Pogroms In Russia
The anti-Jewish riots in Russia, termed the ‘pogroms’, were not of such organized planning and plotting. Therefore, the origin and execution of the pogroms is unclear and left unto interpretation. For a while, the pogroms were open to understanding as a conspiracy theory, in which case the Russian government plotted the pogroms. Now, more modern interpretations are of more thought-out theories, in which case there were many underlying causes imbedded and rooted into the Russian resentment and ultimate looting of the Jews. The sources used in this essay are those that changed the way we analyze the pogroms. In their own way, the historians revolutionized the study of the pogroms, transitioning it from the conventional idea of a government conspiracy, …show more content…
Avrutin notes that up until about fifty years ago, many historians were puzzled by how quickly the pogroms broke out, and how all the pogroms occurred simultaneously. It was a very commonly held idea that the government conspired against the Jews and did not come to their security or condone the pogroms at all. Therefore, it would make sense that people would instantly believe that the Pogroms must have been organized by some greater power like the Russian …show more content…
While this paper includes many books and historiography articles that have the same or very similar theses, Aronson’s history study is most in-depth. Aronson delves into the many root causes of the harsh Russian resentment towards the Jews. These sources of resentment include economic, social, political and religious conspiracies embedded into the Russian resentfulness towards the Jews. Aronson’s organization of his book is helpful to understand the flow and natural progression of the resentment, and the eventual build-up, resulting in the disastrous pogroms. The sources and evidences that Aronson used to further develop his thesis make his proposition seem nothing but logical and valid. To me, the arguments made by Aronson are most fascinating. Aronson uses sources not only derived from the government in order to attest his thesis, but also Russian citizens who were culprits of the
Annotated Bibliography On The Warsaw Ghetto Uprising
742 Words | 3 PagesMiranda Nichols Ms. Reyes English 1 6th period 10/20/14 An Annotated Bibliography http://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/jsource/Holocaust/uprising1.html "Holocaust Resistance: The Warsaw Ghetto Uprising." The Warsaw Ghetto Uprising.
Stephen Eric Bronner's Rumor About The Jews
260 Words | 2 PagesStephen Eric Bronner analyzes how the Jewish Zionist movement shape the Protocols and reflect the ideologies that are challenged between the two during the rise of the anti-Semite movement. He argues the ideas in this pamphlet are a complete forgery, yet they “helped shape the mass movements, revolutions, and wars of the twentieth century.” (4) Chapter three of his book, Rumor About the Jews, attempts to explain the effort the Protocols make against the modernity linked to political anti-Semitism supposedly taking place at the hands of Jews and their reactions to it. Antisemitic ideology, Bronner states, in contrast to the Judeophobia of earlier times, “presupposed a denial of the Jew both as a person and as a Jew.” (59)
Sierakowiak Diary Extract
1167 Words | 5 Pages“Oh, God, what's going on here? Panic, departures en masse, defeatism” (Sierakowiak). Every day, victims of the Holocaust who resided in ghettos felt the same plunge of fear and confusion as Dawid Sierakowiak. The ghettos were vile places. Hundreds of thousands packed into only a few square miles, not to mention the intemperate Nazis that oppressed Jews at every turn.
Dbq Russian Jews
536 Words | 3 PagesFrom 1880 to 1924, to escape persecution from Alexander the II’s reign and anti-Semitism, Russian Jews came to America for a chance at a new life, and for economic reasons. They were one of the biggest groups of Eastern Europeans that arrived to Ellis Island. A vast majority of the Jews settled on the East coast in places such as the Lower East Side, Boston, and Philadelphia, and other bigger cities including Chicago, Seattle and Des Moines. The jobs Russian Jews held were mostly low skilled trades, such as tailors, butcher, or even worked in the early sweatshops, stated by Epstein, “By 1900, about two hundred thousand Jews were in the garment industry on the Lower East Side.” The primary reason Russian Jews left to immigrate to America was to escape Anti-Semitism from their ruler, Czar Nicholas II, rumored to have been killed by Jews.
Under A Cruel Star Critical Analysis
1386 Words | 6 Pages“Under A Cruel Star” despite being an excellent book to read was not credible or believable as compared to Kevin McDermott’s scholarly article. Heda Kovaly depicts popular opinion under Communist dictatorship as being controlled by terror of the government. She states that popular opinion no longer comprised morals or humanity, but instead was uttered by fear and doubts of the consequences of their actions and the domination of the government. This significance of life can be explored and tested against details found in secondary sources. “Under A Cruel Star”, a primary source, provides personal experiences through the political difficulties of Jews while secondary source in Kevin McDermott’s article provides accurate facts of events that
Essay On The November Pogroms
971 Words | 4 PagesA strategy the Nazis used to oppress, isolate, and control the population is strong government. In “The November Pogroms”, by Alfons Heck, Kristallnacht is a government sanctioned event to damage Jewish businesses, synagogues, and property. The author writes, “I watched open-mouthed as small troops of SA and SS men jumped off trucks on the market place, fanned out in several directions,
Holocaust Informative Essay
1386 Words | 6 PagesEveryone who has learned about World War II should know about the Holocaust. The Holocaust was during the same period of World War II. “What is it called the Holocaust?” you may ask. The Holocaust originates from the Greek language and means “completely burnt offering to God.”
Holocaust Bystanders Essay
1272 Words | 6 PagesIntroduction: During the Holocaust, many people suffered from the despicable actions of others. These actions were influenced by hatred, intolerance, and anti-semitic views of people. The result of such actions were the deaths of millions during the Holocaust, a devastating genocide aimed to eliminate Jews. In this tragic event, people, both initiators and bystanders, played major roles that allowed the Holocaust to continue. Bystanders during this dreadful disaster did not stand up against the Nazis and their collaborators.
History Of Historiography Of The Holocaust Essay
894 Words | 4 PagesHistoriography of the Holocaust Historiography essentially is “the history of history”. It looks into what historians have said about a given historically relevant event or topic, how their interpretations have changed over time and where, what and why are the disagreements between the historians. This paper tries to look into these aspects for the topic the Holocaust and explain how knowledge of the historiography of any given event is important in understanding the event itself. The Intentionalist historians like Lucy Dawidowicz see Hitler as a strong leader believe that the Holocaust was something that Hitler had planned for years Structuralist perspective Keywords Holocaust; Hitler; Jews; Intentionalism; Structuralism; Revisionism; Holocaust Denial THE HOLOCAUST
Dehumanization Quotes In Night
714 Words | 3 PagesIn Night one of the ways that the Jews were dehumanized was by abuse. There were beatings, “I never felt anything except the lashes of the whip... Only the first really hurt.” (Wiesel, 57) “They were forced to dig huge trenches. When they had finished their work, the men from the Gestapo began theirs.
Group Conformity In The Holocaust
1471 Words | 6 PagesMany Germans, during WWII had started to take on the ideology of Hitler – that Jewish citizens in Germany were the cause of their poverty and misfortune. Of course, many knew that this was merely a form of scapegoating, and although they disagreed with the majority of Germany’s citizens, many would not speak up for fear of isolation (Boone,
Anti-Semitism In The Holocaust
1400 Words | 6 PagesThe Holocaust is a shining example of Anti-Semitism at its best and it was no secret that the Nazis tried to wipe out the Jews from Europe but the question is why did the Nazis persecute the Jews and how did they try to do it. This essay will show how the momentum, from a negative idea about a group of people to a genocide resulting in the murder of 6 million Jews, is carried from the beginning of the 19th Century, with pseudo-scientific racial theories, throught the 20th century in the forms of applied social darwinism and eugenics(the display of the T4 programme), Nazi ideas regarding the Jews and how discrimination increased in the form of the Nuremberg Laws , Kristallnacht, and last but not least, The Final Solution. Spanning throughout the 19th century, racial theories were seen. Pseudo-Scientific theories such as Craniometry,where the size of one’s skull determines one’s characteristics or could justifies one’s race( this theory was used first by Peter Camper and then Samuel Morton), Karl Vogt’s theory of the Negro race being related to apes and of how Caucasian race is a separate species to the Negro race, Arthur de Gobineau’s theory of how miscegenation(mixing or interbreeding of different races) would lead to the fall of civilisation.
Summary Of Ordinary Men By Christopher Browning
1458 Words | 6 PagesUnderstanding the psychological motivations of the perpetrators of the Holocaust is a daunting task for historians and one that has been argued over for decades. One of the most important considerations when considering this questions is that of what sources to use and how one should interpret them. While a variety of sources may be available to study the Holocaust, all of them are not appropriate or helpful in attempting to understand perpetrators. For those sources that are used for this purpose, it is important to evaluate them and acknowledge possible moderator variables that might impact interpretation. The diary of Felix Landau is quite a different source from those used for Christopher Browning’s Ordinary Men, and these sources, and
Essay On Jewish Resistance
900 Words | 4 Pages________________ ____ _________________ _________________ _________________ _________________ Working Title : Jewish Resistance: When Arms Go Up & Flags Come Down “Between 5 & 6 million Jews-out of the Jewish population of 9 million living in Europe-were killed during the holocaust.” This quote, derived and utilized in this paper from a website that is most focused upon history and its historical background and contents. The Holocaust was the mass/systematic extermination of a specific race or group of people, places, or things.
Was The Russian Revolution Inevitable Essay
716 Words | 3 PagesTHE RUSSIAN REVOLUTION ___________________________ 1. How could the Russian Revolution have been avoided? What factors could have been changed that might have stemmed the call for revolution? Or, was the Russian Revolution inevitable? Why?
More about Pogroms In Russia
Annotated Bibliography On The Warsaw Ghetto Uprising
742 Words | 3 PagesStephen Eric Bronner's Rumor About The Jews
260 Words | 2 PagesSierakowiak Diary Extract
1167 Words | 5 PagesDbq Russian Jews
536 Words | 3 PagesUnder A Cruel Star Critical Analysis
1386 Words | 6 PagesEssay On The November Pogroms
971 Words | 4 PagesHolocaust Informative Essay
1386 Words | 6 PagesHolocaust Bystanders Essay
1272 Words | 6 PagesHistory Of Historiography Of The Holocaust Essay
894 Words | 4 PagesDehumanization Quotes In Night
714 Words | 3 PagesGroup Conformity In The Holocaust
1471 Words | 6 PagesAnti-Semitism In The Holocaust
1400 Words | 6 PagesSummary Of Ordinary Men By Christopher Browning
1458 Words | 6 PagesEssay On Jewish Resistance
900 Words | 4 PagesWas The Russian Revolution Inevitable Essay
716 Words | 3 Pages