In the process of Comparing and contrasting qualitative, quantitative and mixed methods design, a retrospective view is cited in an attempt to aid in the current debate. When we reflect on a simular situation that occured with Socrates and Plato versus multiple or relative approaches of Protagoras and Gorgias of the Sophists. The process can be compared and contrasted to balances or mixtures of the extremes by Aristotle or principle of balance, under the more moderate scepticism of Cicero, Sextus Empiricus. It can also be traced back to ancient Western philosophy as outlined and argued by Burke, Onwuegbuzie, & Turner, (2007). In some way it can be argued, that a similar rival spirit continues to agitate researchers on the dawn of the 21st …show more content…
Therefore, from the forgoing discussions, there is need for greater inclusion of qualitative and mixed methods in the social and behavioural sciences moving forward. The comparison and contrast between quantitative, qualitative, and mixed methods will undoubtedly be more pronounced as researchers challenge new frontiers such as the social and digital medias. The International Journal of Social Research Methodology (April 2006) attested to the growing interest with respect to design methodologies in the social sciences. As a result, several factors can be accredited to this …show more content…
Bryman (2010), argued that although the paradigm wars had subsided in recent times, there were still discussions as to the legitimacy of mixed methods. However, as researchers move into the 21st century; mixed methods legitimacy is no longer a debated matter. Journal of Mixed Methods Research (2009), has reported an increasing number of fields which originally relied on quantitative and qualitative methodologies have seen significant potential with mixed methods approach to research problems. Fields such as education, psychology, social sciences, behavioural sciences, and health sciences has greatly benefited through its full acceptance. Currently, all three methods perform on parallel planes in the academic community although qualitative approach is still viewed as inadequate for the natural sciences. O’Cathain, Murphy, & Nicholl, (2007) argued in favour of mixed methods design, partly because of the strong position attributed to this method in recent research activities. Creswell & Plano Clark (2011) agreed that mixed methods has matured significantly and can now directly compliment the traditional quantitative and qualitative research methods. With the ever increasing popularity of qualitative methodology, researchers in social sciences and other disciplines have yet another methodology from which to choose.
However A critique of all the methodologies is that they only look for what they intend and ignore other possibilities. The findings therefore support their respective perspective and must be considered only
Qualitative Critique Review The research article, “ Perceptions of patient-provider communication in breast and cervical cancer-related care: A qualitative study of low-income English and Spanish- speaking women. The article is qualitative study because its aim is to explore perceptions of Spanish-speakers who experience a experience a combination of patient-provider language concordance and discordance through the care continuum. It uses direct quotations of the participants to explain its findings. Melissa Simon, Daiva Ragas, Narissa Nonzee, Ava Phisuthikul , Thanh Luu, XinQi Dong, who are the authors of article, collected and analyzed the data.
The Summary of “Qualitative Research Technique for Data Collection”. In this summary, I would draw 3 main points of the article. First, the overview of the qualitative research which covers its definition and purposes. Second, I would describe concisely about the common methods or techniques respectively of the qualitative research, and thirdly, I would uncover the pros and cons of each of the drawn techniques in brief. Overview of Qualitative Research Qualitative Research is mainly about exploratory research.
The best way to seem valid is to outline the methods and exact steps used and to ensure they are clean. Using a theoretical framework helps show people that this type of data collection is still science-based and not as weak as it seems. Dr. Cropley personally finds that grounded theory is the best method as it is more structured, solid, and scientific, which also makes it easier to
This does not exclude a quantitative approach being associated with a post-positivist approach. In contrast, for a researcher who favors interpretive, knowledge is a matter of interpretation (Schutt, 2009) so that the quest for understanding the complex world of lived experience demands that the researcher interact with the research objects/participants to get the viewpoint. The investigator favored a post-positivist approach since he believes that human knowledge can be challenged and modified in light of further investigation. Following is a description of the methodology that was followed for this
For performance of a research, its methodology must be clear to the researchers. A clear methodology indicates the methods or techniques to be used as well as their relevance for the study. In choosing an appropriate methodology Guba& Lincoln (1994, pg. 105) argue, “Questions of method should be secondary to questions of paradigm”. The issue is one of choosing the most appropriate research method to achieve stated research objectives. Keeping this view a combination of qualitative and quantitative methods has been used.
This thesis examined and analyzed the qualitative
The Biopsychosocial approach is made up of biology, psychology, and social influences that help humans function. Each function has their own view of behaviors and mental processing, but they can not function on there own. Of the three approaches, social influences are the changes unintentionally or intentionally, in our emotions, behaviors, attitudes, and relationships when being effected by others. There are key perspectives of social influences such as conformity, family dynamics, and compelling models of the media. Conformity is when you change the way you behave for someone intentionally or unintentionally.
Mixed Methods – Transformative Design Introduction: Transformative philosophy has been around since the 1980s and 1990s, it arose from individuals who believed that the postpositivist assumptions imposed structural theories that did not fit marginalized people in our society, transformative research is defined as that which “transforms” or causes a major change in thought patterns. It is also one of the philosophies that considered in mixed methods. Historically, the transformative writers have drawn on the work of Marx, Adorno, Marcuse, Habermas, and Freire.
There are several factors that must be included in the selection of a methodology, such as the setting for the research, the goals of the study, and the nature of the subject matter. Each of these factors will be examined specifically. Creswell (2009) asserts that qualitative design is a way to explore the meaning ascribed to social or human problems and when problems are not well understood and requires exploration. The qualitative research gives the researcher more options when selecting a research design as far as strategies and worldviews. In addition, in qualitative research data can be collected through a broad range of observational and interview strategies and by taking a more inductive approach (Creswell,
The test for those included in teaching courses in research strategies lies in guaranteeing that those examining undertaking qualitative research are not just mindful of the reactions commonly made by its detractors yet they are additionally cognizant of the procurements which can be made to address matters, for example, validity, transferability, reliability and confirmability. Prospective specialists can then survey the degree to which they find themselves able to apply these non-specific systems to their specific
Interdisciplinary research is becoming increasingly important for meeting societal needs and addressing real-world issues that demand collaborative and integrative approaches. Disciplinary, Multidisciplinary, and Interdisciplinary Approaches to Research There are several approaches to
But, it is not always true that Triangulation offers the solution to the limitations of the two methods (qualitative and quantitative research methods.), because they need not necessarily complement each other in every way. There are limitations with Triangulation in terms of it being time consuming again and also the need for additional resources, thus making it more expensive as well. There is a need for academic experience in order to use Triangulation appropriately and in a balanced
The Elements of the Research Questions and Hypotheses for a Proposed Study A qualitative study states the research questions. It does not frame the specific goals for the research, nor does it predict the outcome (Creswell, 2014). The research questions are in two forms: a central question and associated subquestions. A central question is “a broad question that asks for an exploration of the central phenomenon or concept in a study” (2014).
This quantitative method utilised an objectivist epistemology with a post-positivist theoretical perspective. Objectivism claims that meaning is discovered, based on observed events, rather than being constructed or imposed