ipl-logo

Pros And Cons Of Submerged Social Welfare Programs

738 Words3 Pages

The submerged state has been growing in recent history and has resulted in negative implications for American society. The “submerged state” is a term coined by Cornell University Political Scientist Suzanne Mettler which describes federal social welfare policies policies that, by design, are not very visible to citizens. Social welfare policies are designed to reduce the economic insecurity and inequality generated by capitalist markets and were created to provide assistance and services to the neediest individuals and families, including temporary assistance due to job loss or injury, and to assure economic security in old age (Heerwig, 10/6). Examples of social welfare policies include food stamps, veterans’ benefits, and Medicare and …show more content…

For example, 53.3% of people with student loans were not aware that they were benefiting from a government social program (Mettler, 809). This leaves Americans in an unfavorable predicament. If people are unaware that submerged social welfare programs exist, they can not take advantage of them and are much more likely not to support them. The problems with submerged social welfare programs extend even further, as there are many cases of policies that are ineffective in aiding people who need them the most. Furthermore, people who are not aware of bad social welfare policies are not in a position to fight for their removal. For example, the home-mortgage interest deduction is ineffective because it costs the government over 100 billion dollars a year to maintain, yet it benefits the wealthy much more than it benefits the poor (McCabe, 10/8). This is unfortunately not an aberration as many of these submerged policies benefit the rich much more than they benefit the poor. Mettler says, “Most of the submerged state benefits high income people the most, even if a lot of middle income people receive some benefits from these same policies” (Shannon, 5:19). Many of these submerged social welfare policies are helping the affluent more than the disadvantaged, which makes them a waste of tax

Show More
Related

  • Social Welfare Flaws

    1111 Words  | 5 Pages

    The U.S Government has social welfare systems that supports lower class in need. From home providing programs like “Welfare” and “Section 8 housing” to food providing programs like “Food Stamps” and “WIC “( Women, Infants, and Children ). The U.S government economy has declined immensely over the years resulting in a high unemployment rate and very high market pricing. Therefor, theres a very large group of people who are struggling financially, in need of food or shelter, cant find a job, income cant support their kids, etc .. Also there is an additional group of people mainly immigrants who simply struggle to speak the language and can’t really find there place in this country.

    Read More

  • Myth Surrounding Welfare

    189 Words  | 1 Pages

    The article addresses the myth surrounding welfare. Americans common belief government's aid enhances corruption among poor people has its roots in the past —even Franklin Delano Roosevelt considered welfare “a narcotic, a subtle destroyer of the human spirit.” However, recent statistics highlights the beneficial’ effects of cash assistance for the poor. The welfare positively impacts the life of children, improving the quality of their nutrition and education. Moreover, in a moment of great economic recession the welfare is the only net that can support people in need.

    Read More

  • Welfare Reform In America

    1113 Words  | 5 Pages

    In the words of welfare policy experts Robert Rector and Jennifer Marshall writing in National Affairs: Material poverty has been replaced by a far deeper “behavioral poverty” — a vicious cycle of unwed childbearing, social dysfunction, and welfare dependency in poor communities. Even as the welfare state has improved the material comfort of low-income Americans by transferring enormous financial resources to them, it has exacerbated these behavioral problems. The result has been the disintegration of the work ethic, family structure, and social fabric of large segments of the American population, which has in turn created a new dependency class. Is this the America we want? It is not compassionate to leave a whole class of people in perpetual dependence.

    Read More

  • Rebecca M. Blank's Welfare Reform

    664 Words  | 3 Pages

    Since the money is taken out of citizens checks, the people have no problem voicing their opinion on the matter as they do most topics involving how tax money is used. There are people who are in favor of welfare and those who are opposed. Rebecca M. Blank, currently the chancellor of the University of Wisconsin-Madison, is one who is skeptically in favor of welfare. She has written several books

    Read More

  • Welfare System Abuse

    641 Words  | 3 Pages

    If another person relies that you are getting paid without working, they are going to think that they can do the same. They are now able to collect money from the working class, for as long, as they are unemployed, for doing nothing. After a while, welfare recipients may get the mentality that won’t ever have to work again. Why? Because the government keeps robbing tax payers of their money and handing it to individuals who feel the need to do nothing because they know they will still get money regardless.

    Read More

  • What Donald Trump Doesn T Understand About Welfare By Brian Hanley

    955 Words  | 4 Pages

    Hanley wrote this article in order to persuade his readers that welfare is a very crucial part of some people’s lives, and Donald Trump should not cut its funding. In order to achieve this, Hanley makes use of statistics and facts throughout the article explaining how beneficial social welfare truly is. He conducted research and credited most of his findings to historian Michael B. Katz of the University of Pennsylvania. In the article, he states that there was a 60% decline of people living in poverty between 1960 and 1980 due to social welfare. He also states that between these

    Read More

  • What Is The Welfare Reform Act Of 1996 By Barbara Ehrenreich

    517 Words  | 3 Pages

    The Welfare Reform Act of 1996 was a landmark legislation that drastically altered how the U.S. government approached poverty. Passed during Bill Clinton's presidency, the reform aimed to decrease the dependency on state support by promoting self-reliance and employment among the populace. This initiative gave birth to the Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF) program. However, despite the seemingly positive intentions, the Act arguably created a plethora of issues. In fact, many have criticized the reform for its unrealistic assumptions about the reality of poverty in America.

    Read More

  • How Has Ronald Reagan Impacted Society

    1373 Words  | 6 Pages

    During Reagan’s Presidency, he reduced many welfare programs that he believed were taken advantage of, such as job training and unemployment insurance benefits (Chidester and Knott). Reagan benefitted modern society through his change in the welfare system by reducing programs that related to careers so that people who were capable of helping themselves but chose not to do so, stopped receiving assistance from the government. This began a trend with following presidents to better the welfare system in order to benefit society. Ronald Reagan pushes the idea to adjust welfare when he says, “The irony is that misguided welfare programs instituted in the name of compassion have actually helped turn a shrinking problem into a national tragedy” (“Welfare Reform”). During Reagan’s radio address on February 15, 1986, he extended his thoughts on how welfare has caused poverty, a problem that was once shrinking, to explode across the United States.

    Read More

  • Essay On Welfare Drug Testing

    1317 Words  | 6 Pages

    When times get rough it meant work harder, but now thats in the past. Today when life gets tough it means go Welfare. Welfare is a widely abused program, for example, nationwide there are millions of Americans that receive welfare from the government. (“Welfare Drug Testing”). It is very important that our taxes aren’t going to people who repeatedly and purposefully choose to abuse the welfare program.

    Read More

  • Synthesis Essay: Welfare Keeps America Alive

    788 Words  | 4 Pages

    Welfare Keeps America Alive Public assistance, or welfare, defines itself as a public or private social service aimed towards assisting those who are inclined to be more disadvantaged than the general population. Public assistance helps these disadvantaged by providing a minimal but steady income from organizations, such as the TANF (temporary assistance for needy families) or the SSI (supplemental security income).These organizations help the struggling to regain their previous successes thus, creating a better stabilized economy. Public assistance is needed due to the increasing poverty rates in the United States caused by unemployment and physical disabilities. A common misconception made about welfare is that anyone who applies for the assistance automatically becomes a recipient.

    Read More

  • Welfare Drug Testing Essay

    1104 Words  | 5 Pages

    However, the receivers of several different government handouts, such as farmers, college students, and wealthy home-owner, do not realize they are getting their benefits because we are given them in ways that allow us to tell ourselves that we get nothing. “Political scientist Suzanne Mettler has called this effect the “submerged state” (Badger). Whereas Schaberg provides ample evidence that drug testing welfare recipients is unconstitutional, it is actually Badger’s research on the double standard which convinces me that if those on welfare are drug tested, everyone else receiving benefits from the government should be as

    Read More

  • Disparities In Social Welfare

    707 Words  | 3 Pages

    Introduction Disparities in social welfare has long been an issue affecting minority and structurally disadvantaged groups in America. These populations can be described as socially and economically lagging behind the majority of their other social counterparts. This state often further restricts their opportunities for advancement. Although accomplishments in increasing the economic capabilities of minority groups have led to significant progress in the social and economic welfare for disadvantaged populations, crucial issues are still not adequately addressed and the progress made is far from the goals of many social welfare organizations seeking to uplift disadvantaged populations to acquire sustainable and prosperous living. Opportunities

    Read More

  • Social Welfare Dbq

    530 Words  | 3 Pages

    The social welfare has been a debatable argument for year in the U.S, many since the people have different beliefs in the welfare policy. Many time being is that the federal government had chosen to stay away from social welfare while also choosing to be heavily involved with it, making the federal agencies heavily involved in policy making. Since poverty was considered a problem, they believe that the problem would get better within time if there was a sudden change to make anti-poverty programs. In the great depression 1930’s the local and state government provided support for the poor, many assistances coming from churches were people would receive free food and agencies supplying the size of aid available to them.

    Read More

  • Camden Chronicles Children In Urban Poverty Summary

    1002 Words  | 5 Pages

    A lot of people who are critics of the welfare programs argue that people are poor because they are lazy and they live off government handouts but that is not the truth at all. As we can see from the video, most of the

    Read More

  • Essay On The Challenges Facing America Today

    826 Words  | 4 Pages

    Today in American society, countless people feel that they are entitled to everything no matter what. People who abuse the welfare system is a perfect example of how people believe that they deserve everything without having to actually do any work, causing laziness and selfishness. These individuals misuse welfare that helps countless people by taking the money for individuals who can’t support themselves or can’t find a job, and use it as a way to get free money without working. Another problem is that some of the youth demands respect of others without earning it and expect a successful job right out

    Read More

More about Pros And Cons Of Submerged Social Welfare Programs

Open Document