Benefits of Participation Trophies Participation Trophies and Their Benefits Derek Lewis Pierpont Community and Technical College Participation Trophies and Their Benefits Participation trophies are both loved and hated. However, they are beneficial to kids in many ways. Some people do not like them because they think that they are rewarding kids for nothing. In life, structure is needed, and especially in children. It is very important that these kids get introduced to structure as soon as possible, so they can get used to have a well-rounded life. Introducing trophies is an easy way to support structure in their lives. Instead of a symbol for victory, trophies can be seen as many other symbols as well for developing structure. …show more content…
Structure is a very important and vital skill for children to be taught. A great way to introduce some structure in their lives is by giving them participation trophies for them trying and participating in whatever sport it may be. At their age, this is beneficial. Any sort of trophy will expose and introduce them to the fact that if they participate, they will be rewarded for doing so. If these kids do not learn this type of basic structure at this young age, it will be very hard for them to grasp the concept of it later in life. Without structure, it may lead to them making bad choices later in their lives and doing things that they may not see as wrong. However, if they do learn some basic structure by receiving these participation trophies, they will learn the basis of very many vital skills needed to succeed later in life. Trophies are not just symbols of winning; they are symbols for several other things also, including that participating in life will do one good (Stevens, …show more content…
However, these two things need to be established to kids’ lives as early as possible. If these things are not established, kids may not feel as if they really mean anything to any part of a team or anybody. With that being said, trophies are a great way to raise anybody’s self-esteem and self-worth. These trophies will allow these kids to believe that they were important to something or someone since these trophies are essentially symbols of appreciation and milestones. An easy way to construct self-esteem is by participating in activities, such as team sports (Dickinson, 2005). If they do not learn self-worth and self-esteem at a young age, it may come back to haunt them later in life. If kids do not have a high self-esteem, it may lead to them being unbelievably unhappy at time and sometimes, even make them depressed. Without self-worth, these kids may allow people to walk all over them during their life. Self-esteem and self-worth are extremely crucial and need to be something that every kid is introduced to in their life. Even if these trophies do not raise a kid’s self-esteem and self-worth through the roof, it is still a good starting point for them
In paragraph 4 Mr. Abate prompted, “Watching a peer receive a trophy and not receiving one yourself can be degrading”, no kid wants to see somebody be awarded a trophy but not get rewarded themselves. If a child loses interest because they never receive a trophy they might stop playing the game or stop participating in the team building activities. Parker Abate also suggested that the trophies should be given because of the time, dedication, and effort they put in to being on the team and playing on the team, “These kids dedicate time, effort and enthusiasm, and they deserve to have something tangible to make them feel that their participation was worthwhile”, it would seem unfair to have the kids give so much for
Corey Turner explains his ideas about children getting a participation trophy, as Professor Carol Dweck says in the article, Should Kids Get a Trophy For Showing Up? " My daughter rarely showed up for the soccer team. She had a terrible attitude," "At the end, she got a giant trophy and would have been devasted had she not. " Playing a sport or activity should be about having fun with the people you're with and not only about the prize; however, in this text, we can see that many people in sports undersee this connection.
A popular issue today, should kids get participation trophies for trying? One side says, “Yes they should get participation trophies”. While the other side declares “No they should not get trophies”. I believe that kids should not get the trophies. Not handing out trophies will help kids in many ways.
These trophies send the message that they don’t have to work hard, they can succeed in life even when they do not put the effort into it, and that they should look to society to judge them and tell them if they are a winner at something or losers. If these are not the
A better way to acknowledge participation other than a trophy is a certificate or a ribbon .I think when a child gains a trophy they have a better sense of accomplishment and appreciation for their hard and dedication.
Many people believe they should get participation trophies, but many people believe they should not. I think kids should get participation trophies at young ages only. Participation Trophies should be given out to younger kids for many reasons. Little kids should get participation trophies because it helps boost their self-esteem. It would help kids be kind and caring to other people and kids.
Whenever your child plays a sport, you would want them to get a trophy, but if they don't do anything and still receive a trophy, then they are being set up for failure. In the real world, you will not earn anything from doing nothing, but when your child receives a trophy for doing nothing, they are being taught that they don't need to do anything and they will still be rewarded. Firstly, participation trophies show kids that all they need to do the rest of their lives is just show up and they will do good. When kids play a sport, you want them to get a trophy for winning, not for just being there and participating.
There is a variety of reasons why participation trophies are a bad idea to kids sports. My first reason to not give them out is because the pride of winning and getting a trophy should be earned. No matter what sport or how old you are, you should be taught hard work. To get a trophy, you should work hard all season to win the
There is a lot of controversy on whether or not participation trophies send a powerful or dangerous message. The truth is they send a dangerous message. In the article “Participation Trophies Send a Dangerous Message” by Betty Berden, the argument highlights how participation trophies can send the wrong message to young athletes. Young athletes should not get a reward for doing the bare minimum.
They also promote lazy behavior and thinking simply showing up you deserve something. From about age five and on people generally start to get more competitive, giving out prizes for nothing can dull this and slow them down in life. Stated directly from the text above trophies that are given out for participation are meaningless. a prize is ment to be
While it is true that becoming a champion could be pressurizing to a younger child, wanting to be the best around at something is something that carries on even outside of sports, into life. We should be expecting kids to want to compete to win, not just to be participating. To be the winner of a sport will give you the mental mindset to be the best at other things later in life, such as being the best at their job, or being the best in school. One way that participation trophies could actually work is if each award was given to the child player with a purpose. The coach stating each players strength on the team as they hand them the award could give a powerful message to the children, showing them that they have control over their success.
Should all athletes receive a participation trophy? According to "Trophies For All," athletes are being rewarded with participation trophies. Participation trophies do not give kids the right idea about earning things in the real world. They are also not the best use of ball club's limited amount of money. Additionally, trophies can start to lose their meaning.
Children should not receive trophies just for participating. It teaches them bad life lessons and can set them up for failure in the long run. Giving children participation trophies can give them the wrong kind of praise. A player who demonstrates a bad attitude on the rare occasions that he or she shows up can be unfair to their team mates.
Participation trophies diminish the meaning of winning and produce a lack of motivation among our youth today. Though rewarding all players with a trophy is counteractive, positive reinforcement is not. Positive reinforcement is key in the process of encouraging adolescents to continue to pursue the sport they are playing. The winners should receive a trophy to endorse their hard work and accomplishment; those who lost, but kept playing, should receive a non-materialistic item such as a pizza party or ice cream to acknowledge their determination when playing the game. Without loss, there is no motive to
Every kid is a winner. No matter what the score is, the final result or whatever happened on the ice, field, pitch or court, every kid is a winner. At least, that is what participation medals are teaching young kids. When I played youth sports, which is roughly three years ago, we didn’t want to be rewarded because we signed up to play. We wanted to be rewarded after reaching a milestone; first, second or third place.