The documentary title “Secret of the Wild Child” is an interesting title that captivates the audience to watch the video because of the last two words wild child makes the audience curious to what does a wild child look like and how does it behave. The music in the video sounds is calm and nurturing playing through some scene in the video. This was broadcast by PBS on its series NOVA. NOVA often includes interviews with scientists doing research in the subject areas covered and occasionally includes footage of a particular discovery. It was aired on October 18, 1994. It remains relevant because it talks about how child neglecting can have a severe outcome on child development such as the extreme case with Genie. The nova episode talks …show more content…
At first, it was clear Genie could understand more than she was able to speak. Slowly, over 2 years, she began to understand more and more. She finally picked up the difference between singular and plural nouns, negative and positive sentence distinctions, possessive constructions, a few prepositions, and some modifications. Toward the end on Genie research in the fall of 1974 NIHM, the National Institute of Mental Health stopped funding the Genie project, citing failure to collect data in a scientifically meaningful way. For linguist Susan Curtiss, it was time to sum up her years of work with Genie. She finally picked up the difference between singular and plural nouns, negative and positive sentence distinctions, possessive constructions, a few prepositions, and some modifications. Unfortunately, Genie didn’t seem to be able to put words together in a normal, grammatical way. This seemed to support the idea of a critical period for acquiring language. It is unclear if her inability to learn was due to the fact that she had missed her critical period, or the fact that she had undergone extreme trauma as a child. It is also hard to assess this case because researchers weren't able to test her immediately upon discovery to …show more content…
The University of Rochester wrote an article about language development critical periods. In this article, it talks about the evidence for the critical or sensitive period for language acquisition. And question concerning a critical or sensitive period for language acquisition. The article go more into depth on critical period than the documentary which was focus more on the scientist experience with Genie. The definition given by Rochester for critical period is a maturational time period during some crucial experiences in development or learning, resulting in normal behavior (Rochester, 2006). In the documentary we are told that a child who did not learn a language before puberty then it is nearly impossible to learn a first language. Here we are able to learn the reason why it’s difficult for a child who has reached puberty won’t be able to speak the language properly. We learn that feral or abused children are exposed to their first language after puberty they show an extreme shortage in phonology (system of sound), morphology (he study of the forms of words), and syntax. This is why Genie was not able to speak the English language at proficiently because her phonology was abnormal, and her control over English syntax and morphology was limited to the simplest aspect of language (Rochester, 2006). Learning this gives us a better understanding on why genie is
In Karen Russell 's short story, “St. Lucy 's Home for Girls Raised by Wolves”, she takes the character Claudette on a journey from a barbaric, careless wolf to a independent, determined girl. Claudette is the narrator of this short story. She and her pack start off in the woods, where they lived all their lives, the nuns in the home use the handbook to take them from the woods and teach them to be civilized humans. Claudette goes through this journey, trying her best, for if she cannot become human, she will have nowhere to go. The nuns split the girls learning process into 5 stages, each one filled with new things.
In chapters 14 and 15 of Into the Wild, Jon Krakauer becomes more than just an investigator or a narrator, he becomes a character. He tells his story of climbing the Devils Thumb, which exposes the similarities between himself and McCandless. This aids to his understanding of McCandless’s motivations, without ever meeting him, due to the parallels in their personalities and family issues. Chapter 14 is devoted to Krakauer’s story about his youthful love for mountain climbing. At age 23, he plans to do a dangerous climb on the Devil’s Thumb in Alaska alone. “
The book Into the Wild by Jon Krakauer portrays a teenager named Christopher McCandless, who is unsatisfied with the conventional and materialistic lifestyle that society has come to value. McCandless’s unusual adventures and subsequent death led to comments describing his actions as irrational and cowardly. Yet, one must fully understand the principle that McCandless was standing for before evaluating his decisions. Christopher McCandless’s values are exemplified in his letter to Ronald Franz, where he emphasizes the need for an individual to take risks and embrace nature; in doing so, he reveals himself as a brave and adventurous man who refuses to let boredom take over his life. Christopher McCandless insists that a life of uniformity is damaging to the adventurous spirit that is inherent to all people, and
The answer is an obvious, yes! As stated earlier, the learning development of a feral children who was raised by animals was based on the modeling of the animals involved. However, this case is not trivial for Genie because of the grave abuse and isolation. One theory proposed in Psychology was that young children can learn certain things, such as language, at a certain time, called the critical periods. In this light, it would have been impossible for Genie to learn any languages.
Genie had been severely abused for over several years. Immediately though researchers and doctors all over the world took a great interest in Genie. They believed her rehabilitation from her severe social isolation was possible. Her
While isolated, Genie had no sense of self, had no ideas of social norms and her only agents of socialization were her parents. While under the care of the hospital and others, she was able to learn and express herself in ways that she was never allowed to before. Finally, able to speak, Genie became able to pronounce simple words. After years of learning, Genie has never been able to fully communicate and has never grasped using questions and sentences. Genie’s influences and insights are accurately described by the sociological concepts
Into The Wild was a tremendous story which Shaun Callarman did not have many positive things to say about Chris McCandless, the main character. He went on this adventure to find out what life is all about in his own eyes. He wanted to see how different living in the wild really was compared to society because he was not satisfied with his living arrangements and household. Shaun’s quote says that he thinks “Chris McCandless was bright and ignorant at the same time. He had no common sense, and he had no business going into Alaska with his Romantic silliness.
What evidence from the Genie Wiley case supports both the nurture and the nature points of view regarding language development? (3 points) Genie Wiley’s case helps support both sides of the nurture vs nature debate. The fact that she learned to talk after more than 10 years of confinement helps support the nature side because proves that she has the ability to communicate in her genes.
During this stage, children start to interact more with peers in school. Through interacting with other kids, children will not only practice their social ability but gain a sense of initiative through planning things themselves as well, thus to feel confident in their ability and decision-making. It is important for children to explore and plan activities by themselves to achieve the feeling of control, yet Genie was not able to decide or try anything in her early childhood. On the contract, she got beaten by her father whatever she did. Therefore, combining the autism and the lack of confidence she expressed after the rescue, we can assume after the fails of the previous development, Genie was apparently not an initiative child.
As Genie cognitively progresses throughout the years after rescue, she gains the abilities to respond to others and interact with certain objects. Even though she did not properly develop her self identity during her childhood, there is evidence that she is beginning to conceptualize her sense of self during her teen years. Feral children, such as Genie, lack a self concept impairing their development. However, in order to solve this, they must require the agents of socialization, immerse themselves in culture, and undergo socialization methods, such as Mead’s “Stages of the Self.” Through constant nurturing and therapy, Genie would have a chance to develop her sense of self and recovery from her previous, feral state.
The reason why Genie's case was so fascinating to psychologists and linguists was that it presented a unique opportunity. They were able to study a hotly contested debate about language development and human growth. Nativists believe that the capacity for language is something that is done naturally. Empiricists think that it is the environment that someone is in plays a key role in human development.
This week, the readings point the spotlight at the some of the depressing hardships that the African-American population frequently experience. In “Naughty by Nature”, Ann Ferguson covers the different perceptions that society has of colored boys. David Knight’s work “Don’t tell young black males that they are endangered” seeks to explain the differents outcomes of African-American youth that arise when society constantly oppresses them. The last article by Carla O’Connor, “The Culture of Black Femininity and School Success”, focuses on the image of African-American woman that is created as a result of them attempting to preserve in a system that opposes them.
What makes one head off into the wild, leaving behind everything? What may be the motvies? In “Sections from Into the Wild” Jon Krakauer examines Chris McCandless motives for why he went into the wild. Krakauer looks into McCandless “great Alaskan odyssey” (203). Knowing Chris’s motives it is alright to try escaping into the wild, but to a certain extent.
Language development is a critical part of a child’s overall development. Language encourages and supports a child’s ability to communicate. Through language, a child is able to understand and define his or her’s feelings and emotions. It also introduces the steps to thinking critically as well as problem-solving, building and maintaining relationships. Learning a language from a social perspective is important because it gives the child the opportunity to interact with others and the environment.
She was also beaten by her abusive father if she attempted to make a noise (Curtiss, 1977). Genie underwent extensive training and tutoring to be taught language. While Genie’s vocabulary expanded greatly, and she adopted the ability to form fluid and plausible sentences, she did not manage to master the comprehension of syntax and the grammatical rules of language. Children however naturally grasp the context of syntax without formal teachings of it. This study therefore supports the argument that children acquire language easier during the initial stages of their life.