ipl-logo

Similarities Between A New Land Of Opportunity And The Last Wilderness

631 Words3 Pages

The passages titled, “The Last Wilderness Preserve'' by Kendra Washington and “ A New Land of Opportunity” by Micheal Serillio both accommodate a familiar topic about the continent of Antarctica. However, though both passages contain the same concept, both writers (Kendra Washington and Micheal Serillio) have contrasting opinions on if human action should be permitted in Antarctica. In spite of their disagreement, Micheal Serillio’s passage uses stronger reasoning, various evidence and a preferable explanation as to why Antarctica should be investigated by humans. To begin, Kendra Washington’s passage titled “The Last Wilderness Preserve” claims that “Any human action that would harm Antarctica is a crime against nature and a threat to our …show more content…

With evidence from the text expressing that “It is illegal to hunt or fish for many kinds of animals, mine for minerals, or drill for oil in Antarctica.” This creates the idea of why many agreements were constructed to keep the land safe. Additionally, another piece of evidence from the text states “There is nothing welcoming about Antarctica, and this may be nature’s way of keeping humans out”. To continue, Washington introduced the counterclaim which states, “Although these restrictions may be removed in the future, most nations have cooperated thus far”. With the rebuttal stating, “If any mineral or oil deposits are discovered, many nations will fight for it”. However, the rebuttal is unsuccessful in supporting the claim, as it goes against the evidence shown in the text. Throughout the text Washington clearly explains how “The Antarctic Treaty” was created in order to protect Antarctica and keep humans elsewhere from it. But, her rebuttal shows how she may have hardly any faith in the Treaty being successful. As the

Show More
Related

  • Summary Of First Wilderness By Mark David Spence

    300 Words  | 2 Pages

    In his essay, “First Wilderness: America’s Wonderland and Indian Removal from Yellowstone National Park,” Mark David Spence argues that the creation of Yellowstone National Park is an early illustration of removing native peoples as a way to “preserve” nature. The idea of Yellowstone being a pristine and untouched wilderness, is challenged by Spence as he brings to light the presence of Indigenous peoples and communities who had occupied the land prior to the national park being established. He advocates for a better understanding of Yellowstone National Park’s history, encompassing the dispossession of the Indigenous peoples within the area. Spence explains how the wilderness preservation of Yellowstone ignores and dismisses any connection

    Read More

  • Summary Of Arctic National Wildlife Refuge By Jimmy Carter

    412 Words  | 2 Pages

    In Jimmy Carter’s foreword to Arctic National Wildlife Refuge: Season of Life and Land, A Photographic Journey, he argues the reason why the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge should not be developed as an industrial site. The former U.S. President signed the Alaska National Interest Lands Conservation Act, which safeguards at least 100 million acres of parks, forests, and refuges in Alaska, as a monumental Legislation. To strengthen his argument, Carter uses evidence that supports his claims along with reasoning to connect the two, and uses pathos to appeal to the audience's’ emotion. Evidence and reasoning are used to support the claims that the Refuge should be kept a reserve.

    Read More

  • Summary Of Arctic National Wildlife Refuge By Jimmy Carter

    564 Words  | 3 Pages

    In the passage, Jimmy Carter states, “ Those attempts have failed because of tremendous opposition by the American people including the Gwich’in Athabascan Indians of Alaska and Canada, indigenous people whose culture has depended on the Porcupine caribou for thousands of years. Having visited many aboriginal people around the world, I can empathize with the Gwich'in struggle to safeguard one of their precious human rights.” He provided evidence that many American are behind this cause, particularly the people living in this area need. He empathized, supported, and protected their needs of the land, and their way of

    Read More

  • A Rhetorical Analysis Of Arctic National Wildlife Refuge By Jimmy Carter

    770 Words  | 4 Pages

    He describes the Refuge as “magnificent,” “timeless,” and “a symbol of our national heritage.” This strong language serves to convey the depths of Carter’s passion for the Refuge, and helps the reader to feel some of that passion as well. This use of emotion helps to build Carter’s case as the audience becomes more connected to the place he wants to protect. After describing the Refuge using such grand terms, Carter goes on to describe the threat faced by the Refuge in similar fashion, describing the development of the land as a potential “tragedy” that would “forever destroy the wilderness character of America’s only Arctic Refuge,” as well as endangering the “precious human rights” of the area’s indigenous people. This powerful language causes the reader to feel that the refuge is under serious threat, and any harm that might come to the Refuge would be devastating.

    Read More

  • Who Is Jimmy Carter's Personal Experience In The Arctic National Wildlife Refuge

    645 Words  | 3 Pages

    When describing his personal experience in the Arctic Refuge, he uses phrases that represent his awe of the area, such as "flooded with life," "once-in-a-lifetime," and "great wilderness," to make the Arctic Refuge area seem sacred, and almost creating a sense of guilt in those considering development in the area, attempting to lead them to abandon their project plans. However, when Carter is discussing the damage that industrialization of the area could do to its wildlife and Native people, he takes on a very concerned tone, describing the Native American conservation efforts as a "struggle to safeguard one of their precious human rights," and stating that the Arctic refuge is a very small piece of "precious wilderness" that still remains after modernization took over the United States and obliterated its

    Read More

  • Into The Wild By Jon Krakauer: Chapter Analysis

    1029 Words  | 5 Pages

    Zoe Engel 6-19-23 Mr. Selfridge Period: 2 Stepping Into the Wilderness The work of nonfiction Into The Wild, by Jon Krakauer, tells the true story of Chris McCandless, an adventurous young man, who leaves home to travel around the continent eventually setting foot into the Alaskan wilderness on a journey that becomes fatal. Highlighted throughout this work of nonfiction is the true story of McCandless’s life, along with bits of Krakauer’s personal life as it relates to McCandless’s. Each chapter begins with at least one epigraph that shares common themes with the following chapter. The focus in this paper will be on chapter 14, “The Stikine Ice Cap,” in which Krakauer shares his experience climbing the Devil’s Thumb in Alaska, and the second

    Read More

  • Summary Of A Strange New Land

    1171 Words  | 5 Pages

    Strange New Land The time period and events of when slavery took place is a topic that is frequently and heavily covered in United States history. Peter Wood’s book, A Strange New Land gives an intrinsic synopsis of slavery from the very beginning of slavery in the Americas dating 1492 all the way through the start of the American Revolution in 1775. Wood reveals insight into the excruciating lives and the daily challenges slaves in the Americas endured.

    Read More

  • The Perception Of Wilderness By George Cronon

    297 Words  | 2 Pages

    The perception of wilderness can be problematic. One of the most prominent points that Cronon made in his evaluation is the ideology that wilderness is an illusion to escape reality. This perception can be ambiguous because it segregates humanity from nature, by establishing the idea that wilderness is separate from everyday life. Also, Cronon calls attention to the issue of dividing the land and calling it wilderness. The issue of this isolation is that it disintegrates humans and nature, rather than bringing them more in unity.

    Read More

  • Analysis Of The Trouble With Wilderness By William Cronon

    90 Words  | 1 Pages

    In his 1995 essay “The Trouble with Wilderness,” William Cronon declares that “the time has come to rethink wilderness” (69). From the practice of agriculture to masculine frontier fantasies, Cronon argues that Americans have historically defined wilderness as an “island,” separate from their polluted urban industrial homes (69). He traces the idea of wilderness throughout American history, asserting that the idea of untouched, pristine wilderness is a harmful fantasy. By idealizing wilderness from a distance, he argues that people justify the destruction of less sublime landscapes and aggravate environmental conflict.

    Read More

  • Arctic National Wildlife Refuge Rhetorical Analysis Essay

    668 Words  | 3 Pages

    With the specific explanation about the influence of the Alaska National Interest Land Conservation Act, that it “specifically created the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge, doubled the size of the former range, and restricted development in areas that are clearly incompatible with oil exploration”, Carter supports his argument that protecting the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge is necessary from a professional perspective of the singer of a relative major act by using ethos, and it not only appeals to the audiences by referring his character as the former US president, but also helps the author to raise credibility of his central argument. In conclusion, Jimmy Carter adeptly utilizes pathos, logos, and ethos to strengthen his argument that the industrial development in the Arctic National Wild Refuge should be prohibited in his foreword to Arctic National Wildlife Refuge: Seasons of Life and land, A photographic Journey by Subhankar

    Read More

  • Jimmy Carter's Argument Analysis

    466 Words  | 2 Pages

    The way he describes his experience when visiting was truly spectacular. They witnessed the migration of tens of thousands of caribou with their newborn calves. In a matter of mere seconds, the sweep of tundra before them became flooded with life, with the sounds of grunting animals and clicking hooves filling the air. He goes on to say that the Arctic Refuge is a symbol of our national heritage and little of that precious wilderness remains among our highways. America is big on leaving a better world for our future generation and he wraps up his argument by saying leaving the Arctic Refuge alone would be the greatest gift we could pass onto

    Read More

  • James Loewen The Land Of Opportunity Summary

    515 Words  | 3 Pages

    In James W. Loewen’s “The Land of Opportunity,” he states that social class affects the way children are raised. He discusses the inequality in today’s society and how the textbooks in high school do not give any social class information. The students in today’s time are not taught everything they should be taught. He states that your family’s wealth is what makes up your future. Loewen discusses that people with more money can study for the SATs more productively and get a better score than someone who has less money.

    Read More

  • Argumentative Essay On Into The Wild

    915 Words  | 4 Pages

    The Alaskan Bush is one of the hardest places to survive without any assistance, supplies, skills, and little food. Jon Krakauer explains in his biography, Into The Wild, how Christopher McCandless ventured into the Alaskan Bush and ultimately perished due to lack of preparation and hubris. McCandless was an intelligent young man who made a few mistakes but overall Krakauer believed that McCandless was not an ignorant adrenalin junkie who had no respect for the land. Krakauer chose to write this biography because he too had the strong desire to discover and explore as he also ventured into the Alaskan Bush when he was a young man, but he survived unlike McCandless. Krakauer’s argument was convincing because he gives credible evidence that McCandless was not foolish like many critics say he was.

    Read More

  • Symbolism In Jon Krakauer's 'Into The Wild'

    2137 Words  | 9 Pages

    Journal 1 Krakauer, Jon. Into The Wild. New York: Villard, 1996. Print. Journal 2

    Read More

  • Martha Stewart And The Cannibal Polar Bear Analysis

    704 Words  | 3 Pages

    In the excerpt the mooallem explains a northern military fort that was known as “the polar bear capital of the world”. with its newfound title came tourists. And with the uprising in tourism comes with the rise in destruction. The author makes a very strong and and almost emotional connection not only to himself but the the polar bears

    Read More

More about Similarities Between A New Land Of Opportunity And The Last Wilderness

Open Document