Quantitative Analysis - Dynamic Credit Ratings Model
Author : Nusheen Shoab
CID: 00755208
Applied Financial Research Project ,2014
Imperial College London
Project Specification
We are an Analytics Division of a Rating Agency offering ratings and advisory services to a large number of Corporate clients. The Analytics Division is approached by the Sales Division to enhance their credit ratings model i.e. upon having criticism from the user’s on its reliability, the ratings team has been asked to enhance their ratings model such that the model takes into account the changing economic circumstances.
The period of Global Financial Crisis provided staggering evidence of the problems caused by inadequate credit ratings. Many corporate
…show more content…
We hereafter refer to the Merton model modified by Moody’s KMV(Crosbie & Bohn,2003) as the Merton/KMV model. The firm defaults when the debt exceeds equity. The default point acts as an absorbing barrier and as soon as the asset value hits this point , the firm is assumed to default. (Crosbie & Bohn, 2003) find that it is not unusual for a firm to not default when asset values reach book values, as many continue to service their debts due to the long term nature of some liabilities. KMV derives the default point to be somewhere between the total liabilities and current …show more content…
AIG faced the most difficult time during the crisis of 2008 when a series of events unfolded with the disclosure of financial losses and subsequent falling stock price. Figure – AIG’s declining stock price during Global Financial Crisis (GFC)
AIG’s financial crisis was intensified when its credit ratings were downgraded forcing it to post $14.5 billion in collateral resulting in a liquidity crisis.
The U.S. government seized control of American International Group Inc, in an $85 billion deal that signaled the intensity of its concerns about the danger a collapse could pose to the financial system making it one of the biggest corporate bailouts in history. Prior to the crisis AIG enjoyed stability and was rated Aa2 in 2005. The company was downgraded subsequently to an A2 in 2008, A3 in 2009 and Baa1 in 2011.
Bank of America (BOA) is a multinational banking & financial services corporation. Bank of America was also downgraded to A1 & A2 by Moody’s in 2009 and 2011 respectively after having enjoyed a rating of Aa1 in 2007. It was further downgraded in 2012. According to Moody’s , these downgrades come in due to either problems in risk management or a history of high volatility . Figure – BOA’s stock price during Global Financial Crisis
After the end of World War I the Untied States entered a period of the Roaring Twenties. During the Roaring Twenties, production was high, spending was high, and the Stock market increased by over four hundred percent. By 1929, stocks were overpriced, factories were overproducing goods, and bad credit all climaxed with the collapse of the American economy. By the time the United States realized what was wrong the economy was plunging with no end in sight. In an attempt to prevent the collapse JP Morgan invested one hundred million dollars into the stock market to try and calm people and prevent selling.
The American sub-prime mortgage crisis and asset-backed commercial paper (ABCP) crisis happened in Canada had huge negative impacts on the financial industry. With the bankruptcy of several major banks in North America, investors lost their faith in financial institutions and were not willing to invest their assets to those financial institutions because of extremely high risks. As a competitive player in the industry, Goodwin also faced this threat and had poor performance. Internal Analysis Strength: Goodwin was a well-diversified company with six divisions in different but related market segments.
This being the cause of prices concerning stocks and shares to increase, to the point that it was nearly impossible to invest in the market. This being a factor in causing companies to terminate their employees swiftly, and if an individual remained employed, their wage decreased dramatically below the minimum wage. Many counterparts had invested in the stocks with loans or borrowed money, and when the market crashed, their share had been utterly wiped out, leaving them with absolutely no money. Individuals who had their money in banks, became skeptical of the banks and started to withdraw their money, to preserve their remaining savings. This, causing the banks to have to take out loans from bigger banks so that they could pay the individuals their money.
The companies kept pushing higher prices than what their products were really worth. This lead to the stock market crash. This meant workers were fired, wages cut, and business went out of business. After the stock market crashed, Americans lost trust in their banks to hold their
In the years leading up to the 2nd Industrial Revolution Americans saw major expansion into western territories. From the annexation of Texas in 1845 to the Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo in 1848 the increase in American land inspired new ideas for the future of American society. The advancement of the American system of transportation during the 2nd Industrial Revolution allowed goods, people, and ideas to travel further and faster. This allowed for previously isolated communities to influence American culture in the central and booming cities as well as affect the way American society was able to import and export goods. Also during the 2nd Industrial Revolution “industrial giants” emerged and controlled the market industries of coal, oil, steel
In this film by PBS it shows the one of the major causes of the 2008 FInancial Crisis; the Credit Default Swaps. The credit default swaps were created by JP Morgan. A credit default swap according to Investopedia is, “A credit default swap is a particular type of swap designed to transfer the credit exposure of fixed income products between two or more parties. In a credit default swap, the buyer of the swap makes payments to the swap’s seller up until the maturity date of a contract. In return, the seller agrees that, in the event that the debt issuer defaults or experiences another credit event, the seller will pay the buyer the security’s premium as well all interest payments that would have been paid between that time and the security’s maturity date.”
Organizational Structure Bank of America is an American financial services corporation and is the second largest bank holding organization by assets, in the United States. The headquarter of the financial organization is situated in Charlotte, North Carolina. The bank has approximately 5,700 retail banking offices and 17,250 ATMs in the United States. The online banking system of the bank has more than 30 million active users.
The AIG Scandal 2005 started when AIG management was issuing a press release describing its third quarter earnings in 2000 to the public. The report showed that the premium of AIG was significantly increasing, while its loss reserves was decreasing by $59 million. However, according to many industry analysts, along with the positive earnings, AIG in fact should show an increase in its loss reserves as well. This caused the investors of AIG suspected that AIG was drawing down its loss reserves to boost its profits. The suspicious of the investors has unfortunately led to the falling of AIG stock price from $99.60 to $93.30 on New York Stock Exchange (NYSE).
In Addition to maldistribution stood the credit structure of the economy, some farmers were in deep land mortgage debt, so they lowered their crop prices in order to regain credit, and because the farmers were no longer accountable for what they owed banks. Across the nation the banking system found themselves in constant trouble. In America both small and large bankers were concerned for their survival, so they began investing recklessly in stock markets and granting unwise loans. These unconscious decisions would lead a large consequence, such as families losing their life savings and their deposits became uninsured. “ More than 9,000 American banks either went bankrupt or closed their doors to avoid bankruptcy between 1930 and 1933.”Although
Was this the right choice for the government? General Motor’s debt was converted into preferred and common stock that was owned by the government. The stocks were then offered to the public (Contorno, 2015). General Motors’ bailout cost taxpayers more than $11.2 billion; this included a $826-million write-off in March from government investments in the “Old GM” before the company’s bankruptcy
Introduction The main objective of this particular case study is to assist Victor Dubinski, the current CEO of Blaine Kitchenware, decide whether or not repurchasing shares and changing the firm’s capital structure in favor of more debt could actually be benefit the company and its shareholders. Blaine Kitchenware is a small cap, public company who focuses on selling various different residential kitchen appliances. Up until this point, the company has only used cash and equity financing to acquire independent kitchen appliance manufacturers, and expand into foreign markets abroad. Given their excess cash and lack of debt, Blaine Kitchenware is considered to be “over-liquid and under-leveraged” (Luehrman & Heilprin, 2009).
EXECUTIVE COMPENSATION Executive compensation is a broad term which comprises of financial compensation and non-financial rewards given to an executive from their firm for their services. This package is decided by a company’s Board of Directors (consisting of independent directors). It should be designed in a manner which incentivizes the executives and motivates them to perform in accordance with the company’s goals and its long term growth. These packages generally include a mix of short-term incentives (including salary, annual bonus, benefits, and perquisites) and long-term incentives (including stock options and restricted shares). E.g. Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella received a compensation package of $84.3 million for the software maker’s
Toms shoes are made from environment-friendly materials like natural and organic vegan substance, including the packaging that is made from 80% recycled waste. Going further on the path of social corporate responsibility, the company can broaden the range of their products and services and explore additional sustainable materials to create their products. Internal Environmental Factors: Strengths 1. Mega Brands Inc. sells a wide range of products like puzzles, building blocks, construction sets, and activity craft-based games. Due to the variation in type of the products they sell, consumers have more options to choose from.
Executive Summary Lehman Brothers were an investment bank involved in transactions worth billions of dollars and one of the most powerful investment banks in the world. Lehman Brothers collapsed in 2008 following bad investment in the sub-prime mortgage market and used bad accounting practices called Repo 105 transactions to try and cover up the bad assets. This report sets out the use of the fraud triangle when describing the actions which led to the collapse. The pressure applied on the bank, the opportunity due to the lack of regulation to carry out the actions and the ability of the bank to rationalise their decision making.
In order to identify red flags for risk management from various financial risk ratios, models, and traditional ratios for Bear Stearns and Lehman Brothers, we list our calculation results below. Based on our calculation, Bear Stearns got 15 red flags, which occupied 68% of total red flags, while Lehman Brothers 12 red flags, occupying 55% of total red flags. These two numbers were high even compared with other investment banks, and companies committed fraudulent activities. In summary, both Lehman Brothers and Bear had high possibility of going bankruptcy.