- Meaning of self esteem According to James William, “self-esteem is a personal judgment of self-worth that is determined by how well individuals evaluate themselves on dimensions that they personally value.” James noted that “Our self-feeling in this world depends entirely on what we back ourselves to be and do.” (James, 1985, p. 54). - Factor affecting self esteem Actually, it can be reliably measured that self-esteem is substantially different among such diverse countries as India, Argentina, South Korea, and the United States (Schmitt & Allik, 2005). What makes it different depends on several factors including demographic characteristics, namely, race, gender and age. Accordingly, there are several experiments and surveys conducted to find …show more content…
For example, two experiments concluded that African Americans score higher than Whites in measure of self-esteem (Gray-Little & Hafdahl, 2000; Twenge & Crocker, 2002). It is also found out that Asians report the lowest self-esteem, and Latinos is between Whites and Asians (Twenge and Crocker, 2002). In addition, Schmitt and Allik (2005) found that people from Japan have lower self-esteem than United States people. To explain for this difference, it is important to consider the possibility that different culture and traditions affect patterns of behavior (e.g., Yamagishi, Hashimoto, & Schug, 2008; cf., Kim & Markus, 1999). Actually, collectivist culture, culture stressing benefit of the group which is traditionally culture of East Asian, may play a role (Markus & Kitayama, 1991). In the collectivist culture, socialization practices do not emphasize high self-esteem expression since it could run counter to culturally valued attributes promoting group harmony (Kim & Markus, 1999). On the other hand, the individualistic country such as the United States stresses the expression of high self-esteem by placing value on freedom and individual rights (Chao, 1995). Consequently, it explains why Asian Americans score lower than Whites or African Americans on self-report measures. Accordingly, research has shown that Asian Americans are more collectivistic …show more content…
There is evidence that the Rosenberg self-esteem scale has acceptable psychometric properties and similar relations with Extraversion and Neuroticism in Japan, India, and the United States (Schmitt & Allik, 2005). Indeed, Cai et al. (2007) shows that Chinese individuals feel positively about themselves but cultural norms related to modesty presses and limited their positive feeling. Likewise, implicit measures of self-esteem are the same between people from Asian countries and the United States (e.g., Yamagishi et al., 2008). The cultural press theory can also be used to explain why African Americans report higher levels of self-esteem than White Americans. To clarify, African-American families strive to plant self-esteem in youth so that they can cope with discrimination (reviewed in Hughes et al., 2006). Likewise, African Americans stress on their “desirable distinctiveness” (Gray-Little & Hafdahl, 2000, p. 26) and therefore report higher levels of self-esteem. To conclude, it can be proposed that African Americans are socialized to communicate pride and Asians communicates
The hierarchy of interpersonal relationships is also most important to this culture as well as maintaining social harmony which is valued over success or self-satisfaction (Johnson & Rhodes, 2015). Recent studies also show that some groups of second-generation Asian Americans exhibit high
Based on the Dimension of Culture Questionnaire, my Asian culture places emphases on human orientation and in-group collectivism. The findings are not at all surprising to “this” native Asian. As I mentioned in my previous self assessment, collective rights trump individual rights
The Asian Model Minority Myth portrays Asian Americans as highly successful, intelligent, and self-sufficient, which erases the experiences of those who face racism, discrimination, and socioeconomic challenges. For example, many Southeast Asian Americans, including Cambodians, Hmong, and Laotians, experience poverty rates that are higher than the national average, and have been historically excluded from the benefits of the "Model Minority" status (ARCC, "The 'Model Minority' Myth About Asian Americans"). The myth can also create a culture of silence and shame for those who do not fit into the perceived "successful" stereotype and can make it harder for Asian Americans to speak out against the discrimination and racism they face. By presenting Asian Americans as successful and high-achieving, the model minority myth hides the experiences of those who have faced discrimination, poverty, or other barriers.
My blog post is directed primarily at Asian Americans like myself, but is also for the eyes of Americans who live in a community with Asian Americans, or anyone who is interested in the subject. I aim to stimulate Asian Americans to be themselves and to bring awareness to my issue of Asian stereotypes and discrimination. Keeping my language casual, but strongly-opinionated, I’m ensuring that my
Midterm Essay It is within our human nature to perceive the world through a racial lens that tints our world black, white, Asian, Mexican, minority, or “other”. The way we are viewed and our impressions of others aid in influencing various aspects of our lives and the lives of those we encounter; from the varieties of jobs we qualify for, the amount of money we make, who we surround ourselves with socially, where we choose to live, our food preferences, the schools we attend, etc. The “all-inclusive” social structure we reside in is impacted by at least one social construction, race. Remarkably enough, most individuals in the United States are mindful of this concept, yet it has failed to be completely dismantled by the society we live in.
Cultural Influences on Asian American Body Image The serious issues pertaining to body image continue to affect the lives of many minorities living throughout the United States today. Asian Americans and their ancestors have endured great scrutiny when it comes to their physical appearance and unattainable standards of beauty. Traditional practices like neck stretching and foot binding have deeply influenced the way Asian Americans view themselves amongst other ethnic groups, as well as their interpretation of beauty.
Often times, culture greatly influences the way one views the world and other people. In fact, culture consistently informs the way one views the world. One way that culture influences views of the world is through self esteem. As shown in the text “Two Kinds” by Amy Tan self esteem affects the way one views the world.
Asians have tolerated this behavior, not because it is okay, but because of discomfort: we are reticent in order to avoid the awkward standoffs and moments of “take a joke” or“but you know it’s true”. These stereotypes were made—not by us, but by others. Meanwhile, over time it has become acceptable for others to brazenly make stereotypical remarks about Asians since backlash is so rare. These beliefs concerning Asians have become so normalized that even though we see this current movement of combatting stereotypes and fighting against racial prejudices, we fail to consider the Asian prejudices and misconceptions.
There is a clear line drawn between these two groups. Although they may appear similar, there is a major distinction. The use of language and traits emphasize the Chinese as the superior minority who is trustworthy and representative of American values. In assigning facial expressions, the Japanese were thought to be “positive, dogmatic, arrogant”. On the other hand, the Chinese facial expressions were “more placed, kindly, open”.
As an Asian American, I have several points to discuss in terms of stereotypes. Through a variety of media, Asian Americans are portrayed by socially constructed stereotypes that are either positive or negative to our community. By explaining the definition of a stereotype and listing three specific ones identified, these points allow one to decide how they could reflect a particular society’s cultural values. These stereotypes include the concept of model minority, the insinuation that Asians are highly skilled at mathematics, and assumptions of our food ways. In each stereotype, I integrate my own experiences to provide a deeper depth of meaning in order to assert that not all stereotypes fully mirror our society’s customs.
In the book “The American School” written by Joel Spring there was a lot of talk about the influences of other cultures who impacted the United States. The popular minority cultures talked about in this book are the African Americans, Hispanic Americans, Asian Americans and the Naïve Americans. They all had historical events that impacted their culture. They are were faced with challenges and obstacle’s they had to overcome. Each of these cultures brings a negative and positive aspect to the American culture.
There are a few links between an individual’s identity, self-esteem and self-image. An individual’s identity is them, their age, their name, ethnicity and background, their family, also their language and education. Their self-esteem means how much they actually value themselves and lastly their self-image is how they view themselves or see themselves. If they have no identity, for example if they are afraid of how others might see them this links to a low self-esteem which can lead to social isolation and/or they might suffer from depression, then their self-image may then suffer such as they forget to look after their personal appearance, hygiene and how they used to dress. On the other hand if they are happy and confidence with their identity then the individual is most likely to look after themselves and their personal image more such as the way they look, dress, eat healthily and exercise etc.
Even in interracial environments such as schools, that interracial contact with whites did not negatively affect Blacks’ self-esteem. The above findings are especially pertinent to the study of African American women and self-esteem. Black women were once predicted to have low self-esteem because scholars thought they internalized demeaning messages of themselves and measured themselves against a white
This week’s lecture was super interesting. In Asian Culture Brief article, The Chinese are the largest single group of Asians in America. According to lecture notes, they make up roughly 6% of the population. While looking at the stats portion, I realized that just like every other cultural group, Asian Americans have many subgroups within their ethnicity that have similarities and differences. For example, a similarity that I was able to point out was the educational expectation.
“When our emotional health is in a bad state, so is our level of self-esteem. We have to slow down and deal with what is troubling us, so that we can enjoy the simple joy of being happy and at peace with ourselves.” by Jess C. Scott, Clear: A Guide to Treating Acne Naturally. Most people want to fill their whole lifetime with happy and beautiful memories, even the things seem small and trifling to others. Due to the thoughts that emotional health influences the conditions of physical health, harmony of physical and emotional health become a strategy to have a happier life.