ipl-logo

Riley Macpherson's Suicide In The Silent Sister By Diane Chamberlain

1680 Words7 Pages

I have just finished reading The Silent Sister by Diane Chamberlain. This book is about Riley MacPherson who grows up in a loving but sorrowful family consisting of her mother, father, and her brother, Danny. She believes that her sister, Lisa, commited suicide as a teenager when she was only two. Riley returns to her childhood home following the death of her father, and she starts to discover secrets about her sister. Riley finds out that she is still alive, and makes it her mission to find her so she can be apart of her life. In this journal I will be evaluating and questioning. Riley MacPherson has two different sides to her; depending on the situation, she can be either relentless or understanding. There are many examples of Riley’s …show more content…

That question was does Lisa make the right choice by faking her suicide? The first possible answer to this question is yes, she made the right decison. There are two major positive results that come out of her faking her suicide. The first result is that her siblings got to live a normal life. She did not go to trial or jail, so the case was basically forgotten. Thus, her siblings did not have people scared of them due to their sister, and they got to live their lives like they would have if this whole situation would not have gone down. Another positive result of faking her suicide is that she got to start a new life. She did not have to go to jail, and she still got to attend college and start a family. There are great benefits to each of these positive results. If she would not have faked her suicide, Riley and Danny would have been the gossip of the town. They would have been pointed at and whispered about for being the siblings of a murderer. However, she is able to spare them of having to suffer from her mistakes by faking her suicide. Also, if she had stayed and went through with the trial, she would have not been able to have a future. She would have spent the majority of her life behind bars, and even when she would get out, it would be almost impossible to get back on with her life. Another answer to this question is no, Lisa does not make the right choice by faking her suicide. There are many negative results as an effect of her faking her suicide. The first negative result is the sadness that plagued both her parents and her. Her parents are filled with sorrow and depression after realizing that they will never see their daughter again, and she is depressed because she knows she will never see her family again. Danny also goes off the deep end after her fake suicide and becomes moody and easily irratible. Essentially, the whole MacPherson family dynamic is ruined after her fake suicide.

Show More
Related

  • Book Report On Famous Last Words By Greg Pollen

    935 Words  | 4 Pages

    I finished the book Famous Last Words by Katie Alender with 312 pages. This book is about a girl, Willa, who is suffering from hallucinations and memories from a ghost; also, do not forget her recent move to Los Angeles. Her new found friend, Wyatt, has been looking into the latest news on the “Hollywood Killer.” With Willa’s clues from a ghost and Wyatt’s gathered information, they both team up to find this man or woman roaming Los Angeles. In this paper I will be evaluating and predicting.

    Read More

  • Summary Of Suicide By Ronda Reynolds

    359 Words  | 2 Pages

    Ronda Reynolds from childhood was determined to become the first Washingtonian state trooper. Although she had high dreams she barely had a chance to explore them. Ronda did not have good taste in men and for that reason she was divorced once and almost completed a second one. On the last night of her second marriage, she was found with gun shot in the head. The county police department declared it a suicide; however, her mother, Barb Thompson, never truly accepted that her daughter committed suicide.

    Read More

  • Brief Summary Of Pretty Tough By Liz Tigelaar

    638 Words  | 3 Pages

    I am reading Pretty Tough, by Liz Tigelaar, and I am on page 100. This book is about two sisters who are entirely different. Charlie Brown whose name is made fun by everyone, wants to fit in and be as close to her sister Krista. Krista Brown, pretty and popular does not want anything to do with her sister, but when they both try out for their school soccer team and they both make it, Charlie does not know what is coming next.

    Read More

  • Book Report: I Rode A Horse Of Milk White Jade

    521 Words  | 3 Pages

    My book is called I Rode A Horse Of Milk White Jade written by Diane Lee Wilson. My book is about a girl that got her foot crushed by a horse when she was a baby. Ever since that incident her family has had bad luck. The narrator of the story was Oyuna. She was telling a story about her life when she was 12.

    Read More

  • Comparing The Issues In Staying Fat For Sarah Byrnes And Hope Was Here

    723 Words  | 3 Pages

    In the end, though it works out alright because she gets adopted by Ms. Lemery. Mark Brittain tries to do just about the dumbest thing anybody can do by trying to commit suicide because of something he

    Read More

  • Suicide In Ethan Frome By Edith Wharton

    933 Words  | 4 Pages

    The suicide was utimatley unsuccessful. Likewise, the death of loved one has terrible and predictable results on the family which leaves the suicide an overall

    Read More

  • Suicides In Teenage Wasteland By Donna Gaines

    464 Words  | 2 Pages

    In "Teenage Wasteland", Donna Gaines has done research that examined specific details of the lives and deaths of the four teens in Bergenfield, New Jersey. She studied suicides by spending time with the teens in the community in order to understand their problems. Donna Gaines establishes a social question concerning about how the “burnouts” have been influenced by the social factors. Social factors, including their personal relationships with others, economic situations- no opportunity for advancement, lack of legitimate hang-out space, drugs, alienation from school and parents, high expectations from parents, and negative judgments influenced the situation in which teens wanted to be isolated and thought suicide was their answer.

    Read More

  • Lisa Parker's Poem 'Snapping Beans'

    630 Words  | 3 Pages

    I. Introduction A. Lisa Parker is snapping beans with her grandmother on the porch, but she is in the process of being changed by her college experience. B. The poem is “Snapping Beans” by Lisa Parker C. Lisa is a Southern girl, who is home from college in the North; she is going through struggles that are bringing about questioning and changing. D. Lisa is letting go of her safe past so that she can move forward into her own life. II.

    Read More

  • Sister Rose's Passion And Stereotypes

    432 Words  | 2 Pages

    The documentary Sister Rose’s Passion, explains how Sr. Rose Thering took a stand against bigotry and prejudice towards the Jewish people. Throughout the documentary, she recounts her experiences of growing up and going to Catholic school. In school Sister Rose was taught that the Jews killed Christ, however, she believed that this was a mistake and a misunderstanding. Today bigotry and prejudice are conveyed through bullying and stereotypes.

    Read More

  • Suicide In Judith Guest's Ordinary People

    263 Words  | 2 Pages

    Someone in America attempts suicide once every minute and someone completes a suicide once every 17 minutes. The story Ordinary People by Judith Guest explains in detail the life of a boy who attempted suicide and how it affected everyone around him. After his brother's death he thought he could no longer life with his self. After attempting suicide Conrad was sent to a mental hospital and revived his health well enough to be sent home. Conrad went home still with “Severe Depressive Episodes [and a] High Risk of Suicide” (33 Guest).

    Read More

  • Amy Tan Confessions Summary

    677 Words  | 3 Pages

    Marissa Woo Ms. Barwise ENG 111 10 November 2016 Acknowledgement of the Unknown: A Delve into Amy Tan’s “Confessions” Amy Tan’s “Confessions” initially appears to stand as a story of verbal and physical abuse, but later is uncovered to be a tale of the complexity of truth and unknown. The narrator describes a moment in her life when she was confronted by anger, fear, and isolation, in the face of young adulthood. She must deal with her threatening and unstable mother, who is slowly losing her memory.

    Read More

  • Suicide In Everything I Never Told You

    997 Words  | 4 Pages

    Suicide is a very complicated event, and there are usually many different reasons why an individual decides to take his or her own life. Often, it involves a number of different people. In the case of Lydia Lee from Everything I Never Told You by Celeste Ng, it technically was her own fault that she drowned in the community lake. However, many people in her daily life did play a role in her decision to go out to the lake in the first place, especially the members of her family. Even though Nath and James both did play a very significant role in Lydia’s decision to commit suicide, Marilyn should be to blame for Lydia’s death because she put too much pressure on her, she disregarded her feelings, and because she never promoted a healthy social life.

    Read More

  • Alison's Struggle With Suicide Case Study

    537 Words  | 3 Pages

    Alison’s Struggle with Suicide Meet Alison Shepard. A 19 year old girl who is a sister and daughter, cousin, niece, aunt. Alison for most of her life growing up was a normal kid who did well in school excelled in sports and loved her family and friends. This all changed right around when she went into her second semester of high school at Carmel High School in Indiana. When she entered her last semester of school her attitude changed drastically in a bad way she went from a very lively out going type

    Read More

  • Point Of View And Irony In Shirley Jackson's Charles

    321 Words  | 2 Pages

    “Charles,” a short story by Shirley Jackson, has received criticism as being an easy story to see through or predict the ending. This story is not as easy to see through as most critics portray. The point of view, the side story, and the irony make this story hard to predict. Point of view is a key factor as to why this story is hard to see through. Shirley Jackson chooses to write this story from the mother's point of view, which doesn’t allow the reader to truly understand the identity of Charles before the mother does.

    Read More

  • The Murmurings Character Analysis

    378 Words  | 2 Pages

    In the book, The Murmurings, Sophie 's older sister Nell commits suicide because she heard voices that no one else could hear. But Sophie does not believe that her sister could do that to herself. So, she comes to the conclusion that Nell 's doctor is keeping secrets about her sister 's mental health, and wants to get to the bottom of it. Along the way gaining a new friend/love interest who has dealt with a situation similar to Sophie 's. After her sister 's death, Sophie 's mother gets hit hard by depression and begins drinking.

    Read More

More about Riley Macpherson's Suicide In The Silent Sister By Diane Chamberlain

Open Document