ipl-logo

Should Victor Frankenstein Have Made A Companion For The Creature Essay

714 Words3 Pages

Should Dr. Frankenstein Have Made a Companion for the Creature? The creature in ‘Frankenstein’ by Mary Shelley is known to have lived an extremely tragic and miserable life. When he finished his tale to Victor Frankenstein, he justifiably demands for a mate to help him cope with all the ordeals he encountered and experienced. This creates the argument of whether Victor Frankenstein was correct in deciding not to create a companion for the creature. I believe Victor Frankenstein was correct in deciding to not create a companion for the creature because the two creatures could reproduce, the female creature may not even be attracted to the male creature, and Victor does not owe the creature the love of a mate. The first reason as to why Victor Frankenstein refused to produce a mate for the monster was because he was afraid that the two creatures would reproduce and spawn a new species. This …show more content…

Ideally, it would be perfect if the two creatures fall in love with each other. But, it is completely realistic for the female creature to be attracted to elegant men rather than the hideous creature. Victor makes this point in the twentieth chapter; “They might even hate each other...she also might turn with disgust from him to the superior beauty of man; she might quit him, and he be again alone, exasperated by the fresh provocation of being deserted by one of his own species.” (179) If the female companion regards the creature with distaste, this would cause more anguish for the creature as he would be shunned by his own kind. In turn, this would cause the creature to seek vengeance and may murder more innocent humans. Victor’s concern of the female creature turning away from the male creature is the second reason as to why I believe that Victor was correct in not creating a companion for the

Show More
Related

  • Could Frankenstein Have Helped The Creature Acclimate And Be Accepted By Society?

    449 Words  | 2 Pages

    Victor should not have told the creature he would build a female companion, procrastinate, then he decides it was a bad idea. When the creature initially requested the companion, Victor knew it was a bad idea yet he agreed. He raised the creature’s hopes when he agreed to create him a female, yet is upset when the creature is upset after Victor does not build the female. The creature just needed a clear ‘yes’ or ‘no’.

    Read More

  • Biblical Allusions In Frankenstein

    540 Words  | 3 Pages

    Frankenstein should’ve taken responsibility for his actions and treat the create as a child, letting him learn the way people commerce and act, showing him the acceptable fashion of society. The creature experienced love and learn of it from the family in the cottage, the creature wanted it and even said he would give up on human’s, leaving for forever. Instead of allowing him companionship, Frankenstein took away hope for him at all, causing the rage to become worse and worse within his creation. Though he created it and had the vast amount of knowledge, Frankenstein lacked the compassion and sympathy it took to allow the creature a chance in the wide world that he had been thrown

    Read More

  • Ultimatum For Frankenstein

    319 Words  | 2 Pages

    In Mary Shelley's Frankenstein, the creature makes many arguments and an ultimate ultimatum for Frankenstein. His arguments may appear reasonable, but when examined closely, they reveal several flaws. The creature demands that Frankenstein create a companion for him, as he is lonely and desires companionship, he demands that he make a female like a creature he has already brought to life. He argues that this is a reasonable request, as it will prevent him from being a danger to society, as he will have someone to share his life with. While this may seem like a plausible argument, the creature's history of violence and destruction makes it difficult to trust that he will keep his promise to behave if given a companion.

    Read More

  • Victor And Frankenstein Similarities

    575 Words  | 3 Pages

    Victor Frankenstein, born with two loving parents unlike the creature. Victor created the Creature then left him because he was disgusted and terrified of what he had created “I rushed out of the room….unable to compose my mind to sleep”( Shelley, 47). the Creature never experienced love because everyone was terrified of him because of his appearance “ He turned on hearing a noise; perceiving me ,...debilitated form hardly appeared capable”( Shelley,89). The Creature ask victor for a companion so he can feel love by someone and so he will not be alone “ My companion must be of the same species, and have the same defects. This being you must create”(Shelley,123).Victoor gets married to Elizabeth and the creature kills her because he does not go through with the plan of creating the Creatures companion

    Read More

  • Similarities Between Grendel And Frankenstein

    616 Words  | 3 Pages

    Frankenstein’s monster wanted a partner, so he can share his virtue and morality with her because he was so motivated by it. Frankenstein’s monster claimed “When I first sought it, it was the love of virtue, the feelings of happiness and affection with which my whole being overflowed, that I wished to be participated” (Shelley 154). The rejections from Frankenstein and the society, after all, led the monster to have an abnormal passion for his partner. He motivated Frankenstein by killing all Frankenstein’s beloved ones just to create a bride for him. In Shelley’s novel, Frankenstein’s monster recalled "…do you think that I was then dead to agony and remorse…

    Read More

  • Parenthood In Frankenstein

    908 Words  | 4 Pages

    By this reference, one can tell how much the action of Frankenstein leaving the creature influenced the monster in his loneliness desires. This is proven for the creature is willing to do wrongdoings to get his desire. By this being said, there is no question on how much this situation would have changed if Victor provided the creature with more affection and company. This makes Victor overly responsible for the wrongdoings that the creature caused in order for him to get company and not be

    Read More

  • Why Do You Think Frankenstein's Creature Is Human Essay

    897 Words  | 4 Pages

    Do you think Frankenstein 's creature is human? In Gris Grimley 's Frankenstein, Victor had created an intelligent creature that when to some good and bad with the encounters he made by other people, He wanted a mate to share happiness and emotions with, like other human beings. I believe that Victor 's creature is human. The creature is considered human because he shows feelings to other people, including Victor and he desires to be happy with a mate that would not be disgusted by him. To begin with, the creature is defined as human because he talks and thinks like a regular human being.

    Read More

  • How Does Walton Use Letters In Frankenstein

    1392 Words  | 6 Pages

    Even though some might argue that Victor deserves it, murder is still murder and it is inexcusable. For this reason, I agree with Victor and his decision to destroy the monster. The monster gives a compelling argument to Victor as to why you should create another monster for him. The monster believes that a companion is his only chance for happiness as he is shunned by everyone and the monster intimidates Victor with threats of death and suffering until victor agrees to create a female monster. When Victor actually does destroy the female monster he does so for several reasons, one of which is so they are unable to breed but it is quite obvious Victor could have solved this problem without killing the female monster.

    Read More

  • Examples Of Moral Conscience In Frankenstein

    800 Words  | 4 Pages

    Victor never gave his creation a female companion which his monster needed greatly because no human women would ever love the monster. The monster was neglected and the best way to help the monster get love and attention would be by giving him a female companion. Victor also knew the monster would kill his wife if he didn't give him a female companion because the monster himself told him. When Victor leaves his life alone in the cabin the night of their marriage that was completely his fault, Victor himself knew that his creation would try to kill his wife that night and he left her vulnerable and alone. Victor Frankenstein could have avoided this entire situation in the first place if he had been his creation's companion and showed love for him, instead of neglect and

    Read More

  • Prep Sheet For Frankenstein

    766 Words  | 4 Pages

    The Creature approaches his creator Dr. Frankenstein with an ultimatum, this ultimatum is that he either makes him a companion or he dies and an example of this would be when the creature says “you my creator, abhor me; when can I gather from your fellow creature that owns me nothing? They spawn and hate me.” (Shelley 184) Dr. Frankenstein listens to the Creature and agrees to create a companion for him. While Dr. Frankenstein is almost done with the Creatures companion he begins to regret his decision and concludes to not finish the project destroying everything in front of the Creatures eyes.

    Read More

  • Frankenstein And Grendel Similarities

    889 Words  | 4 Pages

    We have established that the monster from Frankenstein is one of a kind and feels alone, this brings up one of his main goals, seeking a life companion. In the novel, when talking to Victor, the monster states, ““You must create a female for me, with whom I can live in the interchange of those sympathies necessary for my being…””(Shelley 125) The monsters’ goal in the novel is not to hurt victor as some might argue, but to achieve a companion that will not shun him. While, trying to achieve this goal leads to suffering and hardships to many in the novel, it is seen that the reason is to fulfill one of humanities’ basic goals, achieve a companion. In the novel Grendel, we see that Grendel is also wanting a companion or friend to talk to.

    Read More

  • Companionship In Frankenstein

    898 Words  | 4 Pages

    If the narrator had been the creature, the reader would sympathize with him for creating him to be alone vs feeling bad for Frankenstein’s loss. The different point of views offer more evidence to support the author’s message about companionship. Shelley writes from Frankenstein’s point of view, “I have but one resource; and I devote myself, either in my life or death, to his destruction” (Shelley, 1818, p 188). In this quote, we can see how the lack of his wife, friend, and brother has driven him insane with anger and revenge for the creature.

    Read More

  • Cost Of Conceit In Frankenstein

    1044 Words  | 5 Pages

    The creature asks one thing of Frankenstein, which is for him to create a female counterpart so that he can have a companion that will not judge him for being so different. Frankenstein is sympathetic at first and begins the creation of the female counterpart, but he soon stops because the risks of having two creatures is too great. He bases his decision on logic instead of emotion, he cannot risk the negative outcomes of creating another creature. There is only one positive outcome out of the multiple possible outcomes. The negatives outweigh the positives, which leads to his ultimate decision of stopping the creation of the second creature.

    Read More

  • Violence In Frankenstein

    705 Words  | 3 Pages

    Frankenstein 's Creature Victor 's creature was mixed with some good and bad inside of him. The creation of the creature started when Victor 's mom had died, and he wanted to control life and death. So, he had the idea of creating the creature. The creature was 8 feet tall, was deformed, and had other people 's body parts attached to him. The only thing the creature wanted was to have someone to keep company with.

    Read More

  • Frankenstein: The Relationship Between The Creature And The Creator

    1131 Words  | 5 Pages

    Both of the characters Frankenstein and the creature had contrasting motives throughout the novel. Frankenstein wasn 't really seeking for a main thing as the creature was seeking for companionship. In "Frankenstein: Creation as Catastrophe" Paul Sherwin states "Creatures utmost desire is that another reciprocate his need for sympathetic relationship. " The creature just wanted someone to love him and care for him. Someone that he could depend on.

    Read More

More about Should Victor Frankenstein Have Made A Companion For The Creature Essay

Open Document