How would you demonstrate leadership if you were stranded on an island? In the novel Lord of The Flies, by William Golding , a bunch of boys get into a plane crash and are stranded together on a deserted island. All of the boys resources were lost during the crash, so the boys need to learn how to adapt and survive on the island. None of the boys parents survived so they needed to figure out how to survive on their own. The boys try to organize themselves and assign roles to every person on the island. While the boys are on the island, they fail to work together, they fail to follow these roles, and end up turning on each other. This leads to boys on the island getting hurt and they end up destroying the island itself. Jack and Ralph demonstrate …show more content…
Jack states, “See? See? That’s what you’ll get! I meant that! There isn’t a tribe for you anymore! The conch is gone” (Golding 181). The conch is a symbolism of civilization and meeting. Ralph would use this conch to call meetings and give everyone chance to have an equal say in the subject they were discussing. Jack destroyed the conch and tried to force Ralph to join his tribe. Jack acts like a dictator and wants complete control over all the boys on the island. Jack uses fear to get the other boys on the island to do what he tells them to do. Jack gave the boys on the island harsh orders, because he wanted everyone living on the island to be under his control. Since Ralph and Piggy wouldn’t join Jack’s tribe, Jack ordered the boys in his tribe to kill piggy and they also tried to kill Ralph. Ralph expresses, “Seems to me we ought to have a chief to decide things” (Golding 22). Ralph wants the island to be run like a democracy.When the boys first arrived on the island Ralph had the original idea of voting for a chief. All of the boys voted for Ralph for chief. Jack turned on Ralph because he did not believe Ralph was the right person to be chief. Jack thought he was a much better leader so he named himself chief and had the goal of getting everyone to leave Ralph's tribe and join his. Ralph does give orders to the boys but they are given to keep the boys safe. Ralph gives everyone the chance …show more content…
Ralph says, “I’ll give the conch to the next person to speak” (Golding 33). Ralph doesn’t want the complete power on the island. He wants the rest of the boys to have a role and wants everyone to work together. Ralph uses his power to create organization and keep all of the boys on the island safe. On the other hand, Jack cares too much about power, and uses it in a negative way. Jack will do anything to get more power over the boys. Jack resorts to harmful ways to get the boys to follow him and do exactly what he says. Jack uses his power to order the boys in his tribe to kill
Ralph is looking out for all the boys by mentioning the fire and rescue, Jack using the feast to lure all of the boys in one gathering cast a vote to have the leader of the island. Jack isn’t concerned about rescue or getting off the island but instead wants leadership over the whole island. In short, Jack is leading the boys away from the main objective, putting a carrot on the stick and the pig follows as they slowly devolve into savages. However, some readers consider Ralph to be responsible for the chaos and destruction because Ralph wasn’t a fit leader who could properly control the boys on the island.
The boys could have easily chosen Jack instead of Ralph, especially given the fact that Jack had previous experience as a leader; he is first seen surrounded by a group of faithful followers, his choir group, that continue to obey him on the island. Even Piggy, who showed support towards Ralph from the beginning, is intimidated by Jack's authoritative demeanor. However, Jack is missing that key characteristic that made Ralph so appealing: the symbol of power and strength. Any sense of leadership that Jack held was overshadowed by the image of Ralph standing confidently with the conch shell in hand. Ultimately, the young boys identified Ralph as their leader based on the power they believed he symbolized.
Therefore, with the conch, Ralph was able to voice his problems with the boys, which means that the conch, at the moment, still has some power since Ralph’s opinions were heard by the boys. In addition to the conch, during chapter six, the conch loses power to order the boys. As seen in chapter 6, when they find that there is no beast, all of the boys have different things they want to do after, but Ralph commands the boys to follow him because he is the leader who has the conch. Jack gets annoyed at this and says, “‘We don’t need the conch anymore… It’s time some people knew they’ve got to keep quiet and leave deciding things to the rest of us’”(Golding 101-102), Jack states, and the rest of the boys would agree because clearly, they aren’t as enthusiastic about following Ralph’s actions anymore.
I’ll put a hook later. In the novel Lord of the Flies, by William Golding, a group of around 30 boys get into a plane crash and end up stranded on an island. They struggle to gather food and resources, as well as building shelter. They hope to be rescued but instead of working together, they separate into groups and fight amongst themselves, even resulting in death. They fail to choose a clear leader and the boys become divided because of this.
A leader to one may not be a leader to all, but a respected leader is recognized as the best. A group of boys stranded on an island starts the tale of Lord of Flies by William Golding leading to an adventurous tale. This takes place in World War II surrounding the life of young British Boys. The boys on the island vote to decide on a chief among themselves and Ralph comes out victorious. Although Ralph is not the oldest or strongest, the little ones follow him endlessly through the well-earned respect that shines in his leadership.
The book revolves around the actions of Ralph, the boys elected leader, Jack, the controlling, and aggressive choir boy, and Piggy, the smartest of the group yet least respected. Throughout the course of the book we see the grip had Ralph has on the group and their humanity slip away from minor acts of rebellion, the progression of killing animals and their reasoning with the loss. With their struggle of adjusting to living on the island with no order, superior intelligence, or real authority we see without the control civilization imposes on us we revert to more savage beings.
Secondly, Ralph is very determined. He wants what is best for the boys , so he has to want things done right and in a decorous fashion. Ralph wants the shelters to be finished, food to be gathered and/or hunted, the fire to stay ablaze to help them be rescued, but most importantly, he wants to pull their weight and contribute to the workload. Jack on the other hand, just wants to hunt and stay on the island forever having fun, which will ultimately dwindle the boys’ chances of getting off the island and going home. Ralph just wants what is best for the boys.
How can we ever be rescued except by luck, if we don’t keep a fire going? Is a fire too much for us to make?” This shows that Ralph used the conch to call for a meeting for the kids to discuss things and used his deep concerns for the fire to try to drive the other kids to work harder on it. Jack’s leadership however is, “I’m not going to be part of Ralph’s lot-… Anyone who wants to hunt when I do can come too.”
These boys felt that Ralph was not providing the rights that they needed. On the other hand Jack was. This was a reason to form a new government. The boys wanted fun, food and protection, which was nothing Ralph provided. Ralph’s main goal was to get off the island, where the boys wanted to enjoy their time.
Imagine you are heading to vacation on a plane and all of a sudden you crash on an island with a bunch of strangers with no connection to the outside world. Lord of the Flies was written by William Golding. A plane full of boys who didn’t know each other crashed on an island with nothing to help them escape. The boys had to grow up quickly and some had to take on the rule of being a leader for the rest of the boys. There were many conflicts between the boys all throughout the book.
Throughout the novel, Jack consistently demonstrates a disregard for rules and a desire for dominance and power. When he leads the boys in hunting and violence, he taps into their savage and primal instincts - including Ralph’s. As Jack proclaims, "The conch doesn't count at this end of the island" (Golding, 150) it becomes evident that he prioritizes dominance and power over order, authority, and the established rules on the island. In the midst of their destructive rivalry, Jack’s failures teach Ralph important lessons. Witnessing Jack’s inability to maintain the signal fire makes Ralph recognize the value of collaboration, communication, and planning for survival.
Ralph makes way more rational decisions than Jack, and his solutions to problems always have a better outcome. Since we see Jack desperate for people to join his tribe, and when someone refuses, he orders his followers to "Go on [and] tie them" (Golding 179) and then proceed to torture them until they finally do join the tribe. Jack is a ruthless leader who is willing to do whatever, abuse power, and go on to make the most irrational decisions only to accomplish his single goal, to become the absolute leader. While Ralph is seen with only a few followers, he makes reasonable and rational decisions. For example, after Piggy's glasses get stolen, Ralph suggests, "... take the conch to say this.
Ralph wanted to remain in power because he knew he wouldn’t do stupid things and kill people. He knew once Jack convinced the boys to join his tribe to have fun, his leader role was gone. In fact, this didn’t stop Ralph from trying to have a say in Jack’s actions. Ralph always wanted to do what was best for the boys. Even if the boys didn’t see it because they wanted to have fun like Jack.
In Lord of the Flies, Ralph and Jack are both leaders, but only one of them can be the leader. When the group kids decide on Ralph, Jack seems okay with it. This is until Jack demands a revote, with Ralph winning again. After this, Jack gets mad and decides to leave Ralph’s tribe and start his own: “I’m [Jack] going off by myself.
At the beginning of the story, the boys try to create a functional society. Ralph and Piggy are the first to try to establish this. They find a conch shell, which creates a noise that eventually becomes a way of summoning everyone on the island. At the first meeting, the boys decide that they need a leader, or at least some sort of hierarchy to create order. They decide on the “chief” democratically, with Ralph getting more votes than the only other person who runs, Jack.