Prostitution: Why Consensual Sex Should Be Legalized
The selling of sex in exchange for money is a concept that has been utilized since the ancient civilizations. It is no wonder than that prostitution is known as the world 's oldest profession. To many feminist advocates, prostitution is a barbaric and dehumanizing act that should be outlawed. However, this is untrue as sex work is a necessary means of income for approximately one million women in America. As there will always be people selling their bodies for money, the U.S. government should prioritize providing legal support and health-related resources for sex workers. This may be put into place by legalization. Many countries in Europe have already taken steps to help ensure the safety
…show more content…
Named the Nordic Model or Swedish Model, this approach is an elimination method that makes it a criminal offence to purchase sex, but not to sell. The goal of this is so dissuade Johns from taking advantage of women who may otherwise not have the ability to step away from prostitution. The difference between full legalization and decriminalization is that the latter imposes restrictions that can impact the rate sex work occurs. The Nordic Model has been the most successful as evidenced by the reports of satisfaction by escorts and general public. However, it does restrict men who are wanting to purchase sex. This concept is highly debated because if two adults are consenting to the transaction of money for sex, there is no reason it should be criminalized. This argument is further criticized by anti-prostitution activists that say it undermines gender equality and promotes the objectification of women (Glazer). These activists capitalize on the problems that harm reduction/elimination methods fail to absolve and argue for complete criminalization of all sex …show more content…
Their arguments are widely moral-based, with responses that identify the inequalities and human rights violations that arise as a result of prostitution. Melissa Farley, the founder of the Prostitution Research and Education organization, is one of the most famous figures who voices these dissents. She has extensive knowledge in prostitution and its harmful effects on sex workers and society as a whole, and she is especially passionate about fighting it in Nevada. Farley stated the following in response to questions posed by United Nations Women: “They [prostitutes in Nevada] can’t be protected from these harms. The institution of prostitution is so corrupt, so violent that it can’t be fixed. It must be abolished. There is now much empirical data showing that whatever its legal status, prostitution is connected with violence. A sex buyer described prostitution as “renting an organ for 10 minutes.” Women in prostitution tell us that this makes them feel like “toilets.” This dehumanization by sex buyers has devastating effects” (Farley). While her comments are not completely untrue, she uses sweeping generalizations that all sex workers are suffering. Farley also does not make the distinction between sex workers and those who are victims of sex trafficking, which are completely
The sexist origins of the criminalization of prostitution tie into the issue of criminalizing victims of sex trafficking in that the blame has historically been on those providing the service instead of the individuals paying for it; in fact, “young girls are prosecuted at reportedly higher rates than even the men who exploit them” (Annitto, 2011, p.
Prostitution has continuously remained “shielded” from the perceptiveness of society because of its objectionable characteristics. However, the problem still remains and in my opinion, “it will still exist for years to come.” Ultimately, the Bylaws of Canada has not been able to decipher or impede this problem, apart from triggering elusiveness in the acceptance of anything that is lawful and unlawful in relations to prostitution. All over the world prostitution entwines with the economy of every city, with a potential of legal and non-legal revenue.
Sex Trafficking is a form of modern day slavery that exists throughout the United States and globally. It is one of the biggest lies in society (Farley et., 2014). The Vanderbilt Law Review indicates that the majority of prostitutes do not enter the prostitution lifestyle on their own free will choice, but instead becomes a prostitute due to a variety of vulnerabilities that both pimps and traffickers exploit. This explains why young women get blindsided and think they are becoming a prostitute when in reality they are a sex trafficking victim (Elrod 2015). When the United States made prostitution illegal, it did not change the mentality of the johns.
In the past few decades, a debate has arisen over the legalization of prostitution in America. Proponents of the cause claim that legalizing and regulating it would bring about a reduction in crime, improve public health, aid the poor, boost tax revenue, improve conditions for existing prostitutes, and allow those who willfully choose this path to do so without fear of punishment. Opponents claim the practice to be immoral and believe that permitting prostitution would escalate sexually transmitted diseases, cause increases in human trafficking, and further the oppression of
Banning prostitution will drive it underground and making treatment and monitoring more difficult. However, registering prostitutes makes the state involved in prostitution and does not address the health risks of unregistered prostitutes. In Australia where sex-work is active and legal. Registration of sex-work is not practiced and education campaigns have been extremely successful and the non-intravenous drug user/sex workers are among the lower HIV-risk communities in the nation.
In the decades following this case, many changes to legislation have been made with the welfare of sex workers being seen as more important and more emphasis is put on ensuring they are safe (Wattis, 2015). LESSONS
After researching about multiple different topics that are presumed problems in the United States that need resolving, sex trafficking is a line of work that goes against any religion. Does the United States do enough to prevent people from joining this line of work, or are they pushing papers so they don 't get involved? Does the United States of America take action when needed, or do they have enough laws placed that can prevent pimps from selling innocent human beings? Prostitution, the practice or occupation of engaging in sexual activity for payment arrived from the latin word “prostituta”. While researching this topic it was found to be very controversial.
Research suggests that indoor workers may be more exposed to rape or attempted rape because their work occurs behind the closed doors of a brothel (“Brothel safety a dangerous myth”). The concealed walls of the brothel will only silence the screams of victims. As seen through the state of Victoria, it is naive to believe that the light of legalization will dissipate the roots of sexual abuse against sex workers. The only way to demolish this pattern of violence against sex workers is by making prostitution illegal in
The Encyclopedia of Prostitution and Sex Work states, “Traffickers often physically and psychologically brutalize their victims to gain total control over them” (Ditmore 365). In other words, in order to have total control over the people and to make them more susceptible to their commands, brothel keepers emotionally abuse their sex slaves. Often times, when trafficked victims are deemed no longer useful, they are thrown out to the streets. After Monica is thrown out of the brothel for having HIV, Lakshmi is told, “‘don’t bother looking for your friend,’ she says. ‘She’s out on the street’” (210).
Throughout the decades, the stigma around prostitution has drastically changed, and it has become viewed as a demeaning, immoral,
Prostitution: Should It Be Allowed In the United States? In the Netherlands prostitution has been legalized and is currently being regulated by the government. While in Sweden, a different model for prostitution has been implemented, known as the big-stick model by some activists. So the question is, should prostitution continue the way it has for years in the U.S. with no signs of changing our laws on prostitution, similar to the model in Sweden?
Prostitution is considered to be one of the oldest professions. Prostitution is an illegal business in many countries of the world and it is considered to be largely immoral. However, its scope is expanding simultaneously with the globalization of business and culture, which is the hallmark of our time. Researchers and activists continue to discuss whether it is possible to consider the purchase and sale of sexual services as an industry. Is it necessary to regulate the activities of prostitutes in a legal way, or should they be provided with legislative and medical protection?
Furthermore prostitution cannot be deemed immoral as prostitution itself is a trade similar to many other jobs in the society. A person’s right to sell their sexual services is neither more nor less of a right than that of person selling their labour-power in any other of its multifaceted forms. For example a person doing manual labour is selling his/her body, a writer sells her mind and a bodyguard or wrestler sells the services of their body. The feminist argument is that, Prostitution is merely a job of work and the prostitute is a worker, like any other wage labourer (Patemen, 2010, p.9). Many people believe that the act of prostitution involves buying another person for money, this is not the case.
Prostitutes are people, too. Prostitution is such a complex issue; no one ever scratches the surface of sex work. Prostitution is commonly known as the world 's oldest profession yet has been outlawed in forty-nine out of the fifty states in the United States. Legal-prostitution can require all sex workers to practice safe sex as well as get tested frequently to reduce the spread of diseases. Reduction of violence against women starts with the availability of sex.
The United Nations’ Convention held in 1949, stated prostitution to be “incompatible with human dignity”. According to the Oxford Dictionary, prostitution is defined as "The practice or occupation of engaging in sexual activity with someone for payment." Often referred to as the “oldest profession” in the world, prostitution has become a burning issue in today’s world. The ongoing debate on whether to legalize, criminalize or decriminalize prostitution seems to be quite unresolvable. This paper investigates the negative impacts of legalizing prostitution such as 1) encouragement of prostitution, 2) increase in the incidence of human trafficking and 3) exposure of prostitutes to severe harm such as drug abuse, infection from sexually transmitted diseases and violence, which clearly supports the fact that prostitution should not be legalized.