ipl-logo

Proposition 227 Argumentative Analysis

638 Words3 Pages

After I watched the episode of “Think Tank” that discussed the aftermath of Proposition 227 in California, I realized how contentious the debate about bilingual education has been in the past and how it still continues to be today. The video hosted Dr. Krashen, an advocate of second-language acquisition and bilingual education, and Mr. Unz, an advocate of English-Only Education, in a debate about the effectiveness of bilingual education and Proposition 227.
On one side of the debate is Mr. Unz, the author of Proposition 227. He claims that the English-Only method is more effective than the Bilingual Education approach for teaching Limited English Proficient (LEP) students. Mr. Unz states that it is very easy for students to acquire a second-language …show more content…

There are more qualified teachers and resources put in to place for Spanish speakers. I firmly believe that Bilingual Education programs help students acquire English, while preventing them from becoming academically deficient. A good education in your first language will positively impact your ability to acquire a second language. I have experienced this benefit firsthand while learning Spanish and becoming bilingual. I believe it would be incredibly demoralizing to be forced to learn a second-language without having an opportunity to develop a solid base in your first language.
The debate between supporters of Pro-Bilingual Education and Pro-English Education is a battle that will stand the test of time. In recent years, it has become a politicized dispute and is no longer just a language issue. It has become an issue of culture. English will continue to be the dominant language of the United States, but the population of LEP students will continue to grow. As long as this debate remains so polarized, it will be difficult to give LEP students the education that they truly

Show More
Related

  • Report On Oil Reserves In Cocopah Territory And Bilingual Education

    1320 Words  | 6 Pages

    A study at Johns Hopkins found that bilingual education teaches bilingualism without compromising English proficiency. Comparable studies have shown that students gain proficiency in the second language and outperform their nonimmersion peers on standardized reading in English. The Current Status of Bilingual Education Programs in Arizona In 2000, Arizona passed Proposition 203, which required English-only instruction in all public schools.

    Read More

  • Proposition 57: Argumentative Analysis

    2010 Words  | 9 Pages

    Yes on Proposition 57 When Robert Gonzalez was 17 years old, he was charged as an adult because the public defender said his actions were an”adult-like crime”. Robert Gonzalez was the “wheel-man” during a robbery. The sentenced Mr.Gonzalez got a sentence of 20 years with 4 months. Proposition 57 is mainly for the juveniles that are getting a second chance to go to rehab and to get better. Proposition 57 is trying to get passed because there are too many people that are getting put into prisons for reasons that can be solved another way.

    Read More

  • The New Bathroom Policy At English High School, By Martin Espada

    976 Words  | 4 Pages

    Bilingual people often get pushed away or bullied for not being able to speak a new language. Bilingual speakers should feel like they belong in their own identity. They should also speak out about their struggles and challenges with bilingualism. In the essay, "Hunger of Memory", Richard Rodriguez explains that being able to keep his native tongue while also learning a new language can be very helpful in the outside world. Being able to acknowledge different languages can help at school, work, or even just the grocery store.

    Read More

  • Compare And Contrast The Mendez Et Al V Westminster Board Of Education

    1662 Words  | 7 Pages

    As a teacher, I am committed to give each of my students the right to receive help. Just because a student is having trouble pronouncing the English language I know that I shouldn’t talk down on them or ignore them because they are not grasping the language better than others. I am entitled to equally teach my students and find ways to help them better their learning. As a bilingual teacher, I will find programs or other activities that I know can help them, so that they can be successful.

    Read More

  • Analysis Of Hunger Of Memory By Richard Rodriguez

    2169 Words  | 9 Pages

    When I was younger I was enrolled into Bilingual classes since preschool which cost me dearly. While taking these classes I had trouble learning English and Spanish words at the same time. I struggled through elementary school because I was not used to focusing primarily on English which affected my grades. While it is true that colleges look for students who know more than one language, the problem with that requirement is that students who focus on two languages at once are more likely to fail their classes because they do not have their full attention directed towards the English language and they don’t pay attention to that factor. Colleges do not see the risk of being a bilingual student.

    Read More

  • Pros And Cons Of Proposition 227

    922 Words  | 4 Pages

    Before and after of proposition 227, bilingual education is one of most controversial educational issue in California. This issue naturally provokes many following issues since California is one of states that have a high population of immigrants. There are many pros and cons of banning the bilingual education. This paper examines how California’s decision of ending the bilingual education influences the elementary school students, especially the English learner students. In order to do so, historical background needs to be explained.

    Read More

  • Liberal Arts Argumentative Analysis

    991 Words  | 4 Pages

    With the year-round pressure pertaining to college applications on high school seniors follows the impending decision of choosing an appropriate college major. Generally, the decision-making process involves prioritizing one field of interest over another, however, due to globalization and constant innovation in technology determining a college major has increasingly become the modern day equivalent of the metaphorical line between life and death. Even so, the obvious choice would be the prestigious STEM fields over liberal arts due to the instant job opportunities which are seemingly ludicrous to a recent graduate. Nevertheless, liberal arts education should be encouraged to be pursued at higher education institutions in USA because it helps

    Read More

  • The New Bathroom Policy At English High School Summary

    575 Words  | 3 Pages

    Language forms a part of culture and identity. Bilingualism is the right to speak multiple languages. Part of bilingualism is keeping and developing a passion for language. In the essay “The New Bathroom Policy at English High School,” Martín Espada suggests the definition of bilingualism and the importance of keeping it. Espada understands the difficulty of continuing to speak Spanish.

    Read More

  • The New Bathroom Policy At English High School By Martin Espada

    513 Words  | 3 Pages

    Being bilingual can be both useful or irritating, having the ability to communicate and understand several languages or being raised to be an interpreter for your parents. As you become more exposed to a variety of languages you can often observe how society treats certain languages. Martin Espada is a lawyer and poet who defends Spanish speakers in America, makes it clear about the role of language in his essay, “The New Bathroom Policy at English High School.” He asserts that the importance of language is created from cultural identity. When Espada shared what he learned about maintaining and defending Spanish he proceeded to say, “Defending the right of all Latinos to use the tongue of their history and identity creates in me passion for Spanish itself.”

    Read More

  • Being Bilingual Research Paper

    423 Words  | 2 Pages

    One in five United States residents speaks a foreign language. Try to do the math of this and it gives you roughly sixty-one million people in the United States that speak a foreign language. Being bilingual helps you in many different ways. It helps with your first language. It helps you communicate with others in ways that you were not capable of doing before and helps with your self-confidence.

    Read More

  • Speaking In Tongues Analysis

    1764 Words  | 8 Pages

    Having a second language in your background is so impactful on one’s life, providing them with more skills. This is the 21st century and having this skill helps an individual be

    Read More

  • Bilingual Persuasive Speech

    750 Words  | 3 Pages

    The more language knowledge significantly helps towards your career as you know. Bilinguals have the privilege of get their information from a wider variety of resources. Also, it has great educational benefit to kids. Many studies suggest that bilingual children tend to have a higher concentration and are better at working through distraction while doing their school work. Research has shown that bilinguals score higher on average on tests involving creative thinking or problem solving.

    Read More

  • Teaching ELL Students

    245 Words  | 1 Pages

    The figure 4.1, shows the results and comparison between six styles of teaching ELL students. The data information is based on standardized tests taken by the students. The result shows that ELL students exposed to the two way developmental bilingual education facilitated the student’s experience the most, making it the most efficient. A benefit of bilingual programs for ELL students is that it allows the students to maintain their culture, a huge aspect of culture is their native language. A child who moves to a new country should not feel like their native language should be forgotten, I believe students should learn about the importance and advantages that come with speaking multiple languages.

    Read More

  • Case Study: Equal Access To Education Plan For Bell School

    1509 Words  | 7 Pages

    Currently, according to PEIMS financial data reported to the Texas Education Agency, $2,057,556.00 are allocated for regular education while only $112,931.00 are allocated for bilingual education (Kemp-Graham, 2014, p. 23). Since 90% of students at Alexander Graham Bell School of Communication, Language, and Culture do not speak English as their primary language at home it would greatly benefit the school to put more funding into bilingual educational programs that would allow students to learn in a language they are more comfortable with while concurrently strengthening their English Language skills (Kemp-Graham, 2014, p. 20). This new emphasis on bilingual education will help to close the gap in all language speakers by allowing each equal access to the concepts being taught by providing them in the language that students are comfortable with at that time, while simultaneously increasing each students English Language skills building toward a community that can more effectively communicate and thus get to know and value each other’s unique individual cultures, histories, and backgrounds. This plan will call for a doubling of the current bilingual education funding at the expense of that amount being taken from the general education funds.

    Read More

  • Pedagogical Implications

    1002 Words  | 5 Pages

    6. IMPLICATIONS This chapter discusses the pedagogical and the research implications that evolved from this early sequential bilingual project conducted during the early years. The implications are based on the performance of the bilingual educators, the early childhood teachers and the children involved, as well as the materials employed to carried out this implementation. 6.1.

    Read More

More about Proposition 227 Argumentative Analysis

Open Document