Pros And Cons Of Affirmative Action In Colleges
In order to access higher education, most educational institutions require applicants to list their race as a component to their admissions decision. Affirmative action established this factor to provide equality for ethnic minority students. However, since the process primarily benefits minorities, Caucasian applicants such as Allan Bakke and Abigail Fisher have challenged the ideals of affirmative action, claiming that racial components instead served as a factor for their college rejections. The consistent amount of affirmative action cases has motivated some educational institutions to question their stance on racial admission components. While certain scholars argue that affirmative action promotes equality, other experts argue that it …show more content…
Rohit Joshi, who serves as a student at John Hopkins University, states in his article, “It’s Time to Change Affirmative Action in Colleges,” that affirmative action
“overcorrects” racial “bias” by providing minorities with “advantages.” Joshi’s word choice conveys his criticizing tone which enhances his idea that affirmative action does not help minorities in a fair manner. Instead of equalizing every student’s benefits, Joshi believes affirmative action provides minorities with more benefits that discriminate against nonminorities. In response to Stanford University’s consideration of reevaluating affirmative action policies, authors of The Diversity Myth: "Multiculturalism" and the Politics of Intolerance at
Stanford, David Sacks and Peter Thiel, state that the purpose of affirmative action was to
“redress” discrimination and develop “integration” among enrolled students. However, Sacks and Thiel utilize the observations of Thomas Sowell to dispute the positive outlooks
…show more content…
Based on these reasons, Sacks and Thiel believe that instead of accomplishing its purpose of putting an end to discrimination, affirmative action has instead promoted discrimination and unequal rights to certain students.
In order to solve the issues of affirmative action, the authors suggest that the “sole criterion” for admissions should revolve around personal “achievements” which race can not be categorized into since they describe it as a personal “trait.” By focusing solely on merit, colleges would be evaluating students based on aspects that are considered to be nondiscriminative.
Therefore, colleges would not have to endure any questioning regarding the admission of any of its enrolled students.
In the end, the decision to continue affirmative action has served its purpose for African
American writers such as Neblett and is utilized as the primary method for aiding disadvantaged minorities achieve equal educational benefits to nonminorities. However, other critics declare that affirmative action discriminates against nonminority races, and it does not primarily
Supreme Court Case Regents Of The University Of California V. Allan Bakke
721 Words | 3 PagesThe U.S. Supreme Court Case Regents of the University of California v. Allan Bakke was officially decided June 28, 1978. The case addressed the issue of use of affirmative action in university admissions processes. Affirmative action, also referred to as positive discrimination, was a result of the Civil Rights Movement of the 1960s, and was intended to ensure equal entry to educational institutions or employment entities to certain groups that “have historically suffered invidious discrimination” (Janda et al., 477). However, sometimes this method causes discrimination of other groups, through establishment of racial quotas. University of California employed the process of affirmative action and instituted racial quotas in its admissions
Supreme Court Case: Abigail Fisher V. University Of Texas
776 Words | 4 PagesUp and until this point in time, the court has generally ruled that promoting educational diversity is in fact a compelling state objective, but in today’s America, educational diversity has been established and is thriving. In this day and age, using race as a factor in college admissions is not needed. The Fourteenth amendment ensures the equal protection of the law to each and every citizen. We may not discriminate in order to promote
Supreme Court Case Study: Fisher V. Texas
858 Words | 4 PagesThe Supreme Court made a mistake when they decided with the University of Texas; no college should take in race as a factor when selecting applications of students. In 2007, two female high school students applied to the University of Texas; one of the girls being Miss Abigail N. Fisher. Abigail was a caucasian, in the top 12% of her school at Stephen Austin High School, but she was denied by the University of Texas along with a friend of her’s. However,
The Truth About Holistic College Admissions By Sara Harberson
1802 Words | 8 PagesIn the article, “The Truth about ‘holistic College Admissions”, Sara Harberson expresses how universities that are not allowed to use racial preferences on college admissions, are still devising strategies to work around the laws to produce the same result. Harberson states how the institutions are using what is called “holistic admissions”, which allows a college to factor in a student's background, race and income. By filtering out the minority groups, they are creating a less-diverse community, preventing students of certain backgrounds from a proper education, and taking away opportunities from students based on their ethnicity. Colleges are using racial segregation in the admission process so that they can have a white-favoring campus
HBCU Research Paper
157 Words | 1 PagesHistorically Black colleges and universities (HBCUs) are institutions of higher education in the United States founded primarily for the education of African Americans. Prior to the mid-1960s, HBCUs were virtually the only institutions open to African Americans due to the vast majority of predominantly white institutions prohibiting qualified African Americans from acceptance during the time of segregation. As such, they are institutional products of an era of discrimination and socially constructed racism against African Americans (Joseph, 2013). Successfully, millions of students have been educated in spite of limited resources, public contempt, accreditation violations, and legislative issues. The purpose of this research paper is to discuss
Grutter V. Bollinger Essay
1526 Words | 7 PagesIs affirmative action still necessary for guaranteeing equal access to educational opportunities at elite universities and graduate schools? Should admissions decisions be based solely on academic criteria and merit? Key Words: affirmative action, Grutter V. Bollinger, and diversity. Grutter V. Bollinger Research Paper 3 Affirmative Action in Education Affirmative action was formed more than fifty years ago.
Fisher Vs. Texas Argumentative Analysis
350 Words | 2 PagesThe Supreme Court emphasized the learning benefits from a diverse student body. This ruling was also a win for people that are against racial preference. The ruling said, “Courts must consider whether such preferences are narrowly tailored to achieving their educational goals
1967 Referendum In Australia
870 Words | 4 PagesI believe one of the most significant referendums in Australia that was carried, is the 1967 Referendum to include Aboriginal people within Section 51 and 127 of the Constitution. Prior to the 1st of January 1901, the Australian Constitution took effect and the Commonwealth of Australia was formed. Under the laws of the Australian Government, Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples were not included as citizens. Instead they were treated as foreigners in their own land. On the 27th of May 1967, a Federal referendum was held to determine whether two references in the Australian Constitution, which discriminated against Aboriginal people, should be altered or entirely removed.
The Case Of Students For Fair Admissions V. University Of North Carolina
2018 Words | 9 PagesFurthermore, the University of North Carolina's admissions policies do not discriminate against Asian American applicants. The university's holistic admissions process considers a wide range of factors, including race, and does not rely on quotas or predetermined targets. The university points to evidence showing that Asian American applicants continue to be admitted at high rates and that their enrollment numbers have increased in recent years. The petitioner’s claims under federal civil rights statutes are without merit. The University of North Carolina's use of race in admissions decisions does not discriminate against any particular racial or ethnic group, and its policies are consistent with Supreme Court precedent that allows for the limited use of race in college admissions to achieve diversity.
Standardized Testing Bias
1523 Words | 7 PagesAnother thing that places students of color at a disadvantage in college admissions is the persisting cultural bias in high-stakes testing. “High-stakes” tests are those that are tied to major consequences, such as admission to college, or even high school graduation. Fair education reform advocates have long been citing an extensive record of standardized testing concerns, many of which relate to racial bias and discrimination. As researcher and author Harold Berlak explains in the journal Rethinking Education: Standardized testing perpetuates institutionalized racism and contributes to the achievement gap between whites and minorities. For instance, the deeply embedded stereotype that African Americans perform poorly on standardized tests
Shackled Runner Thesis
1028 Words | 5 PagesAccording to the dominant theory the affirmative action was firstly introduced to deal with two types of social disruption in the 1960s as campus protests and urban riots in the North. However, this article is based on different theory as dominant theory's empirical evidence is limited. It examines the initial reason for advent of race-conscious affirmative action in 17 undergraduate institutions in the United States. And according to the research this article concludes that there were two waves that contributed to affirmative action: 1) first wave in the early 1960s introduced by northern college administrators 2) second wave in the late 1960s introduced as a response to the protests of campus-based students. This article will help me to establish the main reasons for introduction of race-conscious affirmative action in undergraduate
Argumentative Essay On Racial Equality
1734 Words | 7 PagesThroughout many of the affirmative action legal cases, one of the main arguments from proponents is that it is necessary in order to right the wrongs of past racial discrimination. Some say that affirmative action is justified because even though white applicants may be more qualified, this is only because they did not face the same hardships as their minority counterparts (Rachels, Ethics, 1973). Many argue if we do not integrate disadvantaged minorities into mainstream social institutions, they will continue to suffer the discrimination that has plagued our country for centuries and that this is detrimental to not only the minorities but also society as a whole (Anderson, 2002, 1270–71). However, the debate has recently shifted to the benefits of diversity in the classroom which the Supreme Court has affirmed as being a positive thing
Arguments Against Affirmative Action
196 Words | 1 PagesOne of the most significant current discussions in legal and moral philosophy is affirmative action. Affirmative action is a positive discriminatory action or policy intended to eliminate discrimination based on race, ethnicity, nationality, and gender in workplaces and educational institutions. The dispute behind affirmative action relies on the public’s comprehension of it and because of its ambiguous constitution. A multitude might argue that this policy ensures equality by forcing institutions to accept citizens regardless of for instance disability or that they are minorities. Supposedly, it’s purpose
Essay Affirmative Action Should Be Abolished
438 Words | 2 PagesIn one of the articles we read, Terry Swenson says, “Minority students don’t want to be there for the benefit of the majority population, nor do they want to be called upon as the representatives of their race every time the topic comes up in class discussion.” This proves the point that there is no direct benefit from Affirmative Action. Many think that it is promoting diversity, but these minority students don’t want to be seen as the token representative of their race. They are even against Affirmative Action somewhat themselves. As a minority in this country, they become singled out in many circumstances because of this.
Pros And Cons Of Affirmative Action
1068 Words | 5 PagesAffirmative Action is a policy favoring those who tend to suffer from discrimination, especially in relation to employment or education. “I’m not one that believes that affirmative action should be based on one’s skin color or one’s gender, I think it should be done based one’s need, because I think if you are from a poor white community, I think that a poor white kid needs a scholarship just as badly as a poor black kid”(Watts). If you are going to give a destitute, colored kid a scholarship, why can you not give one to someone who is not colored and is also poor. If people are going to use this action, make it civil for all, not just others based on their race and or gender. This is why Affirmative Action is denied on multiple times and is
More about Pros And Cons Of Affirmative Action In Colleges
Supreme Court Case Regents Of The University Of California V. Allan Bakke
721 Words | 3 PagesSupreme Court Case: Abigail Fisher V. University Of Texas
776 Words | 4 PagesSupreme Court Case Study: Fisher V. Texas
858 Words | 4 PagesThe Truth About Holistic College Admissions By Sara Harberson
1802 Words | 8 PagesHBCU Research Paper
157 Words | 1 PagesGrutter V. Bollinger Essay
1526 Words | 7 PagesFisher Vs. Texas Argumentative Analysis
350 Words | 2 Pages1967 Referendum In Australia
870 Words | 4 PagesThe Case Of Students For Fair Admissions V. University Of North Carolina
2018 Words | 9 PagesStandardized Testing Bias
1523 Words | 7 PagesShackled Runner Thesis
1028 Words | 5 PagesArgumentative Essay On Racial Equality
1734 Words | 7 PagesArguments Against Affirmative Action
196 Words | 1 PagesEssay Affirmative Action Should Be Abolished
438 Words | 2 PagesPros And Cons Of Affirmative Action
1068 Words | 5 Pages