Does dysfunction of the prefrontal cortex lead to antisocial behaviour?
990
The development of the prefrontal cortex (PFC) contributes to the human capacity to modulate emotions. This ability is significant as disruption due to brain dysfunction can have harmful effects on an individual’s capability to function adaptively in society. However, the idea that the PFC has a significant role in the regulation of aggression and violence has been challenged by studies that highlight the complexity of the multiple causes of antisocial behaviour and consequences of having an impaired PFC. Yet through brain imaging, modern research have shown a relationship between dysfunction of the PFC and antisocial behaviour.
Studies have shown a link between alcoholism and cognitive deficits; one theory that explores this is the “frontal lobe hypothesis”. This is based on the idea of a “specific vulnerability of the
…show more content…
One of the causes found by Rantakallio, Laarra, Isohanni, and Moilanen (1992) is nicotine exposure to a foetus. They found that the offspring of mothers who smoked were twice as likely to have a criminal record by the age of 22, compared to the offspring of mothers who were non-smokers. This study shows “the significant link between smoking during pregnancy and later conduct disorder and violent offending” (Raine & Adrain, 2002). Furthermore, one cause of ADP is deficiency in nutrition as Neugebauer, Hoek and Susser (1999) found a causal relationship of malnutrition and antisocial behaviour during WW2. When Germany was withdrawing food from Holland pregnant women suffered severe malnutrition and their male offspring were found to have 2.5 times the rates of ADP compared to the offspring that did not suffer nutritional deficits. Both studies show that dysfunction of the PFC is not the only cause of antisocial behaviour as there appear to be a number factors
Aggression and Violent Behavior, vol. 45, pp. 51–74, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.avb.2018.05.007. Accessed 16 May
Early onset brain injuries are linked to “severe behavioral deficits and aggressive tendencies,” which can lead to “acquired sociopathy” (Meadows, 2005, p.
Individuals who score high of the PCL-R have limited range of depth feelings, meaning that psychopaths usually do not feel depressed. In fact, individuals who had suicidal tendencies tend to score lower in the “shallow affect” symptom. On the hand, PCL-R Factor 2 focused on the antisocial factor which indicates whether the individual has violated norms or laws. Some symptoms include early behavioral problems, lack of realistic goals, irresponsible, juvenile delinquency, early behavioral problems, etc. Dixon Jr may have scored higher in Factor 2 due to his juvenile delinquency record and his aggression towards the inmates during the beginning of his sentencing.
In the Life-Course Persistent Theory, it is thought that neuropsychological deficits caused during pregnancy or outside of pregnancy, combined with parental neglect or abuse creates life-long criminals. According to Moffit, the creator of the Life-Course Persistent Theory, the neuropsychological deficits cause antisocial behavior, impulsiveness, and an unruly temperament. As Buss discusses in his novel, damage to the brain caused by these neuropsychological deficits, can cause a high range of emotions such as rage and jealously. The damage to the brain can also damage the frontal lobe which determines our sense of what is right and wrong (Buss, 26). According to Moffit, the brain damage and neglect, leads the person to become a life-long criminal.
This region guides behavior, working memory, and inhibition (Barch and Sheffield 224). In psychotic disorders like schizophrenia, there is evidence of impaired activity in the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (Barch and Sheffield 224). This inability to properly regulate the activity of this region could impact decision-making, such as pursuing physician-assisted suicide. While personality disorders are consistent over time, some disorders, such as borderline personality disorder, are characterized by impulsivity (Brodeur 18). This could also make providing an accurate understanding of one’s wish more difficult (Brodeur 17).
Adrian Raine, criminologist and author of "The Anatomy of Violence: The Biological Roots of Crime," has said before, is a very important factor in criminal behaviour that affects about 75% of a person’s criminal activity. In his book, Raine explores the many evidences that lead up to biological and genetic influences on crime
The four cluster “B” personality disorders include antisocial, narcissistic, borderline, and histrionic disorders. These are also the most common of all personality disorders. Antisocial personality disorder is expressed by a continued pattern of neglect for other people’s rights, and also for violating those rights. It typically begins during childhood or as a teenager and continues into adulthood. Jeffrey Dahmer had antisocial personality disorder, he was arrested in February 1992 for multiple charges of rape and murder.
The prefrontal cortex (PFC) exhibits a key role in the working memory and has an established link to the executive functions of cognition and behaviour. Impulsive behaviour is displayed in patients that suffer lesions to the PFC, as one of the important functions is that of inhibition. Therefore there is evidence to suggest that dysfunction to the PFC leads to anti-social behaviour, which is characterised by actions which cause harm to others or disturb the environment. As the PFC is crucial for the development of moral judgement, it is thought that damage to the frontal lobes in the developmental stages (during childhood) may result in adaptive deficits which continue through to adulthood (Eslinger, Flaherty-Craig & Benton, 2004).
The development of the prefrontal cortex (PFC) contributes to the human capacity to modulate emotions. This ability is significant as disruption due to brain dysfunction can have harmful effects on an individual’s capability to function adaptively in society. However, the idea that the PFC has a significant role in the regulation of aggression and violence has been challenged by studies that highlight the complexity of the multiple causes of antisocial behaviour and consequences of dysfunction of the PFC. Yet through brain imaging, modern research have shown a relationship between dysfunction of the PFC and antisocial behaviour. Studies have shown a link between alcoholism and cognitive deficits; one theory that explores this is the “frontal
Reasons et al. , (2016) found that, “offending and victimization are a consequence of multiple risk factors,
Most crimes, they argue, are simple to commit, require no long-term planning, and provide few long-term benefits. In addition, this theory implies that individuals who were inadequately parented before the age of eight develop less self-control than individuals of approximately the same age who were raised with better parenting. Gottfredson and Hirschi argue that parents must monitor their children, recognize bad behavior, and correct this bad behavior. If self-control has not developed by ages eight to ten, they argue, it is not likely to develop. As a result, research have indicated that low levels of self-control are relevant to criminal and impulsive
Smoking increased the likelihood of abortion, premature birth, and low birth weight, whereas drinking alcohol can cause the child to have a disorder called fetal alcohol syndrome (Levay and Baldwin, 2014). This part is also correlated with one of my classes, which I will talk
Did you know that drinking not only affects your liver but also your brain, heart, pancreas, immune system, and can even cause multiple types of cancers? In today 's generation drinking has become a social aspect in society that not only adults partake in, but underage kids do as well. In spite of all the public awareness regarding the use/abuse of alcohol, we continue to hear sad stories of accidents and deaths caused by alcohol. Why is that we do not seem to understand the effects of alcohol on the human brain? Lets go over it one more time.
Unlike the last articles, this article discusses in depth the effects prenatal alcohol exposure has on the brain and how it affects brain development (Thomas, J. D., Sather, T. M., & Whinery, L. A., 2008). Since most teratogenic studies would not meet the code of ethics when done on humans, most of the time they are studied in rats or other mammals. This studied specifically focused on the third trimester, when the hippocampus is more susceptible to harm (Thomas et al., 2008). These rats were divided into groups, some were given alcohol for about three weeks, then half of them were placed in cages with a running wheel and the other half without (Thomas et al., 2008). The researchers in this study hypothesized that exercise would lessen the effects that alcohol can have on spatial learning and cognitive function (Thomas et al., 2008).
In others, neurons form more connections. (Martin, 2000) These brain changes can be long-lasting and can lead to the harmful behaviors seen in people who abuse drugs. Adolescents drug abuse coexist with other mental disorders, such as attention-deficit-hyperactivity disorder, affective disorders,