The results were clear that smacking your child is very negative. The American academy of pediatrics and other important health development companies take a stand against parental to child physical punishment, both at home and at school. A study showed that the more the parents spanked their children for not being social, the more antisocial behavior would increase in daily life. The more the children are hit, the more likely they are to hit other kids whether its outside of school or in, including family members and adults, and more likely they are to hit their wife when they grow up. Studies show that even a few times of being hit as a child are likely to have depressive symptoms later in their life. An analysis of eighty-eight corporal punishment research studies of over six decades showed that corporal punishment of children was associated with negative outcomes, including increased delinquent and antisocial behavior, increased risk of child abuse and spousal abuse, increased risk of child anger and adult aggression, decreased child mental health and decreased adult mental health. It has also been shown that corporal punishment has an adverse effect on a child’s cognitive development.
Spanking is good for the mind because it teaches children. The author also states that a study shows that people who are spanked perform better at school and is most likely to want to college than their peers who had never been physically disciplined. Also stated in the article, research lack much info because it was difficult to find subjects who had never been spanked. In the study that was conducted it shows that results that others do not show because it involved 2600 individuals that never been spanked. It was difficult in more traditional time to find subjects. Also other studies have been conducted that support this that spanking is good for child’s
Should physical means of punishment be an option to discipline our children when they are misbehaving? The use of corporal punishment to discipline children remains one of the last holdouts of old-fashioned childrearing in the United States (Gershoff, 2010). Corporal punishment (or also known as physical punishment) is defined as the use of physical force towards a child for the purpose of controlling the child’s behavior, and is often used as a punishment (Rimal & Pokharel, 2014). It is inflicted on the child’s body with the intention of causing some degree of pain or discomfort (Cashmore & de Haas, 1995). Over the course of the years, corporal punishment has been controversially spoken about whether if it’s an effective or barbaric method of discipline to raise a child. According to Elizabeth Gershoff (2010), after conducting a meta-analytic scientific research on the intended and unintended effects of corporal punishment in children she concluded that the harm from corporal punishment outweigh any benefit of immediate child compliance. The effects of corporal punishment in children are many but among them, in this essay I will solely discuss about the effects of increased aggressive behavior, mental health problems, and eroded quality of children’s relationships with their parents.
Spanking is a form of discipline that parents use towards their children when they are doing something that is deviant. However there are both pros and cons when it comes to spanking a child. A study done by Murray Strauss was conducted to see if spanking increased antisocial behavior in children. A total of 807 mothers, with children ages 6 to 9, were chosen in the study (Strauss, Sugarman, & Giles-Sims, 1997). The results showed that 45% of mothers that spank their children do it around 2.1 times a week (Strauss, Sugarman, & Giles-Sims, 1997). As the years progressed and the spanking continued, Antisocial Behavior tended to worsen as well. The study also found that when parents reduced their tendency of spanking, Antisocial Behaviors tended
In this section, they explain spanking should be used as a last minute resort, and also very sparingly at that. When you spank your child you need to be careful not to take it too far, sure a smack on the behind might be needed a few times but full on beating your child into submission should never be needed. If you take the punishment too far, this is what can lead to potential trauma in these events. You should also always have a reason for spanking your child that is reasonable for the punishment. If they do something as small as leaving a light on after leaving the room this should not welcome a spanking, but if they are tossing a glass cup up in the air, and it shatters all over the floor potentially even putting a crack in the floor if you have hardwood, that may deserve a beating. It’s just important to note that while smacking your child can have a positive effect, it’s very important to not overdue
even if spanking is maltreatment and it 's wrong to strike your kin. In his article spanking could be a disciplinary live, not maltreatment. Get a position individuals, Matt Walsh offers a story a couple of functionary alleges that” NFL back Adrian Peterson’s recent arrest for allegedly abusing his four year previous son has once more sparked the talk over whether or not spanking is associate degree acceptable type of discipline. tho ' some contend of any type of physical correction equates to maltreatment, there 's an enormous opening between a gentle spanking properly administered out of affection associate degreed an out of management adult discharge their emotions by physically abusing a
In conclusion, spanking is an ancient act used by parents of many races and ethnicity, and depriving parents of the freedom to establish discipline in their children by comparing a spank to physical abuse is erroneous. Indeed, a good old spank in the buttocks will certainly prove a point when a child misbehaves. After all, even the famous idiom says short-time pain for long-term
Children are being shaped into someone they’re not and are being led to bad behavior. Overall, spanking has negative effects on a child’s overall health. Children have poor parent relationships, has lead to death and child abuse, and has an effect on a child’s behavior. Spanking is a poor choice when it comes to discipline. Kids aren’t able to bloom and become the flowers they’re meant to
According to parenting.com, 94% of three and four-year-olds have been spanked at least once during this past year, 74% of mothers believe spanking is acceptable for kids ages one to three, and 61% of parents say they use spanking as the main form of punishment for their children (O'Callaghan, 2014). As seen through these statistics, it is obvious that the majority of parents do spank their kids. However, there are various factors that play into the spanking being done such as the region of the country, family income, and race, and religion. Children in the south are more likely to get spanked, lower income means more spanking, African-American mothers tend to spank their kids more than other ethnic groups, and parents strong religious beliefs spank more than those who are less (O'Callaghan, 2014). It is very clear that spanking is a form of punishment parents use on their child(ren).
Although, I did not enjoy receiving spankings from my aunt’s husband, I do believe spankings can be effective, especially since pain is a basic motivator for driving behavior, when the objective is clear and reasonable force is used. Berger states
Does spanking harm children? There is an immense difference between a spanking and intentionally harming a child. Spanking does not lead to child abuse and/or later violence; Being harmfully abusive since a beginning does lead to later violence. Naughty Children, who are not lightly spanked, tend to feel that they are superior and bigger than their weak parents, and therefore attempt or achieve in “ruling” their home. By defining the issue that children need to learn that when they make poor choices or break rules in their future, they will be punished in different forms. They may not be punished by their parents or peers anymore, but by the law. By refuting the counter arguments of those who claim that a spanking is another form of child abuse, spanking
Spanking also known as corporal punishment has a lot more negative aspects as it has positive. One of them being mental illness and sociological issues. Researchers have conducted their studies and found that a child that is beaten on a daily basis has a 70% higher chance of going towards drugs to escape there stress.3 Spanking also causes tress to the child and this lead them to lying to parents and get into more trouble just to avoid the punishment they will face. Another reason on why corporal punishment has more negatives than positives is the fact that corporal punishment or spanking leads to mental issues as well as psychological issues, when a child is beaten, he gets angry and this rage builds within them and causes them to harm another to relieve themselves this is a psychological issue that many teen faces and is the number 1 reason on why school violence like stabbing and shootings occur. Also, you can put out a fire with fire because what you do is what your children will learn from you, children at a small age look up to their parents. They think and wish that they were just like him so by spankings or beating your child this will ultimately cause them to do the same. Child rearing also leads to child abuse it is said that 75% of child abuser were beaten and spanked as a child, so they take their frustrations and anger out on their own kids and so on.3 As said before many parents who spank their child don’t know the difference between spanking and beating and even if they do they still believe that they are right. So by ending spanking as a whole this will reduce the number 1 cause of child abuse, beating instead of spanking and also family disputes and drug issues among teen in today’s
According to a meta-analysis of seventy-five studies conducted by Elizabeth T. Gershoff and Andrew Grogan-Kaylor, spanking is detrimental to a child’s development. There are many known negative effects of spanking children that affect a person from childhood through adulthood. The only positive outcome of spanking that was discussed in this study was more immediate compliance from children. It is no wonder that the effectiveness and appropriateness of spanking is commonly debated in today’s society because eighty percent of children in all cultures are spanked. It is troubling that there is an abundant amount of research that proves spanking is detrimental to children but it is still a commonly used discipline tactic by parents.
Spanking a kid, whether it’s with bare hands or a flat object, may lead some kids to actually rebel against their family. As they grow up to a certain age, kids might start smoking, sneak out of the house and do other immoral meretricious actions as an outcome to get even with their family for previously spanking them. Some brats that are daily spanked may even get to the point where they would want to retaliate from the person that is usually spanking them.
Growing up in a household of 15, 10 being children under 14, there wasn’t enough time and space for timeouts and physical punishment just wasn’t effective for each different child. ‘A Case Against Spanking’ by Brendan Smith and ‘Spare the Rod, Spoil the Child’ by Leonard Pitts, are two articles expressing their different views on corporal punishment. Even though physical punishment is an immortal disagreement, ‘The Case Against Spanking’, gave efficient evidence and strongly address opposing views to support no physical punishment.