‘Are we bound by it?’: Language and Gendered representations of power in Oleanna The world chronicled in David Mamet’s Oleanna is entirely disparate from the utopian paradise that Pete Seeger croons about in his song. Here, every use of language is charged with assumptions of power and gender that Mamet seeks to explore and critique. This review, using the film as a template seeks to investigate the way in which use of and access to language invests the individual with a certain semblance of power, thereby exploring how authority and domination is predicated on the application of these linguistic strategies by both genders. Distraught student Carol’s attempt to seek help from her professor John sets the plot in motion. What follows is palpably …show more content…
John doesn’t let her speak and patronisingly counters her every remark with drawn out refrains of ‘Yes. . . that’s right’. John’s penchant for interrupting and choosing to ignore Carol’s repeated pleas of ‘teach me’ is rooted in a sense of linguistic privilege that the membership of an academic institution affords him and he uses this power to appropriate Carol’s use of language. He deliberately uses convoluted academic words (such as stoics, paradigm) aimed at distancing and defining the power dynamics between them, and revealing that the access to language is contingent on socio-economic factors. Carol later castigates John for his elitist use of language saying, ‘then why can’t you use that word?’ John’s delusional claim of being a liberal educator who seeks to remove the ‘an artificial stricture between teachers and students’ is shattered by Carol’s assertion that he is a ‘vile’ hypocrite who ‘believes in nothing’. John recounts an anecdote where he was made to ‘feel stupid’ and seemingly sympathises with Carol’s plight. However, Critic Deborah Tannen claims that ‘any show of solidarity necessarily entails power.’( Tannen 3). By identifying with Carol, John automatically places himself in a position of privilege by generalising her and refusing to …show more content…
Language is laden with presumptions of the culture and for a man in a position of power like John to ridicule and dismiss it is extremely oppressive and exploitative just as his remarks about the futility of education are, ‘what is that but rape; I swear to God’ Carol asserts. The power dynamic is exhibited through verbal and non verbal cues in the course of the film. The inability to ‘understand’ and the deliberate defining of certain terms accounts for the shift in power balance. John defines prejudice as, ‘An unreasoned belief. We are all subject to it. When it is threatened, or opposed, we feel anger. . . ’, John’s prejudiced anger strikes back in his explosive outburst in the final scene of the film. Mamet throws light on the prejudices of society that we have internalized to the point of not registering their consequences and forces us like John to, ‘look in [y]ourself and see those things that I see. And you can find revulsion equal to my own.’ The especially striking images of the ladder and the paper airplane serve as pivotal symbols. The ladder that they both wrestle with emblematises the hierarchy of academia, and the phallic plane that is passed around during their verbal jousting represents the
In “Slurring Perspectives,” Elisabeth Camp begins with the argument that slurs are “powerful” and “insidious” precisely because they “present contents from a certain perspective, which is difficult to dislodge despite the fact that it is precisely what a nonbigoted hearer most wants to resist.” It is this reason why slurs are considered more offensive than “pure expressives” like “damn,” because they denote certain negative properties which are meant to contain harmful, “truth-conditionally robust properties” (Camp 330). Camp then goes on to say that slurs “conventionally signal a speaker’s allegiance to a derogating perspective on the group identified by the slur’s extension-determining core” (Camp 331). It is this derogating perspective
1. In the chapter “The Test Case” in How to Read Literature like a Professor by Thomas Foster, Foster presents several different interpretations of the story “The Garden Party”. Foster then shows the readers interpretations of the short story that his college students have articulated. Foster’s interpretation, however, goes much deeper.
Even after Owen accidentally kill’s John mother by hitting her with a baseball, the two boys remain friends. John tells tales of his and Owen’s lives, from when they are kids to Owen’s death, and even after that horrible event. Owen effects every aspect of John’s life in a way that no other person could. The novel, however,
John, a missionary, for the first time she is the little girl lost in the woods. St. John is very passionate about his work as a missionary in India, which is what he is home prepping for. Once the reader gets to know St. John he is a hard and cold man, who focuses on one thing and that is marrying a beautiful woman and taking her with him to be his missionary wife. This makes the reader and Jane ignore the fact that he is handsome, blonde, and blue-eyed. Now to focus on that Jane came into St. John’s life poor, starving and alone.
In her essay, The Legacy of Eleanor Roosevelt, author Betty Houchin Winfield argues that because of her journalistic career and the precedent she had on the role of the first lady, Eleanor Roosevelt was one of the most influential women in American history. Winfield, unlike many other authors who write on the topic, does not spend an extensive amount of time focusing on Eleanor’s works in organizations and charities. However, Winfield chooses to support her argument by supplying ample information concerning the precedent Eleanor left not only on the role of the first lady, but also on the role of the American woman. Although only briefly mentioning her active involvement in several organizations, The Legacy of Eleanor Roosevelt is effective in demonstrating how by
Due to the occupation that Mr. Hanks holds, there is often a perceived disconnect between the average person and himself, which can then make delivering an important message all the more difficult as there is no emotional connection between him and the audience. Tom overcomes this hurdle with the aforementioned use of the universal feeling of love, which all can relate to. Once common ground is found between the speaker and the audience, he begins to foreshadow his later
Differences among social classes are apparent in every single society; such distinctions were especially visible in the British Isles during the late nineteenth century, the setting of Henry James’s 1891 short story “The Pupil”. James portrays an employer-employee and an employee-client relationship of scorn with its roots in socioeconomic inequality by using devices such as point of view and diction. The narration’s focus on Pemberton’s point of view highlights the class disparity between the characters, thus explaining Pemberton’s distaste for his employer and student. The author writes the story from a third person limited point of view with its focus on Pemberton’s perspective.
Some classmates felt that his last shred of hope to keep him alive was his hatred for the party while others agreed that his love for Julia would help him from conforming back to the ideals of the party. When discussing what another classmates have found in class it has helped me to understand other points I might have overlooked in the novels we have read. I have improved from these activities by writing down other points and
You’re not qualified to teach here in England.’ When Hortense attempts to challenge the white lady she is shunned immediately and asked to leave, she is rejected for teaching on the basis of her race. Hortense contests normalised racial views that ‘Blacks should similarly occupy a lower position in the class structure since their biology or culture limits their skills, education and interests.’ Despite Hortense’s teacher training in Jamaica she is deemed inadequate to teach in England because she is not white or essentially ‘British’. An unsuccessful attempt to elevate her educational prospects is a means to subvert racial expectations and beliefs which are upheld about Black women.
It is at this point Laurie’s behavior at home rivals that of Charles’s behavior at school and the readers can begin to see the parallels between Laurie’s and Charles’s behavior that leads to the determination that Charles is made
Exercise 4: In Toni Morrison's Nobel Lecture, she uses parallel structure to emphasize the pervasive nature of oppressive language. Morrison structures her argument by listing various types of language, each introduced with the same phrase "whether it is. " This repetition of structure reinforces the idea that oppressive language exists in many forms and is ubiquitous.
Charles Baxter’s “Gryphon” provides an interesting look at standardized education and the way society views those who deviate from it. Baxter shows this through how the narrator Tommy views his new substitute, Miss Ferenczi. The character Miss Ferenczi tries to revolt against the clinical and strict standards of society and positively impact the morality and ethicality of herself, Tommy, and the fourth graders. While some readers may think that Miss Ferenczi is either morally inept or somewhat delusional, she proves herself to be a person who cares to teach the children how to love learning.
In Martha’s personal narrative, “The Scholarship Jacket,” Martha Salinas shares her experience when she has earned the scholarship jacket but almost loses it to a less deserving peer. In the beginning, 14 year old Martha, is attending in a small Texas school in 8th grade. Martha knows she would get the scholarship jacket because she has earned straight A’s for the past 8 years. Forgetting her PE bag in one of her classrooms, she overhears a conversation between her history teacher, Mr.Schmidt, and Mr. Boone, her math teacher. When she hears they were arguing about her and who would get the scholarship jacket, Martha became shocked and ran.
Mr. Keating breaks the students out of their shells and they come alive. The students also become engaged after starting “Dead Poets Society” they begin to express themselves through poetry. 4. How do changes in the immediate situation affect the
Language is a direct indicator of power; those who are adept in controlling the language are able to exploit the ignorance of those under them and thus assert their dominance. As demonstrated throughout