Pros And Cons Of Youth Restorative Justice Conferencing
CONCLUSION
Considering all the positives and negatives youth restorative justice conferencing has on the youth offenders, families and victims involved, the following research question needs to be answered:
Should youth restorative justice conferencing be made obligatory for offenders in Queensland?
If restorative justice conferencing is made obligatory, then the impacts conferencing would have on the family members and victims involved will not change from how they currently are. The only change that will occur, is that more family members will be able to support their children through the process. Along with this, more victims will be able to tell their stories, hear why the youth offender had offended, and receive support while finding a
…show more content…
While youth offenders will still have the same positive impacts, there would be additional negative impacts that arise. As more youth offenders are obligated to attend a restorative justice conference, then there may be more young people attending who are not understanding the process or what is occurring and hence are not impacted the same way someone who understands the process would be. This means that these young people would not be receiving the positive impacts youth conferencing has. Additionally, if more youth offenders are obligated to attend a conference, then an increased number of young people would be attending with the intention, not to learn from their mistakes, but simply to avoid going to jail or receiving a sentence on their criminal record. This means the youth offenders would be attending these conferences because they must, not because they want to. All the positive cases that have been seen in youth conferencing so far, have been with youth offenders who want to attend the conference and hence, are open to participating and listening to all the parties involved. If a youth offender is attending a conference because it is obligatory, the benefits that are associated with restorative justice conferencing would be eliminated and that would make the process
Summary: The Virginia Juvenile Court System
1278 Words | 6 PagesBased on these two theories, and the quest for restorative justice, the purpose of the proposed peer/youth court is to provide a positive peer atmosphere offending youths can develop pro-social behaviors. This will lead to significant reduction in re-offending and promote positive peer-to-peer
Lindsey's Lack Of Restorative Justice
1437 Words | 6 PagesEducation will be provided to the juveniles to explain the repercussions of their actions and the results of another offence. Education will also be proved to the parents/guardians to improve the home situation and how to help the juvenile take on the restorative justice program in full force. Pre-program assessments must be completed for every juvenile to be place in this restorative justice program. Assessments will be taken often during and after the programs completion. The initial assessment will be a set in place to gather background information on the juveniles family/community situation, and continuous mental, physical and
Restorative Justice Practices Meeting The Philosophical Goals Of The Juvenile Justice System
452 Words | 2 PagesThe balanced and restorative approach provides a significant change in toles and image of the juvenile justice system from a revolving door to a resource. The resource makes juvenile offenders accountable and enhances the quality of life within communities by community restoration using preventive services to help improve the safety of the community. 2-Compare and contrast the different types of restorative justice (i.e., VOM, FGC, NRB, peacemaking/sentencing circles)
How Is The Youth Criminal Justice Act Fair And Equitable
855 Words | 4 PagesA huge way in which the YCJA promotes equity is through its main focus on rehabilitation rather than just the punishment of the child. A study from Justice Canada found that the YCJA’s focus on rehabilitation has led to a significant drop in the rate of re-offenses among youth offenders proving that through rehabilitation, the youth are more likely not to re-offend, resulting in not returning back to the justice system (Justice Canada). To add onto that, the YCJA has created specialized courts for youth to better meet the unique needs of the
Youth Criminal Justice Act (YCJA)
771 Words | 4 PagesA clear majority of vulnerable youth find themselves jostled around in the youth criminal justice system, this includes youth whom are homeless, impoverished, suffer from abuse, or have mental illnesses, among other factors (Office of the Child and Youth Advocate, 2015). Furthermore, in New Brunswick where police and courts are provincially run, the practice of EJMs is very inconsistent, therefore it is up to where the youths live if the measures are to their advantage or not (Office of the Child and Youth Advocate, 2015). Therefore, the Office of the Child and Youth Advocate suggest more consistent practices and protocols are needed to ensure the proper use of these measures
Nsw Police Force Essay
1513 Words | 7 PagesRetrieved from https://www.police.nsw.gov.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0004/508315/COCE_113782_01_Dec_14.pdf. Cunneen, C., White, R., & Richards, K. (2013). Juvenile justice: youth and crime in australia. Retrieved from EBook Central.
Barry Levinston's Sleepers And The Restorative Justice System
849 Words | 4 PagesA study done by Criminal justice inspection Northern Ireland found the rate of recidivism went down when young offenders were diverted into restorative justice furthermore study concludes that people were often quite pleased with the outcome of the restorative justice(Restorative Justice Council,
Labeling Theory Of The Juvenile Justice System
2037 Words | 9 PagesWhen a juvenile offender interacts with the criminal justice system, the impacts that the applied language and interaction has on the offender have the ability to last a lifetime (Curtis et al). Due to this, it is important to explain both the goals and the limitations of the juvenile justice system which set it apart from the overall criminal justice system. The paramount goal of the juvenile justice system is rehabilitation (Curtis et al). This goal should be uniquely identified alongside the previously established goal of community-wide crime reduction. The main limitation on the juvenile justice system is the large amount of discretion given to officers in the system (Curtis et al).
Just Mercy By Bryan Stevenson: Summary
743 Words | 3 PagesJuveniles that go through the rehabilitation process will be able to have a clean record after they reach 18, whereas the exact opposite if they went through the adult justice system. Stevenson feels that, “We’ve become so fearful and vengeful that we’ve thrown away children, discarded the disabled, and sanctioned the imprisonment of the sick and the weak—not because they are a threat to public safety or beyond rehabilitation but because we think it makes us seem tough, less broken.” (289) This quote represents the treatment towards juveniles in prison and how the potential of these children is wasted. The goal of rehabilitation is to help the youth understand the consequences of their actions and learn how to make better choices in the
B Impact On Victims: Youth Restorative Justice Conference
1932 Words | 8 PagesBy having the victims participate in a youth conference and tell their stories to the young offenders, the young people would start to understand the consequences and impacts that their actions had and begin to feel empathy towards the victim and remorse for their actions. This is a large part of why youth restorative justice conferences happen and why they are beneficial for both the youth offender and the victim. These are just some of the benefits and impacts youth restorative justice has on the victims of the
Recidivism In Canada
1156 Words | 5 PagesYouth crime in Canada has decreased overall but that does not mean crime has disappeared as there are cases where youths. Studies have shown that the “typical” method of justice, through incarceration has not made a huge impact on juvenile offenders ( S.M. Tarolla et al. 127). Which makes this topic so important because if young offenders are not given the right help and treatment they could continue onto the adult criminal justice system. Furthermore, if there is a way to identify recidivism, and provide help for young offenders then we would be adhering to the goals of the criminal justice system which is to rehabilitate and put people back into society as productive peoples.
Examples Of Restorative Justice
1337 Words | 6 PagesLegislation would provide a framework for state and local implementation that includes protections for victims’ and offenders’ rights, parameters for programs, and guidance for incorporating restorative justice into existing criminal justice system. There are four different opportunities for introducing restorative justice into the existing criminal justice system: “(a) at the police level (pre-charge); (b) the prosecution level (post-charge but usually before trial) [;] (c) at the court level (either at the pre-trial or sentencing stages[)]; and (d) corrections (as an alternative to incarceration, as part of or in addition to, a non-custodial sentence, during incarceration, or upon release from prison[)].” An Oregon statute could provide a logistical outline for implementing restorative justice at all four points in the juvenile justice
Should Juveniles Be Rehabilitated Essay
1046 Words | 5 PagesIn addition, many of the leading youth justice researchers have found that “the current youth prison model, which emphasizes confinement and control, often exacerbated youth trauma and inhibits positive growth while failing to address public safety” (Shaffer). In addition to juveniles being affected by incarceration, society and communities are affected as well. Since there is little regard for juvenile inmates safety and incarceration is not deterring juveniles from offending, communities are affected as well as the juvenile once the juvenile is released. In many cases, the crimes juveniles commit are generally theft, robbery, vandalism, and other crimes that affect people directly. These acts create fear in communities and causes the people residing in these communities to feel a lack of safety in their homes.
Juvenile Justice System Pros And Cons
486 Words | 2 PagesThe chance to revisit their cases and apply for parole eligibility would give thousands of individuals in prison a new hope. Even though the law isn’t set in stone and youth can still be charged with life without parole, depending on the judges decision at the end of a case, the judge being required to take into consideration the mental capacity of the youths understanding (or lack of understanding) about their wrongdoing and its consequences will make these harsh
Thesis Statement On Juvenile Delinquency
2409 Words | 10 Pages(1994). JUVENILE OFFENDERS: WHAT WORKS? A Summary of Research
More about Pros And Cons Of Youth Restorative Justice Conferencing
Summary: The Virginia Juvenile Court System
1278 Words | 6 PagesLindsey's Lack Of Restorative Justice
1437 Words | 6 PagesRestorative Justice Practices Meeting The Philosophical Goals Of The Juvenile Justice System
452 Words | 2 PagesHow Is The Youth Criminal Justice Act Fair And Equitable
855 Words | 4 PagesYouth Criminal Justice Act (YCJA)
771 Words | 4 PagesNsw Police Force Essay
1513 Words | 7 PagesBarry Levinston's Sleepers And The Restorative Justice System
849 Words | 4 PagesLabeling Theory Of The Juvenile Justice System
2037 Words | 9 PagesJust Mercy By Bryan Stevenson: Summary
743 Words | 3 PagesB Impact On Victims: Youth Restorative Justice Conference
1932 Words | 8 PagesRecidivism In Canada
1156 Words | 5 PagesExamples Of Restorative Justice
1337 Words | 6 PagesShould Juveniles Be Rehabilitated Essay
1046 Words | 5 PagesJuvenile Justice System Pros And Cons
486 Words | 2 PagesThesis Statement On Juvenile Delinquency
2409 Words | 10 Pages