Pros And Cons Of The Shareholder And Stakeholder Debate
5. CRITICAL ANALYSIS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
5.2 The Shareholder-Stakeholder debate
There is no doubt that the shareholder and stakeholder theories are both dominant theories of corporate governance. Having already discussed the pros and cons of each theory, it is now important to analyse the debate arising to be able to determine which of the two will enable better corporate governance. First of all, it is important to highlight that this debate has emerged over the last decade and has always been a concern for most advocates of good corporate governance.
Globalisation of capital markets, greater shareholder activism, rise of institutional investors and profitability and wealth maximization as the main objectives of corporation have always lead to the acceptance of the shareholder theory as an effective theory of corporate governance. Indeed, one of the perceived strengths of this theory is that it is workable and practicable. This is because of the fixed objective of managers which is to take into account the interests of the shareholders only and failure to do so might result into derivative actions being taken against them. Nevertheless, most of the arguments proposed in favour of this theory fail to sustain it. Under corporate law, more specifically the separate legal personality principle, the company is considered to be a separate person from its shareholders. Thus, at no point can the shareholders claim to be owners of the company. Because of the same reasoning,
Why Are Stakeholders Important In Healthcare
133 Words | 1 PagesSome of the important stakeholders include: internal (executive and senior management, such as CFO, CEO, CNIO, CMIO, CIO, departmental directors), interphase (focus groups representing front line clinicians, pharmacists, nurses, other allied healthcare professionals) and external ( e.g. government regulatory bodies, patients, accreditation associations). As a stakeholder is any individual that can affect or be affected by the CIS deployment, it is important to identify and engaging them early on is critical to the latter success. The interphase stakeholders know best the workflows at the point of care and will help identify a system that is compatible with the needs and has functionality that is in line with the processes. The internal stakeholders
Advantages And Disadvantages Of Non Compete Agreements
1006 Words | 5 PagesNowadays, more employers require new workers to sign “Non-Compete Agreements”, in order to prevent insiders from taking consumers’ data, business secrets or newly researched technologies to competing firms when the workers leave. A non-compete agreement is a contract between an employee and employer that confines the ability of workers to involve in business which competes with their current employer. The agreement is most often signed at the beginning of employment. It puts a limit on the employee to not work for a competitor company immediately after leaving their employment with the current company.
What Are The Pros And Cons Of Corporate Sponsorship
612 Words | 3 PagesSynthesis Essay: Corporate Sponsorship Corporate businesses sponsor just about everything: professional sports teams and stadiums, theaters, music halls, dance performances, art galleries, museums. Everywhere you look you will see ads for energy drinks, make-up, radio shows, you name it. Though sponsorship is for the most part accepted in everyday life, corporate sponsorship in high school can be controversial. There are both pros and cons to it. It benefits the schools by providing much needed funding especially for art and music programs.
Dick Smith Failure Case Study
1023 Words | 5 PagesThe Failure of Dick Smith Electronics Identify: How the latest edition (3rd) of the ASX Corporate Governance Principles plausibly halts the failure of Dick Smith Electronics (DSE) will be discussed in this essay. I argue that 3rd of ASX Corporate Governance Principles might not be the best corporate governance practices for the listed entities in Australia. As can be seen from the DSE case, it complied with the majority of the principles and recommendations, but the DSE’s collapse still happened. Therefore, the better application of this practices should be developed.
Market Revolution Pros And Cons
1236 Words | 5 PagesThe market revolution, which started in 1815, transformed worker lives, and improved the nation vastly; although it also dropped the economy as well. The traditional market, which was based upon power generated by animals and water, was slow in activities such as transportation. The growing nation underwent peace, which then catalyzed the reform of the organization of the economy. As such, transportation was heavily improved upon, along with manufacturing, banking, and commercial law. However, there were also two panics during the time that occurred that led to many Americans who were anxious and uncertain about working in the country.
Richard Graeter's Stakeholders
259 Words | 2 PagesA Stakeholder is any individual who has a vested interest in a business and is affected by the organisations decisions and strategies (Pride, Hughes & Kapoor 2015, p. 10). Therefore, the people most affected by Graeter’s decisions to take a long term view of the business rather than aim for short term profits are the family members who have a stake in the business. At the present, Richard Graeter II (CEO), Robert Graeter (vice president of operations) and Chip Graeter (vice president of retail operations) manage the business and are responsible for all the decisions regarding its operations. Graeter’s management team have chosen to forgo the opportunity for short term profits by adhering to the traditional manufacturing process used by Louis
Stakeholder Salience Theory Case Study
1043 Words | 5 PagesThe Stakeholder Salience Theory, created by Mitchell, Agle and Wood, are based upon the combination of the three relationship attributes to generate general types of stakeholders. These attributes include: Power; Legitimacy; Urgency. “Stakeholder salience” is defined as the degree to which managers give priority to competing stakeholder claims. Therefore if a stakeholder consist of all three attributes, he/she/it will be of most importance and will have more rights and privileges than a stakeholder that consists of only one of the three attributes. As seen in the picture on the right, you can differentiate between the different types of stakeholders, according to where they get placed given the attributes they consist of.
Stakeholder Analysis Body Shop
941 Words | 4 PagesIntroduction This case study explores the acquisition of the Body Shop, which is one of the largest franchise cosmetics companies in the world, by L’Oreal. The main concentration of the case study aims at investigating the impact on business ethics and corporate social responsibility by the concentricity of the Body Shop and L’Oreal and how the general attitude and buying behaviour is distorted in the course of this acquisition. L‘Oreal being the big conglomerate in the cosmetics industry acquired the Body Shop International which is comparably small but having iconic brand of environmental and socially responsible concerns, on 17 March 2006, through a covenant of $1.2 billion. The combination of two brands in a newly formed conglomerate implies a combination of values, principles and associations that might affect a company’s appeal. The verity that L 'Oreal 's acquisition of the Body Shop provides plenty of potential growth opportunities is undeniable; nevertheless the question of how well the acquisition sits in the group of the world 's largest cosmetics company is another matter.
M1 Unit 1 Business Essay
1245 Words | 5 PagesIn this assignment I am going to discuss the stakeholders of two contrasting business’. Sainsbury’s: One important stakeholder is owners. The owners of Sainsbury’s they have it in their best interest to make the business as successful as possible by setting aims and objectives for themselves and their employees. They want to make the most profit they possibly can whilst keeping their customers and suppliers happy.
Ritz Carlton Business Analysis
840 Words | 4 PagesOwners: who have to be able to provide the resources to set up the strategy, they are on the back office but are important decision-makers. They are involved in optimising the company’s profit. Investors: they provide money to help the company to get enough resources to set up the strategy.
Two Types Of Stakeholder Analysis Of Mcdonalds
755 Words | 4 PagesStakeholder analysis Stakeholder are entity that will affect the organization actions, objectives and policies. There are two types of stakeholder which is internal stakeholder and external stakeholder. The McDonald’s stakeholders are customers, suppliers, employees, managers, government, local communities and pressure groups. Customers Customers are the external stakeholders of the company, no customer mean zero profit.
Pros And Cons Of Shareholder Activism
919 Words | 4 PagesIn recent years, activist shareholders and their influence on organisations has become a very important and highly debated issue. According to Smith (1996), shareholder activism refers to monitoring, controlling and attempting to influence or change the organisational control structure of companies that do not tend to pursue the goal of shareholder wealth maximization. One of the major tendencies of shareholders to vote against the excessive remuneration packages of the chief executives of top British firms was noticed in the spring of 2012 and eventually, this incident was called "Shareholder Spring" . While some analyst disagree over the extent to which an increased shareholder activism in "shareholder spring" had effect on the way UK organisations are governed, it is believed that that attempts of shareholders to
Stakeholder Theory
997 Words | 4 PagesThe History of Business Ethics and Stakeholder Theory in America Ethics play a huge role in the global business field, since considerations have to be made on moral practices, values, and judgments that govern the direction and overall success of the company. Consequently, over the progression of history, managers, entrepreneurs, and stakeholders at the helm of organizations have always had the mandate of making moral resolves on matters of ethics. According to Hunter (2003), such an approach to ethical behavior prompts a substantial growth in the organizational corporation, as well as maximizing business profits, and creating a reputable company image (Cutler, 2004). Notably, the overall performances of organizations that take part in unethical
Role Of Stakeholders In Aviation
963 Words | 4 Pages3. Stakeholders: Definition:A person, group or organisation that has interest or concern in an organisation. Stakeholders can affect or be affected by the organisation 's actions, objectives and policies. Some examples of key stakeholders are creditors, directors, employees, government (and its agencies), owners (shareholders), suppliers, unions, and the community from which the business draws its resources. Not all stakeholders are equal.
Role Of Corporate Governance In Nestle
1346 Words | 6 PagesA system to check and balances the benefit of all the board of directors and to avoid some of top management from making decisions that only benefit themselves is created and named corporate governance. Corporate governance means the system of rules, practices and processes by which a company is directed and controlled. The set of rules provided as a guidelines for the board of directors to make sure that accountability and fairness in a company’s relationship with its stakeholders such as financiers, customers, management, employees, shareholders and also society in order to achieve company’s goals and targets in a manner that add a value to the company. All of the stakeholders play an important role in corporate governance to ensure that
More about Pros And Cons Of The Shareholder And Stakeholder Debate
Why Are Stakeholders Important In Healthcare
133 Words | 1 PagesAdvantages And Disadvantages Of Non Compete Agreements
1006 Words | 5 PagesWhat Are The Pros And Cons Of Corporate Sponsorship
612 Words | 3 PagesDick Smith Failure Case Study
1023 Words | 5 PagesMarket Revolution Pros And Cons
1236 Words | 5 PagesRichard Graeter's Stakeholders
259 Words | 2 PagesStakeholder Salience Theory Case Study
1043 Words | 5 PagesStakeholder Analysis Body Shop
941 Words | 4 PagesM1 Unit 1 Business Essay
1245 Words | 5 PagesRitz Carlton Business Analysis
840 Words | 4 PagesTwo Types Of Stakeholder Analysis Of Mcdonalds
755 Words | 4 PagesPros And Cons Of Shareholder Activism
919 Words | 4 PagesStakeholder Theory
997 Words | 4 PagesRole Of Stakeholders In Aviation
963 Words | 4 PagesRole Of Corporate Governance In Nestle
1346 Words | 6 Pages