In a group, there are always people who prove to have better leadership skills then others and the strongest people can most likely influence the weaker people into obeying them. However, the strongest person sometimes isn’t the the best leader. In the book, “Lord of the Flies” written by William Golding, Ralph and Jack fight silently to be the leader of the boys on the island. Of the two, I believe that Ralph is a better leader because he has a better understanding for the boys and stayed on track on getting rescued instead of having “fun”. He also has more common sense and treats the boys better than Jack and although Jack’s actions help the boys physically survive, Ralph’s “civilized” leadership allowed him to keep the boys under control. Ralph treats all the boys with respect. Ralph's leadership is exemplified when he defends Piggy who is one of the weakest in the group. During an argument between Jack and Piggy, Jack slaps Piggy and breaks his glasses. Ralph calls it "A dirty trick" (p. 72). This demonstrates Jack's failure to respect other people, while at the same time Ralph's concern is to have a better …show more content…
For example, Piggy suggests the use of the conch, and when Jack and the hunters steal the fire, Piggy suggests that Ralph's group build another fire on the beach. He demonstrates this as the text states, "a strange mood of speculation" (pg. 78), Ralph realizes that “thought wa a valuable thing, that got results . . . . Only, decided Ralph as he faced the chief's seat, I can't think. Not like Piggy” (pg. 78). I can say that Ralph is creative because while other boys aren’t concerned with being rescued, Ralph sets about building hut and thinking of ways to maximize their chances of being rescued. He shows being creative as the text states, “They're hopeless. The older ones aren't much better. D'you see? All day I've
Ralph furiously arrives to reclaim Piggy’s specs as he is useless without them, and confront Jack about the stolen fire. These reasons lead the entire confrontation to fights and pure chaos. They fight over the stolen fire and Piggy’s specs. Ralph calls Jack a thief, and Jack loses it, making the first lunge. They stand chest to chest in pure frustration.
This is a terrible leadership quality. A third reason why Ralph’s style of leadership is better is that Ralph knew what was best for the boys overall. He was always looking for the boys best interest and had good intent, while Jack’s dictatorship consisted of Jack thriving off of the power making only himself feel good and trying to make that last. In the novel Lord of the Flies, there are various types of leaderships evident. Ralph and Jack, both showed a great sense of leadership on the island and towards
After reading Lord of the Flies I asked myself a question, was Ralph a good leader or not? In my opinion Ralph was a decent leader, but he could’ve been better. He was a good leader in some ways, but he wasn’t in other ways. Some readers argue that Jack would’ve been a better leader than Ralph. I think if Jack and Ralph became co leaders they would’ve succeeded more in bettering the tribe and surviving more as a group.
A true leader thinks wisely and must know and use his resources in a sufficient way. In which Jack did. Mr. Merridew also uses his physical strength in a wise way. One act he did that proves that justifies this is when there was another assembly going on. The boys started arguing, Finally Jack had enough and decided to leave Ralph and make his own group.
The Lord Of The Flies Do you think that Ralph is a better leader than Jack? In the Book, The Lord Of The Flies Ralph and Jack are always in a competition to be the leader or all of the other boys on the island because if they don't make agreements and assign tasks to each other so they can survive on the island by themselves until they get saved. The problem is that all of the boys favor Ralph as a leader instead of Jack. So Ralph already has an advantage over Jack for being the best leader and the most favorite leader on the island. Ralph and Jack compare as leaders because they both fight over the conch, they both want to be the best leader, and they both want all of the power, And Ralph is favorited over Jack because or hoe jack treats them Ralph and Jack would always fight over the conch.
He shouts to Jack that he has not done what he supposed to do. The readers can clearly notice that Ralph is doing all the difficult tasks alone as a sachem while Jack does something he enjoys. This also shows that Ralph is a charismatic leader; moreover, he has a great responsibility for the boys on the island. Piggy assists Ralph with
A leader is a person who commands and is followed. A good leader is a person who is selfless, flexible and smart among many other qualities. In the novel Lord of the Flies by William Golding, the character Ralph has proven to be an effective leader by showing his ability to gain and show respect and prioritize what is important for everybody on the island. Respect is the feeling of admiration towards somebody for their abilities, qualities, or achievements. Ralph has managed to obtain the kids respect as well as transmit it.
He is helpful and caring towards the other boys and relates to their normal human actions. Later, however, Ralph grows apart from Piggy, which is the good side, and grows closer to Jack, the bad side of human nature. The ego of the human personality is represented through Ralph; he must compromise between the attitude of Jack, following under the id category, and the superego thoughts of Piggy. Jack believes that he should have the freedom to do what wants and it doesn’t matter what the outcome is,while Piggy believes that decisions made on the island should be logical and they should follow the rules of the regular word. After the death of Piggy, deciding what to do next is hard for Ralph.
Jack has more of a primitive view on surviving on the island that it is all about hunting and keeping the fire going. he doesn't really do anything to keep the rest of the boys happy. While Ralph on the other hand is a little more civilized in that he does things like he wants to build shelter for the boys and does things to look out for the boys. Both of their ways can be liked and disliked by the boys on the island. For example this quote from the book explains Jack's primitivity.
German journalist John Zenger once stated, “Great leaders are not defined by the absence of weakness, but rather by the presence of clear strengths”. When one is in a situation where a person who can delegate adequately is necessary, one that displays the fundamental qualities will successfully guide the society. Throughout the novel Lord of the Flies, the boys on the island represent various aspects of leadership, characterized by differing strengths. However, the protagonist, Ralph, undoubtedly triumphs in this position over others because his idiosyncrasies allow him to be a powerful leader on the island. Throughout William Golding’s novel, he clearly depicts Ralph as an effective leader through his desire for the survival of everyone,
Ralph struggles to keep the boys working together on the grounds that everyone, except Piggy and Simon, are narrow-minded. For example, in chapter 2, when the boys made the signal fire, Piggy says: ‘I’m scared-’ … ‘You’re always scared. Yah-Fatty!’ … ‘Now look-’
After Jack and his choir agree to tend to the signal fire, Ralph spots a potential rescue ship but finds that Jack’s group let the fire go out as they went on a pig hunt, making Ralph extremely enraged and disappointed. Whereas previously there were only minor arguments that resolved quickly and easily that did not damage their relationship much, this marks the official beginning of the conflict of Ralph against Jack. After this incident was yet another turning point. What started off as an assembly “to put things straight” resulted in Jack disputing Ralph’s authority and leading everyone away in a show of clear mutiny. This shows that Jack is distancing himself and the group away from Jack.
They blinded me. See? That’s Jack Merridew’”(Golding 169). This is an example of Jack’s lack of respect for Piggy and Ralph. Jack and his tribe didn’t bother thinking about the safety or needs of the other boys they were stealing from.
Ralph possesses those certain qualities that allow him to be the best fit leader. Ralph has succor for all the boys on the island, including the outcasts such as Piggy, the voice of reason, Simon, the spiritual figure, and all the young children. When Piggy, Ralph’s closest friend on the island, was complaining about Jack, saying, “I know about me. And him. He can’t hurt you: but if you stand out of the way he’d hurt the next think.
Ralph is first introduced as the fair boy who is a natural born leader. He applies Piggy’s intelligence to think of a way to summon the other survivors on the island. Ralph follows through with Piggy’s idea and uses the conch which emits a loud sound that can be hear through the island. The sound eventually lures the group of boys towards them. His leader instincts are best portrayed when he’s able to side with Jack after offering to share his power: “The suffusion drained away from Jack’s face.