Both the American and French Revolutions were based upon the Enlightenment ideal of freedom. Each nation desperately wanted eradicate the monarchies that controlled them and refused to represent each nation’s citizens. French king Louis XVI had an immense need for wealth to support himself and Queen Marie Antoinette, despite having good intentions, his leadership skills were poor (Furet). The British King and Parliament also attempted to severely control the American colonies (Morgan 8). In both cases this resulted in extreme taxation of the people of each nation. Once the idea of revolutionizing was planted, the reaction from the over-taxed citizens was inevitable. Although both the French and American Revolutions were fought in the name …show more content…
In France during the 1700s, the Third Estate felt oppressed by their government, over taxed and neglected by the French Monarchy, despite making up 97% of the Country (Beck 654). Around the same time, the British Parliament was severely trying to control the American colonies, and to gain the most profit possible from them by passing a trade law called the Navigation Act. This prevented the colonists from trading their valuable commodities to any countries except Britain (Morgan 10). Although both governments were gaining money from the taxation of their citizens, the nation’s debt was still increasing. This, as well as the consistent spread of Enlightenment ideas and the Scientific Revolution inspired both nations to revolutionize in the name of freedom …show more content…
After King Louis XVI was executed, France became a republic with universal voting rights. In attempt to create a new France, the National Convention tried to erase France’s past and made many changes to the people’s socio economic life. However the American colonies first step after revolutionizing was setting up a functional government, with a constitution providing equal power in the Legislative, Executive and Judicial branches (Branches of Government). The new form of government was based on the Greek democracy with some aspects of the British government, and the idea of a representative or president that came from the Ancient Rome . The American Constitution was heavily influenced by the colonists wanting to break away from the King and Parliament and Enlightenment ideas. After the oppression they faced under British government, the early Americans established a Bill of Rights , protecting their rights as American citizens (Beck
Taxes, which is still a commonly disagreed topic, were a major reason the people of France revolted. The members of the first estate were paying only a fraction of what the members of the third and event the second were. Arthur Young, a man who travelled through France from 1787 to 1789, made the observation that land owned by nobility and people of the upper class was taxed very little compared to the land owned by common citizens (Doc. 1). This injustice took a great toll on members of the third estate and
The French Revolution was the third estate’s fight against the government of France in an attempt to get rid of unfair taxation and their bad leader, Louis XIV. It happened because there was a bad harvest, financial crisis, other countries and areas were introducing democracies, Louis XVI was a bad leader, and society itself was unfair. The goals of the revolutionaries were to gain a say in government, have a more equal divide in social classes and their responsibilities, and to have a better ruler, which were not achieved for over 25 years. Because of this, the French Revolution was not a success, as the events and government in France that followed the revolution directly contradicted the main goals people fought for.
Have you ever wondered how a king can be so terrible that his own people want him dead? The French Revolution stemmed from people's demands that were influenced by Enlightenment ideals. These ideals were the positions and thoughts the Enlightenment philosophers supported. With the influence of Enlightenment ideals people wanted more. John Locke, an English philosopher, had ideas that influenced revolutions, more notably, the French Revolution.
The American and French Revolutions were two momentous events that occurred in the 18th century and had a profound impact on modern thought and politics. By comparing these two revolutions, we can gain a better understanding of how they affected social structures and democratic institutions, and provide a more comprehensive assessment of their success. Both revolutions aimed to challenge the existing order and establish a new system, but the American Revolution focused on achieving independence from British rule and promoting economic growth, while the French Revolution sought to overthrow the absolute monarchy and promote social equality. Examining their similarities and differences can provide valuable insights into the broader implications
There were four main revolutions taken place and they were known as the Atlantic Revolutions including the North American Revolution from 1775 to 1787, French Revolution from 1789 to 1815, Haitian Revolution from 1791 to 1804, and Spanish Revolution from 1810 to 1825. These revolutions arise due to the oppression of people towards the political issues and injustice to the different class of people in the society. Also, the revolutions originated to the weak political authorities, especially the ruler. For the American Revolutions, the Americans opposed the political issues and the weak government.
There are different types of revolutions all around the world. English, American, French, and Latin Revolutions are one the most important ones that happened. These revolutions all have something in common. All of them emphasize the enlightenment idea of freedom. Although all of these revolutions started differently they ended up making a change.
Introduction: The American Revolution and the French Revolution were two major events that significantly impacted our world’s history. They both were characterized by a commitment to freedom, democracy, and equality. The American Revolution and the French Revolution's goals were to change the way that their rulers treated their nation's people. However, there were fundamental differences between them that led to different outcomes.
After three centuries of colonial rule, Spanish and Portuguese America got independence. Between 1808 and 1826 all of Latin America except the Spanish colonies of Cuba and Puerto Rico remained under Spanish rule. This was the result of a combination of long-building tensions in colonial rule and a series of external events. The reforms imposed by the Spanish in the 18th century provoked great instability in the relations between the rulers and their colonial subjects in the Americas. Many Creoles felt Bourbon policy to be an unfair attack on their wealth, political power, and social status.
The French was influenced by the American Revolution because they saw how successful it was and thought it would work for them
The French, Haitian, and American Revolutions were all sparked from the minds of the colonists, slaves, or lower classes who were treated with inequality by their own governments. In each location, there was a noticeable trend of mistreatment between government and people. In Haiti, slaves brought over by the French who captured the island, and forced them into brutal labor in what was the most valuable and wealthy are at the time. The government and leadership in France was corrupt as they were in much debt. King Louis XVI and Marie Antoinette lived in Versailles far from the other forms of government, abusing the country wealth.
With such an ideological basis, it becomes clear when one sets out to compare the French Revolution and American Revolution that people felt the need to be free from oppressive or tyrannical rule of absolute monarchs and have the ability to live independent from such forces. The leadership in both countries at the time of their revolutions was certainly repressive, especially in terms of taxation. Both areas suffered social and economic hardships that led to the realization that something must be done to topple the hierarchy and put power back into the hands of the people. While there are several similarities in
As a result of their revolution, the Americans got their independence from Britain and introduced enlightenment ideas into their government. The American government after the revolution was much different than the government before the revolution. Before the revolution the American people were not represented in government and had no say. After the revolution the American people became the government. People elected other people that they trusted to go represent them in government.
Prior to the Revolution, French citizens lived under the rule of oppressive regimes and rulers. France was controlled by an absolute monarchy in the years leading up to the Revolution, which vested power in the central government, giving rights and freedom to an elite few while depriving the masses of those same rights. Anger and resentment grew among French citizens: they had little land, high taxes and suffered from high rates of poverty, food scarcity and lack of basic supplies under the regime. Europeans wanted the same type of change the Americans revolutionized for themselves. Although the Europeans had the same ideas as the Americans, their Revolution had bumps along the way.
The French Revolution came about after much financial and representational distress. Some of the goals these revolutionaries had were to overthrow the monarchy and create a representative republic, to provide equal representation for the Third Estate, and to abolish the noble-veto. Whether these goals were accomplished or not is left up to debate for many people. However, I think they were both successfully accomplished and failed at the same time. Essentially, the revolutionaries achieved what they were fighting for, but that only lasted a short time.
The autocratic monarchy, greedy leaders, lavish expenditure created political cause for the revolution. The French citizens wanted to change their country’s political views and long standing traditions. We have seen this in our own country lately. Socially it was a very miserable time.