Welfare Dependency: Social Disorganization Perspective
Introduction
To discuss about welfare dependency, I would like to use social disorganization perspective for my argument. Welfare dependency means that many poor mainland immigrants or the people who are poor but they have basic ability for work or maintain their daily life, however they only depend on the welfare provision from government such as Comprehensive Social Security Assistance(CSSA). As welfare dependency seems a problem affect to Hong Kong’s economy, I may explain the problem through social disorganization perspective and to find out the welfare dependency’s major problem. On the other hand, I am going to explain how the social disorganization perspective help us to explain not “only lazy people would live on CSSA” (Leung, 1998)and
…show more content…
Welfare dependency was a social problem that start from 1997. After 1997, the CSSA cases are increasing in the few year. In 1998, Leung Kin Pong who is the social welfare department president at that time said “only lazy people would live on CSSA.” This quotations let the people who need to pay for tax and the people who get CSSA feel angry and have some conflict from in the society. Poverty, lower class and unemployment think can’t maintain their life so they need to get CSSA but they think government should not think they are the lazy people and the people who need to pay tax think the lazy people wasted their money for maintain a group of lazy people’s life. Also, we can see there are some description of “avoid people over relied or depended on the CSSA from the Social Welfare Department’s …show more content…
We can see the economy development in Hong Kong was quickly increase for around 2% per year. However, the Asia Financial Crisis have affected Hong Kong’s economy a lot. The Asia Financial Crisis was beginning in July 1997 it let Hong Kong’s GDP have decreased around 6%. Furthermore, the unemployment rate have increased about 5% in 1997-1998. There was around 70,000 people have lost their work. According to the statistic, we can see there is 70,000 people have no income but only increased 40,000 CSSA cases in 1997-1998. I think we can prove that there were somebody have lost their work but not rely or “live on
Social Welfare Flaws
1111 Words | 5 PagesThe U.S Government has social welfare systems that supports lower class in need. From home providing programs like “Welfare” and “Section 8 housing” to food providing programs like “Food Stamps” and “WIC “( Women, Infants, and Children ). The U.S government economy has declined immensely over the years resulting in a high unemployment rate and very high market pricing. Therefor, theres a very large group of people who are struggling financially, in need of food or shelter, cant find a job, income cant support their kids, etc .. Also there is an additional group of people mainly immigrants who simply struggle to speak the language and can’t really find there place in this country.
Welfare Reform In America
1113 Words | 5 PagesIn the words of welfare policy experts Robert Rector and Jennifer Marshall writing in National Affairs: Material poverty has been replaced by a far deeper “behavioral poverty” — a vicious cycle of unwed childbearing, social dysfunction, and welfare dependency in poor communities. Even as the welfare state has improved the material comfort of low-income Americans by transferring enormous financial resources to them, it has exacerbated these behavioral problems. The result has been the disintegration of the work ethic, family structure, and social fabric of large segments of the American population, which has in turn created a new dependency class. Is this the America we want? It is not compassionate to leave a whole class of people in perpetual dependence.
Myth Surrounding Welfare
189 Words | 1 PagesThe article addresses the myth surrounding welfare. Americans common belief government's aid enhances corruption among poor people has its roots in the past —even Franklin Delano Roosevelt considered welfare “a narcotic, a subtle destroyer of the human spirit.” However, recent statistics highlights the beneficial’ effects of cash assistance for the poor. The welfare positively impacts the life of children, improving the quality of their nutrition and education. Moreover, in a moment of great economic recession the welfare is the only net that can support people in need.
Social Welfare In The 1800s
300 Words | 2 PagesThat the social welfare policies is more caring for the poor because back in the 1930's it was a largely private system of charity collapsed in the face of many because of the widespread economic destitution of the federal government which created the beginning of an American welfare state. Also the social welfare system was a new program that was put into place which gave the national government the power to oversee the programs and gave the government the security for all Americans, economic and the poor. Although the social welfare includes many different polices enacted over many years since the Great Depression which has change the system back in 1935 it was entirely private which composed of an extensive system of voluntary philanthropy
Canadian Welfare State Essay
426 Words | 2 PagesThe bridge to prosperity: The Canadian welfare state. Through the years, Canada’s security and prosperity it’s one of the most important topics between its citizens. Introduced in the Second World War, the “welfare state” aims to give an equality service, a minimum income, protection for the elders, unemployment and disabilities as in sickness. For some, the decisions made were debatable given the tough times: pogey, the Medicare program and the Canadian Pension Plan (CCP) represents an ideal standard of living an economically healthy life moreover its one of the most important values the Canadian society is built on.
Australian Welfare Reform
399 Words | 2 PagesThe Australian welfare system plays an integral role in the protection of the health and well-being of all Australian citizens. However, due to rapidly changing socio-economic factors, the Australian welfare system may not always be capable of providing just and satisfactory support to the disadvantaged. As a result, the Australian government regularly undertakes important welfare reforms by amending its social policy, in order to remunerate the faults and compensate for social changes within the Australian welfare system. In 1990 the commonwealth government expressed particular concern regarding the dramatic increase in lone parents and people with disabilities receiving pension-type payments.
Welfare State In Canada
533 Words | 3 PagesThe welfare state developed in Canada because of the influential effect of business that has a powerful relationship with the federal government, even at times where Conservative or Liberal parties were in power. Through economic development, the state helped raise the qualifications for the labour force, while reducing their expectations at the same time. Along with that, the state gave businesses its bailouts, subsidies, funding guarantees, and infrastructure, at this time. Comparing Canada and the United States helps to outline what is discrete about Canadian politics. In Canada, businesses were never exposed to the same kind of strict anti-combines rules and regulations as those found in the US.
Welfare In Colonial America
656 Words | 3 PagesDavidson states that women on welfare do not sit around or are not of specific ethnicity, but rather they find themselves penniless in certain life circumstances. They usually stay in system for couple of years and often attend schools. Some of them may return to the system, simply because the jobs pay less than welfare and have no health benefits. The second argument that Davidson presents is that “welfare encourages teen pregnancy and large dependent families” (1997). Her findings show that it is impossible to live off the welfare and the monthly allowances would not even cover the diapers’ expenses.
Social Welfare Dbq
530 Words | 3 PagesPoliticians attitudes on Poverty was to approach and prevent while also finding a solution to end poverty. The social Welfare policy is mainly the opinions of many politicians in congress, the great society was a safety net for the poorest people in Americans. But they failed to deliver the main problem that the “culture of poverty” individuals that were living in impoverished areas and were facing economic and social
Poverty In Canada Essay
549 Words | 3 PagesThe issue of poverty is multifaceted and far too broad to address in this paper, but it is important to understand its connection to social policy like the SSA. According to Chappell (2014), "poverty has no single official or universally accepted definition; every country has a different view of poverty and, even within the same country, people 's views on poverty change over time" (p. 239). Although it is hard to define, poverty is deeply entrenched in the development, implementation, and public response to Ontario 's passing of the SSA in
Social Welfare In Canada
835 Words | 4 PagesSocial Welfare Policy and Child Protection – Strength and Limitations Since last two decades Canada being experienced softer and harder forms of neo-liberal economic impetus (McKeen, 2006). Many of these reforms targeted social benefits and divided marginalized people into deserved and undeserved category (McKeen, 2006). At a large level, social policies are shaped by the exploration of dominant ideas about a social issue. Existing political views and the interest of the dominant policy community are predominantly influencing policy making (McKeen, 2006). The mainstream discourses for solutions of social problems and policy outcomes are increasingly underrepresented and narrow down the focus of social welfare in Canada (McKeen, 2006).
The Role Of Democracy In The Korean War
3004 Words | 13 PagesConsidering that Korea was one of the poorest countries in the past, Korea stood at the thirteenth place in world’s largest economy in 2007. Korea also surpassed United Sates $20,000 mark in per-capita. Both were one of the greatest achievements that Korea achieved and it shocked not just the United States but also other countries around the globe. In addition, the world saw how South Korea was included in the list of countries that were able to recover quickly and efficiently when the Asian financial crisis occurred in 1997. The recovery post the Asian financial crisis embarked their path to innovation and genuine economical
Tensions Inherent In Balancing Social Policy
291 Words | 2 Pages1.What are some of the tensions inherent in balancing social control and social treatment functions of social policy today? Social welfare policies and programs humanistically liberate and enhance the well being of many individuals. At the same time, these aiding policies posit chaos and limitations on the lives of those who seek them due to underlying economic and political agendas. Hence, creating tensions including but not limited to antithetical views on how resources should be distributed (essentially, a power imbalance), contradictions regarding an individual’s right to a free and autonomous life, negative stigmas towards individuals who need assistance and discrimination.
Argumentative Essay: Welfare Doesn T Work
831 Words | 4 PagesMillions of Americans receive government aid such as welfare every year. Of those Americans who are on welfare, many are unemployed. Some people may need welfare because they don’t make enough money to support their families. However, the amount of money spent on welfare every year is tremendous. Welfare should be taken away from those who don’t work.
Essay On The Challenges Facing America Today
826 Words | 4 PagesToday in American society, countless people feel that they are entitled to everything no matter what. People who abuse the welfare system is a perfect example of how people believe that they deserve everything without having to actually do any work, causing laziness and selfishness. These individuals misuse welfare that helps countless people by taking the money for individuals who can’t support themselves or can’t find a job, and use it as a way to get free money without working. Another problem is that some of the youth demands respect of others without earning it and expect a successful job right out
More about Welfare Dependency: Social Disorganization Perspective
Social Welfare Flaws
1111 Words | 5 PagesWelfare Reform In America
1113 Words | 5 PagesMyth Surrounding Welfare
189 Words | 1 PagesSocial Welfare In The 1800s
300 Words | 2 PagesCanadian Welfare State Essay
426 Words | 2 PagesAustralian Welfare Reform
399 Words | 2 PagesWelfare State In Canada
533 Words | 3 PagesWelfare In Colonial America
656 Words | 3 PagesSocial Welfare Dbq
530 Words | 3 PagesPoverty In Canada Essay
549 Words | 3 PagesSocial Welfare In Canada
835 Words | 4 PagesThe Role Of Democracy In The Korean War
3004 Words | 13 PagesTensions Inherent In Balancing Social Policy
291 Words | 2 PagesArgumentative Essay: Welfare Doesn T Work
831 Words | 4 PagesEssay On The Challenges Facing America Today
826 Words | 4 Pages