Should Electoral College Be Abolished Argumentative Essay
怒枠ract
It has been long debated that the winner-take-all-principle of the Electoral College should be abolished for reasons that it fails to promote loyalty, equality and democracy. Some of the arguments against the Electoral College are: it has the risk of so-called “faithless” electors and the possible role of the Electoral College in depressing voter turnout. On the other hand, arguments in favor of this principle defend that it: enhances the status of minority interests and maintains a federal system of government and representation.
This Research paper will use the following sources: Keeping the Republic by Barbour and Wright, Federalist No. 68 by Alexander Hamilton, the documents written by William Kimberling and Tara Ross and the
…show more content…
Until now, citizens cannot vote directly for their president that breaks democratic principles and obscures presidential politics. But, are these arguments enough to prove that the winner-take-all principle of the Electoral College be abolished even if it has proved that it has worked well in this century having no election of the president that has been decided in the House of Representatives? The winner-take-all principle of the Electoral College is used in most states and in the District of Columbia except in Maine and Nebraska. This principle means that in a state, the candidate who has the majority or the plurality of the popular vote gets all the electoral votes of the state. This principle, then, does not guarantee that whoever wins the nationwide popular vote, is sure to be elected as the president for the Electoral College determines the winner of the election. For those who object the winner-take-all principle, they worry that the Electoral College system has: the risk of so-called “faithless” electors and the possible role of the Electoral College in depressing voter turnout. On the other hand, arguments in favor of this principle defend that it: enhances the status of minority interests and maintains a federal system of …show more content…
So, rather than basing the number of the electoral votes in each state according to its number of representatives and senators, the electoral votes would be based on the percentage of the “popular vote won”. Although the proponents of this plan argue that it retains the Electoral College vigor, “the results would be closer to the national popular vote outcome” (Ross, 2004). They also argue that, “the voices of minority voting groups would be reflected in the final election tally because even ballots cast for third-party candidates could be reflected in the national results” (Ross, 2004). Thus, it is also likely to happen that a presidential candidate can win the election without winning the popular but Ross claims that, it will happen less likely than the system that we have in present
Levinson The Purpose Of The Senate Summary
1618 Words | 7 PagesThe checks and balances that the founders desired between the Senate and the House would be reflected in the competing political parties within the House. 2. Sanford Levinson argues that the Electoral College is a “dreadful system of presidential selection” that is beyond defending. Using Madison’s Notes and the Federalist Papers, explain the A) purposes of the Electoral College (why they chose this method over others) and B) whether or not Publius’s defense applies to current debates over maintaining or eliminating the Electoral
Pros And Cons Of The Electoral College
1344 Words | 6 PagesDo We Need the Electoral College? Following the 2016 election many individuals we shocked to find Donald Trump had won the Presidency while not having the popular vote. They were unaware of how the electoral college works and how the president is actually elected through the electoral college rather than the popular vote. But, before we find out if we need the electoral college, we must look into why it was created, and look at the pros and cons of the electoral college as well as the pros and cons of the proposed system to replace it.
Electoral System Dbq Essay
730 Words | 3 PagesWhen the Democratic System in America was founded in 1787, it was built on the sturdy ideals of equality and fairness. The founding fathers of the constitutional convention developed the Electoral college system with the best interests of the American people in mind, as the average person was highly under-educated and they did not trust them to make a decision as important as the But over time as society and even our democracy has changed, it has become ridden with flaws and corruption especially in the electoral college and voting system. The effects of the Electoral College’s inefficiencies oppose the very ideas our democracy was built off of. Because of the over-representation of small states, the broken promises of political equality, and
Electoral College Strengths And Weaknesses
976 Words | 4 PagesThe Electoral College When the Founding Fathers congregated and drafted the government of the newly-formed America, they wanted a system that would not produce a tyrant, but could also produce a strong executive that would lead and consider the people. They created a system in which power could be checked and with hope, incorruptible. Distributing political power into the Legislative, Judicial, and Executive branches, and an elaborate process to elect leaders in each, the American Constitution was a document revolutionary in its conception. There are irrefutable strengths of the Constitution, just as there are undeniable weaknesses, however both are huge influences on the shaping of our modern political arena. As discussed in this paper,
Should Electoral College Be Abolished Essay
960 Words | 4 PagesShould the Electoral College be Abolished? Who really votes for the President, population or state? When the Constitutional Convention, they agreed on the fact that the leader must be chosen by a system using an Electoral College because they did not believe that voters had enough information on the candidates to make a good decision. An Electoral College is a system in which the president and vice president are chosen indirectly. Each state and the District of Columbia get one electoral vote for each of their senators and representatives.
Electoral College Be Abolished
1378 Words | 6 PagesShould the Electoral College be Abolished? After the 2000 presidential election, and more recently the 2016 election, many have suggested that America abolish the electoral college, as it has elected the candidate with the lower popular vote on multiple occasions. Although a direct democratic approach to presidential elections (where the election is decided by popular vote) appears to many as an appropriate solution, this approach would grant too much power to large metropolitan areas, make rural votes practically irrelevant, and take away power from states. In order to prevent a situation like such, the electoral college should not be abolished—it must remain, but slight alterations should be made so that America is more equally represented.
Should Electoral College Be Abolished
445 Words | 2 PagesThe Electoral College should come to an end because it disregards the popular vote, it was built on racism and sexism, and it creates a power imbalance between electors. Many people may think that the Electoral College helps out voting system. However, people's votes don't count, which creates a false sense of security. The Founding Fathers were some of the greatest men in history, right? Wrong.
We Should Abolish The Electoral College
301 Words | 2 PagesFrom September 1st to September 17th, I asked 17 random students from the University of Texas at San Antonio if we should abolish the Electoral College. Out of my findings, I discovered that the majority of students were for the abolishment of the Electoral College. The results were relatively close with 58.82% of the respondents for abolishing the Electoral College and 41.18% for preserving it. However, there was a margin of error of 23.76%, and a 95% confidence interval of 35.06% to 82.58%.
Electoral College Argumentative Analysis
423 Words | 2 PagesI really enjoyed this video because ever since I grasped the idea of the Electoral College I have disagreed with it. However, I never really did any research revolving what goes on behind closed doors. The premises most definitely lead to the conclusion without any additional points. We see that the Electoral College ruins democracy because citizens of smaller states have a louder, more important voice than their larger neighboring states. This means that the votes of the larger states will, in a sense, be ignored also like the wants, and needs of people in set states.
Should The Electoral College Be Abolished Dbq Analysis
635 Words | 3 PagesTime-out for the Electoral College Write thesis here. Write Background here. Write prompt/question here. The Electoral College is unfair and should be abolished because third party candidates are given no chance to win the election, voting isn’t distributed equally, and it is undemocratic and flawed. One reason why the Electoral College should be abolished is that it’s almost impossible for third party candidates to win.
The Importance Of The Electoral College
1237 Words | 5 PagesHowever, since this method of election is not completely reliant on the popular vote, it is possible for a candidate to become a minority president: a president who only received a majority of electoral votes (and not of the popular vote). Thus, the question arises whether the Electoral College is an appropriate method of selecting a president. After further analysis, it becomes clear that the Electoral College is not a proper mechanism for electing the president.
Essay On Should Electoral College Be Abolished
837 Words | 4 PagesAll through the history of the United States of America, many people have discussed the abolishment of the Electoral College. For many reasons, some believe it is what makes our country have the type of government we have, some believe that it's what limits the power of the government, and many people such as Mitch McConnell believes it is what gives us our freedom and prosperity. While these are valid arguments there is a multitude of reasons to why the electoral college should be abolished. Such as there is only a need for twelve states in order to become the president, popular vote of the people for president can still lose, and the Swing states are given too much power and attention compared to that of the other states. This is why I believe in the abolishment of the Electoral College.
Argumentative Essay: Should The Electoral College Be Abolished?
612 Words | 3 PagesThe candidate would only have to convince the fifty biggest cities in order to win the election. I agree with the first article in the sense that we should keep the electoral college, but get rid of the popular vote. The popular vote does very little when it comes to the presidential election, though the electors chosen by the popular vote are supposed to vote for their party's candidates, they do not always do so. I also agree that the electors should be those who reside in each state and chosen at random. That way, the president is more so chosen by the people instead of those who "represent the people".
Summary Of Point Abolishing The Electoral College
1603 Words | 7 PagesBenjamin Bolinger, the author of, “Point: Abolishing the Electoral College,” believes that America was founded on the idea of majority rule. He asserts that the Electoral College defies these ideals through the winner-take-all system, which has allowed candidates to lose the popular vote but still earn a ticket to the white house. The author believes that the President should be chosen the same way as every other elected official, by a popular vote. In a popular vote, the majority would rule and every person’s voice would matter (179). In addition, the author points out that America was also founded on the phrase, “no taxation without representation,” and yet four million United States citizens are excluded entirely from voting in the election.
Argumentative Essay On Electoral College
975 Words | 4 Pages(Black, 2012) So, while it is clear that the Electoral College was set up to ensure all states have a voice, it now seems to have the ability to take away the voice of the people. It is necessary to look at our voting process and make the necessary changes needed to ensure the process of electing our President represents the voice of the people. By switching to a majority vote we ensure that the voice of all people are not only heard, but are represented equally, which is how it should be under the one-person, one-vote
More about Should Electoral College Be Abolished Argumentative Essay
Levinson The Purpose Of The Senate Summary
1618 Words | 7 PagesPros And Cons Of The Electoral College
1344 Words | 6 PagesElectoral System Dbq Essay
730 Words | 3 PagesElectoral College Strengths And Weaknesses
976 Words | 4 PagesShould Electoral College Be Abolished Essay
960 Words | 4 PagesElectoral College Be Abolished
1378 Words | 6 PagesShould Electoral College Be Abolished
445 Words | 2 PagesWe Should Abolish The Electoral College
301 Words | 2 PagesElectoral College Argumentative Analysis
423 Words | 2 PagesShould The Electoral College Be Abolished Dbq Analysis
635 Words | 3 PagesThe Importance Of The Electoral College
1237 Words | 5 PagesEssay On Should Electoral College Be Abolished
837 Words | 4 PagesArgumentative Essay: Should The Electoral College Be Abolished?
612 Words | 3 PagesSummary Of Point Abolishing The Electoral College
1603 Words | 7 PagesArgumentative Essay On Electoral College
975 Words | 4 Pages