ipl-logo

Pros And Cons Of Preimplantation Genetic Screening

837 Words4 Pages

According to the Advanced Fertility of Chicago: “PGD, preimplantation genetic diagnosis, is the process of removing a cell from an in vitro fertilization embryo for genetic testing before transferring the embryo to the uterus.” In other words, genetic testing can be utilized to test for chromosomal normalcy and/or possible genetic-inherited diseases. Those people in favor of the process can be characterized by others as eugenicist, a person who aims to improve the genetic standard of the human race. This causes those to be opposed to the PGD practices, as in their eyes, they are immoral. I, however, disagree with those beliefs, as PGD is not on any path to beginning ‘designer babies.’ Preimplantation genetic screening should not be seen as a controversial topic, as fears against it are discouraging medical research and the fact that it is used to prevent illness and disease. …show more content…

Two contentions in opposition to my claim would be declarations that preimplantation genetic diagnosis can lead to the controversial ‘designer babies,’ and that PGD is unnatural. Designer babies are future, science-fictional, and would be genetically altered to be beautiful, without illness or disease, and highly intelligent. It is a media-hyped topic with more fiction than science. These people think about the topic differently than I, as they are not yet caught up on the progress of the field. According to Carole Wegner, “Frankly, we don’t know which genes to pick, if we could pick them and how and when to turn them on etc etc. And even if we could ... there’s this little thing called environment and self-determination that would foil that game plan.” Basically, we are quite a ways from physically being able to go in and know how to change the genetics of embryos. Additionally, the

Show More
Related

  • Rhetorical Analysis: Are We Asking Our Scientists To Play God

    1791 Words  | 8 Pages

    Mankind has always been motivated by the desire for progress, accomplishment, and empowerment. The exceptionally steep rate of technological development during the twentieth century starting with the invention of the zeppelin in 1900 and advancing to the creation of more sophisticated technologies such as the world wide web is evidence of this truth. In the midst of all of these impressive innovations, biological scientists developed recombinant DNA techniques that gave them the power to alter genetic material. As biotechnology has become more refined and the application of genetic engineering in both agricultural and medical fields has become more common, the practice has fallen victim to harsh scientific and ethical scrutiny. The debate is

    Read More

  • Suzy Wnuck: Chapter 4, Reasons, And Conclusions

    542 Words  | 3 Pages

    The public is opposed when screening includes traits unrelated to health diseases such as the selection of hair and eye color, height and other enhanced characteristics. 4. Many want the government to determine and set in place what is acceptable and unacceptable in Pre-implantation genetic

    Read More

  • Science Vs. Progress In The Progressive Era

    897 Words  | 4 Pages

    In today’s world, you can have your baby with blue eyes, perfect height, and how you want your baby to look when is old. Now we can even make a baby be born smart because now scientists are more specialized in genetic and how the genes work. For example, if women can’t have babies she can rent a belly from another woman so she can have the baby but the baby is going to have the DNA of the women who can’t have babies, not of the other woman. Is pretty impressive how today scientist can modify genetically the genes of babies before they are even born. Now in today’s world is almost possible to create the perfect baby if we want.

    Read More

  • Non Identity Headache

    1635 Words  | 7 Pages

    The Non Identity Headache Ethics and morality are the backbone of our society, taking different forms, whether it be religion, science, or other personal beliefs, it lays down a golden rule of what is and what isn’t acceptable. However, morality becomes difficult to apply to controversial topics, especially those such as pre-birth human enhancement and human reproductive cloning due to the fact that it applies to other humans. One of the most important topics that arise from discussing these issues is the Non Identity Problem. In order to try and provide reasoning for both pre-birth enhancement and human reproductive cloning, I will first explain what the Non Identity Issue is and its relation to genetics, then explain how it may affect one’s

    Read More

  • Gattaca Argumentative Essay

    260 Words  | 2 Pages

    In the science fiction movie Gattaca, Vincent Freeman was conceived the normal way. He spent all of his life dreaming of being able to go out into space. In order to make his dream come true, Vincent has to trick the system and ‘transform’ into a valid, or someone who was conceived through invitro fertilization. The society discriminated against those who were conceived the normal way. If I were given the opportunity to genetically engineer my child I would because I could ensure that my child would not obtain and illness and my child would fit into the society.

    Read More

  • Summary Of Steven Pinker's Defense Of Dangerous Ideas

    1048 Words  | 5 Pages

    As a society we are adapting, changing, and growing every day. Genetic modification is happening; many people are just not aware. Genetic engineering is great for society because it can cause many new advancements for the as in world with no diseases and a world without hunger. “There is a good case for exploring all ideas relevant to our current concerns, no matter where they lead” (Pinker 533). Although no one knows how far genetic enhancing and cloning could go makes it a dangerous idea, does not mean as a society that we ignore it.

    Read More

  • Genetic Testing Ethics

    878 Words  | 4 Pages

    M6D1 Ethics and Genetic Testing As we all can agree, our genes play a highly important role in making us who we are as humans. If the information produce by genes is normal than everything can turn out normal and infants can be born healthy. There are those incidents the genetic information produce by genes is wrong and results of this information can lead to injury, disease, and/or illness of the fetus (Munson, 2012).

    Read More

  • The Pros And Cons Of Pre-Implantation Genetic Diagnosis

    1077 Words  | 5 Pages

    When it is decided what is a ‘human’ then at whatever stage the embryo or baby is at then the treatment is considered to be under human rights. During the process of PGD instead of being implanted into the mother some embryos are often discarded due to them have inheritable disorders or abnormalities which could affect the offspring. For an individual who believes that a human starts when it is an embryo, the discarding of the unfavourable embryos after the results of PGD could be suggested that it is murder. This is where PGD becomes an ethical issue because is it morally acceptable to terminate a fertilised embryo which could otherwise if implanted live a happy and healthy life? Where is the fine between a human and an embryo and what is the limitation in which the process of PGD should not happen?

    Read More

  • Prenatal Screening

    1488 Words  | 6 Pages

    Farmers and ranchers have been manipulating genes for plants and animals well before gene sequencing and molecular techniques were practiced. The size of a grapefruit and coloring on cattle may be attributed to the former. With new knowledge about animal and plant genomes, scientists can now delicately screen, edit, and splice genes for varying reasons. This paper intends to explore some of the more common techniques in genetic engineering (prenatal screening, gene manipulation, and cloning) for humans and the ethical issues surrounding them. Genetic technique and screening has entered the medical scene in numerous countries.

    Read More

  • Prenatal Testing Argumentative Essay

    1171 Words  | 5 Pages

    Prenatal genetic testing has been a source of controversy over the past few years, and is increasing as medical technology develops. The arguments supporting prenatal testing verses advocates that are pro life no matter what, is under great pressure to decide if prenatal tests are ethical. Bonnie Steinbock, a professor of Health Policy and Philosophy at the University of Albany, and Hank Greely, head of Stanford’s center for Law and Biosciences, both argue against prenatal genetic testing. They both believe that prenatal testing can promote abortion. Although they both share the same viewpoint on how individuals should not use prenatal testing, Greely writes a more persuading and convincing argument due to fewer fallacies.

    Read More

  • Pros And Cons Of Eugenics

    722 Words  | 3 Pages

    No collection of mortal men should be put in charge of who is worthy of reproducing or not. Eugenics was not formally put into effect for a reason. Other routes can be taken to improve the future generations without depriving the living humans of their right to have

    Read More

  • Argumentative Essay: The Ethics Of Designer Babies

    1584 Words  | 7 Pages

    However, many scientists say this is already possible in a much safer and less invasive way. It is far easier to genetically screen embryos for high-risk versions of genes following in vitro fertilization and prior to implantation in the mother. Not to mention, we already practice this as a society, for example, when smart rich people marry other smart rich people, they usually produce another generation of smart rich people; which is known as assortative mating. Another example is when a mother aborts a fetus that has a genetic defect, or when IVF

    Read More

  • Designer Babies In Aldous Huxley's Brave New World

    2065 Words  | 9 Pages

    Doing the procedure undermines evolution and could even reverse it. The reason humans have been so popular in terms of surviving and reproducing is due to the genetic diversity given to them from two million years of evolution. Now, not everyone will look exactly the same, but most will be pretty, healthy, and smart because almost everyone has the same idea of what a “better” human is (“Designer Babies: The Good and the Bad”). Almost no parent who would go through with the procedure would choose an ugly and dumb child.

    Read More

  • Summary: The Ethical Dilemma Of Designer Babies

    1192 Words  | 5 Pages

    “Where do babies come from?” Every child at one point or another will ask this classic question. Depending on the age of the child, some parents will tell the story of the stork, or if they feel it is morally wrong to lie to their child, they will just say “when two people love each other.” Sooner or later, either through mischievous friends or eventually from their parents, a child will learn the biological development of a baby. They then believe this is the only way a baby is created- simple and easy.

    Read More

  • Human Cloning Be Banned Essay

    862 Words  | 4 Pages

    “The main arguments against genetic modification of human embryos are that it would be unsafe and unfair, and that modification would quickly go beyond efforts to reduce the incidence of inherited maladies” (Caplan). During the altering genes in the mother 's womb cause a lot of dangerous situations and

    Read More

More about Pros And Cons Of Preimplantation Genetic Screening

Open Document