The rest cure is the treatment of disease by rest and isolation in a good hygienic environment. During the early nineteenth century, women were thought, by many men, to only be able to clean the house, take care of the kids, and have babies. When a woman became depressed, she was thought to need the rest cure and after she would be better, but as we see in “
A Yellow Wallpaper” by Charlotte Perkins Gilman this is not necessarily true. Depression treated by isolation can further deteriorate the mind causing the lost of mental faculties.
The effects of isolation on both the narrator and the author both shows how the rest cure inadequately treats patients with postpartum depression (PPD). The effects of the rest treatment pushes women to borderline
…show more content…
If the brain does not have anything to occupy itself then a man or woman will go into a state of depression. Being isolated from the outside world for so long caused her brain to start hallucinating. Also, the author of the book “The Yellow Wallpaper” Charlotte Perkins Gilman stated “ I wrote the yellow wallpaper with its embellishments and additions to carry out the ideal…and sent a copy to the physician who so nearly drove me mad...it has to my knowledge saved one woman from a similar fate-so terrifying her family that they let her out into normal activity and she recovered.” A woman who had had the rest cure along with the narrator and the author has either driven them insane or to the borderline of insanity. The effects of the rest cure on many women were devastating to their health and is a unreliable treatment to treating postpartum depression.
Jane’s efforts to avoid others from looking at the hideous painting, shows how that
…show more content…
A loss of sleep will also affects one 's ability of their brain to function successfully. If you do not sleep and you look at the same thing all day for 3 months the chances for you having a stable mind are slim to none. John also goes on to say that people can
ot visit her. If she cannot see the people that she loves, then her being depressed will be more likely. The narrator goes on to say “ I wish john would take me away from here… it is so hard talking with john about my case, because he is so wise, and because he loves me so.” Women were not known to have have a voice in the 1800’s they had to do what the men said most of the time. She really has been trying to get away for her mental health, but John never lets her leave in fear that she was not well yet. John pitied his wife and whenever she told him something he would try to convince her that his way was right cause he is the doctor. John says “ why darling… our lease is up in three weeks, and I can’t see how to leave before.” When she tells
John how she feels, he basically goes around the question since “ John knows best.” John has most definitely depressed her even more then she was at the
Due to this happening, it makes getting any information from her husband impossible. Not only does she not know what John wants her to say, but also why he is even in
She is faced with helping her husband make the biggest and most final choice in his life so far. Since they have been apart for a while, separated by prison, it would be incredibly easy for her to say that he should live and give up his good name just so she can still have her husband and her kids have their father. It would be incredibly difficult for her to see John for a few minutes after a long time apart and say he can sacrifice himself for the greater good. However, she sees the situation as that: him sacrificing himself for the greater good. She is also strong enough to admit part of the blame is her own, that she has a hand in the guilt he feels about their relationship.
Doctors of the 19th century thought they were above everyone else because of their education and had a tendency to disregard the patient’s suggestions. Jacobus asserts in his work that “The hysteria that is femininity must be repressed in the interests of a masculinist psychoanalytic theory; the uncanny that is narrative must be repressed in order to sustain a realist view of fiction” (qtd. in E. Showalter 30). As the subject of male doctors’ authority, 35 years of feminist criticism had turned the interpretation of the story’s narrator into a victim of patriarchal control. In “The Yellow Wallpaper,” John says, “you really are better, dear, whether you can see it or not. I am a doctor, dear, and I know” (Gilman 236).
(Gilman 445). This impactful sentence proves to the audience that when the day for the woman to leave the room came, her sickness was now in full control of her mind and she embraced it. The personification used in the short story followed the reactions of how the ill
Jane being ignored is a reason why she has some mental issues. She feels ashamed of what she is feeling and society makes it hard for her to want to talk about this with anyone. Not being able to talk about it, causes Jane’s depression to get worse with
John had been especially proficient at diverting certain topics that which he will not speak with his wife about. When dear “John is away all day, and even some nights, when his cases are serious” (377) the narrator may not be concerned if John might take the opportunity to be away from his marriage or if he is indeed working with other patients late in the night. She just accepts her lot in life to be alone, vulnerable and totally dependent at the same
Without this scene you may think she doesn't obsess over him as she once did. This scene confirms that through it all she stills love John and wants him to come with her. Of course he turns her down, again proving John’s (better late than never)
Jane also includes that she is left alone for extended amounts of time. Even in John’s claims of caring he is constantly gone and away from the person who he needs to watch after most. Jane writes, “John is away all day, and even some nights when his cases are serious” (2). There should be no reason why John would leave her alone in the country in a house she is unnerved by when he I trying to cure her nervous depression. He seems to be contradicting
Depression and isolation caused by the misdiagnosis caused Jane to go insane. The rest treatment was a common form of cure for people with depression. It worked for some people while it did not work for some. Instead of curing the depression, it only sends the patients into further depression and isolation.
Usually to avoid anxiety cases and worry, any news from home were properly edited. Mitchell believed that secluding the patient from the family was beneficial as some cases of nervous breakdown were caused by instability in families and stress in the household. Other than boosting a patient’s health the treatment also included education where Mitchell would take the patient through philosophical trainings, logical thinking and ways of controlling emotions. This was referred as moral reeducation and it helped the patient gain patience, consolation and resignation (Bassuk
As a result, he suffered from PTSD. In the article, “Madness, Mystery, Reality and Illusion,” Liam Clarke argue that there is a connection between the way magic captures an audience and psychiatric patients, in the sense that they are transported to another world. John is trying to preserve his mind, the same way how he felt when he did magic is the way he wants to feel now. John has his illusion of being innocent and naïve about everything. His wife, Kathy Wade is missing and there is the misery of what happened to her.
Throughout the nation and our world people are suffering from this disease. Depression effects people of both genders, all ages, and any background. The history of mental illness, specifically depression were extremely helpful in today’s treatment and diagnosis. We know that all individuals are different and because of this, we can assume that each case of mental illness, more specifically depression, is unique in its own way as well. One treatment that is very effective for one person may not be equally as effective in a similar case simply because of the differences in patients.
Who in her quest to replace the wife of the man she had an affair with (John
So, despite not leaving John due to her limited options, that action, displayed her opposition to her husband’s
As we come to discover John, controls the narrator and she, with her benevolence and love that she has for John trusts whatever he advises her. All through the start of the story, it is obvious that the narrator wishes to talk, however, something holds her back and this consumes her since she has nobody to converse with. The narrator says, "It is so hard to talk with John about my case, because he is so wise, and because he loves me so". The incongruity of this quote and of the entire story is that this is a marriage, but the relationship amongst John and the narrator are