Pros And Cons Of Civil Disobedience
Ayden Jacques Magdalen Middle School Culminating Project 6 March 2023 Civil Disobedience There have been more than 400 anti-government protests worldwide since 2000 with 23% lasting for more than three months as an act to establish religious and governmental freedoms. Bedau states, “An act of civil disobedience is an act in violation of a law (or a specific group of laws) which is undertaken for moral reasons” (Bedau qtd. In Hall 15). Civil disobedience can bring lots of good and bad things into the world. It can create change, give religious freedoms, but it can also force change and bring violence to a peaceful community. Civil disobedience …show more content…
Breitenbach says, “Creating a new law would be set up in a way that would not affect the others because the law/laws would replace any laws that would disagree or counteract it.” The changes made by civil disobedience will not get in the way of other laws already set in place by the government because new laws will replace any laws that disagree with it. As described in five pros and cons of Civil Disobedience, “Those who are participants and leaders in civil disobedience campaigns seek to change the worldview of those involved in the conflict so that the conditions that led to the conflict do not recur.” The people that lead the protests in any country are there to seek change in communities. They are also there to make sure that the conditions that led up to that protest will not happen …show more content…
The need for Social Disobedience. https://www.nateliason.com, Published 13 Aug. 2018. Accessed on 22 Feb. 2023. Five pros and cons of Civil disobedience. Asia- Pacifics economics https://apecsec.org/5-pros-and-cons-of-civil-disobedience/ , Published 18 August 2016, Accessed 21 Feb. 2023. King, Luther. Free Speech / Civil Disobedience | Police Department. University of California, Los Angeles https://police.ucla.edu/other, n. d. Accessed 21 Feb. 2023. Lefkowitz, Robert. An encyclopedia of Applied Ethics. Academic Press, 15 Oct. 1997. Marcou, Andreas. Violence, Communication, and Civil Disobedience. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/. n. p. 7 June 2021. Accessed on 22 Feb. 2023. Paul VI. “Dignitatis humanae.” Vatican.va. Vatican II. 7 Dec. 1965. https://www.vatican.va/archive/. Accessed 22 Feb. 2023 (-- removed HTML --) Pego, Anabella. The Institution of Civil Disobedience as means of Democratization. The Hannah Arendt Center for Politics and Humanities https://hac.bard.edu/amor-mundi. Published 6 Apr. 2015. Accessed on 22 Feb. 2023 Schiffmann, Avi. Global Protest Tracker-Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. Carnegie-Endowment for national peace https://carnegieendowment.org/publications/, n. d. 22 Feb.
Compare And Contrast Letter From Birmingham Jail And Antigone
1117 Words | 5 PagesIn the world that we live in today, civil disobedience is a subject that has been and continues to be an extremely relevant issue in life. But even though it is a relevant topic, it is one that brings much disagreement when conversed about. The topic that is widely debated to what is the most effective way that civil disobedience can be used by citizens against unjust laws and rulings by those in power, using words or in the most extreme cases getting violent. There is a wide range of ways that civil disobedience is used, in Sophocles Antigone and Dr. King’s Letter from a Birmingham Jail two different methods can be seen. King uses the power of his words to unite a nation against the unjustness of a country, while Antigone uses the power of
Comparison Of Letter From Birmingham Jail And Malcolm X
2022 Words | 9 PagesCivil disobedience is a non-violent act of protest or resistance against unjust actions from the government. This form of collective action is based on the belief that individuals have the right and duty to challenge the authority if it acts against the interest of the people. In recognition of this, prominent figures of the Civil Rights movement often discussed civil disobedience; eventually debating on the justification of violent disobedience. In this essay, I will examine the arguments presented by Martin Luther King Jr. in his “Letter from Birmingham Jail” and Malcolm X in “The Ballot or Bullet” to recognize the various usage of civil disobedience; ultimately, evaluating the moral justifiability of using violence as a means of promoting
Keystone Pipeline Analysis
837 Words | 4 PagesIn recent years in can be noted that civil disobedience is prominent in American culture. This can be portrayed in the recent events of the Keystone Pipeline activists. Many activists have blamed the government for their problems just as Thoreau did in his essay “Civil Disobedience”. There can be a parallel drawn between these two topics even though they have decades between them. In these times it is still logical to believe that civil disobedience is the right course of action.
Examples Of Disobedience Sparks Progression
692 Words | 3 PagesSydney Krcmarik AP Argument Essay 30 January 2023 Disobedience Sparks Progression Oscar Wilde’s statement about disobedience being a valuable way to promote social change is valid as long as those who are fighting remember that they are fighting to bring positive change to their community. When citizens are motivated to really see change and think more about their community as a whole, rather than their own personal power, real change is possible. For example, Susan B. Anthony’s fight for women's rights led to her doing many disobedient acts. Nonetheless, she did them unapologetically, knowing that she was bringing necessary change and progress. However, when the angry civilians of the French Revolutions rebelled, their leaders tried to strike
Stonewall Riots Rhetorical Analysis
782 Words | 4 PagesWhen disobeying the law in a peaceable manner, the participants lose out on media coverage (due to their lack of sensationalism and interest level to viewers looking for immediacy and sanitization in the coverage of current events) except when called upon by the court of public opinion. In a free society, censorship of topical media bars citizens from a truly transparent government run by and for the people. By speaking out against such bias through action, civil disobedience itself is an act of resistance against censorship, and therefore a proponent of the values of free press and speech. These are keystones in American
Letter From A Birmingham Jail, By Martin Luther King Jr.
800 Words | 4 PagesIn a free society, civil disobedience is used to nonviolently protest laws against injustices to create positive change. Change is accomplished with the best intention and through nonviolent
Examples Of Civil Disobedience In Antigone
513 Words | 3 PagesCivil disobedience is an act or way of disobeying the law/government. You don’t cooperate with the law(s). Many people don’t cooperate with a law and so they protest in a way without using violence. Protesting is part of an act of civil disobedience, it’s a way for people to show or prove their point of view. In the article “ On the Duty of Civil Disobedience” states when a person’s conscience and law clash, the person would follow their conscience rather than the law.
Civil Disobedience In The United States
678 Words | 3 PagesThe idea of civil disobedience in the hope of making a valuable contribution to one’s cause is an extremely controversial topic. When working towards a common goal, what is considered justifiable and what is considered too far? Many will attest that there is a fine line between standing for your cause and simply committing criminal acts; however, for many Americans, this line is extremely blurry and cannot truly be defined. As young Americans, we are taught that the glorious land and country we live in is unrivaled by any other nation.
My Conceptions Of Civil Disobedience
1101 Words | 5 PagesIf you asked me a few weeks ago what I thought about civil disobedience and what actions are forms of civil disobedience I would have answered with very simple responses, such as marching, protestings, etc. But as I’ve begun to learn more about different forms of civil disobedience and developed a nuanced understanding of these said actions I can say that my beliefs and understanding has changed. The texts that I have read over the past week have provided me with insight that has vastly changed my conceptions and knowledge on what civil disobedience is and how it is practiced. My conceptions of civil disobedience were originally fairly shallow as I briefly stated.
Theme Of Disobedience In Fahrenheit 451
929 Words | 4 PagesDisobedience The history of our society constantly proves that it has and is being shaped by protesting beliefs, hiding under the law, and disobeying rules and norms. In 1891, Irish author Oscar Wilde (1854–1900) observed, “Disobedience, in the eyes of anyone who has read history, is man’s original virtue. It is through disobedience that progress has been made, through disobedience and through rebellion.” Many examples of disobedience have been shown in literature. Some show the outcome of disobedience as successful, although it doesn’t always work out the way it was intended.
Oscar Wilde And Civil Disobedience And Social Progress
995 Words | 4 PagesIrish author Oscar Wilde claimed that disobedience is a valuable human trait, and that it promotes social progress; thus, without it, social progress would not be made. Civil disobedience is to social progress as hard work is to academic success. With hard work comes academic success, and with civil disobedience comes social progress. Though some see disobedience as a negative trait, it is what has promoted social progress in history by challenging social standards and requiring new social rules to be made. Civil disobedience challenges social standards by expanding views on the current guidelines.
Examples Of Civil Disobedience In Antigone
1005 Words | 5 PagesToday we are all called to enact on our own civil disobedience when we are faced with injustice and unfair laws, we are called to make a stand and a declaration to stand up for what we believe
Summary: The Case Against Civil Disobedience
1290 Words | 6 PagesPeople's justification to engage in civil disobedience rests on the unresponsiveness that their engagement to oppose an unjust law receives. People who yearn for a change in a policy might sometimes find themselves in a dead end because their “attempts to have the laws repealed have been ignored and legal protests and demonstrations have had no success” (Rawls 373). What Rawls says is that civil disobedience is a last option to oppose an unjust law; therefore, providing civil disobedients with a justification for their cause. Civil disobedience is the spark of light that people encountered at the dead end and they hope that this spark of light will illuminate to show that an unjust law should not exist at all. Martin Luther King, Jr, in his “Letter from
How Is Civil Disobedience Effective
1251 Words | 6 PagesCivil Disobedience Thousands of dedicated people march the streets of a huge city, chanting repetitively about needing a change. They proudly hold vibrant signs and banners as they fight for what they believe in. Expressions of determination and hope are visibly spread across their faces. These people aren’t using weapons or violence to fight for their ideas; simply, they are using civil disobedience.
Essay On Civil Disobedience
1360 Words | 6 PagesCivil Disobedience is known as breaking the law because you don 't agree with a certain law or have a peaceful protest about that law or what you believe in. An example would be when Mahatma Gandhi walked miles to the Indian ocean as the citizens gathered more and more to fight for there Indian Independence. This occasion was called the Salt March. The reason for The Salt March was a March were all the citizens from India walked with gandhi to fight back for their Independence from the British, since it was taken away from the British.
More about Pros And Cons Of Civil Disobedience
Compare And Contrast Letter From Birmingham Jail And Antigone
1117 Words | 5 PagesComparison Of Letter From Birmingham Jail And Malcolm X
2022 Words | 9 PagesKeystone Pipeline Analysis
837 Words | 4 PagesExamples Of Disobedience Sparks Progression
692 Words | 3 PagesStonewall Riots Rhetorical Analysis
782 Words | 4 PagesLetter From A Birmingham Jail, By Martin Luther King Jr.
800 Words | 4 PagesExamples Of Civil Disobedience In Antigone
513 Words | 3 PagesCivil Disobedience In The United States
678 Words | 3 PagesMy Conceptions Of Civil Disobedience
1101 Words | 5 PagesTheme Of Disobedience In Fahrenheit 451
929 Words | 4 PagesOscar Wilde And Civil Disobedience And Social Progress
995 Words | 4 PagesExamples Of Civil Disobedience In Antigone
1005 Words | 5 PagesSummary: The Case Against Civil Disobedience
1290 Words | 6 PagesHow Is Civil Disobedience Effective
1251 Words | 6 PagesEssay On Civil Disobedience
1360 Words | 6 Pages