ipl-logo

Richard Swinburne Miracles And Historical Evidence Summary

885 Words4 Pages

Abby McVay Richard Swinburne Miracles and Historical Evidence Summary: "We have four kinds of evidence about what happened at some past instant-our own apparent memories of our past experiences, the testimony of others about their past experiences, physical traces, and our contemporary understanding of what things are physically impossible," Richard Swinburne mentioned in the second paragraph (page 455). Swinburne ponders what evidence would be needed to support miracles and then challenges arguments put forward by philosophers, like Hume, and the laws of nature. Swinburne's evidence for supporting miracles consists of four main arguments mentioned in the quote. Once the guidelines to support evidence are identified, Swinburne argues that …show more content…

Based on laws of nature and his arguments, he would argue yes because even though it goes against the laws of nature, the testimonies have equal weight and justification. According to the three subsidiary principles, how can one rule out any of the testimonies? For instance, how can Swinburne say that fifty individual testimonies, that are fairly consistent, of this experience or event be called reliable? Swinburne cannot logically state that all fifty people were right if they had the same account of the apple incident if the laws of nature are in place. There are things like delusion and exaggeration to some degree. He also goes on to think that the testimonies have the same justification as the laws themselves. If this were the case, wouldn't we have our own biases towards our own testimonies? How would we then perceive universal laws, if there are any with this way of thinking? For example, if the apple incident had occurred, those fifty people would believe that they have more justification in their testimonies than the laws of nature. If their testimonies were correct and had justification, then the laws of nature would be broken, which cannot happen. It cannot happen because we see the laws of nature in practice all the time, like electric lights and gravity, but how can one throw out a testimony that someone found true if they see it happening, like the laws of nature? Let's provide the apple example again; but instead of fifty people witnessing it, there was only one. Should we ought to shut this person down for believing that this event happened even if nobody else saw the event and it violates the laws of

Show More
Related

  • Summary Of Lindsay G. Robertson's Conquest By Law

    1879 Words  | 8 Pages

    Lindsay G. Robertson's Conquest by Law: How the Discovery of America Dispossessed Indigenous Peoples of Their Lands centers on the landmark 1823 Supreme Court case Johnson vs. M'Intosh. Robertson's research provides previously undiscovered knowledge of the circumstances surrounding the case, placing the case in a new context both politically and judicially. Robertson tells the story of a costly mistake, one made by the American judicial system but paid for by an indigenous people who to this day suffer from the effects of American settlement. As reviewer Christopher Tomlin writes, "Robertson's narrative is far less concerned with parsing its legal doctrine, than with the historical circumstances of the case itself." Robertson begins his

    Read More

  • What Are The Facts Of Lavallee Court Case

    1404 Words  | 6 Pages

    Facts Angelique Lavallee killed her common law partner, Kevin Rust, by shooting him in the back of the head late one night after a party at their home. Lavallee was frequently a victim of physical abuse in the relationship, defining her as a battered woman. She made several trips to the hospital for injuries, such as bruises, fractured nose, black eye and multiple contusions, excused by unbelievable reasons. Witnesses testified to seeing and hearing the abuse committed by Rust onto Lavallee prior times to the party as well as at the party that evening. The shooting occurred subsequent to an argument that Lavallee and the deceased had been having in the upper level of the home, after Rust had reportedly told Lavallee to kill him or he would

    Read More

  • The Miraculous Journey Of Edward Tulane: An Analysis

    397 Words  | 2 Pages

    One novel in particular that I love is Kate DiCamillo’s The Miraculous Journey of Edward Tulane. What I find most remarkable about this novel is that although it is geared towards a younger audience, it still holds many valuable lessons that are applicable to older audiences as well. Edward Tulane is a rather cynical porcelain rabbit who had lived life too comfortably. However, everything changes when he is lost by his owner, and after spending months in a toyshop, Edward admits that he didn’t care about anyone anymore.

    Read More

  • Segregation In Letter From Birmingham Jail

    946 Words  | 4 Pages

    If the law degrades a human, legalizes difference, or imposes on a minority group, it is an unjust law. Segregation is one example given, it affects a group that is unable to change anything due to other regulations. In addition, he explains how

    Read More

  • The Seventeen Second Miracle Analysis

    412 Words  | 2 Pages

    The Seventeen Second Miracle’s opening sets a melancholy mood. “ Just a few feet away, in the shadow of a stack of unopened birthday gifts. Sparks knelt beside her lifeless sister.” The author presents the situation of Flick, Sparks, and Rex to catch the reader 's attention. It effectively does that when it portrays Flicks sudden death.

    Read More

  • What Is The Impact On Richard Wright's Life

    222 Words  | 1 Pages

    Richard Wright’s father (Nathan Wright) has impacted and shaped Richard by making Richard’s young life full of anger, sorrow, and sadness and his grown life full of skepticism, regret, and emptiness. This is shown when Richard briefly writes about his father. Wright recalls and describes what his father looks like to him as well as how their relationship was, “He was the lawgiver in our family and I never laughed in his presence. I used to lurk timidly in the kitchen doorway and watch his huge body sitting slumped at the table….He was quite fat and his bloated stomach always lapped over his belt. He was always a stranger to me, always somehow alien and remote”

    Read More

  • The Courage Of Richard Wright's Life

    215 Words  | 1 Pages

    The first event in the book, the house burning down, started off big and was captivating. It shows the eventfulness of Richard Wright’s life, it pulls us in to read more of it, and introduces the characters of his family. The fire that Richard starts defines his personality right away, rebellious and restless. The first quote shows how reckless and dangerous Richard’s curiosity can be, he was interested in seeing how something would look in flames, not anticipating danger nor thinking of the consequences, doing this all because he was bored. Many of the actions he commits can be attributed to those traits shown in this first event.

    Read More

  • How Did Queenie Kill Her Husband

    581 Words  | 3 Pages

    Did Queenie kill her husband Arthur or did he actually fall down the stairs? That was the question that was asked when Queenie returned to her house and ten minutes later called her friends into her house. Queenie claims that, “Arthur slipped and fell on the stairs”(1 “Slip or Trip”). According to the evidence his body is in the wrong position and the glass in his hand shows that he was set up by Quinnie. Therefore, Quinnie did kill her husband Arthur and set it up to look like Arthur had died on his own.

    Read More

  • Summary Of The Validity Of Using Anatomically Correct Dolls

    1036 Words  | 5 Pages

    Introduction A 5-year old boy, whose parents are undergoing a divorce, reports that he was sexually molested by his father. His mother takes him to a psychologist who evaluates him using various techniques, including a clinical interview, Anatomically Correct Dolls, and a test she has created called “Detection of Childhood Abuse Test” (DCAT). The psychologist is called to testify in court about her findings. (1) What are the issues related to the validity of using Anatomically Correct Dolls for this purpose?

    Read More

  • How Does Tom Robinson Show Innocence In To Kill A Mockingbird

    732 Words  | 3 Pages

    In the novel To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee the term mockingbird symbolizes innocence in a person. In the novel it focuses on the fact that innocence, represented by the mockingbird, can be wrongfully harmed. There are two characters: Tom Robinson and Arthur “Boo” Radley that are supposed to represent the mockingbird. In the novel, Tom Robinson is the best example of a mockingbird because he is prosecuted for a crime he did not commit. Also, he was judged unfairly based on the color of his skin in his trial.

    Read More

  • Pros And Cons Of The Daubert Standard

    1404 Words  | 6 Pages

    Framing Truths How do we know what is true? How do we know if a man sentenced to death was truly a murderer? A question echoed by thousands of people revolting against the death penalty as the story of Todd Willingham made it to the headlines. In The New Yorker, under the title of Trial by Fire, came the terrifying enigma: “Did Texas execute an innocent man?” followed by a thorough listing of the evidence that was used to convict Willingham of setting his house on fire and resulting in the death of his three children, and how they were later disproved. There is a great misconception about the source of controversy in issues like these.

    Read More

  • Galen Strawson's Analysis

    786 Words  | 4 Pages

    He then goes on to expand on the consequences of the Basic Argument. He announces that the result of this is "that there is a fundamental sense in which no punishment or reward is ever ultimately just"(221). This would mean it is just as fair to punish or reward people for their actions as it is the color of their hair or face

    Read More

  • Brief Summary Of John Newton's Amazing Grace

    942 Words  | 4 Pages

    “Amazing Grace” is about a time when John Newton was in a storm and prayed for the Lord’s mercy. John Newton was born in London on July 24, 1725. His mother was Elizabeth Scatliff. Newton loved learning from his mother because his father was barely ever around. Newton’s mother was a Christian religious woman.

    Read More

  • How Did Christianity Influence The Scientific Revolution

    826 Words  | 4 Pages

    First, the example of Mary giving birth to Jesus as a virgin is an impossible event because there was no such technology back in the day that allowed this. Next, the example of Jesus walking on water is impossible due to the fact that law of gravity still comes into play. Seller states, “The whole Christian worldview entails the subordination of reality, identity, and causality to the whims of an alleged God for whom there is no evidence and who is therefore to be accepted on faith.” From stating this, he means that even though there is no evidence to prove that any of these events actually happened, the fact that these miracles are a part of what connects Christianity to the Scientific Revolution and it just needs to be

    Read More

  • James Fowler's Stages Of Faith

    384 Words  | 2 Pages

    James Fowler's "Stages of Faith" does not have a direct reference to religion, but it is a very closely related to religious faith. I would like to compare my spiritual journey with this stages of faith presented by Fowler to support the relevancy of his model. The first stage is called Early stage. Since it is a early and infant stage of faith, distinguishing reality from fantasy might not be easy, and children might have hard time understnading the concept of devil (Berger,2014). Second stage is Mythic (Literal) Stage, and everything is one-dimentioanl and literal (Berger, 2014).

    Read More

More about Richard Swinburne Miracles And Historical Evidence Summary

Open Document