The Power Dynamics In And China Has Hands By T. Tsiang
In any given social situation or relationship, a power dynamic exists. When creating an authentic narrative, it is crucial that those power dynamics exist within the text. However, since each person holds with them a multitude of identities, power dynamics are not necessarily clear-cut or based on simple dichotomies. In H.T. Tsiang’s novel And China Has Hands, the protagonist—Wong Wan-Lee—is faced with the task of understanding how power dynamics function, and struggles to find spaces and moments in which he has agency and power. While traditional gender politics would make it seems as though Wong Wan-Lee has more power and sense of control over Pearl Chang in And China Has Hands, the deliberate presence of intersectionality complicates the …show more content…
Even in these moments when Wan-Lee tries to take control of Pearl Chang, she still manages to keep her agency in these situations. For example, in this same moment when Wan-Lee dehumanizes Pearl Chang to a piece of food by violently grabbing her breasts, Pearl Chang switches to the dominant role in their relationship by stopping the assault and walking away. Pearl Chang not only takes control of her own body in this moment and has the agency to walk away; she also takes a moment to confront Wan-Lee Directly. She moves away from him and yells “This is not a tennis ball; this is my breast! This is not a Lee-Chee nut; this is my nipple! You hurt me! I thought you were born in China, the land of Confucius, Lao-Tze and Buddha. But you are as tough as any white brat I ever met when I was South!” (106). In this single moment, Pearl Chang subverts the power dynamic in two ways. First, she reclaims control of her body, and also humanizes herself in a way that confronts his seeing her body as an object and as food. Second, she also confronts the idea that he is better than her because he has a “more pure” Chinese identity. In comparing his actions to the actions of a southern brat, she makes the savageness of his actions more clear (connecting back to that first moment when they were drinking tea) and addresses the fact that his is not innately more refined because he has a “more authentic” Chinese experience. Thus, in this single moment, Pearl Chang is able to subvert Wan-Lee’s ideas of the power dynamic of their relationship by reclaiming agency over her own body, and by addressing the problematic beliefs that create the foundation of his
Bigotry In Stacey Lee's Outrun The Moon
970 Words | 4 PagesThey were not wanted in “white stores”, “white schools”, or even “white towns”, and they were tormented daily because, simply, they were not like the vast majority of people that lived in that area. Most of the Chinese who lived in Chinatown were destined to wash laundry, plant gardens, and chop wood because it was nearly impossible for them to get an education higher than the eighth grade. Stacey Lee, a Chinese-American author, brings all of these cultural issues to life in her novel Outrun the Moon. Her main character, Mercy Wong, faces bigotry every day. Despite this, she is unwavering in her quest to break through the barriers that have been placed in order to get a higher level of education and “become useful”.
Suyuan Vs Jing-Mei
190 Words | 1 PagesAccording to Suyuan, if one exemplifies the flawless daughter, cruel, callous complications are competently overcome. Because talent symbolizes each individual’s charisma, Suyuan decides to schedule piano lessons for Jing-mei. Jing-mei refuses to play the piano because she wants to represent herself in her own way. “ ‘You want me to be someone that I’m not!’ I sobbed.
Summary Of Maxine Hong Kingston's The Woman Warrior
906 Words | 4 PagesIn Maxine Hong Kingston’s nonfictional novel, The Woman Warrior, Kingston tells five different stories separated in chapters. Kingston wanted to express to her readers what it was like living a life as a Chinese-American. Not only did she have difficulties along the way but she also had to manage fitting in. She is constantly being put on the spot due to her parent’s Chinese traditions and her American lifestyle.
Essay On Ji-Li Jiang's 'Red Scarf Girl'
1081 Words | 5 Pages“Her actions remind me that, even under unbearable circumstances, one can still believe in justice,” in David Henry Hwang’s foreword, in Ji-Li Jiang’s memoir Red Scarf Girl, commemorated even during the Great Proletarian Cultural Revolution anyone can overcome adversity (9). Ji-Li Jiang was a young teenager at the beginning of the Cultural Revolution, and living through a very political time in China’s history made Ji-Li into the person she is today. Ji-Li’s intelligence, her choices, and family devotion made her into the headstrong and successful person she is today. Even when Ji-li thought she was unintelligent, others saw she was wise. There were many moments when Ji-Li was reminded she was very smart.
Pico Iyer's Where Worlds Collide
1272 Words | 6 PagesIn opposition to Waverly, the character Jing-Mei has experienced repeated rejection and failure in her attempt to become a prodigy and finally comes to the decision that“I could only be me,” and any attempt at developing new skills or talents was futile (Tan, 24). So, it is because of her past experiences of continuous defeat that she bases her perception of her self worth and capabilities. While in some cases, one may respond in the complete opposition of Jing-Mei, continuing to persevere in spite of their failures, they still draw on the previous experiences they’ve had, utilizing them as an inspiration or a learning
S. Buck's The Good Earth And The Possibility Of Anti-Orientalism
1841 Words | 8 PagesThe novel’s fictional version of China is sometimes an unfairly bleak portrayal of the country, and its most shocking scenes cohere with false Orientalist narratives of Western imperialism and Asian inferiority. However, for an American author, Buck writes with unique authority; few Westerners in her era could match her breadth of knowledge about China, and even fewer could match her dedication to the advancement of cultural empathy with China. Despite the inescapable influences of dominant Orientalist narratives, Buck was able to craft a socially truthful, yet relatable text for Western audiences. Looking back at the outsize impact of The Good Earth, it becomes clear that it defies conventional definitions of Orientalism. Rather than assigning the ‘Orientalist’ label as a veiled accusation of racism and ignorance, scholars should instead recognize that—with the appropriate author intentionality and real-world impact—certain Orientalist works could be culturally acceptable, if not valuable
Boxer And Saints Quotes
516 Words | 3 PagesChoosing between what is moral and choosing what is right for the nation can be two quite different decisions. In the graphic novels, Boxer and Saints, Gene Luen Yang writes and illustrates the experiences that two different Chinese people have during the Boxer’s rebellion. In the Boxer’s novel, Bao is a leader of the Big Sword Society that will lead them to rebel against the foreigners who he believes is making China evil. Through the perspective of Bao, Gene Luen Yang questions should one be willing to put aside personal autonomy to defend their national identity.
Summary Of Lives Of The Nuns By Sh Chong
541 Words | 3 PagesShe rebels against her parents rules/wishes and pursues her life in religion. She asks her father “why must I submit three times before I am considered a woman of propriety?” stating a question why women are supposed to follow orders from men and not allowed to complain or go against (Baochang). Xu Chong pursues her journey to practice Buddhism against her family's will. Then Xu Chong seeks advice from the Buddhist magician monk who told him to return home and fast for three days.
Two Kinds By Amy Tan
421 Words | 2 Pages" Mama is saying this because she knows that Jin-Mei isn't trying. Also life for her in china must've been hard. The conflict is reaching it’s climax when mama slapped Jing-Mei. “My mother slapped me.
Gene Luen Yang's Boxers Chapter Summary
600 Words | 3 PagesGene Luen Yang offers a humanistic perspective on western imperialism in China during the late nineteenth century to early twentieth century in his graphic novel Boxers, a tragic narrative about Chinese grassroots resistance against foreign occupation in which an armed revolution ultimately fails. The novel focuses on religious identity, and cultural connections in the face of invasion. Boxers highlights the negative effects of imperialism through clashes between different religions, ideologies and power structures. Therefore, the criticism of western imperialism presented in Boxers could support a world systems theory approach to international relations because it shows to exploitation through westernization and the squandering of cultural
Internal Conflicts In Amy Tan's The Joy Luck
224 Words | 1 PagesBoth Jing-mei and her mother faces each form of conflict and they are revealed throughout the story. Jing-mei and her mother have some very good examples of internal conflicts. It was one part of the story when Jing-mei feels sad that she couldn’t live up to be that person that her mother wants her to be. It is showing that Jing-mei feels bad. She’s not living up to the dream that her mother thought up for
Two Kinds Character Analysis
937 Words | 4 PagesHowever, this determination sometimes appears to be obsessive to the point of running her daughter’s life for her. Regardless, she is only trying to help, as she encourages Jing Mei by asserting “‘You can be best anything.’” (1). Because of this, it suggests that although she is very harsh on her daughter at times, it is only to make sure that Jing Mei can use her full potential and not end up losing everything like her
Battle Hymn Of The Tiger Mother Analysis
1757 Words | 8 PagesThis method of parenting is very close to dictatorships in the past or to oppressive parties, in how they impose their will upon others. This book may have been a last ditch attempt to resurrect the hands on, suffocating, coercive, and never ending demands style of parenting that some Chinese parents (not all) have done at some point in time” (Psychology Today, Gray). This source also give evidence on statistics on the Chinese American reviewers that they were two-fold more likely to strongly dislike or dislike the book than were other reviewers. 1 star: 40.5% vs. 20.9%, 2 stars: 11.9% vs. 5.8%, 3 stars: 2.4% vs. 11.7%, 4 stars: 9.5% vs. 15.0%, 5 stars: 35.7% vs. 46.6%. Polarized reactions to the book are reflected in these data, for both the Chinese and non-Chinese reviewers.
Mao Era Gender
1474 Words | 6 PagesThe burgeoning rebellion of a young girl in northeast China. A girl’s struggles to obtain for herself the education her parents inspired her to attain. An exploration of gender and identity as experienced by two sisters…… These memories are crafted with honesty. During the Cultural Revolution, women made substantial gains.
Chinese Postmodernism Analysis
1811 Words | 8 PagesChinese identity is defined by a past of injured and scars, this is up to now the most evident message lingering behind whatever narrative style post-Tiananmen has produced. The experience of loneliness that all the protagonists suffer cannot be read as personal experience or the vicissitudes of a family saga but as a national allegory and the matrix of China as whole. There is a deep feeling of desolation for a plot that, save few occasions, offers details of a life of humiliation and hardship, describes inevitable loss, condemns its heroes to a bitter and solitary ending. Our guess is that the anti-Confucianism and anti-intellectualism of the past decades have emptied China of any residual of humanism, the roots-seeking experience acknowledges that the roots are dry, the reality they have to face is chaotic but turning back is no help for its chaos again. Tradition eroded, role models come loose, fathers are cruel and mothers are missing, life remains unfulfilled stuck between man’s aspiration and the existential need to survive, and those characters discovered themselves alienated from their family, their village, the whole community and the sense of history, frozen between life and death.
More about The Power Dynamics In And China Has Hands By T. Tsiang
Bigotry In Stacey Lee's Outrun The Moon
970 Words | 4 PagesSuyuan Vs Jing-Mei
190 Words | 1 PagesSummary Of Maxine Hong Kingston's The Woman Warrior
906 Words | 4 PagesEssay On Ji-Li Jiang's 'Red Scarf Girl'
1081 Words | 5 PagesPico Iyer's Where Worlds Collide
1272 Words | 6 PagesS. Buck's The Good Earth And The Possibility Of Anti-Orientalism
1841 Words | 8 PagesBoxer And Saints Quotes
516 Words | 3 PagesSummary Of Lives Of The Nuns By Sh Chong
541 Words | 3 PagesTwo Kinds By Amy Tan
421 Words | 2 PagesGene Luen Yang's Boxers Chapter Summary
600 Words | 3 PagesInternal Conflicts In Amy Tan's The Joy Luck
224 Words | 1 PagesTwo Kinds Character Analysis
937 Words | 4 PagesBattle Hymn Of The Tiger Mother Analysis
1757 Words | 8 PagesMao Era Gender
1474 Words | 6 PagesChinese Postmodernism Analysis
1811 Words | 8 Pages