Pros And Cons Of Operant Military Conditioning
Classical and Operant Military Conditioning
Daniel Morrison
Stanly Community College
ENG 112
Mrs. Drake
Mar. 10, 2023
Abstract
When it comes to military training there are two different ways to train soldiers the operant or classical way. The operant way is where soldiers are trained but are not rewarded for completing something, and this is the method our military currently uses. The other method is classical in which a solider is trained, but gets a treat once completed the task. When it comes to these two methods there are always different viewpoints, such as the positives of using the two different types of training. Both operant and classical training have good parts to them and how they train a soldier to become a nation protector.
…show more content…
These two different types of training have been used throughout history to train soldiers in the military. As operant is a more harsh way of training a soldier, but it still has its pros and cons. Classical conditioning is a nicer way of training more soldiers to complete their tasks but also has its pros and cons. Both classical and operant conditioning have challenges they put the soldier through, which can be …show more content…
As both of these types of trainings put soliders under intense mindset challenges as they both and used to change a soldier's mindset into the mindset of a soldier ready to battle. An article states, “ who reacts to external and internal changes of not only by separate parts of his/her psyche (mental processes, states, features) but as a single whole mediating his/her actions, deeds, behavior, attitudes by personal features” (Zinchenko, Veraksa, Leonov, 2011, p.59). As these two types of training change a soldier's mental aspects to ready them for the battlefield it also leads to them not being able to return to normal life as they have been turned into killing machines. As this is a major problem causing soldiers not to be able to return to society, but they both can be used as effective training types for soldiers. These two different types of training have been used throughout time to train soldiers in the military. As operant is a more harsh way of training a soldier, but it still has its pros and cons. Classical conditioning is easier for soldiers in training to complete their tasks but also has its pros and cons. Both classical and operant conditioning have challenges they put the soldier through, which can be
College Football Teams Should Go Semi-Pro Analysis
736 Words | 3 PagesIt demands discipline. It builds character. It teaches team spirit and unquestioning obedience to authority, qualities needed for men in the military going to defend American
The Journey Of Colonel Shaw
919 Words | 4 PagesThis approach to training was necessary for several reasons. Firstly, the soldiers of the 54th were inexperienced and had never been in battle before. By creating a realistic training environment, Colonel Shaw was preparing them for the challenges and dangers they would face in combat. 6.
Ap Psychology Midterm Study Guide
903 Words | 4 PagesSkinner in 1938.Operant conditioning is a form of learning which explains the relation of behaviors on certain rewards and consequences. The study of the theory only deals with expressible behaviors and not any internal mental thoughts and brain mechanisms. Operant Conditioning works by applying two major concepts, Reinforcements and Punishments, after the behavior is executed, which causes the rate of behavior to increase or decrease. Skinner’s Skinner box experiment with a rat is the base for operant conditioning theory and its concepts. The main principle comprises changing environmental events that are related to a person's behavior.
Summary Of Unmaking Men By Kathleen Barry
1798 Words | 8 PagesIt might have a strong influence on future of the military culture. - Military training needs to be intense. But proper care needs to be taken that it should not be devoid of empathy. A certain preconditioning may soften up and facilitate some aspects of military training. The main objective of military is total compliance in service towards the mission.
Free Will In Opening Skinner's Box By Lauren Slater
612 Words | 3 PagesThis is the idea that people's behavior is based off of the consequences and reinforcements one receives. Slater agrees when she says, “Operant conditioning- a cold phrase for a concept that might really mean we are sculptors and sculpted, artist and artwork, responsible for the prompts we fashion.” (29). I making this comment Slater is agreeing that people are always in one of two positions. One is either the controller, giving reinforcements, or the controlled receiving the consequences they are given for their actions.
Harry Foxx Case Study
1206 Words | 5 PagesOperant conditioning is a type of learning process where the strength of a client’s behavior is modified by reinforcement or punishment. Dr. Foxx’s work with Harry is an example of operant conditioning because of the techniques he used with different levels of consequences, for example time out and physical reinforcements. With that being said Dr. Foxx used Harrys restraints as both positive and negative reinforcements. In addition, some of the examples Dr. Foxx used to work with Harrys problem behavior
Mr. Byrne's Operant Conditioning
443 Words | 2 PagesOperant conditioning is a condition in which the desired behavior or increasingly closer to the approximations to it are followed by a rewarding or reinforcing stimulus. “The fundamental principle of operant conditioning is that behavior is determined by its consequences. Behavior does not occur as isolated and unrelated events; the consequences that follow the actions of an animal, be they good, bad, or indifferent, will have an effect on the frequency with which those actions are repeated in the future,” (Laule 2). A reinforcement strengthens a response, reinforcement
Explain What It Means To Be Well Educated
525 Words | 3 PagesOr do you want a Soldier that can act automonously, take a task at hand with vague instruction and figure out the intention behind it. There has been much debate on the benefits of Outcome Based Training and Education (OBT&E) versus the traditional method of Performance Oriented Training and the discipline and “Attention to Detail” which it provided. II. A. In 2009, the United States Military Academy introduced Outcome Based Training and Education in order
Summary Of On Killing By Dave Grossman
1239 Words | 5 PagesThe use of operant conditioning on soldiers first came into play after World War II and the results of this conditioning were first seen in the Vietnam war. We know this because the book states “there is evidence to indicate that this is one of the key ingredients in a methodology that has raised the firing rate from 15 to 20 percent in World War II to 90 to 95 percent in Vietnam” (pg.318). This increase in the firing rate among soldiers from World War II to Vietnam can be attributed to the operant conditioning methods the army introduced such as replacing bullseye shooting targets with realistic human silhouettes to mimic actual war scenarios. Another way in which armies incorporate operant conditioning into their training is through repetition, whether it is in the gun range or in personal training, the goal is to make that action become automatic when the soldier needs it. An example of this is found in the book “The Vietnam era was, of course then at its peak, you know, the kill thing.
Cultural Competency In The Military
892 Words | 4 PagesSoldiers are being asked to operate in very complex situations on today’s modern battlefield; therefore preparedness for a myriad of missions requires a high level of training. As a former observer controller who has worked at a combat training center for over three years, I can say that these training scenarios are very real and designed to push leaders and their Soldiers to the limits prior to completion. As trainers of the unit, we were required to develop scenarios around a unit’s particular future mission in order to validate their standard operating procedures. This validation was designed to stimulate creative learning/problem solving in an environment where the bullets are not real and the wounds were non-life threatening. The Army understood early on, in order to defeat an enemy that was very skilled in information operations/dissemination, we must become culturally involved.
Joint Force Essay
911 Words | 4 PagesAccordingly, they are the most important things a unit does. The Army must focus on three strategic ends for training the Total Force: training units to be versatile and ready to support combatant commanders worldwide;and holding commanders responsible for the development and execution of progressive, challenging and realistic training guided by the doctrine of mission command. The outcome of these efforts will be more adaptive forces capable of achieving regional alignment or mission tailoring as required. Training for operational adaptability will take place at home station and combat training centers, in Army institutions and while deployed. During this critical transition period, Army leaders must recognize that problems do not have predetermined solutions, so training and leader development must continue to foster creativity at every
Compare And Contrast Operant Conditioning And Classical Conditioning
1404 Words | 6 PagesBasically, operant conditioning involves reinforcement or punishment as the way of changes in behaviour or pattern permanently. Operant describes as voluntary response of living organism. The individual response is affected by the later consequences. In short, it is just an easy process of learning that tends to response more when the outcome is manipulated. Operant conditioning was found by Polish neurophysiologist Jerzy Konorsky.
Explain The Key Features Of The Behaviourist Perspective
860 Words | 4 PagesClassical conditioning is a strength of the behaviourist perspective. It’s a type of conditioning and learning process in which something (conditioned stimulus) that has not previously produced a response becomes associated with something (unconditioned stimulus) that produces the response. As result, the conditioned stimulus will obtain the response that the unconditioned stimulus produces. Two stimuli are linked together to produce a new learned response in a personal or
John B. Watson's Theory Of Behaviorism
1558 Words | 7 PagesThis school of thought suggests that only observable behaviors should be studied, since internal states such as cognitions, emotions and moods are too subjective. There are two major types of conditioning: 1. Classical conditioning is a technique used in behavioral training in which a naturally occurring stimulus is paired with a response. Next, a previously neutral stimulus is paired with the naturally occurring stimulus.
Theories Of Behaviorism
1623 Words | 7 PagesMr. B.F Skinner’s brought Operant Conditioning into existence. The Operant Conditioning is command feedback with recompense/ penalizing system based on a behavior. The learner requires to strengthen to maintain interests.
More about Pros And Cons Of Operant Military Conditioning
College Football Teams Should Go Semi-Pro Analysis
736 Words | 3 PagesThe Journey Of Colonel Shaw
919 Words | 4 PagesAp Psychology Midterm Study Guide
903 Words | 4 PagesSummary Of Unmaking Men By Kathleen Barry
1798 Words | 8 PagesFree Will In Opening Skinner's Box By Lauren Slater
612 Words | 3 PagesHarry Foxx Case Study
1206 Words | 5 PagesMr. Byrne's Operant Conditioning
443 Words | 2 PagesExplain What It Means To Be Well Educated
525 Words | 3 PagesSummary Of On Killing By Dave Grossman
1239 Words | 5 PagesCultural Competency In The Military
892 Words | 4 PagesJoint Force Essay
911 Words | 4 PagesCompare And Contrast Operant Conditioning And Classical Conditioning
1404 Words | 6 PagesExplain The Key Features Of The Behaviourist Perspective
860 Words | 4 PagesJohn B. Watson's Theory Of Behaviorism
1558 Words | 7 PagesTheories Of Behaviorism
1623 Words | 7 Pages