ipl-logo

Review Of By Order Of The President, By Greg Robinson

567 Words3 Pages

In By Order of the President, author Greg Robinson examines the controversial topic of President Franklin D. Roosevelt’s decision to relocate more than 100,000 Japanese-American citizens into internment camps for the duration of World War Two using Executive Order 9066. Preceding studies have sought to explain Roosevelt’s decision as a sensible reaction to bureaucratic pressure from military and political leaders on the West Coast, who feared the control Japanese-Americans and pro-Japanese held. Despite the vast examination of the Japanese Internment dilemma, Robinson argues that scholars have not sufficiently examined Roosevelt’s role in creating and implementing the internment policy. Robinson argues that typical narratives tend to diminish …show more content…

The narrative begins with the first two chapters focusing on assessing Roosevelt’s evolving attitude toward Japan and Japanese-Americans, during his pre-presidential years and his first two terms in office. Continuing, Robinson changes directions and focuses on the origin and implementation of the internment policy, beginning with Roosevelt’s decision to issue Executive Order 9066 in February 1942, the authorization of relocating Japanese-Americans from the West Coast into internment camps, the subsequent controversy over with Japanese-Americans deemed “loyal” to the United States, and the decision to finally close the camps in 1946. The final chapter concludes with Robinson attempting to understand how Roosevelt, whom historians have celebrated for his strong commitment to individual rights, could have supported such an unjust policy. Robinson argues Roosevelt’s “past feelings toward the Japanese-Americans must be considered to have significantly shaped his momentous decision to evacuate Japanese-Americans from their homes … whether citizens or longtime resident aliens, [Japanese-Americans] were still Japanese at the core and should be regarded as presumptuously disloyal and dangerous on racial grounds” (p. 118 -

Show More
Related
526 Words | 3 Pages

government implemented a system of outsider confinement offices. They were desensitizing codes word for detainment facilities and filled them with around 120,000 Japanese-Americans, 66% of whom were American residents and about every one of whom wee never charged, attempted or sentenced any wrongdoing. At the time these facilities were considered a “security” measure, but looking back now we can see they were nothing but unjustified judgement caused by the fear of American people and military. “Even in the aftermath of a disaster as largest Pearl Harbor, Eleanor felt the guarantees of the Bill of Rights must be protected. Roosevelt did not agree.

Read More
689 Words | 3 Pages

This, however, is not credible because many Japanese-Americans had lived in America for generations, considering America their true home. The fear in their race is no reason to support the Executive Order 9066. [CONCLUSION] The Japanese internment camps in the United States, caused by the President Roosevelt's Executive Order 9066, was not justified and never should have occurred. The citizens that were locked up in those camps, like women and children, posed no threat to the

Read More
506 Words | 3 Pages

2017 marked seventy-five years since the controversy - President Roosevelt signed the Execute Order 9066 and evacuated Japanese residents to internment camps. By taking this decision, Roosevelt demonstrates his personal responsibilities, the character traits of individuals when feeling accountable for others and taking actions within ones' power. While the authority later apologized and showed willingness to take responsible for any consequences, the law turned out to be tolerable in specific cultures. When issuing the Execute Order 9066, President Roosevelt intended to protect America from a domestic war.

Read More
1370 Words | 6 Pages

Imagine living in San Francisco, CA you’re a 12 year old, Japanese- American boy, you have black straight hair, round glasses, a small petite frame, and all your family were residents from Japan. On April 1, 1942, Lieutenant General John Dewitt from the U.S. Army ordered all Japanese persons, both alien and non-alien to evacuate San Francisco by a designated time. All Japanese-Americans were evacuated, loaded on buses and relocated to camps by the Western Defense Command and Forth Army Wartime Civil Control Administration. Executive order 9066, by President Roosevelt stated the internment of 100,000 American citizens of Japanese ancestry and resident aliens from Japan. On September 1940, Japan signed the Tripartite Pact with Germany and Italy, entering the military alliance against the United States, also known as the “Axis”.

Read More
1699 Words | 7 Pages

How would you feel if one day you were told to leave your whole life behind to live in captivity just because people halfway across the world did something wrong? This horror story was all too true for the thousands of Japanese Americans alive during World War II. Almost overnight, thousands of proud Japanese Americans living on the west coast were forced to leave their homes and give up the life they knew. The United States government was not justified in the creation of Japanese internment camps because it stripped law-abiding American citizens of their rights out of unjustified fear.

Read More
279 Words | 2 Pages

Remember to have an intro, a conclusion and body paragraphS Topic: Propaganda around Japanese internment camps Although the Japanese internment camps were labeled as a way to “protect Japanese-American citizens”, it was the worst decision possible, and ruins the United State’s reputation when people learn about it. Approximately 120,000 Japanese-American citizens were locked away in areas which can be described as Unhygienic, and prison-like. The Japanese internment camps resembled a prison in many ways, for instance, the citizens who lived here had a single room with no privacy whatsoever. Barbed wire and watchtowers were also surrounding the camps, with a guard at each tower for “protection”.

Read More
463 Words | 2 Pages

After the bombing of Pearl Harbor, President Franklin D. Roosevelt issued Executive Order 9066, which authorized the forced relocation of Japanese Americans living on the West Coast. Over 120,000 people were uprooted from their lives and placed in internment camps, where they faced harsh living conditions and limited freedoms. The internment was based on the belief that Japanese Americans were a threat to national security, even though the majority were U.S. citizens and had no ties to Japan. The internment showed the dangers of scapegoating and stereotyping, as a whole group of people were punished based on the actions of a

Read More
187 Words | 1 Pages

In the article “Japanese American Internment,” the author develops the central theme well over the course of the text. First, the author begins by using an excerpt from Franklin Delano Roosevelt’s “Day of Infamy” speech to describe the Japanese attacks and, ultimately, the cause for Japanese American internment. As a result of this, “the president issued Executive Order 9066 … [which] authorized the evacuation and relocation of ‘any and all persons’ from ‘military areas.’” Next, the author describes the relocation process and life in the internment camps.

Read More
808 Words | 4 Pages

Akiko Kurose, who was 16 and attending a Seattle high school at the time, described when, after the Pearl Harbor attack, “one of the teachers said, ‘You people bombed Pearl Harbor’”, referencing Akiko’s Japanese heritage (Document 1). If, indeed, this was the general feeling of all non-Japanese Americans, than it is easy to see how amassed public hatred could lead to the internment of the hated. The government was even aware of the minimal threat posed by the interned—The Munson Report, delivered to President Roosevelt by his Special Representative of the States Department, Charles Munson, has such a statement as follows, “There is no Japanese ‘problem’ on the Coast. There will be no armed uprising of Japanese” (Document 4). And Mary Tsukamoto, who was an American of Japanese heritage, was forced in 1942 to an internment camp with her husband and child, leaving their strawberry farm behind, described her shock, “We couldn't believe that they would need all of us to quit our work to produce our fruit, food for victory... and then be put away”(Document 3).

Read More
786 Words | 4 Pages

Due to the increasing fear of a Japanese attack on the West Coast, Lt. General John L. Dewitt recommended that all people of Japanese descent living in America be removed to the interior of the country. In the article “An American Tragedy: The Internment of Japanese-Americans During World War II” by Norman Y. Mineta, former US Secretary of Transportation, Dewitt backed up his suggestion with rumors that “ethnic Japanese on the West Coast were signaling Japanese ships out in the Pacific ocean” and they “had stockpiled numerous rounds of ammunition and weapons” (Mineta 161). In order to combat this threat in case of enemy invasion, the camps would detain the Japanese Americans so they cannot aid the enemy. The warped logic used to imprison 110,000 people purely based on ethnic background was convincing enough to the American people that they didn’t even question

Read More
572 Words | 3 Pages

This causes President Roosevelt to sign the Executive Order 9066, which resulted in the forcible internment of 120,000 people of Japanese ancestry. More than two-thirds of those interned under the Executive Order were citizens of the United States and had never shown any disloyalty toward the country. But, because of suspicion of the Japanese and didn’t trust them. The article says “The Japanese Americans were forced to leave their homes and businesses, carrying only a limited number of suitcases, with items necessary for their basic needs in the harsh conditions of the camps.” Suspicion caused the Americans to be cruel to the Japanese-Americans just because of their

Read More
1428 Words | 6 Pages

On December 7th, 1941, Japan launched one of the most devastating attacks that occurred on United States soil killing over 2000 citizens. Ironically, the death of these citizens resulted in the United States government violating the rights of over 100,000 Japanese Americans living along the Pacific Coast. The attack on Pearl harbor exacerbated the already present anti-Japanese sentiment within the United States resulting in the removal and incarceration of Japanese Americans in internment camps. This historiographical essay will examine the trends of historical thought regarding Japanese internment during World War II examining sources chronologically by publication date from 1972 to 2017. Early historiographical interpretations, referred to

Read More
496 Words | 2 Pages

The internment of Japanese Americans during WWII was not justified. After Pearl Harbor, many Americans were scared of the Japanese Americans because they could sabotage the U.S. military. To try and solve the fear President Franklin D Roosevelt told the army in Executive order 9066 to relocate all Japanese Americans living on the West Coast. They were relocated to detention centers in the desert. Many of them were in the detention centers for three years.

Read More
320 Words | 2 Pages

After the attack on Pearl Harbor on December 7, 1941, and the start of World War II for the U.S, the government decided that, to keep this country safe, to imprison all people of japanese heritage in internment camps. Japanese Americans were forced to sell their land and most of their belongings and travel on buses to where they would live for the next 5 years. They were forced into quickly built camps, and sometimes forced to build the place they were living in. Most of the living quarters were repurposed horse stables, and multiple families were crowded together in them. In 1944, President Franklin D. Roosevelt rescinded Executive Order 9066, shutting down the camps.

Read More
1523 Words | 7 Pages

Thesis statement: Though many speculate that the act of dropping the atomic bomb on Japan (Hiroshima and Nagasaki) while not doing so on Europe (Germany and Italy) was racially motivated, racism played little to no role in these bombings. The United States of America and her allies were willing to end World War II at any cost, had the atomic bombs been available they would have been deployed in Europe. In the 1940’s there is no doubt that the United States of America was engulfed by mass anti-Japanese hysteria which inevitably bled over into America’s foreign policy. During this period Japanese people living in both Japan and the United States of America were seen as less that human.

Read More

More about Review Of By Order Of The President, By Greg Robinson

Open Document