Advantages And Disadvantages Of Restorative Justice
There are various charges against the employment of restorative justice. Basically, these charges critic the work and ideas of the way restorative justice aims at addressing crime in society. Let’s explore the following charge; “Restorative justice does not fit the thinking of legal practitioners”. (Batley 2005; 24). Thus, legal practitioners often argue that this approach is not fit enough for the criminal justice system. Hence, their perception that restorative justice as not taking seriously the fundamental concerns of a criminal justice system.
Firstly, we need to understand the idea of serving justice according to the legal practitioners. Most legal practitioners employ the retributive approach to address crime. This approach posits that punishment is to right the wrong done in the criminal offence. While the offenders’ suffering or loss which in most cases imprisonment is what constitutes the ‘pay back’ to society and the victims (Batley 2005; 25).
In contrast, restorative justice gives a very profound and different meaning to the term ‘paying back’ for the crime. In restorative justice the offender pays back for the crime committed by taking responsibility and fully acknowledging their actions, that includes repairing the harm and restore the relationship while allowing the victim to know what happened. By so doing, victims and the
…show more content…
This process is congruent to the social work values, which is to respect the worth and dignity of clients and recognising the importance of relationships. Furthermore, it allows parties also have the option of having a relative or friend present to support them in the mediation process. (Naude, Prinsloo, Ladikos 2004;
Unit 1-1: Why We Need Law
1534 Words | 7 PagesMoney is everything in today’s world, more money means more power , so corporations for their major contributions to the economy by giving jobs and paying taxes are favoured by judges whilst an individual is nothing to compare, and yet again corporation can afford to hire better lawyers than what an individual could, rarely does it happen that you hear on the news about an individual who beat a corporation in a court debate, also because of the toll and srees that an individual would have to go through in order to beat a corporation in court. Natalie DeFreitas has made numerous points as to why restorative justice as better than/more effective than the current law system here in Canada. The speaker talked about the 70% recurrence of crimes whereas only 15% repeat crimes after restorative justice, Texas’ crime rates and jail enrollment have dropped, the cost of jail enrollment is 115,000 CAD$ for one year per person, whereas restorative justice only costs about 10,000 CAD$ for the same person throughout the same term and how much more effective can restorative justice be with a provided life example of John’s case, the bottom line is that restorative justice reduces crimes, improves the lives of criminals by healing and makes communities a safer
Protecting Innocence In A Carceral State By Erica R. Meiners
1033 Words | 5 Pages110). According to the author, the aim of restorative justice is to heal communities from an incident where people were harmed and, ideally, help prevent the same thing from happening again. I believe that, there is going to be a higher possibility of crime reduction in schools and in different neighborhood if victims and offenders mediate a restitution agreement to the satisfaction of each other. In conjunction to this, if the government can be more committed in supporting these approaches, I believe that there will be a massive drop in crime
Restorative Justice: A Selective Process
229 Words | 1 PagesRestorative justice is a very selective process, and can only truly work if both the victim and the offender agree to the terms of the conversation. In other words, strict vetting must be done on both the victim and the offender in order for restorative justice to occur. For this type of justice to actually be able to really work and bring about rehabilitation participation must be 100% voluntary otherwise it will fail. This among other things can be listed as a limitation of restorative justice. Another disadvantage is, that restorative justice cannot be implemented in all categories of crimes.
A Brief Note On Indigenous Canada And The Canadian Criminal Justice System
1157 Words | 5 PagesBeing a voluntary process, restorative justice requires the offender to take responsibility for their actions, truly understand their impact, and begin a journey of healing (Eggleton & Saint-Germain, 2018). Many Indigenous offenders are the product of their circumstances and feel helpless against the systemic hurdles they must overcome within society (Editorial Board, 2022). Restorative justice takes a less traditional approach compared to the oppressive justice system of today, enabling the Indigenous offender to be treated as a human being, and not just another statistic (Eggleton & Saint-Germain,
Restorative Justice Model
264 Words | 2 PagesThere are many differences between retributive and restorative justice. Their view on crime, how to control criminality, and response to crime differ. Retributive justice considers the offender taking accountability when they have been punished, while restorative justice focuses on the offender taking responsibility for their actions and attempting to repair the harm that their crime caused. Crime control is a role of the community in restorative justice, as opposed to the criminal justice system in retributive justice. Victims and the community play greater roles in the restorative justice model.
Criminal Justice Restorative Justice
451 Words | 2 PagesWithin the judicial and criminal justice systems, restorative justice is seen as a forward moving process in regards to the way in which the sentencing of offenders is handled (Britto & Reimund, 2013). Restorative justice works to focus on the needs of both the victim and the offender but incorporates the community as well as those who support both the victim and offender (Britto & Reimund, 2013). The approach of restorative justice in not simply a means by which society responds to and reduces crime but instead, provides an equivalently valuable social response to crime (Dancig-Rosenberg and Galt, 2013). Furthermore, the restorative approach places emphasis on the personal and relational harms which were caused by the crime while creating space for dialogue concerning the actual damage, whether directly or
Barry Levinston's Sleepers And The Restorative Justice System
849 Words | 4 PagesThis type of justice system is designed very differently when compared with the retributive justice system. The restorative justice system endeavours to bring the victim and the offender together and allow them to speak with each other in the hopes to support the healing process. It will enable the victims to express themselves to the offender and lets the offender apologize and express their feelings to the victim. The restorative justice system often offers the victims of crime closure. The system encourages both parties to reveal themselves to each other and develop a solution for the future to satisfy both parties involved.
Indeterminate Sentencing
147 Words | 1 PagesRestorative justice also known as balanced and restorative justice is “a sentencing model that builds on restitution and community participation in an attempt to make the victim whole again (Schmalleger 269).” Restorative justice focuses on “crime as harm and justice as repairing the harm”. This type of justice places crime control primarily in the hands of the community. 3. Indeterminate sentencing encourages rehabilitation using general unspecific sentences.
Restorative Justice Vs Utilitarianism
117 Words | 1 PagesRestorative Justice processes are likely to reduce criminals from repeating offenses, as numerous recidivism studies have demonstrated. Thus, it would be more than justified to employ restorative processes a response to crimes under
Pros And Cons Of Retributive Justice
1479 Words | 6 PagesToday our justice system has a multitude of options when dealing with those who are convicted of offenses. However, many argue that retributive justice is the only real justice there is. This is mainly because its advantage is that it gives criminals the appropriate punishment that they deserve. The goals of this approach are clear and direct. In his book The Little Book of Restorative Justice, Zehr Howard (2002), illustrates that the central focus of retributive justice is offenders getting what they deserve (p. 30).
Retributive Punishment: Immanuel Kant And Thomas Aquinas
718 Words | 3 Pages“Retribution” or “Retributive justice” can be defined as “a theory of justice that considers punishment, if proportionate, to be the best response to crime.” (Wikipedia, 2016) Peter Koritansky, philosopher and author made a distinction between two views on retributive punishment in his work entitled “Two theories of retributive punishment: Immanuel Kant and Thomas Aquinas” in 2005 in which he believed that the Thomistic understanding of retribution is superior to that of Kant and this write-up is going to outline the reasons as to why he think this is the case. To illustrate this, it is vital therefore that we understand the Kantian retributivism and Aquinas’s understanding of punishment. Firstly the Kantian retributivism or the theory of retributive by Immanuel Kant suggests that punishment in the form of coercion of force is necessary to establish justice and to punish criminals, he emphasized that “Punishment by a court…can never be inflicted merely as a means to promote some other good for the criminal himself or for civil society, but that it must always be inflicted upon him for the fact that he has committed a crime”
Arguments Against Retributivism
1926 Words | 8 PagesIn this essay, I will discuss whether the claim that retributivists are making are right by justifying whether their assumptions about moral responsibility are well founded. A person who has committed a crime must be punished. Punishment makes sure that the offender pays their debt to the society or state. Retributivism justifies that punishment is payback for crime and its main goal is to give the offender their just deserts.
Disadvantages Of Restorative Justice
2091 Words | 9 PagesBatley (2005) stated that restorative justice is about restoring, healing and re- integrating victims, offenders, as well as the society and also preventing further harm. In this assignment, I will be discussing approaches to restorative justice and illustrating their advantages and disadvantages to offending. I will also provide the applications of these five approaches of restorative justice which are retributive approach, utilitarian deterrence approach, rehabilitation approach, restitution approach and restorative approach in the given case study. I will then explain my preferred approach to justice through identifying a personal belief or value that underpins my choice.
Tyranny Research Paper
715 Words | 3 PagesThis trend and tyranny are discussed in detail and examined in depth in the coming parts. II. A glimpse of history, international principles and practices The concept of compensating victims for the loss they suffered and to restore them by making monetary amends is justified and encouraged because of the “benefit to the victims, possible deterrent effect on the offender or on the public, the possible educative or preventive effect on public morality, the possible reformative effect on offender of ill-gotten gains and the view that compensation has an ‘intrinsic moral value of its own’.”
Importance Of Dignity In Social Work
1101 Words | 5 PagesMaintenance of Clients’ Dignity in the Practice of Social Work The person is always a central axis in the process of social work. A person who becomes a client of the social worker is unique, his life history is unrepeatable. When a professional social worker affiliates a relationship with his client, he knows that his personality is violated, so they together have to try to restore a mutual beneficiary interaction between this person and the society. A social worker can accomplish this purpose just if his activity is conducted by highest values.
More about Advantages And Disadvantages Of Restorative Justice
Unit 1-1: Why We Need Law
1534 Words | 7 PagesProtecting Innocence In A Carceral State By Erica R. Meiners
1033 Words | 5 PagesRestorative Justice: A Selective Process
229 Words | 1 PagesA Brief Note On Indigenous Canada And The Canadian Criminal Justice System
1157 Words | 5 PagesRestorative Justice Model
264 Words | 2 PagesCriminal Justice Restorative Justice
451 Words | 2 PagesBarry Levinston's Sleepers And The Restorative Justice System
849 Words | 4 PagesIndeterminate Sentencing
147 Words | 1 PagesRestorative Justice Vs Utilitarianism
117 Words | 1 PagesPros And Cons Of Retributive Justice
1479 Words | 6 PagesRetributive Punishment: Immanuel Kant And Thomas Aquinas
718 Words | 3 PagesArguments Against Retributivism
1926 Words | 8 PagesDisadvantages Of Restorative Justice
2091 Words | 9 PagesTyranny Research Paper
715 Words | 3 PagesImportance Of Dignity In Social Work
1101 Words | 5 Pages