The American and French revolution are similar because of their causes, courses and consequences, which include taxes, wars and riots, and gained independence in both American colonies and France. With these similarities, there were also many differences between the French and American revolutions. The British began to impose very harsh taxes to the American colonies and the Americans were not happy. The British did this because their nationial debt was very high because of global struggles with France. When they started to tax the colonists this heavily, the Colonists couldn’t do anything because they had no representatives in the British Parliament. The Sugar Act (1764) put a tax on sugar and molasses; the Stamp Act (1765) put a direct tax on all printed materials; and the Tea Act (1773) placed a 3-cents-per-pound tax on tea. …show more content…
Then the Boston Tea Party in 1772, Colonists dressed up as Native Americans and dumped crates of tea and other goods into the harbor so the British couldn’t make any money off of them. Similar to the American Colonies, France was on the brink of bankruptcy and government in debt, so the government imposed a higher price of living. Because of the “estates”, the commoners which was 98% of the population ended up paying for all of the taxes. King Louis XVI noticed how the poeple were unhappy with the taxes, so in effort to make it more equal he called into session the Estates General. This was a meeting at Versailles and it consisted of representitives from the three estates, giving each estate one vote on who should be taxed. The first and second could easily team up
The American and French revolutions were very similar. Although they happen years and miles from each other they had similar ideas and characteristics. People in France and the Americas fought for only one specific reason liberty. France revolution was for liberty in their government and American Revolution was for liberty in their territory and to liberty from Great Britain.
Taxes! After the French and Indian War, the British government needed money to pay for the cost of protecting the colonists from the French and Indians. The British government approved several taxes including the Stamp and Tea Acts to help pay for the costs of the war. The colonists were expected to pay these taxes.
In France during the 1700s, the Third Estate felt oppressed by their government, over taxed and neglected by the French Monarchy, despite making up 97% of the Country (Beck 654). Around the same time, the British Parliament was severely trying to control the American colonies, and to gain the most profit possible from them by passing a trade law called the Navigation Act. This prevented the colonists from trading their valuable commodities to any countries except Britain (Morgan 10). Although both governments were gaining money from the taxation of their citizens, the nation’s debt was still increasing.
France's issues were much more ingrained. The country was bankrupt, and only supported on taxes of the 3rd estate. Clergy and nobility (though the richest) were exempt from paying. Those taxes were also extremely high, and especially a burden for the poorest of the poor. Other problems like famine contributed to the growing rage of the 3rd estate.
The French revolution was violent and bloody and the American war just was not as violent as the French war. Another major difference is the American revolution actually worked while the French revolution failed. As stated before, the French
Another important similarity between the two revolutions in France and America was their emphasis on Enlightenment thought. The first of these ideas is the idea of popular sovereignty. This is the idea that governments were only legitimate if they got their powers from the consent of the people. It also holds that the people should have the ultimate power over their government. Both the French and American Revolutions were based in large part on the desire to take power away from aristocratic elites and give that power to the people.
History is made everywhere, we just don 't take it into consideration as much. Today, i 'll be explaining the differences and similarities about the French and American Revolution. The French Revolution had three estates which were first estate (church clergy), second estate (nobility and the rest of the French people), and the third estate (urban lower class and peasant farmers). They went through a lot, mostly because of debt and unfairness. The American Revolution began with the Enlightenment, which was a movement that looked at government and science and that later traced the French and Indian War which was a war on the ocean that was a conflict that brought many colonists into direct combat for the sake of the English king.
The French and American Revolutions were both turning points in the histories of their respective countries and had a large impact on the world as a whole. They have also often been classified as ‘modern revolutions’ in various papers and books including On Revolution (1963) by Hannah Arendt. This paper aims to compare and contrast various aspects of the American and French revolutions and show that they both have indeed been rightly classified as revolutions. The first similarity between the two revolutions is the fact that they were both born out of societies that were facing severe social and economic problems (“A Comparison of the French Revolution and American Revolution”).
Gentz wrote about these two historic revolutions in 1800 and compared them on various issues. He acknowledged the fact that these revolutions were completely disparate in their goals and ideas. For example, in the American Revolution the colonies were asking for their traditional rights as English citizens, in a calm and orderly way. On the contrary, the French revolution sought to uproot society's traditions to base them on reason alone. This difference lead Gentz to characterize the American revolution as defensive, and the French as offensive.
A Comparison of the French Revolution and American Revolution Related Article The Societal Aftermath of World War I and Europe’s “Lost Generation" Montaigne and Sepulveda: Differences of Conquest & Culture The Rise of Secularism in Medieval Europe Why doesn’t Italy have a homogenous national culture? What are the reasons behind the lack of a strong national identity?
The colonists wanted representation when it came down to being taxed, but the British government would not allow it. The government wanted full control over the people, so they made sets of acts and laws that were placed on taxation. For example, the Stamp Acts of 1765. These acts taxed all papers, pamphlets, newspapers, and cards. The Townshend Acts of 1767 were also a large part of taxation.
The Differences and Similarities between the French Revolution and the American Revolution Alice Lee World History Mr. Neuman New Mexico Connections Academy January 17, 2023 The Differences and Similarities between the French Revolution and the American Revolution Looking back and learning more about the French and American Revolutions, it’s easy to see some of the similarities they share. Although this may be true, both Revolutions have different aspects and interesting differences between them. Some can point out the similarities and differences just by the key elements of each Revolution’s purpose. For example, in the American Revolution, Americans did not fight for abstraction, while the French did.
Enlightenment?” Between the 18th and 19th centuries, two considerable revolutions reflected the ideals of the Enlightenment. Though these ideals played a substantial role in both revolutions, they were more significantly shown in the American Revolution. The French Revolution began with intentions following the Enlightenment ideals but ended up with strong feelings of fear driving the people rather than princples.
The Revolutions were awakening the people inhabiting the countries. The American Revolution and the French Revolution were caused by economic challenges that both the countries faced. The French and the American Revolutions were resulting from the Enlightenment period of time, which put great importance on the natural rights and equality that all people should receive due to them being human. This gave ground to the idea that all people have God given or are born with certain rights and that all people are to be treated equal.
The first way that the French Revolution in the late 1700s and the Russian Revolution in the early 1900s compare is their government. During their times, they both had weak leaders that did not desire to rule, this was King Louis XVI of France and Czar Nicholas II of Russia. Both Royal families were eventually executed or assassinated. Also, both countries around the time of their revolutions were affected by a war in a way, the American Revolution for France and World War I for Russia. Both tried new governments, for France this was democracy and for Russia it was communism.