Recitation Over Anselm's Proslogion Summary
Jesha C. Lor
Dr. Arbo
Intro to Philosophy TR (9:30-10:45 a.m.)
22 October 2015
Recitation over Anselm’s Proslogion In Anselm’s Proslogion, Anselm starts out by asking himself whether there is a single argument which requires no other for its proof than itself alone; and if alone would suffice to demonstrate that God exists. Anselm’s ontological argument is set out in two forms: God exists and God has and will always exist. He begins by stating in Proslogion II that, “Truly there is a God, although the fool has said in his heart, there is no God,” which references to Psalm 14 in the bible of the fool who said that there is no God. For Anselm, this fool represents someone who would agree that, God would logically exist but, still insists that God does not exist. The argument in Proslogian II can be summarize as, we can imagine lots
…show more content…
Anselm uses the painter analogy, “When a painter thinks ahead to what he will paint, he has that picture in his thought, but he does not yet think it exists, because he has not done it yet. Once he has painted it he has it in his thought and that it exists because he has done it,” to explain why things that exists are greater and better than things we only think about or imagine. He says that a painter begin with an idea of what they want to paint and based on this idea, they paint the picture and don’t continue to think about “what they want to paint”. A painter is called a painter because they paint not because they can think. Anselm continues in his argument that, “If God exists only in thought, he could also be thought of as existing in reality as well, which is greater,” and so he
Saint Anselm's Objection To The Ontological Argument
1400 Words | 6 PagesPhilosophy Hamad aldawood Monday, March 19, 2018 Introduction The Ontological Argument was proposed by Saint Anselm to try and ascertain the existence of God. Anselm’s argument is based on the fact that there is a specific concept of God. It establishes the existence of God as "that than which nothing greater can be conceived" (Roth, 1970, p.270). From Saint Anselm’s argument, it is apparent that Ontological Arguments are mostly deductive and a priori.
What Phrase Does Anselm Use To Designate God
458 Words | 2 PagesWhat phrase does Anselm use to designate God? Explain why he formulates his designation in this way. Do you think this is an appropriate way to speak of God? The Phrase he used was “God is that than which no greater can be conceived”. There are two reasons as to why Anselm words this the way he does, reason one is the idea that “ no greater can be conceived” he doesn’t want you to be able to think about something greater hence the idea that no greater can be thought of by a person.
Analysis Of Anselm's Ontological Argument
1625 Words | 7 PagesAnselm’s “Ontological Argument” The general idea of the ontological argument is based on the notion that the concept of God as the greatest being implies that God exists—if not, there could be something greater, namely an existent greatest being—but this being would be God. The structure of the Ontological Argument can be outlined as follows (The argument is based on Anselm 's Proslogion 2): 1. We conceive of God as a being than which no greater can be conceived.
Anselm Of Canterbury's Analysis
301 Words | 2 PagesIf God only exists in human understanding, there leaves a possibility that something greater can be conceived. In this sense, there is an implied
Beatrice Divine Comedy Analysis
969 Words | 4 PagesSince nothing can compare to God, the Deus Homo is the only relatively analogous solution. Saint Anselm’s presumption circulating the explanation of the Deus Homo is preferred over that of
Thomas Aquinas's Five Proofs For The Existence Of God
419 Words | 2 PagesSt. Thomas Aquinas has five proofs for the existence of God. The first proof is the argument of motion. This proof explains that our senses prove that things are in motion, and that an actual movement can create a potential movement into an actual movement. Everything that is in motion is first moved by something else which would be the first mover. The first mover is understood to be God.
Anselm's Argument For The Existence Of God
550 Words | 3 PagesHe also believed that God is the greatest possible being, God exists in the understanding (mind), and that a being that exists in reality and understanding is greater than understanding by its self. Anselm also believed that God had a necessary existence instead of a contingent existence. I do not agree with Anselm when
Ontological Argument For The Existence Of Judeo-Christian God
485 Words | 2 PagesThe ontological argument is one of the three main arguments for the existence of the Judeo-Christian God. This argument is designed to appeal to rational rather than non-rational reasons for the existence of God. Rational reasoning can be identified through the use of reason, logic, argumentation, and our shared observations of the world, whereas non-rational reasoning is characterized by subjective religious experience. However, the ontological argument does not appeal to the logic consisting of our shared observations of the world because it focuses on the reflection of our own idea of God, therefore validating the cosmological argument to be a priori since none of it’s premises require empirical support. St. Anselm of Canterbury provided a renowned version of the cosmological argument around 1080 AD that establishes the existence of God by reflecting on our idea of Him.
Anselm's Ontological Argument Analysis
761 Words | 4 PagesFirstly, it is formidable since he is able to give the atheist the most charitable assumption that “God exists only in the understanding”, and then go on to show its contradiction and reduce it to absurdity. Furthermore, the defense for Anselm’s argument is a strong one. With the infinity argument, Anselm can solidify his claim that his argument is an exclusive argument for “sui generis” entities. Of course, skeptics would have us agree that two such entities may not prove that all such entities can seamlessly pass Anselm’s argument. However, with the infinity argument, we are one step closer to understanding how Anselm’s argument truly works.
Wager's Argument For The Existence Of God
378 Words | 2 PagesThe ontological argument states that perfection is a part of the concept of God, and that perfection entails existence, and so the concept of God entails God’s existence. However, it can be argued that if God is an infinite goodness, then its contrary, evil, should not exist. Alas, there is evil in the world, and, therefore, God cannot exist. The ontological argument also seeks to demonstrate that God exists on the basis of concept alone. Pascal’s Wager attempts to justify the belief in God with an
Anselm's Monologion Sparknotes
1083 Words | 5 PagesAnselm goes on to argue that this "something" must necessarily exist in reality, as something that exists in reality is greater than something that exists only in the understanding. Through his reflections, Anselm offers a unique perspective on the nature of God and the relationship between faith and reason, and his arguments continue to resonate with modern-day philosophers and theologians. The problem of evil and the nature of God, in particular, have a bearing on the discussions currently taking place in philosophy and theology. The Monologion is a foundational text in the evolution of philosophical and theological discussions within the Christian tradition over many centuries, and its influence can still be felt today. In Anselm's Monologion, he presents a unique perspective on the nature of God and the relationship between faith and reason, with the ontological argument as a central feature.
Thomas Aquinas Argument On The Existence Of God
1599 Words | 7 PagesAnselm argument is about God’s existence, comparing God’s, existence of a painting. Anselm argues a painting is a creation that was once an idea in a painter’s head, but that does not mean the idea of the painting was not always alive. In disagreement it is clear that Anselm is a new Christian, because this is what new Christian’s struggle with or complain how they cannot see God so why do they need to seek someone they cannot see with their whole heart. The strength of his argument is Anselm has a point that everybody comes across at one point in their lives that one cannot see God and it is up to this person to put their faith in God. God does want his creation that is us to have a choice in his own existence and he wants his creation to have faith in its own existence.
Ontological Argument Analysis
994 Words | 4 PagesThe Ontological argument was part of the Philosophy of Religion and therefore needed a proof, somewhat of a logical, sound argument. This argument was in fact the most bold, daring, and bewildering argument in the history of Western philosophy. Anselm’s claim that God must exist because the concept of God exists certainly angered a few philosophers like St. Thomas Aquinas while other philosophers like Immanuel Kant tried to disprove such an argument; simply because it was absurd to them. However much absurd this argument may be, it truly was such a beautiful type of reasoning in the eyes of all philosophers. Anselm’s ontological argument started off by stating that the most perfect “thing” that one could possible think of is God and that there is nothing higher.
Rene Descartes Why Does God Exist
681 Words | 3 PagesWhich could come from any idea or imaginative thought hes ever had for example thinking of a ghost therefore ghosts must be devine since they physically dont exist they must have put this in my head for a reason therfore they are god like creatures. This proves, his points have no standing at all.
More about Recitation Over Anselm's Proslogion Summary
Dialectical Journal For The Secret Life Of Marilyn
716 Words | 3 PagesSaint Anselm's Objection To The Ontological Argument
1400 Words | 6 PagesWhat Phrase Does Anselm Use To Designate God
458 Words | 2 PagesAnalysis Of Anselm's Ontological Argument
1625 Words | 7 PagesAnselm Of Canterbury's Analysis
301 Words | 2 PagesBeatrice Divine Comedy Analysis
969 Words | 4 PagesThomas Aquinas's Five Proofs For The Existence Of God
419 Words | 2 PagesAnselm's Argument For The Existence Of God
550 Words | 3 PagesOntological Argument For The Existence Of Judeo-Christian God
485 Words | 2 PagesAnselm's Ontological Argument Analysis
761 Words | 4 PagesWager's Argument For The Existence Of God
378 Words | 2 PagesAnselm's Monologion Sparknotes
1083 Words | 5 PagesThomas Aquinas Argument On The Existence Of God
1599 Words | 7 PagesOntological Argument Analysis
994 Words | 4 PagesRene Descartes Why Does God Exist
681 Words | 3 Pages