ipl-logo

Women In Plato's The Republic

1822 Words8 Pages

In Plato’s the Republic, Plato, in the voice of Socrates, discusses virtue and what the word means. In doing so he spends a good amount of the discussion describing the “ideal” city which he calls the Republic. Many of the elements of this city seem far-fetched and very theoretical, especially the ones concerning women and children. Plato advocates that women should be educated along with men and take up governmental positions. Additionally, he believes that all wives and children should be held in common. This view is controversial, to say the least. In Aristotle’s Politics, he actually brings up these topics and comments on them. In this paper, I will present some Aristotle’s thoughts on the role of women and the family seen in the Republic …show more content…

Specifically for the Guardian class, both sexes would be represented. In order to ensure a competent ruling class, men and women alike would be educated in the same ways. This is a relatively progressive idea given that it did not align with conventional Greek thought, especially since at the time Athens did not recognize women as citizens. Despite this thinking, Plato still holds the belief that women are inferior to men, saying: “it’s true that one sex is much superior to the other in pretty well everything” (455d). He then goes on to say “although many women are better than men in many things” (455d). Based on Plato’s assertions it is clear that he views women as inferior as a whole to men, but not enough to justify excluding them from governing and playing significant roles in the city. Elaborating on this Plato states “men and women are by nature the same with respect to guarding the city, except to the extent that one is weaker” (456a). It follows that women contain the qualities needed to be guardians, albeit to a lesser degree. Although one may be weaker because of their sex, it does not suffice to hold them back if they contain the qualities needed for being a guardian. With this in mind, the divisions between classes based on talents and qualities are more important than those along

Show More
Related

  • Response To Plato's Allegory Of The Cave

    290 Words  | 2 Pages

    They did not have the same opportunities that white cis men had, and they still do not. Did Plato truly think that the most privileged type of person in the world would make the best ruler for all people?

    Read More

  • Similarities Between Sparta And Athens

    1053 Words  | 5 Pages

    On the other hand, in Athens, women are useless as they are not even recognized as Demos. Demos, according to Peter J. Brand (n.d) referred as the rule of the people. To quote, “but only free, native – born males” (p. 29). In the Delian League, whose purpose

    Read More

  • Antigone Gender Roles Essay

    648 Words  | 3 Pages

    Antigone and The Importance of Gender in Ancient Greek Culture In Ancient Greece, there was a social hierarchy onto which everyone fell in one category or another. There were the free and the enslaved, the Greeks and the foreigners, the rich and the poor. Gender was an important aspect in this hierarchical society in which Sophocles’ Antigone (Sophocles) takes place. The men had their roles as the leaders of society, participating in politics, law, and the military.

    Read More

  • Comparing Homer's Iliad And The Code Of Hammurabi

    704 Words  | 3 Pages

    What is worth mentioning in Sophocles’ play is that he not only showed the weak side of women but also the strong ones. For example, Ismene is the traditional role of women in ancient Greek—coward, fear of men power and feeble. For Ismene, "we must remember we were born women, not meant to strive with men" (Antigone). She even chose to die with Antigone while hearing her sentence, for she was afraid that she would be alone, she could not be able to fight against Creon, this men-dominant society. In contrast, her sister Antigone presents the “women power”.

    Read More

  • Argumentative Essay: Why Sparta Is Better Than Athens

    458 Words  | 2 Pages

    In school both boys and girls would learn reading, writing, mathematics, basic-combat, and self-defense. Even Athenian philosophers like Plato and Socrates praised this education system. In Athens only the boys were educated for the most part, so most women went through there lives being illiterate. Other then the blatant gender equality issues the Athenian government had many problems as well. Athens may have had a democracy, but that didn't save the, from corruption.

    Read More

  • The Submissive Women In The Odyssey

    825 Words  | 4 Pages

    Always Submissive and Sexy Do you believe that the two sexes today are treated differently from one another? In the Odyssey, written by Homer, there is a constant comparison between the opposite sexes. Throughout this book, Odysseus struggles to get home to his submissive wife Penelope. He encounters challenges, one of which is beautiful tempting women who urge him to stay.

    Read More

  • The Portrayal Of Women In The Odyssey

    1401 Words  | 6 Pages

    Women are weak, helpless, and have no real purpose other than to serve men and take care of children. . . or so they were perceived in history. In the Odyssey, one can see that Homer’s portrayal of women challenges the depiction of women during that time period. Throughout the book, many women intervened in Odysseus’ journey home to Ithaca, for better or for worse. One will see Penelope, Athena, Circe, and other women impact Odysseus’ expedition home.

    Read More

  • Comparing Women In Aristophanes Lysistrata And Homer's Odyssey

    1005 Words  | 5 Pages

    In Ancient Greek Civilization, women were viewed as submissive. A man always controlled the women; that either being the Father or Husband. Women were forced to stay in the house and complete all household duties. Women were not even granted the right to attend assemblies, participate in politics, or even represent themselves in court. Having little to no overall power in your society can have a huge burden on Women but this can also fuel certain Women to strive to change the society they live in.

    Read More

  • Athens Vs Sparta Compare And Contrast

    721 Words  | 3 Pages

    Women were thought of as dependents of the father or husband. Women lived in gynaeceum: women’s quarters where they could oversee the running of the home and have very little contact with the male world (O’Pry, 2012). Spartan women, on the other hand, seem to have a bit more freedom and were able to own property. Sparta allowed for women to get educated in the same manner as the males. Sparta had a laid back culture and men were to serve in their military.

    Read More

  • Women In Ancient Greece Essay

    1413 Words  | 6 Pages

    In ancient times, there is a general sense that women were simply items and slaves to their husbands. Ancient Greece specifically has a renowned reputation of favoring men. Men possessed the dominant role in public affairs and events while most women were pressured to stay at home. Very few records extensively discuss women; the records focus mostly on men. Despite the lacking records, it is certain how ancient Greeks viewed their women and their relationships with their male counterparts.

    Read More

  • Women In Oedipus Rex

    1175 Words  | 5 Pages

    The treatment of women has been a topic all throughout history. Women would be treated as lesser beings compared to men. Back in 430 b.c when Oedipus Rex took place, women were not treated equally by men in power. An example of this is when King Laius died, Jocasta did not become the ruler. She had to wait for someone to marry her to have a new ruler.

    Read More

  • Women's Roles In Athens And The Hellenistic Era

    569 Words  | 3 Pages

    Women’s roles has changed dramatically throughout history. By looking at the lives of women, it would be possible to tell how the civilians at that specific period of time were living. In this paper, women’s lives in mainly three civilizations would be discussed, the Sparta, the Athens, and the Hellenistic era. In Sparta, women were needed to live at home, while their husbands remained in military barracks until the age thirty.

    Read More

  • Comparison Of Women In Mesopotamian Society

    1261 Words  | 6 Pages

    Different societies view women in different lights. Therefore, a woman’s position is greatly different from one society to the other. The societies in question do not necessarily have to exist at the same time. Even in the same time frame, two societies could exist, where one treat women as equals to men, and another that treats women differently than men, whether better or worse. The societies in question are: Mesopotamia, Greece, China, Rome & Europe, and this essay aims to study different societies’ viewpoints on women, and to compare and contrast them against each other.

    Read More

  • Similarities And Differences Between Ancient Greece And Rome

    852 Words  | 4 Pages

    In the Greece civilization, ladies were not given a position, they were thought to be not as much as slaves. Rome’s general public was separated into

    Read More

  • Essay On Role Of Women In Ancient Society

    981 Words  | 4 Pages

    Over generations, the role of women in society has shifted and changed immensely, improving upon many aspects of rights and values that women have. The changes occurred gave women opportunities to provide ideas, to have the same rights as men, giving women freedom, leading to many contributions of many significant and valuable events. But from current roles of women being equal to those of men, how women stood in ancient society significantly differs and contrast with ours today. Throughout history, the role and significance of women were always outweighed by the dominance and influence of men. The role of women in ancient times varied throughout, depending on the place and area in the world, in which women had different roles and impacts on their own society.

    Read More

More about Women In Plato's The Republic

Open Document