The United States military has had one of the most effective Rules of engagement in the world. But in the past couple of years the ROE have provided ineffective when fighting this new type of enemy. Rules of engagement are defined as “a directive issued by a military authority specifying the circumstances and limitations under which forces will engage in combat with the enemy.” If you look at in the military point of view “I can only engage the enemy when certain criteria is meet or approved. Whereas a civilian would view them as soon as a guy says shoot you go into a type of firing squad mode. Rules of engagement came about to limit the death rate among non-combative threats or how you say innocent people. And to reduce collateral damage witch …show more content…
The casualty rate has increased form the stricter ROEs get. The reason being that if I see a threat and cant engage it when I know I can stop the threat from causing harm/damage. In the Vietnam War the casualty rate was far higher. The reason there being that the ROEs where so closed in the beginning that even if you did see the threat that you could not and where not allowed to engage the theat. I am not saying that this is the only reason that the Vietnam casualty rate was so high but is one of the leading factors. Another thing that causes problems is that the ROEs that are in place now don’t allow our troops the ability to do their job effectively. For example say you are an engineer (the people that do the building in the military community) and your unit is deployed and you are put out on patrol and you see an individual/group carrying a RPG (rocket propelled grenade) and see them heading toward one of you group of people working on a house/building and realize that they have intent to attack your guys but you can engage him because he has not engaged anyone yet that you are aware of. You guy side and you feel as though you are the reason that your brothers died. You could have stopped it. Along with that go with the fact that if you feel as though you are going to be killed or wounded you will try to a job as quickly as possible. If you do something quick you are likely to do something wrong/screw up. Along with the fact that you will most likely not have the objective completed on schedule/time. One of the better effects is that it makes troops responsible for their own actions meaning that if you are to engage an individual. Meaning that the military can’t be charge by group or other countries in the fact that the force needed is self-determined by the
The laws in the military were changed many times through the years by the military, leading people to disagree with new regulations. In a way, the government manipulated the US military and molded
This is important for many reasons, One reason that units must understand and enforce the laws of war and ROEs are so incidents like the My Lai Massacre or the Kandahar/Panjwei Massacre do not happen again. Both of these incidents represent times when the Laws of War and ROEs were not enforced and because of this, many innocent civilians died. War is challenging enough but it's even more challenging when you kill the people that you are supposed to
The point is further established when Colonel Read states, “War is never fair. Who chooses which men get killed and which ones don’t?” (Collier and Collier 200). Warfare comes at a cost, and one never knows who will pay it. By the same token, the authors stress that as long as the fighting goes on only unfair consequences will
The Vietnam war took a major death toll in Vietnam, United States, South Korea, Thailand, New Zealand, and Australia. Just in the U.S., “more than 58,000 American soldiers were killed while more than 150,000 others wounded”. On both sides, there were almost 2 million civilians dead and 1.1 simply on the Vietnamese side. The My Lai Massacre, where soldiers brutally killed Vietnamese children and mothers, presents an example where the war mentally changed the soldiers in the war in a very horrendous way. On the other hand, the United States took brutal losses in the Tet Offensive, where the Vietcong slaughtered over 100 towns and twelve United States air bases.
This led to a lot of things going wrong including less attention to their military, health and weight for the people, and how safe
The Vietnam war began in 1963 with the approval of a military coup in Vietnam. There was a generational rebellion to the Vietnam war. All three of the Kennedy, Johnson, and Nixon administrations were impacted severely by the war and envisioned different ways of ending the war. Kennedy’s administration justified Vietnam war as a test, Johnson continued the war, and Nixon finally ended the war. Kennedy’s administration was impacted by the Vietnam war.
The overall confidence and mood of the country dipped. Those citizens that are against the military elitism of the United States and do not agree with the war feel alienated under a conscription system (“Conscription” 1). The fear that the government may force them or their friends and family to fight in a war they do not believe goes against the American morales that the country was previously proud of. An all-volunteer army fits with the nation’s principles of freedom, equality, and dignity, while a military draft does not (“An All-Volunteer Army” 2). If the United States had to carry out conscription as a means to fight the war, and conscription led to the nation openly protesting in the streets, the war was ineffective.
If a soldier is to seek shelter in a civilian’s home, they allow for that person or group of people to be targeted from the attacking enemy. Not only this, but they are also abusing the earnings of the person because the person has worked hard to provide for shelter and food for themselves and family, and they don’t expect for their sources to be used by soldiers. Amendment four is another document in the Bill of Rights that has shown that the United States if an equal nation. In many other countries, authorities abuse their powers due to corruption to inappropriately prosecute innocent people.
Because of this, a lot of soldiers have gotten sent home because they aren’t gonna be able to fight in battle.
“Our present course [in Vietnam] will not bring victory; will not bring peace; will not stop the bloodshed; and will not advance the interests of the United States or the cause of peace in the world.” Robert F. Kennedy, March 1968 The Vietnam War is one of the most controversial events in American history. The war was between communist North Vietnam and the democratic South Vietnamese. Many Americans felt that we entered the war under false pretenses and were interfering in a civil war that we didn’t belong.
There are more regulations and also technological advancements that kind of make killing people easier. Elliot Rodger's notorious manifesto was the cause of much debate at the time: who should be allowed to have guns? He stabbed three people, but knives aren't going to be illegal, was some rhetoric. Others talked about how mental illness shouldn't be used to justify violence. Hunting is another.
In most cases, people often do better in situations that they want to be in. By demanding men to go to war when they rather be somewhere else, they are not going to do their very best. If you have 60% of men who do not want to be there and only 40% of men who want to be there, your army force will not do as well if you had 100% of men wanting to be there. According to the University of Warwick, they proved that people who are happy work harder than people who are unhappy, in their study they said, “They found happiness made people around 12% more productive, while unhappy workers proved 10% less productive.” This statistic shows that forcing people to enlist will not make their army force better and stronger, in fact it does the exact opposite.
The notion that the soldiers don’t have the ability to make choices for themselves
In the novel, there is definite control that the authority has over the soldiers, one that trained them, but also repressed them, turning the soldiers into empty shells of war. In the film, however, there is a rather unusual absence of authority in the lives of the soldiers. They are told once or twice in the beginning what to do and how to do it but other than that the soldiers are free to do what they want. This lack of authority may have been the root cause of some poorly judged actions that the soldiers take. For instance when Paul and Kat go to find the goose for the second time but because of Paul’s poor judgment, Kat is killed by a kid.
This essay will investigate to what extent did the Strategies and Tactics used by the United States, North and South Vietnam, and the Soviet Union influence the outcome of the Vietnam war? The Vietnam War was one of the most significant war in American History. It was a war that will not be forgotten in a long time due to its surprising outcome and length of the war. One of the key roles in the war that had affected the outcome of the war were the tactics and strategies that were used by different countries. To investigate this question you will need to know about the strategies and tactics that were used by different countries.