be kept alive and put in one body, and the other half of an individual’s brain kept alive and put in another body. Parfit envisions this happening to him, and wonders critically about what will happen to him. He proposes three possibilities: he does not survive; he survives as one of the two individuals; and he survives as both “in that he has two bodies and a mind that is divided” (Loux 375). Parfit thinks that each of these three possibilities should be rejected. Moreover, he wants to refute that for any question concerning personal identity in any case, there must be an answer that is true (Loux 375). He argues that if all the possible answers are unbelievable, then it is difficult to decide which of them is true, and difficult to even keep the belief that one of the answers must be true (Loux 375). He continues saying that if individuals do away with this belief, as he thinks it should be, then these problems will disappear (Loux 375). Parfit’s main use of fission argument is to inspire the claim that identity of an individual does not matter in survival.
Arguments
Parfit’s fission argument emphasizes the hardship of deciding whether a thought experiment is acceptable or not. The argument assumes the possibility of brain bisection or commissurotomy, that is, the puncturing of the corpus callosum, that is, the removal of the cerebral cortex surgically of
Lewis And Clark Argumentative Analysis
180 Words | 1 PagesAfter much debate, America finally offered $15 million for the land and France gladly accepted. April 30, 1803 the treaty was written making Louisiana officially American land. Some people however, were upset with the buy. They had believed that the new land would take all the attention and the older eastern land would get forgotten.
Summary Of Toulmin Model Of Argumentation By Christopher M. Fairman
710 Words | 3 PagesAccording to the Toulmin Model of Argumentation, Christopher M. Fairman has constructed a strong persuasive piece on the case against banning the word retard. The components of the Toulmin Model of Argumentation that will be evaluated to determine the degree to which the argument was successful are the claim, data, warrant, and backing. To begin a synopsis will be provided about the article. Fairman’s main argument of the article is that the word retard should not be banned due to the many negative repercussions of the action. He starts the article stating he would not be making the pledge at www.r-word.org to eliminate the word from his everyday speech.
The Great Spirit Argumentative Analysis
277 Words | 2 PagesDriven by the belief that space was bequeathed to them, the Native Americans feel justified in defending their land against the growing encroachment of the white man as the American landscape unfolds. Their motive is the premise that a higher authority has granted them the right to the space, and that the Great Spirit has created the landscape exclusively for them. Fueled by the formation of conflict over land, the Great Ottawa Chief, Pontiac, in his speech at Detroit, seeks to persuade the tribes, including the Ottawa, Huron, and Pottawatomi to agree to resistance. Invoking the words of the Delaware prophet, Neolin, Pontiac recounts the vision which he believes justifies resistance. Neolin urges the tribes to sever all relations to the customs
Into The Wild Argumentative Essay
462 Words | 2 PagesIn life some feel the need to prove something to others. That they are better, stronger, or even more intelligent. Whatever the case may be people will go through extreme measures to prove themselves. But who do we really need to prove anything to? Is it our parents?
Webster's Essay On Property Vs Freedom
132 Words | 1 PagesWebster states that equal land distribution is more important to freedom, than free speech, trial by jury, or other rights, because “wherever we cast our eyes, we see this truth, that property is the basis of power; and this, being established as a cardinal point, directs us to the means of preserving our freedom.” (111) With this statement, Webster presents the people with the idea, that free speech, trial by jury, and other rights does not present the same significance of power or freedom, that owning property does. Therefore, people should be fighting for laws, which abolish the right to inherit land, rather than the right to speak freely. Once one accumulates enough land, they hold the power to freely express the rights, which are referred
Rogerian Argumentative Analysis
561 Words | 3 PagesBeatty understands the way the world works in retrospect to the events leading up to the current situation of their government. As a fireman you must know what you are doing and how it benefits your society. Beatty explains the reason that books are banned to Montag, and doing so helps us understand the most important factor in the story. You must not offend anyone whatsoever. To maintain peace you must cease from reading or writing anything that could slightly be taken out of context.
Analysis Of Neal Shusterman's Unwind
982 Words | 4 PagesAn example of the negative mental side effects of receiving a transplant would be best shown in the case of Cyrus Finch, who received a complete temporal lobe (Shusterman 126) which deals with emotional association (Smith 21). This leads him to steal without reason and causes him to feel things that he himself should not feel (Shusterman 138-139). In cases like his, the person’s issues highly resemble a new type of dissociative identity disorder, formerly known as multiple personality disorder, where a person’s personality seems to split into two distinct personas (“Dissociative Identity Disorder”). Even without receiving a brain piece, the people who receive transplants are still faced with the life of the unwound teen. This is made apparent when the Admiral gathers all who were given parts from Harlan Dunfee.
Descartes Sixth Meditation Analysis
1919 Words | 8 PagesIn the sixth meditation, Descartes postulates that there exists a fundamental difference in the natures of both mind and body which necessitates that they be considered as separate and distinct entities, rather than one stemming from the other or vice versa. This essay will endeavour to provide a critical objection to Descartes’ conception of the nature of mind and body and will then further commit to elucidating a suitably Cartesian-esque response to the same objection. (Descartes,1641) In the sixth meditation Descartes approaches this point of dualism between mind and matter, which would become a famous axiom in his body of philosophical work, in numerous ways. To wit Descartes postulates that he has clear and distinct perceptions of both
Summary Of Steven M. Cahn's Introduction And First Chapter On Argument And Reasoning
1100 Words | 5 PagesAnalyze Steven M. Cahn’s introduction and first chapter on Argument and Reasoning. (p 9-20). With other videos and articles assigned this term, what is Philosophy? How does reason help when asking questions? Philosophy originated in Greece and literally means the love of wisdom in the Greek language.
Phineas Gage Essay
1000 Words | 4 PagesThe case of Phineas Gage was a phenomenon which lead to a surge in research on the PFC and its functions. O’Driscoll and Leach (1998) published an article called ‘No longer Gage’ which reported Gage’s personality change after his prefrontal region was damaged by an iron pole being driven through his brain. They noted that his fellow co-workers, who previously thought highly of him, described him after the accident as ‘fitful,
Argumentative Essay On Lobotomy
1658 Words | 7 PagesDuring the twentieth- century, lobotomy became a popular procedure performed on patients with neurosis such as schizophrenia, bi-polar mood disorder, personality disorder, etc. Many scientists, especially at the time, argued that poking holes through parts of the brain and swishing parts around helps make patients more calm and cooperative. I predict that lobotomy had no benefits for the patient but rather in a dissociative state to appear calm. By understanding the history of lobotomy, patients' experience and stories, and alternatives we can grasp a better view in how lobotomy was unethical and ineffective. Lobotomy has evolved from various techniques, patients, countries, and psychosurgeons.
Summary: A Dialogue On Personal Identity And Immortality
773 Words | 4 PagesIn “A Dialogue on Personal Identity and Immortality”, Gretchen Weirob and Sam Miller conduct a philosophical debate about the possibility of a continued existence after death. Weirob argues that she herself cannot exist after death because her identity is composed of her body, rationality, and consciousness. In Derek Parfit’s “Personal Identity” he ponders how the concept of identity works, and how the true nature of our identity affects some of the most important questions we have about our existence. I believe that Velleman did a better job of exploring the idea of identity than Weirob did.
The Cask Of Amontillado Argumentative Essay
672 Words | 3 PagesThe Cask of Amontillado Argumentative Essay Edgar Allen Poe is a famous writer who is well-known for his short stories. The Cask of Amontillado is one of Poe’s short stories which is about two men, Montresor and Fortunato. Fortunato did something to Montresor, the act is unknown, but it angered Montresor badly enough to make him feel the need to seek revenge. The story portrays Montresor’s long, drawn out plan to kill Fortunato. In the story, it is clear that he was set on killing Fortunato, because of his actions and emotions shown toward Fortunato.
Derek Parfit's Theory Of Personal Identity
1354 Words | 6 PagesEach hemisphere of the man’s brain is then separately transplanted into the two waiting bodies. The aim of this case for Parfit is to establish whether or not the man survives. It has been proven
Today's Lesson Argumentative Analysis
980 Words | 4 PagesThe rivalry between students who believe they should be able to use their cell phones in class and teachers who believe them to be disrespectful has caused a ripple effect that now bleeds through many classrooms roaring its controversial head. And here we are stuck in an ongoing battle seldom won by students. The position that students should not be able to misuse their cell phones in a classroom setting is one held by the author of “Today 's Lesson: Life in the Classroom Before Cellphones” Louise Katz, who believes that “those halcyon days” were over (Katz). Likewise, Zoya Kahn, the author of “Why Cell Phones Do Not Belong In The Classroom” has a similar stance on the topic, Kahn states that “it is in everyone’s interest for instructors to
More about Parfit's Theory Of Argumentative
Lewis And Clark Argumentative Analysis
180 Words | 1 PagesSummary Of Toulmin Model Of Argumentation By Christopher M. Fairman
710 Words | 3 PagesThe Great Spirit Argumentative Analysis
277 Words | 2 PagesInto The Wild Argumentative Essay
462 Words | 2 PagesWebster's Essay On Property Vs Freedom
132 Words | 1 PagesRogerian Argumentative Analysis
561 Words | 3 PagesAnalysis Of Neal Shusterman's Unwind
982 Words | 4 PagesDescartes Sixth Meditation Analysis
1919 Words | 8 PagesSummary Of Steven M. Cahn's Introduction And First Chapter On Argument And Reasoning
1100 Words | 5 PagesPhineas Gage Essay
1000 Words | 4 PagesArgumentative Essay On Lobotomy
1658 Words | 7 PagesSummary: A Dialogue On Personal Identity And Immortality
773 Words | 4 PagesThe Cask Of Amontillado Argumentative Essay
672 Words | 3 PagesDerek Parfit's Theory Of Personal Identity
1354 Words | 6 PagesToday's Lesson Argumentative Analysis
980 Words | 4 Pages