ipl-logo

Rousseau On The Social Contract Analysis

953 Words4 Pages

Rousseau’s writings On the Social Contract critiques many aspects of modern society, including the use of representatives in most governments. With this critique, Rousseau attempts to persuade the readers that having a representative form of government is tantamount to being enslaved. This begs the question, is modern society wrong to use representative forms of governments or is Rousseau being courted by a utopian visage? Rousseau is persuasive in his arguments, however the impracticality of populaces sans representatives is a firm counterbalance. Rousseau’s main argument against the use of representatives in the political sphere is that utilising representatives thwarts any attempt at truly reaching the general will of the citizens. He states …show more content…

On the contrary, representatives do not signify laziness from the citizen. The logic and necessity of representatives comes from the size of a given population. The use of representatives does not create the state that Rousseau denotes as doomed to fail “in a well-run city everyone flies to the assemblies; under a bad government no one wants to take a step near them” (218). Rousseau’s impression of representatives implies that they are being used in lieu of the citizens actually attending themselves or tracking the legislature. While it is true that the representatives speak in place of the citizens, they are speaking the will of the group they represent. Those in question cannot be detached from their voters as Rousseau seems to believe they will be, if they are detached from the voters then they will not be able to perform to the general will. Representatives allow for the general will of the many to be heard by a few; the many has given their voice to the representative, but that does not mean the many no longer cares about the outcome. If anything, people will be more invested in seeing how the general will will be directed. Representatives would be chosen carefully as they are the voice of a given group of people. The deliberations over the potential representatives would certainly illicit the presence and care of the citizens. The …show more content…

Having a cold, not liking crowds, having to travel a bit to the gathering location; all of those and other inconveniences should be forgotten and ignored. However, when a population of citizens who can voice their opinions at the gathering grows too large it is no longer a good way to follow the general will, it becomes nothing more than a ruckus. Consider the caucus style of voting the U.S. utilises in some states; these are relatively small groups of people, in most cases no more than a thousand per district due to poor voter turnout, but only some voices are heard in deciding whom to vote for. Not everyone’s will is accounted for, and it takes hours. Rousseau’s picture of a government run without representatives would either be an incredibly slow, and inadequate to fulfilling the general will of the populace, or be incredibly small so the general will is

Show More
Related

  • Scientific Revolution DBQ

    1225 Words  | 5 Pages

    In any case of failure to protect the rights, the people were in their complete right to overthrow the government (Doc 2 & Pg. 630) In agreement, Rousseau believed that the government’s power also comes from the consent of the people, which he included in his book, The Social Contract. (Pg. 632) Rousseau included much more ideas that incorporated political aspects, but he also his thought about

    Read More

  • Creation Of The United States Dbq Essay

    571 Words  | 3 Pages

    Rousseau’s beliefs coincided with the beliefs of other Enlightenment thinkers. This is shown when he writes, “Duty and interest thus equally require the two contracting parties [the people and the government] to aid each other mutually” (Document 3). In that period of history, it was typical for people to be ruled by a monarch and they had very little say, if any, in the laws and policies that impacted their day to day life. Rousseau felt that the system was outdated and it made citizens feel as if they were living in someone else’s home rather than their own, so he theorized that by fabricating a system in which the government and the people are forced to work together, it creates a sense of unity and equality. This works because “ … an offense against one of its members is an offense against the body politic.

    Read More

  • Locke And Rousseau's Government: The Primary Ideas Of Government

    1677 Words  | 7 Pages

    The Primary objective of all leaders should be to control citizens. A society that allows authority to be challenged will never succeed. This source depicts an authoritarian or totalitarian view of what a governing body should look like. The author suggests that the primary objective of government should be the “control of the citizens”, and therefore that the individuals should entirely obey said government.

    Read More

  • Creation Of The United States Dbq Essay

    812 Words  | 4 Pages

    Rousseau’s beliefs coincided with the beliefs of other Enlightenment thinkers. This is shown when he writes, “Duty and interest thus equally require the two contracting parties [the people and the government] to aid each other mutually” (Document 3). In that period of history, it was typical for people to be ruled by a monarch and they had very little say, if any, in the laws and policies that impacted their day to day life. Rousseau felt that the system was outdated and it made citizens feel as if they were living in someone else’s home rather than their own, so he theorized that by fabricating a system in which the government and the people are forced to work together, it creates a sense of unity and equality. This works because “ … an offense against one of its members is an offense against the body politic.

    Read More

  • Analysis Of The Social Contract By Jean-Jacques Rousseau

    1012 Words  | 5 Pages

    However, by doing so, we retain our individuality and freedom. In chapter 6, of the social contract Rousseau argues that people need to give up their individual freedom and unite for the common good of all in order to overcome the natural threats to their own existence. It is their own existence that motivates them to give up their individual freedom and unite. The problem with the social contract lies in the opposing forces of individual freedom versus the sovereign that was formed when they united.

    Read More

  • Social Inequality In John Locke And Jean-Jacques Rousseau

    1253 Words  | 6 Pages

    The questions of the whether social inequality is justified and the extent of government to address said inequality are some of the foundations upon which societies and economies are built. Two key philosophers on this issue – John Locke and Jean-Jacques Rousseau – differ on this subject. In Two Treatises on Government, Locke holds that individuals have a right to property derived from their labor, citizens consent to the existence of inequality in society, and governments are instituted among men to protect said property. In contrast, Rousseau writes in Discourse on the Origin of Inequality and The Social Contract that inequality should be strictly limited and that governments have a duty to act in the best interest of its citizens by maintaining

    Read More

  • Locke Vs Tocqueville Analysis

    1084 Words  | 5 Pages

    Introduction: While freedom as a concept feels fairly intuitive, nuances in interpretation can change the basis of an argument. John Locke’s Second Treatise of Government and Alexis de Tocqueville’s Democracy in America do not define liberty in precisely the same way, which in turn guides two different visions in how a government should function. When examining a core concept in an argument, it is important to inquire to whether its treatment is adequate. Is either definition of liberty sufficient, and does either author’s envisioned government adequately address liberty in that system? This paper will argue that Locke’s definition of liberty remains in the literal sphere while Tocqueville’s is more conceptual, but neither Locke’s nor Tocqueville’s

    Read More

  • Rousseau's Discourse On The Origin Of Inequality

    511 Words  | 3 Pages

    However, I think it is important to remember Rousseau’s concept of perfectibility and understand that because of this trait it was almost inevitable that humans would eventually become social. Yet, it is not inevitable that humans would become politically unequal, as that is a direct result of government institutions. As well, Rousseau himself in further writings even expresses the hope that a new form of social contract could help to ease some of the political inequalities that plague contemporary society. This then suggests that the cause for these issues is not rooted in being social, for it is possible to live among others in a setting where equality has been institutionalized. Rather, the problem lies with corrupt and capitalist governments that serve to perpetuate inauthenticity and private

    Read More

  • How Did James Madison Influence The Role Of Government

    518 Words  | 3 Pages

    Madison believed that the key to preventing an unjust majority was a governing body that reflected the principle of representation for a very large and diverse base of constituents. Representation prevents unjust views and special interests from guiding and establishing public decisions. The role of the representative is also to listen to their body of constituents and overall public interests to promote a consensus founded on the good of the public. Madison believed that true representation is a two way line of communication between the representative and the represented, and from that an overall consensus can be reached. Madison’s ideas of representation are still very much a part of our government today, as seen in the very structure of our modern day legislative bodies from district to state as

    Read More

  • Rhetorical Analysis Of Civil Disobedience

    673 Words  | 3 Pages

    The individual's relationship to the state is a concept often entertained abstractly; at variance with this is Civil Disobedience, which analyzes Thoreau's first direct experience with state power in his brief 1846 imprisonment. Thoreau metaphorically detailed his search for virtue in the quote, "The finest qualities of our nature, like the bloom on fruits, can be preserved only by the most delicate handling. Yet we do not treat ourselves nor one another thus tenderly." (Thoreau 8) In Civil Disobedience Thoreau as earnest seeker and flawed captive of the conscience concertedly attempts to correct this shortcoming within the context of slavery and the Mexican-American War.

    Read More

  • Rousseau's Influence On Abbe Sieyes

    877 Words  | 4 Pages

    The first difference is who should the General Will be determined to. In Rousseau’ opinion, the social contract would not exclude anyone, and would “receive each member as an indivisible part of the whole” (Rousseau 8). However, in contrast to Rousseau’s “whole society,” Sieyes indicated that the Third Estate in France represented everything. The first reason why Sieyes stated so was that the First and the Second Estate were “like ravenous wolves,” who could not think of anything “but subduing and enslaving their neighbors” (Rousseau 107) while the Third Estate was the ones who carried out the work that sustained society (Lualdi 113). The second reason was that the nobles had all kinds of privileges and exemptions, “and even rights that are distinct from the rights of the great body of citizens” (Lualdi 115); therefore, they should be excluded from the common law.

    Read More

  • Summary Of John Stuart Mill's Consideration On Representative Government

    1128 Words  | 5 Pages

    Introduction: John Stuart Mill essay on Consideration On representative Government, is an argument for representative government. The ideal form of government in Mill's opinion. One of the more notable ideas Mill is that the business of government representatives is not to make legislation. Instead Mill suggests that representative bodies such as parliaments and senates are best suited to be places of public debate on the various opinions held by the population and to act as watchdogs of the professionals who create and administer laws and policy.

    Read More

  • Compare And Contrast Jean Jacques Rousseau's Understanding Of Factions

    1324 Words  | 6 Pages

    This paper examines both Jean-Jacques Rousseau and James Madison remark concerning ‘ factions ’ as the potential destructive social force to the society. To layout and examine, this paper will first outline and discuss on Rousseau’s understanding of factions in The Social Contract,and Madison’s discussion on factionalism in the Federalist Papers 10.But there are many component surrounded with their view’s on ‘factions’,so it is important to consider together. Firstly,I will consider the definition and the element surrounded with their view on factions. With regard to Jean-Jacques Rousseau in The Social Contract,he believes that the society can only function to the extent that people have interest in common.

    Read More

  • Compare And Contrast Baroque Vs Enlightenment

    479 Words  | 2 Pages

    Although the two eras overlap, the Baroque era and the Enlightenment differ drastically from one another. Generally pictured and thought of as an artistic movement, the Baroque era eventually led to the Enlightenment, a more philosophical-based movement. In the Baroque era, people gained fame for their artistic talents. During the Enlightenment, people gained fame due to their scientific ideas and work.

    Read More

  • Argument Essay: The Definition Of Freedom

    1090 Words  | 5 Pages

    Representatives of the people are a big part in preserving freedom, this gives the people a voice in choosing what they need to succeed. For a working society that still has freedom, it needs representatives, just like in Abigail Adams letters to her husband John, he acted like a representative for the women so they were noticed and taken into account. Abigail had written these letters to John about what was happening in her daily life and the status of the town; she had asked John to “remember the ladies, and be more generous and favorable to them than your ancestors,” this was one of the first steps in womans freedom. Without representatives of the people there would be no freedom to establish or

    Read More

More about Rousseau On The Social Contract Analysis

Open Document