Pros And Cons Of Compulsory Licensing
Introduction
Compulsory licensing is one of the major talking points not just in India but largely in most countries around the world, be it developing or the developed countries and opinions range right to the extremes. The advantages of compulsory licenses, especially in the pharmaceutical sector are obvious. It allows access to essential drugs. On the flipside, accusations of it hurting innovation also abound. The project aims to look into look at both sides of the coin and hopefully come to a conclusion on how a balance can be achieved.
Compulsory Licensing in the Pharmaceutical Sector
March, 2012 was a historic day in terms of compulsory licensing in India. The first compulsory license was given to Natco to produce a generic version of
…show more content…
There are generally two circumstances under which a generic version of a patented drug can be legally manufactured, either by a voluntary license by the patentee or by a compulsory license. In the case of a voluntary license, patent holders use their discretion to decide on either exclusive or non-exclusive terms, the rights to manufacture a drug on an agreed fee. Compulsory licenses are usually granted when the exclusive rights which are held by the patentee don’t meet the reasonable needs of the society or they are anti-competitive in nature. It allows to keep a check on pharmaceutical companies to price their drugs at an affordable level and to innovate further on processes to bring down the cost of …show more content…
The TRIPS agreement allows for compulsory licenses as a part of the agreement’s overall attempt to strike a balance between promoting access to existing drugs and promoting research and development into new drugs. ‘Compulsory license’ does not appear in itself in TRIPS, but there is the presence of Article 31 which speaks about uses of the patent without the authorisation of the patent holder. Compulsory license is a part of this use which includes the usage of the patent by the governments of different nations. It is vital to note how the TRIPS agreement initially was. Article 31(f) used to be read to prohibit the manufacture of generics in third world countries for exporting to countries which were experiencing a health crisis. It essentially resulted in countries lacking indigenous pharmaceutical manufacturing capacity could not effectively access
Pros And Cons Of The Orphan Drug Act Of 1983
322 Words | 2 PagesThe Orphan Drug Act of 1983 was signed for the main purpose of promoting the research, treatment, prevention and diagnosis of rare disease or condition. Here the products which are used in rare disease can be drugs, biologics and medical devices. A rare disease means any disease which affects less than 200,000 persons in the United States or one in which the manufacturer has no expectation of recovering the money from development and sales in the United States. According to this act, there are certain incentives will be provided to the manufacturers who will develop orphan drug for the rare disease and condition. Thus, this act can encourage the treatment for rare disease.
Opium Trade Dbq
268 Words | 2 PagesStruggling to maintain social order and strength, the Qing Dynasty placed restrictions on opium trade; however, this backfired, provoking retaliation from British traders and leading to a war that would create the Unequal Treaties. The detrimental socio economic effects opium had on China were beginning to surface during the late 1830’s, causing an influx of smokers and a decline in bullion. Although China’s economy suffered, this was the most viable foreign trade option for the British. There was low demand for the cotton the British offered to China, but the increased profits from opium would do more than compensate. Thus, British merchants took various measures to circumvent China’s policies to stop the illicit trade and managed to find
Bennett Drug Policy And The Intellectuals Analysis
304 Words | 2 PagesThe outcome of attempting this would make it even simpler to gain a profit in the drug industry. In the author’s opinion, if the process to acquire drugs becomes simpler, then the number of individuals
Pros And Cons Of Ban The Box
194 Words | 1 PagesVery good discussion Thomas, I also concur that the purpose of 'ban the box ' is to give an ex-offender a better shot at going farther in You have provided many valid points regarding the use of body cameras by police officers. Indeed that the utilization of body cameras by officers do provide transparency and accountability towards potential and suspect individual in question to include officers ' conduct. The officers must also use good judgment and with plenty of discretion when executing their legal authority to use such device. Like you also mentioned, some witnesses would be reluctant in assisting with the investigation, if they know that video cameras could potentially be release to the public that could result in retribution.
Andrew Jackson's Gullification Crisis
240 Words | 1 PagesThe purpose of this was to give the American factories an upper hand to competing countries. Upon the time of this issue there were many in favor of the nullification
The Pros And Cons Of The Pharmaceutical Industry
1631 Words | 7 PagesTherefore the government should regulate the pharmaceutical industry because the industry is harmful towards the economy and patients. The government can achieve this by enabling a cap on prices of specialty drugs and ensuring DCTA is not
Pros And Cons Of Concealed Carry
113 Words | 1 PagesSelf-defense is key to survival in the day that we are living. The concealed carry law allows any person from the age of twenty-one years of age or older to carry a firearm, if they have a permit to carry that firearm. The law was passed so that you could legally carry a firearm in public to protect yourself. It is called the Second Amendment. There is two sides to this argument some people believe you should be able to carry a handgun on your hip in public.
Gun Registration Pros And Cons
662 Words | 3 PagesEnhanced Gun registration could potentially significantly lower the amount of guns bought through straw purchasing sales and corrupt FFL’s. Gun registration happens at the initial sale of the firearm, and legally binds the buyer to that gun, just like your car registration verifies the you are the legal owner of your car. What enhanced gun registration could do is deter someone from binding themselves to a weapon and then giving it to someone else, and be responsible for what is done or committed with that weapon. Background checks are another easy and affective means of preventing guns from getting in the wrong hands. The public opinion on background checks has changed drastically over the past decade; according to the Pew Research Center, in 2000, the overall populous of the United States was only 29% in favor of background checks as opposed to 2015 which is now a staggering 52% (Pew Research).
Thomas Jefferson And The Embargo Act Of 1807
849 Words | 4 PagesCorrespondingly the US lost over eighty million dollars in exports as the
Roosevelt's Regulation Railroads
500 Words | 2 PagesThings produced such as Dr. James’ Soothing Syrup, was intended for baby’s, teething pain, which contained a drug called heroin. Gowan’s Pneumonia Cure contained a addictive painkiller called opium. Small industries fell into a greater disputes, while trying to compete with President Roosevelt, or other big businesses. This quote shows that he really sided big business. “We demand that big business give the people a square deal; in return we must insist that when anyone engaged in big business honestly endeavors to do right he shall himself be given a square deal.”
Satire On Drugs
557 Words | 3 PagesToday many countries try to regulate the numbers of drugs users as many as they can by using the scary promotions and commercials to attract the attention from people, albeit ineffective. Rather than using the outmoded methods, legitimacy should be announced for all drugs in order that the regulation will process more ease for the government. In this procedure, the government can legislate the limitations for drugs consumption and people will be able to understand drug disadvantages profoundly. Therefore, allowing drugs as ordinary substances will abate the drug consumption. The aforementioned issue, in brief, the drugs is a too danger to leave it as it is so it should be legalized.
Fire In The Blood Essay
1068 Words | 5 PagesWhy? Mainly because of very high prices of ARVs and international patents that didn’t allow the drugs to be manufactured at cheaper prices causing mass destruction. The main problems that are highlighted in the documentary are high prices of the drugs (which lead to higher deaths), Restrictions on imports, patenting of drugs (cheaper generic drugs couldn’t be manufactured) and monopoly by big pharmaceutical companies ( leading to higher prices of life saving drugs) and players at stake were Pfizer, Cipla, Private Companies and generic drugs
Pros And Cons Of Marijuana Legalization
1729 Words | 7 PagesPros and Cons of Marijuana Legalization Marijuana is the most commonly used illicit substance in the United States. More than half of American adults have tried using marijuana at least once in their life. You may have read or heard stories on how marijuana use was mostly linked to people who were very vocal with their opinions. Seeing their favorite performers during a live concert may have been the start of the spreading of this illegal drug which has caused so many lives. When experts found out about the ill effects of marijuana, people who were found to be using them were put behind bars.
Human Body During The Renaissance
1668 Words | 7 PagesFor that reason, is why the we have modern pharmaceutical industry, and the world of patent
Porter's Five Forces Analysis Pharmaceutical Industry
720 Words | 3 PagesMany new companies to enter the market without burden of costly tasks such as research and development, clinical trials and manufacturing of drugs. Moreover, patent expiry is one of the reasons which is offering opportunities for lower cost generic manufacturer in terms of greater market access. Additionally, the government has increased their focus on healthcare cost cutting. It is creating pressure on the authority to allow early introduction of low-cost drugs in the
More about Pros And Cons Of Compulsory Licensing
Pros And Cons Of The Orphan Drug Act Of 1983
322 Words | 2 PagesOpium Trade Dbq
268 Words | 2 PagesBennett Drug Policy And The Intellectuals Analysis
304 Words | 2 PagesPros And Cons Of Ban The Box
194 Words | 1 PagesAndrew Jackson's Gullification Crisis
240 Words | 1 PagesThe Pros And Cons Of The Pharmaceutical Industry
1631 Words | 7 PagesPros And Cons Of Concealed Carry
113 Words | 1 PagesGun Registration Pros And Cons
662 Words | 3 PagesThomas Jefferson And The Embargo Act Of 1807
849 Words | 4 PagesRoosevelt's Regulation Railroads
500 Words | 2 PagesSatire On Drugs
557 Words | 3 PagesFire In The Blood Essay
1068 Words | 5 PagesPros And Cons Of Marijuana Legalization
1729 Words | 7 PagesHuman Body During The Renaissance
1668 Words | 7 PagesPorter's Five Forces Analysis Pharmaceutical Industry
720 Words | 3 Pages