Canada and China have distinct economic and political systems that shape their respective societies in different ways. These systems dictate the level of government involvement, the freedom of enterprise and diversity of opinions in the country, so they have a substantial effect on areas such as education, wealth distribution, and the governments’ approach to resolve current issues. China operates under a communist political system with a mixed economy that leans towards a command economy. The Chinese Communist Party (CCP) holds complete control over the political system in China, and other political parties are denied. The CCP owns and controls production and resource allocation, while allowing a certain amount of corporate freedom and private …show more content…
The Chinese economy is heavily state-controlled, with the government playing a major role in directing investment and sometimes controlling corporate giants. Starting in 2008, China enacted its Anti-Monopoly Law, which provides a guideline for regulating dominant firms and preventing anti-competitive behaviour (Huld, 2022). Ironically, the inequality has been further fueled by state-owned enterprises and state-controlled corporations. As a result, in the recent decade, the top 1% of households in China control nearly one-third of the country's wealth, while the bottom 25% of households hold just 1% of the wealth (Xie & Jin, 2015). This does not fit with the broad definition of a command economy, where most resources are publicly owned and people have more equal income. In Canada, the wealth distribution is more balanced, where they have a larger middle class and a smaller number of people in poverty. Statistics Canada reports that in 2016, the wealthiest 20% of families in Canada possessed 63.7% of the country's total net worth, while the least wealthy 20% of families held just 1.1% (Statistics Canada, 2022). The Gini Coefficient is a measure of income inequality in a region, ranging from 0 to 1, with 1 representing a complete inequality. China’s Gini Coefficient has fluctuated around 0.38 in recent years (The World Bank, 2018), and Canada has a value …show more content…
Due to the variance between economic systems, the Chinese and Canadian governments play different roles and take different methods to cope with it. The centrally planned economy in China allows the government to play an active role in managing the economy and have more control over the supply chain. Therefore, they can take coordinated action more quickly according to the ever-changing situations. On the other hand, Canada’s economy is more market-driven. They let the “invisible hand” naturally regulate the market, and it may respond to the current situation more slowly since it is a natural process without human intervention. But the Canadian government still takes action when it is needed. For instance, they increased the diversification of sub-products to hedge against damage from supply chain issues (Boileau & Sydor, 2021). In short, countries that have mixed economies but with different tendencies to command or market economies have different levels of government intervention when facing a
100,000 manufacturing jobs were lost to the FTA in the early 90’s,a burden which fell disproportionately onto poor working class women, centred mostly in Quebec. Restructuring meant a relocation of jobs from native industry towards a growing service economy, with the frictional unemployment of this time increasing poverty rates by 17.8% by 1995. Fiscal policy during the Mulroney years mirrored the United States in its gradual reduction on social spending and the continuing transfer of taxation from business income to the incomes of Canadians. Fearful that higher regulation would result in further capital flight, the Mulroney conservatives found capitulation an easier pill to swallow. Canada’s trade relationship with the United States understandably increased, rising to 73.5% of total export in 1989 to 80.8% a decade later.
Compared to the United States, Canada has something like seven or eight times more crown corporations. Which is insane how much the government controls competition. If you want evidence of all of the crown corporations that Canada has compared to the United States, just search up how many the United States has then search up the same for Canada and you will see the difference instantly. Examples of just the well known in Canada are CBC, Bank of Canada, Canada Post, Royal Canadian Mint and that is just skimming the top of the most known. With Canada having seven or eight times more crown corporations, then the United States they have more power over resources than the citizens - which is the majority of the country.
Hon. George Brown explained how the union of Canada “will throw down the barriers of trade and give [them] the control of a market of four millions of people”. The example of United States success in trading was an influence in instilling this idea. If trade became a simple endeavor material would be transported across the nation at greater rates allowing for substantial
From 1929 to 1945, Canada looked to become trustworthy trading partners with the United States. A way in which Canada strengthened its trade with the United States was by branching out from just being trading partners with Britain. Even though Britain was Canada’s primary trading partner, it was not until the 1920’s that Canada began to trade with the United States. A decrease in tariffs from 1913 to 1930, and zero or near-zero tariffs imposed by the U.S Revenue Act of 1913, allowed Canadian exporters to trade freely with the United States. As a result, Canadian exports to the United States rose from $104 million in 1911 to $315 million in 1930.
In Elizabeth Economy’s monograph, the Third Revolution: Xi Jinping and the New Chinese state, the topic of a new modern china is discussed and breaks down how President Xi Jinping wishes to steer the country into the future. Elizabeth Economy explains President Xi Jinping’s desire to constitute a Third Revolution and how there will be a “New Chinese State.” To start, one must first understand China’s past to learn what a “New Chinese” State would look like. During the time of Mao Zedong, China attempted to become a player on the World scale.
It is a good sign for foreign companies to enter into Canadian market by establishing new branches or cooperating with existing companies in Canada. The economic freedom is above world average and region average, however, the score is declining in the recent two years (see Figure 1). It may imply that the market would
Throughout the 20th century and into the present time, the government has played an active role in stabilizing the economy through a range of policies and actions. From the Great Depression and the New Deal policies to the financial crisis of 2008, the government has intervened in the economy in various ways to prevent economic instability and promote growth. While these interventions have often been necessary, they have also been controversial, with some arguing that they interfere with free markets and hinder economic progress. Based on the analysis of government intervention in the economy throughout the 20th century to the present time, it is clear that while government actions have been necessary to prevent economic instability and promote
Throughout the nineteenth and twentieth centuries the Canadian government developed several racist and discriminatory policies to contest the settlement of Chinese immigrants in Canada. Following the government’s reaction to Chinese immigrants, a Canadian moral panic evolved. In particular, Chinese immigrants faced extreme prejudice socially, physically, and morally. The first Canadian Prime Minister, John A. MacDonald (1867–1873, 1878–1891) had a vision for the ideal “white” European dominant Canada, and his successors continued with this Aryan vision.
China is considered a ‘one party’ state. There is really no formal political opposition in China to challenge the CPC, nor the CPC’s power kept in check by the liberal democratic principles of the separation of powers and rule of law. While the CPC is an authoritarian organisation that does not tolerate opposition or challenges to its rule, within the party itself, there does not seem to be a spectrum of diverse political
Throughout Canadian history, free trade in particular has changed Canada and it’s economy for the better. The free trade agreement (FTA) signed in 1989, assisted Canada’s economy in many ways, such as removing most of the tariffs on trade goods, increasing trade with the USA, and leading the way to the creation and signing of the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA). All of these boosted Canada’s economy and strengthened the bonds with new and old trade partners. After this agreement was established, it becomes clear very quickly that the FTA was exactly what Canada needed. As well as opened new doors to opportunities for Canada.
Elections in China are based on a hierarchical electoral system, meaning the leader is directly elected from a group of representatives, who are elected by the voters of the locals in that area; much similar like how Australians can vote in electorate. The difference is that the Chinese government is a single party state, creating a single centralized focus of power within the country. This power is granted to the Paramount Leader, who is the highest leader of the party and the state. Due to so much power concentrated in a small group of people, there are often reports of corrupt high officials from within the party. The Transparency International had ranked Australia in the top 10 countries with low levels of corruption and China 80th
Canada is known for its vast forests, prairies, and freshwater lakes, while China has vast deserts and mountain ranges. In my opinion, both countries need to take steps to protect their natural resources from the negative impacts of industrialization and
In this day and age, today’s countries and their cultures are immensely different and unique in comparison to each other. China and Canada are no exceptions. The Chinese, known for their famous silk production and their Great Wall of China, hold an impressive history ranging over 5000 years. Canada on the other hand, has only been in the game for 150 years. The British colonization in 1867 had a major impact on the First Nations and has left a serious mark on their community.
The Great Depression of 1929 not only hit America severely but also devastated the Canadian economy where had the USA as a main partner of trading. This high interdependency on America brought a huge shock to Canada and her economy was replete of increasing unemployment and poverty. Two governments, here, attempted different approaches to recover the massive aftermath and these can be divided into two phases: Bennett’s government of 1930-5 and King’s of 1935-9. Although they both faced failure from Laissez-Faire, they had made different attempts in terms of unemployment, trade and economy including foreign affairs, and agriculture. Both governments here tried to reduce the unemployment by providing pubic works schemes and relief programmes.
` A key feature of capitalistic ideology is the promotion of individualism, that is, the principle that individual effort is rewarded and benefits the individual. In contrast, a key feature of socialist ideology is the promotion of the good of the collective over the individual. China has been a socialist nation since the latter half of the 20th century. Yet, the last 20 years have brought extensive economic reforms that have transformed the country into a pseudo-capitalist market economy. Has this economic transformation been mirrored by an ideological one?