ipl-logo

Lies Hoaxes Comparison

1308 Words6 Pages

The following comparison will be based on the cartoon essay Science Tales: Lies, Hoaxes, and Scams written by Darryl Cunningham in 2012, as well as “Dire Predictions about Climate Change”, written in form of letters to the editor of The New York Times, 15.05.2012. The two texts share the common theme of climate change.

The obvious similarity between the two texts is the focus on climate change and where it comes from, as well as attempting to make the reader think a certain way. They want to persuade the reader to believe their particular point of view with reference to the controversy over global warming.

The main difference between the two texts is the medium used to display and explore the ideas. Text A is an entertaining cartoon displaying …show more content…

This expands the possible purposes of the text. However, it is thought the title of Cunningham’s book, from which the cartoon essay is taken, Science Tales: Lies, Hoaxes, and Scams, is more relevant in creating a purpose as it already makes a certain opinion clear. He refers to scientific theories as tales, which, by definition, are “narratives that relate the details of some real or imaginary event, incident, or case; story” (Dictionary.com). He then continues his title with ‘Lies, Hoaxes and Scams’, which refer to falsehoods and untruths. By publishing a story about climate change in this book of falsehoods and untrue science theories, he already makes it clear that he does not agree with this theory and believes it is wrong. His last caption “All this has taken place even though the 2000s have experienced a solar output decline” sounds somewhat cynical. All through the cartoon he has given facts and figures that may or may not give evidence for climate change, but he diminishes them by ending saying, that people say that what is happening is climate change and global warming exists, but that’s not possible seeing as we’ve had a solar output decline. Cunningham makes this fact seem like it outweighs all the others presented before and makes his viewpoint on the matter very clear by finishing with this

Show More
Related

  • Summary Of Why Bother By Michael Pollan

    712 Words  | 3 Pages

    The Temperatures are rising, carbon emissions are increasing, ice caps are melting at a faster rate than most scientists expected, and planet earth is experiencing ecological and environmental issues due to global warming. Earth as we know it might change drastically in the next couple of decades, and it is our responsibility to preserve the environment and preserve earth. Michael Pollan's Why Bother? opens the reader's eyes in a powerful way to global warming and related environmental crises. Pollan uses rhetorical strategies such as current and past events, logos and pathos to persuade the reader "to bother"(218) and start thinking of the environment as an issue that involves all the people. Pollan approaches the reader from different standing

    Read More

  • Summary Of Dialectical Journal For Sal And Phoebe

    1441 Words  | 6 Pages

    Chapter 1: Sal and Phoebe: Deeper Meanings. My thoughts on Salamanca have always been varying. At first, I saw her as rude, or stubborn, “I was not sweet that day. I was being particularly ornery. I wouldn’t sit down and I wouldn’t look at Margaret.”

    Read More

  • Nt1310 Unit 1 Assignment

    807 Words  | 4 Pages

    With good judgment, one may agree with the author that sometimes it can go sour. In conclusion, two texts are alike with slight differences such as formality and filler words. The first article is an informal language with jargon and few filler words. On the other side, the second article is more informal due to filler and everyday words.

    Read More

  • Rhetorical Analysis Of PSA

    390 Words  | 2 Pages

    This PSA was created by the National Wildlife Fund to raise awareness about global warming and how they believe that it is bad. Since they are against global warming and the melting ice caps they want to convince people to follow the same stance. To bring this message forward they use a variety of rhetorical devices including the clear use of the loaded word. They main quote that makes sense of the PSA and ties it together is “When the ice caps melt, so will he.” The use of loaded words such as “Melt” and “He” leave marks in human emotion as humans tend to remember words and not points meaning that once the viewer is gone they can remember that PSA as they just remember the point.

    Read More

  • CNS Analyzing Nasa's 'A Blanket Around The World'

    1346 Words  | 6 Pages

    The article created of which is supported by Nasa, tries to make it clear to the general audience that the issue of climate change is real. Nasa being rated to be factual high on the biased scale can be trusted as it favors no political side, making their articles based on scientific evidence. The article opens up stating “Most climate scientists agree the main cause of the current global warming trend is human expansion of the "greenhouse effect” A strongpoint of which this article has would be its ability to inform the average viewer about the issue of climate change. Due to this article being supported by Nasa, a pro-science website, this source can be trusted as this article would be backed up by the scientific theory. Comparing to the article created by CNN which backs the creation of “synthetic trees”; Nasa’s article would be meant to inform the reader, however, due to CNN’s political biased towards the liberals, the average viewer may see the article only favor the political view due to the biased.

    Read More

  • Native American Rite Of Passage

    487 Words  | 2 Pages

    Native Americans are the type of people to celebrate their culture. These people still celebrate rites of passages from 500 years ago. Native Americans do ceremonies that are usually tradition to complete their rites of passage. These passages can be elaborate or for some, really personal. The two stories “The Medicine Bag” and “Apache Girl’s rite of passage” share similarities and differences.

    Read More

  • Cherokee Girl Rite Of Passage Analysis

    682 Words  | 3 Pages

    These two ways bring many advantages and disadvantages. One advantage of having the text it bring more details and emotion. It can also show more of their inner thoughts. But there are some disadvantages. One disadvantage is that it can be difficult to picture how the story's setting is taking place.

    Read More

  • Themes Of Fledgling By Octavia Butler And The Mortal Instruments By Cassandra Clare

    1056 Words  | 5 Pages

    The theme of the novel Fledgling by Octavia Butler is “don’t give up, keep going” with the main characters trying to make things right, even if they don’t know what to and that their friends will always have their back and the same goes for the book The Mortal Instruments by Cassandra Clare. Because both of their themes forces on persevering; getting through tough times and always have your friends there to support you - but they write in completely different ways. - The connecting themes for both authors is the main character in both books is very headstrong and they were both thrown in to a very new world and want to find out answers

    Read More

  • Chagakrabarty And Nixon's Impact On The Environment

    1347 Words  | 6 Pages

    They both demonstrate that climate change and is a result of history and that outlets such as literature have the power to shift the discourse on the

    Read More

  • Summary Of Why Bother By Michael Pollan

    722 Words  | 3 Pages

    Almost anyone who will read this essay has undoubtedly heard of the climate phenomenon Global warming. Global warming is a topic that gets discussed very often nowadays, most notably during political debate and discussion. Politicians use certain stances on global warming to appeal to voter’s emotions and logic in order to gain votes and support for their campaign, however climate change is nothing new, during the past several hundred thousand years the Earth has heated up and cooled down and even experienced so called “ice ages”, which is a period where glacial deposits located at the northern and southern hemispheres have grown due to dramatic global cool downs. Don’t be confused by climate terminology though, the global warming so widely

    Read More

  • Deliberative Speech

    786 Words  | 4 Pages

    Somehow, as the speech continued to its later half part, the speaker added a new rhetorical situation that might not be expected by the general audience. This imposed rhetorical situation is climate change. When DiCaprio said, “And lastly I just want to say this: Making The Revenant was about man 's relationship to the natural world. A world that we collectively felt in 2015 as the hottest year in recorded history”; he induced the audience to accept climate change as an exigence that occurred at the time and morphed the speech into a deliberative tool. The addition of climate change as another subject in the speech shifted its purpose from an instrument to give positive feeling to a means to induce

    Read More

  • How Did Some Scientist Fight Back Michael Mann

    661 Words  | 3 Pages

    Scientist Fight Back Michael Mann reports that the research he and other scientist have been doing concerning climate change has been called into question by politician whose goals are to find answer that will defend their policies. These same politicians and their allies, those in the fossil fuel industry have targeted and attacked Mann and his colleagues because of the evidence they’ve uncovered regarding climate change. However, with evidence of global warming and rising CO2 levels, Mann and his colleagues have been able to fight back. The initial attacks on Mann and his colleagues came because of research behind the hockey stick graph, a set of graphs developed by scientist because of extensive research studies and support from other scientist and researchers that demonstrate an increase and steady change in the earth’s climate over

    Read More

  • All Summer In A Day And The Veldt Analysis

    650 Words  | 3 Pages

    Two very versatile stories can still share a very common theme. All summer in a day and The veldt both by Ray Bradbury share the common theme of Desire can control the way people act towards others. There comparisons and differences play out in the story to even better the theme. In the first place, both of these complex stories share the same theme of, desire can take control over the way people act towards one another.

    Read More

  • Before The Flood Rhetorical Analysis

    961 Words  | 4 Pages

    Ethos was supported by the statements made by scientists and politicians. Pathos were used by showing imagery with climate being changed and affecting populations. Logos were used by scientists as well as statistics to help show how the climate is actually being changed. The strength of the claims being made throughout the film were all supported and also came with real world proof as well so they were all valid. I agree with the majority of the claims being made in the film, especially the negative claims made by companies and politicians who whole heartedly knew what was going on but didn’t contain any claims to attack the claims being made about the climate change being

    Read More

  • Deception And Deception Research Paper

    854 Words  | 4 Pages

    Is seeing really believing? Or is it just our brains trying to clarify a situation? But just because something is seen doesn 't mean that it is always believed. Or is it? Deception is an odd thing that can make people view something as simple as a remote control as something that will change your life forever.

    Read More

More about Lies Hoaxes Comparison

Open Document