In his 1978 book Orientalism, Edward Said sheds light on an abstract theory called Orientalism. Said starts out with an introduction in which he gives some very definite examples of what Orientalism is not. Orientalism is not about westerns trying to hinder people of the east. It is also not solely about politics, as the theory is much more complicated than that. Finally, It is giant bundle of books depicting the Orient. Orientalism is then explained as the concept that western society views the world as two separate and unequal parts, the Orient (the East) and the Occident (the West), and that the east needs the west to dominate it so that the east can become better. The book then goes on to discuss that this is not a new topic, in fact, …show more content…
Due to Balfour’s position in the British government and perceived knowledge of the eastern cultures, he believed he was entitled to make assumptions about Europe, Egypt, the Occident and the Orient as a whole. What made Egypt such an eye-opening example was that it verified, exaggerated and showed the negative connotations that the West has of the East. In 1907, Evelyn Baring the 1st Earl of Cromer from England was in charge of Egypt, and he was oppressive. Also in 1907, Balfour gave Cromer his approval, and this helped Cromer to achieve a sizable retirement sum of fifty thousand pounds for his work in Egypt. Balfour claims that if Cromer had not been in Egypt, it would be worse off than it is …show more content…
The majority of my summary is explaining what Orientalism is and what its principles are. This takes up the bulk of my summary because it is the most important part of Said’s writing to understand. If one does not fully understand what Orientalism is, then they will not even be able to come close to grasping the true meaning and essence of the work. Another important aspect I decided to include in the summary was both Balfour’s and Cromer’s ideas. These two perspectives give us a firsthand example of someone whom both believed in Orientalism and who spread it to many who would take their word as fact. Said also used many of their thoughts to back up his claims, so it is necessary to include them in the summary to help provide a sense of what the structure of Said’s writing is like as well as what sources he used. I chose to leave out a lot of ideas from the last pages of the text. I found that these pages provided less overarching concepts and less main ideas. The last pages tended to delve more deeply into real life examples, and one does not need them to understand the major keys to Orientalism. The paragraph I chose to paraphrase was fairly concise already, so I included almost every aspect of it. Each sentence in the real text needed to be conveyed, which is necessary because each idea builds upon the last one. If I were to leave something out, it would seem incomplete
Wilson acknowledges that Muslims do not want anyone to redefine the initial teachings of Islam or the Qur’an and believes the students in Egypt should be taught their own history rather than someone else’s. In arguing with someone of the Middle East over this you begin to lose the empathetical understanding for their reasoning behind their defense and in turn Wilson agreed. Omar’s perception of the West had begun to change the more he engaged in Wilsons Western perception. Even Shepard had stated “Islam and the West have not only interacted and influenced each other but today there are many who are both Muslim and Western” (Shepard,
They provide the exotic “other”, a juxtaposition with the Greeks who were perceived as the model of a civilized people, a literary trope that dates back to Herodotus and can be found in other Hippocratic texts, such as The Sacred Disease. The Greek author asserts that there is a certain “…feebleness of the Asian race” resulting from their “…mental flabbiness and cowardice.” (AWP 160) This, the author claims, leads them to be less warlike and be supportive of a monarchy—characteristics that would have been anathema to a Greek and would have placed Asians as mentally inferior to the Greeks. This emphasis on the inferiority of their mental condition is a theme that has been continued in by white authors in Western medicine with its views of Africans.
“A Distant Mirror” was written by Barbara W. Tuchman. This book is nonfiction and could be used as a textbook. Tuchman was a scholar, writer, historian, journalist, and 2 time recipient of the Pulitzer Prize. She wrote first-hand as a French Nobleman. She also has written many works of history such as: “Bible and Sword”, “The Proud Tower”, “The Zimmerman Telegraph”, and many more.
These elements make up the text, and without them, there would be no point in reading because there would probably be no
In the late 1800s, Europe was scrambling to conquer vast amounts of land. Imperialism had swept the continent by storm, with many countries vying for pieces of Africa and Asia to control. From 1880 to 1900, Britain, France, Germany, and Italy fought for African possessions and by 1900, nearly the whole continent had been split and placed under European rule. There was plenty of motivation for Europeans to conquer the world, and while some supported it, others didn’t. Most people in Europe at this time held ethnocentric views toward the “uncivilized” cultures in the world.
He writes about how the immediate difference is causing these races to be on the brink of extinction, mostly because of how backward these races are. Evelyn Baring (document 7) writes about how a European is better educated than an Oriental and a better thinker as well, but they also have a bond of hard work between them. During this time the British had colonized in Egypt, like they had in many other countries. The difference was that Egypt also took this as a good thing and they began to learn from the British and try to make themselves more educated and like the
When filling out surveys or job applications, all Asians must check off the “Asian American” box regardless of national origin or place of birth, forcing a single classification on an extremely diverse group. This aggregated approach to understanding Asian American is not new, it has been present since the us versus them Occident-Orient approach that powered racism against early Asian immigrants. With the increasing presence of second and third generation Asian Americans, it is time to redefine what it means to be Asian American and to discover a new manner of framing the Asian American experience as unified yet diverse. The best approach to emphasize diversity is through stressing the national, socio-economic and gender differences within the Asian American
It might have a views others similarities but it is not this one for sure. Also, in the last part of the book, the epilogue, he had mention that “there are various estimates and several arguments about the social, cultural and
To begin, Said 's essay has quite an interesting quote that pertains to how he believes the past has been neglected. "Bride and groom wear the ill fitted nuptials of Europe, yet behind and around them are the clothes and objects of their native lands." (page 572) It is an interesting quote because it follows how most of Palestine has followed into the modern "European society" - such as: wanting to wear the white gown and tux that are shown in media. Not only does it feel as if Said 's trying to convey how modern society has ruined the values of tradition and culture, but simultaneously, it 's as if he 's angry at modern society for changing Palestine into another westernized country.
‘The Good Earth’ and the Possibility of ‘Anti-Orientalist’ Orientalism In 1931, American author Pearl S. Buck published The Good Earth, an English-language novel depicting a peasant’s life in rural China. The novel was immediately a financial and critical success; after selling millions of copies, it would win the Pulitzer Prize in 1932. Buck’s writing was praised for its evenhanded and insightful portrayal of Chinese culture and society. Retrospectively, however, many scholars have criticized it as a well-intentioned but reductionist and Orientalist treatment of China. Using Said’s conception of Orientalism as an analytical framework, this essay examines and evaluates charges of Orientalism in The Good Earth.
I decided to switch my artifact for the research paper from John Erick Dowdle’s No Escape (2015) to Francis Ford Coppola’s Apocalypse Now (1979) because I think this film is more suitable for what I want to research, which is how and why the media actively shapes Americans’ perception of historical events. I am also especially interested in the role Orientalism plays in this process. Unlike No Escape, Apocalypse Now has a lot more historical significance because it came out a few years after the Vietnam War (1955-1975) and is considered one of the most famous films about the Vietnam War. In addition to that, there is more room for debate about the significance of the film and its portrayal of Southeastern Asians.
4.0 Recommendations Future authors of Asian Texts, should read Anh Do’s autobiography and scan the words extremely carefully to understand how Do, kept the reader interested in every word he wrote. And put themselves in Do’s shoes, by
“The impression I had was that we were leaving the West and entering the East” (Bram Stoker ) This is one of the opening statements with which Stoker’s main character, Jonathan Harker, starts his description of the landscape he encounters while traveling across the continent towards Transylvania. As we come to understand later on, this remark is the first of many to segregate the West from the East in Dracula, converting rural Transylvania into “a place where the supernatural reigns supreme.” (Light, 2009: 243).
the Orient is not only adjacent to Europe; it is also the place of Europe 's greatest and richest and oldest colonies, the source of its civilization and languages, its cultural contestant, and one of its deepest and most recurring images of “the Other.” In addition, the Orient has helped to define Europe (or the West). (1) Othering is an inherent classification and differentiation of peoples or cultures. This specific definition of Othering involving Europe and the Orient can be applied to other colonial constructions in which one society defines and reifies its centrality in juxtaposition and in comparison to another, neighboring community: the relationship between North Dormer and the Mountain.
I write this not as an Egyptian citizen, but rather as an individual that is worried about his homeland country’s future. Egypt is a nation that has many communities and therefore different cultures, beliefs and opinions. These different cultures form the final Egyptian culture with its traditions and customs. The citizens of Egypt are very proud of their culture and are trying to protect it from external modifications. Nevertheless, Egypt needs to integrate itself with diverse cultures as it is in the process of developing and needs to reshape and gain specific habits in order to advance.