ipl-logo

Reva Siegel Summary

1105 Words5 Pages

broad concept and does not have a clear-cut definition. Even though the government should interfere as little as possible in people’s private lives, a right as controversial as a woman’s choice to have abortion requires a sturdy, precisely defined constitutional basis that is capable of providing protection for such an important women’s right.
B. Reva Siegel’s Contribution to the Equality Approach Another scholar who is in favor of the equality approach and who reinforces MacKinnon’s argument is Reva Siegel. She has written a historical piece that is extremely important to understand both the women’s movement and the process of constitutional change through cases like Roe v. Wade. Her main historical argument is that the understanding of …show more content…

For instance, there have been many people who argue that women need to be protected from abortion. I think what she is trying to highlight here is that these arguments are based on old, backwards, paternalistic ideas that women should be protected from bad decisions, or from coercion, by taking away their decisions instead of empowering them to make the choice themselves. This paternalistic way of thinking is unconstitutional under the Equal Protection Clause. MacKinnon said that “the point is to apply existing law to women as if women were citizens—as if the doctrine was not gendered to women’s disadvantage, as if the legal system had no sex, as if women were gender neutral persons temporality trapped by law in female bodies.” Siegel agrees and says that abortion bans are subordinating and based on archaic …show more content…

First, the equality argument in this context should be looked at as a way of showing how the legal system leaves out women’s rights and concerns when defining reproductive rights. Second, the right to abortion is all-inclusive and is not based on two different liberties, but on the fact that they are connected. I think any analysis should include both the aspect of the physical as well as that of the social. If it does focus on one or the other, it should acknowledge that the approach is

Show More
Related

  • Norma Mccorvey's Abortion Case Study

    150 Words  | 1 Pages

    The author’s purpose was to challenge the fact that there really wasn’t a human side to abortion, just feminist lawyers pushing their agenda. Norma McCorvey, author, filed a case known in court documents as Jane ROE against Henry WADE, the district attorney of Dallas County who enforced a Texas law that prohibited abortion, except to save a woman 's life. The ruling allowed for legal abortions during the entire pregnancy, but set up conditions to allow states to regulate abortion during the second and third trimesters. The Court held that a woman 's right to an abortion fell within the right to privacy protected by the Fourteenth Amendment. This information will be effective in my debate since, because of this case, the decision gave a

    Read More

  • 14th Amendment Pros And Cons

    519 Words  | 3 Pages

    " The Texas abortion law was ruled unconstitutional, but was not the only state to be unconstitutional toward abortion laws or women's rights. Still to this day the right for a women to have an abortion is not fully fair. It is being looked upon as inhuman, and wrong for a woman to have an abortion, but more women have been more accepting since 1973. Roe v. Wade helped women's right and showed the court how unconstitutional the states had been toward women's

    Read More

  • Essay In What Ways Did The Supreme Court Shape Women's Reproductive Rights

    2213 Words  | 9 Pages

    The purpose of the case is a value to my investigation as its verdict resulted in paramount reproductive independencies, demonstrating the Court’s authority over human freedoms, paired with progressiveness towards individual liberties. The content of the case is a value to my investigation as it includes several provisions expanding women’s rights, including the need for privacy, removal of limitations on the frequency of abortions and the attempts to save fetuses, demonstrating the severe lack of rights in 1985, necessitating revisions. The contents of this case is a limitation as it discusses the involvement of states and physicians to halt abortions, subsequently not focusing on actual limitations of reproductive rights, including cases in which abortion was illegal. This fails to demonstrate the full scope of restrictions on women’s rights

    Read More

  • Roe V. Wade Argumentative Analysis

    2168 Words  | 9 Pages

    From 1848 to 1920, an outrageous span of 70 years, women fought for equal rights, to have their voices and opinions heard. Little by little women have gained rights they have so passionately fought for. In 1973, about 50 years after women became eligible to vote, and began to be taken more seriously, the case of Roe v Wade granted women to have one of the most impactful rights to date, to terminate an unwanted pregnancy. Now, it is safe to say that all women and perhaps most men would not want women to lose the rights they have today, especially because there have been many influential women around the world who have been given the chance to be impactful because of the rights they possess. So, if we do not want to take away women’s rights and

    Read More

  • The Impact Of Roe V. Wade

    309 Words  | 2 Pages

    Sanger wanted women everywhere to refrain from the negativity that stemmed from abortions and unwanted pregnancies. As time passed woman everywhere won a huge victory in 1973 case of Roe v. Wade. The Supreme Court adjudicated that the states had no jurisdiction to outlaw abortions during the first trimester of pregnancy (PBS.ORG). This new law brought a new wave of opposition to abortion and continues to cause differences of opinion among supporters of women’s rights and supporters of life. According to “What has been the Impact of Roe v. Wade”, four decades after the law was passed the issue of abortion remains contentious.

    Read More

  • Mary Anne Warren's Rights Of Abortion

    794 Words  | 4 Pages

    As humans, we are given different rights that are meant to provide us with a chance at a good life. However, these rights can become compromised when it comes to conflicts between a pregnant woman and her fetus. The right of the fetus to live is seen as inferior to the right of the mother to have an abortion. Although each of the rights is different, it is not appropriate to say that one citizen’s rights are more superior than another citizen’s rights.

    Read More

  • Rhetorical Analysis Of Florence Kelly's Speech

    838 Words  | 4 Pages

    But we are almost powerless,” (Line 78-80) this is one such example of her assertiveness towards the issue. She also directs the sentence to the women attending her speech by using the word ‘powerless’ as at that time, women did not have any voting rights and therefore no say in anything. She also

    Read More

  • Declaration Of Sentiments Rhetorical Analysis

    696 Words  | 3 Pages

    This obviously shows she is on the side of women's rights in her argument and again, quoting the Declaration of Independence, gives her the quality of formality using lines from a piece that dear to American

    Read More

  • Immigration Persuasive Speech

    709 Words  | 3 Pages

    As a woman, I believe that my rights should not be determined by some man in Washington DC. Instead, everyone should be entitled to their own opinion. Abortions and contraceptives are not procedures or medications that women usually advertise and frankly, it is none of government’s business what women choose to do with their own bodies. They are not the property of men or the

    Read More

  • Roe V. Wade Argumentative Essay

    1038 Words  | 5 Pages

    Before Roe v. wade the number of deaths from illegal abortions was around 5000 and in the 50s and 60s the number of illegal abortions ranged from 200,000 to 1.2 million per year. These illegal abortions pose major health risks to the life of the woman including damage to the bladder, intestines as well as rupturing of the uterus. The choice to become a mother must be given to the woman most importantly because it’s her body, her health, and she will be taking on a great responsibility. A woman’s choice to choose abortion should not be restricted by anyone; there are multiple reasons why abortion will be the more sensible decision for the female.

    Read More

  • Women's Reproductive Rights

    1329 Words  | 6 Pages

    Women’s rights have been a long struggle in America’s legal system, as well as in the religious world, for many decades and women continue to have challenges, concerns, and struggles today. Fighting for what is best for their bodies such as a woman’s right to contraceptives to control whether she will get pregnant or not was not ideal for religious and personal reasons but would find a worthy advocate in a woman who would dedicate her life for women’s reproductive rights. The right for a woman to have an abortion became a legal battle that went all the way to the Supreme Courts in a very well-known case. It has always been a double standard in what was right and wrong, moral or immoral, towards women than men. A man was looked at with respect

    Read More

  • Persuasive Speech Outline On Abortion

    1277 Words  | 6 Pages

    VIII. Abortion is a really serious thing and should only be pondered after the persons involved have considered other alternatives such as give it to the other persons that in need of a baby as adoption. IX. I don’t believe that the abortion argument should be about rights, but about potentiality. X.

    Read More

  • Rhetorical Analysis Of Women's Rights To Suffrage By Susan B Anthony

    1137 Words  | 5 Pages

    In today’s world, it seems to be that women have the same rights as men, but it wasn't always this way. The speech “Women’s Rights to Suffrage” by Susan B Anthony is the most compelling of all. Susan B Anthony persuades the audience that all women should have the same rights as men. It’s shown through the speech that the federal constitution says “we the people”, the government has no right to take away rights from just one gender, and that women are considered people as well. The fact that the constitution says “we the people” is a primary point in this speech.

    Read More

  • Argumentative Essay On Pro Choice

    1132 Words  | 5 Pages

    Doris Gudino Professor Chounlamountry Political Science 1 27 July 2015 Pro-Choice Anyone? A woman has, undoubtedly, the freedom to procreate, but once a woman chooses to retreat from that freedom, a commotion arises. Abortion is a woman’s choice for many reasons. It’s her body, therefore, no one else can decide for said person.

    Read More

  • Critical Analysis Of Abortion

    1021 Words  | 5 Pages

    “Abortion -should it be a right of every woman in the present context- A critical analysis” 1. Introduction I elected to present my dissertation on a topic based on ‘abortion’ since it is a hidden social menace in our society. It is like an iceberg. The tip represents the reported abortions, which everyone sees.

    Read More

More about Reva Siegel Summary

Open Document