ipl-logo

Pros And Cons Of Involuntary Asylum

1000 Words4 Pages

Involuntary admission and medication have been administered to the mentally ill and disabled for centuries; this course began in the 1800s when the first insane asylum opened in Britain after the 1808 County Asylum Act. While many organizations are aimed at equal rights for all who are not a direct danger to themselves or others, there is still large injustice for the mentally handicapped when his/her rights are violated by being pushed into unnecessary hospitalization. Countless innocent, mentally ill people are impacted by having treatments they are involuntarily given; fortunately, organizations such as Mental Disability Rights International are attempting to make a difference by fighting against the treatment the mentally disabled receive …show more content…

To summarize, “a person must be seen as a danger to self or others and hospitalization would be the least restrictive means of treatment” (Oberg). The hospitalization must be for a short time and the principle strongly urges the opinion from a second doctor, although it is not seen as a necessity. Involuntary treatment can only be given when patients are seen to be an impending danger; however “if all efforts were exhausted”, then judges will tend to favor the doctors at giving the patients treatment, especially if the pros of treatment outweigh the cons that may occur (Sederer).
Since doctors can make the call for treatment, sometimes without the consent of the mentally ill or disabled, as well as the mental disabilities not being visible, it can make coverage for the patients difficult. When getting coverage for the mental disabilities, “people who suffer from mental illness [tend to] have a hard time trying to get insurance coverage for various reasons, such as difficulty in proving their condition, little attention being paid to mental illness, and limited coverage from providers who do not deem mental illnesses a health

Show More
Related

  • Greystone Parks Psychiatric Hospital Case Study

    525 Words  | 3 Pages

    In addition to, some Consumers are not aware of their illness. Never-the-less, in the State of New Jersey people who are deemed as a danger to themselves or others due to a mental illness is involuntarily committed to this facility by a judge who has written the orders. At “Greystone Parks Psychiatric Hospital” there are certain protocols that must be followed before people are admitted into this facility. The protocol is as follows, patients stay in either the A1/B1 units.

    Read More

  • Varying Views Of Dorothea Dix And Franklin Pierce Concerning The Federal Government

    657 Words  | 3 Pages

    The 1800’s made steps towards equal opportunity and Civil rights, but laws had not fully established in comparison to today. Medical law makers quickly adopted the concept and between the 1960-1980’s large state-operating mental-health hospitals systematically dismantled. Problems generated, however when funding for the proposed community mental health centers was never implemented. (Reluctant Welfare State,

    Read More

  • United Sates Prison Analysis

    125 Words  | 1 Pages

    People often are guilty of letting things that are out of sight be out of their mind, but human rights should not be something overlooked. The imprisoned mentally ill has been often overlooked and there voices are not heard as they struggle everyday in inhumane conditions. The eight amendment states that no cruel and unusual punishments is to be inflicted upon the prisoners. Is the United Sates prison systems treating mentally ill prisoners according to the eight amendment? The largest prison rates belong to the United states and of those imprisoned, around the world, they are ten times more likely to be suffering from a mental illness (Mills, 2007).

    Read More

  • Assisted Outpatient Care Pros And Cons

    299 Words  | 2 Pages

    Like many mentally ill Kentuckians, Morton was neither dangerous enough to be kept in a hospital for long nor healthy enough to care for himself in the community. If successful, House Bill 94 would "keep people out of the revolving door of the hospital," Sheila Schuster of the Kentucky Mental Health Coalition told the committee. Most states have adopted some version of "assisted outpatient treatment" since the 1980s, when families of the mentally ill began to lobby for it. Police or family members can have the mentally ill involuntarily committed to a hospital for treatment once they deteriorate to the point that they pose a threat to themselves or others. First, at a hearing, a judge would decide if the individual met various criteria, including having a severe mental illness, symptoms of anosognosia, a likelihood that he would be a danger to others and a determination that outpatient treatment was the least restrictive alternative available.

    Read More

  • Asylums In The Early 1900s

    630 Words  | 3 Pages

    Whereas mental asylums in the 1870s focused on methodology, lunatic asylums in the early 1900s tackled the issue of sanitation and communicable diseases. Beginning in 1912, the Indian Government, under the influence of the Britain, passed the Indian Lunacy Act of 1912.14 This act specified guidelines for the management of mental asylums, including various procedures for admissions and standards of care.14 At this time, changes were also occurring structurally within the mental asylums in Britain.14 These changes were transforming the care of the mentally ill into a more professional setting.14 As a result, British India underwent similar transformations to the structure of their cells and the status of mental conditions. For instance, controlling

    Read More

  • Confederate Memorial Day Essay

    828 Words  | 4 Pages

    Another issue that the American prison systems were facing was their constant practice of locking away mentally ill individuals to very long prison sentences that only seriously worsened their conditions, and even made their chances of overcoming mental illness, nearly impossible. Even medications that were prescribed to these individuals made them suffer serious and sometimes even worse, side effects. Although some states banned the high rates of mentally ill individuals to prisons, this only meant they were more targeted and thrown in jail for petty offenses by police. Many prisons do not have the resources, nor the skills needed to adequately and appropriately care for the mentally ill, therefore many of them suffer and even die from this

    Read More

  • 8th Amendment Capital Punishment

    1708 Words  | 7 Pages

    Yet, there is a significant proportion of death row inmates are mentally ill and the research evidence found suggests that mental illness is often, in fact, an aggravating factor as far as capital sentencing bodies are concerned. The Supreme Court eventually came to the conclusion of this: “If it is cruel and unusual punishment to hold convicted criminals in unsafe conditions, it must be unconstitutional to confine the involuntarily committed - who may not be punished at all - in unsafe conditions” (French, 2005) There are rights that each individual has, and there needs to be guidelines to make sure each person is treated fairly, even if they do not deserve such

    Read More

  • Mental Illness In Girl, Interrupted By Susanna Kaysen

    834 Words  | 4 Pages

    In the book Girl, Interrupted, by Susanna Kaysen, one of the biggest focal points is mental illness. Mental illness can be tough to talk about, simply because the phrase “mental illness” encompasses such a wide range of conditions and conjures up images of deranged people, but it is very important, especially in this book. There is a certain stigma that people who are put into mental hospitals because they have medical problems or are insane and a possible danger to society. While this is sometimes true, it is far more common for patients to need help for a disorder, but just don’t know where to go or what to do, and can end up putting themselves or someone else in danger.

    Read More

  • Second Great Awakening: The Insane

    253 Words  | 2 Pages

    The insane are known to have been cursed with unclean spirits ever since the beginning of America who takes its views from the Old World. It was only during the Second Great Awakening that people, Christian activists and often women, sought to reform the prisons and asylums. For Americans, asylums are now remnants of the past; the mentally ill are now bestowed the right to live normal lives and they are now even given the choice to decide if they wish to seek help and take medication. Even so, it is undeniable that people with schizophrenia or bipolar disorder are unwillingly trapped inside a mind often not their own. Some of them, if left alone and uncared for, face dangers in society.

    Read More

  • Summary Of The Documentary The New Asylums

    602 Words  | 3 Pages

    Their are around 500,000 mentally ill people that are put away in prisons and jails. In the documentary “The New Asylums”,Ohio's state prison system reveals the issues that are ongoing with mentally ill inmates. The major problem we have today is that no one is taking care of the people of these people. Most mentally ill people live by themselves with no family or friends to take care of them and they are off their medications. The mentally ill come in to prison on non violent offenses such as disturbing the peace, trespassing, etc. After leaving mental hospitals they usually end up on the streets and become homeless.

    Read More

  • Community Mental Health Act Of 1963 Essay

    1349 Words  | 6 Pages

    Introduction Prior to the mid-1960 virtually all mental health treatment was provided on an inpatient basis in hospitals and institutions. The Community Mental Health Act of 1963 was established with its primary focus on deinstitutionalizing mentally ill patients, and shutting down asylums in favor of community mental health centers. It was a major policy shift in mental health treatment that allowed patients to go home and live independently while receiving treatment, (Pollack & Feldman, 2003). As a result of the Act, there was a shift of mentally ill persons in custodial care in state institutions to an increase of the mentally ill receiving prosecutions in criminal courts.

    Read More

  • Mental Health Act 2007 Essay

    796 Words  | 4 Pages

    To ensure that the illness of an individual does not worsen they are provided for without any charge which then stops them from being readmitted in to hospital. Individuals who do not have any money to pay for after treatment when they leave the hospital will not be able to fully recover if there was a fee for the aftercare and this would discriminate against those with a low income or very little money at all. Having these services enables all sufferers of mental disorder the chance to heal fully, without any cost burdens. An advantage of this Legislation is that it protects the service user 's right to be protected from harm and danger. Some, patients suffering from mental health issues result to self-harm or may harm others.

    Read More

  • Misdiagnosis In Mental Illnesses

    950 Words  | 4 Pages

    John Goodman, in his article, “How Government Regulations Is Undermining Mental Health Care”, discusses how the business of medical care is twisted and how the government, in imposing regulations on mental health care, is creating a situation where the medical care providers lose interest in actually addressing the needs of the mentally ill. Goodman mentions a previous publishing of his which touches on the issue in medical care of how health plans are manufactured to draw in the healthy and turn away the ill; the ones who are actually suffering and actually need medical treatment. He provides statistics from medical journals that detail the twenty million Americans suffering with substance abuse and the forty two point five million adults living with a mental illness who are all not getting the proper care they require. Another point Goodman makes is that while treatment options are provided in brochures and such, many people seeking legitimate treatment will find that those options are inaccessible to them for a variety of reasons with the main source of those reasons being the government regulations placed on medical care. Government regulations on medicines and other medical care can be beneficial in some situations, but in others, it can prove disadvantageous to

    Read More

  • Pros And Cons Of The Petition Law

    284 Words  | 2 Pages

    ” The process of committing someone in for treatment differs from every state a physician can bring anyone they may have concern for in order to do an evaluation because of the Petition Law. There are two major legal principles for the process of involuntary commitment of patients with a mental illness. The first legal law is parens patriae, which is comprised of components the government would have traditionally viewed as the basis for the need of treatment of patients who are committed. The second is the responsibility of the state to intervene on behalf of its citizens who cannot act in their own best interest.

    Read More

  • Asylums By Goffman Analysis

    516 Words  | 3 Pages

    Asylums Total institutions of our society can be listed in five rough groups. The first group are the institutions established to care for people that are felt to be both incapable and harmless, such as people who are blind, elderly people, orphans (Goffman 1961). The author feels that if these people are able to look after themselves to a certain extent they should not be locked up in asylums. For example when elderly people are put in nursing homes, they often lose their independence as they become dependent on other people all the time.

    Read More

More about Pros And Cons Of Involuntary Asylum

Open Document