Feminism and Its Influence On The Protagonists in Charlotte and First They Killed My Father
Introduction
Throughout both Charlotte and First They Killed My Father our main protagonists are seen doing heroic and rebellious acts. Both have been through war, genocide, and heartbreak. These conditions have made both Charlotte Salomon and Loung Ung change their views on the world and themselves. Between the two protagonists, Loung Ung is more of a traditional feminist.
Traditional Feminism and Its Roots. Many believe the false narrative of feminism being a “new age thing,” when in reality, feminism is seen all throughout history. Traditional feminism is defined as “the belief in full social, economic, and political equality for women.” (Britannica)
…show more content…
At this camp, she will learn how to fight and become a soldier in case the Angkar needs her assistance in the war. “The camp you are going to is for the bigger, stronger children. There you will be trained as a soldier so you can soon help fight the war.” (pg 130) Loung is seen as physically strong. She is a hard worker and a good fighter, driven by rage and hatred. Along with leaving the camp, Loung has to leave her sister Chou as well. “Chou, you're older than me, stop being so weak” (pg 130) Loung says this in response to Chou crying during their final goodbyes. Loung takes pride in being emotionally and physically …show more content…
Loung had the opportunity to fight back and somewhat protest for her rights, while Charlotte, unfortunately, didn't. A disadvantage Charlotte had was her family history of mental illness. From the beginning, Charlotte was plagued with stereotypes due to her family history and her religion. People believed she was insane because “Insanity runs in the family.” (pg 94) In reality, she was mentally ill, but she was held back from a lot of things because of it. She relied on the women figures in her life, as well as her love interests. She was extremely emotionally dependent on her love interests, and it prevented her from making choices of her own. She let what others thought about her influence her self-esteem. Loung had the advantage because she did not have the codependency Charlotte experienced. Loung was forced to be independent, while Charlotte chose to be. Loung was both physically and mentally stronger than
To start off, Loung had heard some stories about a woman from a nearby village who had turned out to be a cannibal. Most said she was a good woman but the Khmer rouge caused her to be like this monster. Evidence from the memoir Loung explains, “She was so hungry that when her husband died from eating poisonous food, she ate his flesh and fed it to her children. She did not know that the poison in his body would kill her and her children as well.”
At the beginning of the book Charlotte likes the captain because they are of the same social class but as the novel progresses, Captain Jaggery's true colors start to show. Charlotte soon comes to discover her true self from many different events she experiences with the crew and the captain. When the cook, Zachariah, approaches Charlotte to tell her that Captain Jaggery is actually a very cruel person and is responsible for the amputation of Cranick’s arm, Charlotte is in complete dis belief but still feels inside that Zachariah isn't lying. When the captain wants Charlotte to read bible passages to the crew Charlotte still
As clarified in a faculty essay, the title gives deep meaning to how this affected her. With the title literally talking about her father’s death, the weight of his killing is truly shown and what a high impact it had on her and her life. The loss of her father created an realization like no other; it was the moment when she knew she truly had to grow up. Growing up, Loung considered her father to be all knowing and a protector, she knew that he was the reason they all survived, “Pa was [their] strength and [they] all needed him to survive…” (108). And without him, she needed to find strength.
Her father, Nao Kao Lee, was especially enraged on two occasions. One, when the doctors were performing a spinal tap on Lia, he said that was when “Lia was lost”, as the Hmong believed that procedure would cripple her in this life and her future lives . The second occasion was when he misunderstood that he had to sign a paper that stated that Lia would die in two hours, when it fact “released in two hours” was what was written. “In the Hmong moral code, foretelling a death is strongly taboo.”, and so Nao Kao grabbed his daughter and ran. He was caught afterwards, but these scenarios show that the Hmong had a strong sense of values that the doctors weren’t able to understand and both parties were at a disadvantage.
Similarly, in ‘First They Killed My Father’, the significance the father had on the narrator can also be examined. On page 47 of ‘First They Killed My Father’, Loung, and her family have reached a checkpoint where they would need to be questioned by the Angkar. Referring to her father, Loung quoted “He reaches down and puts his hand on top of my head. It stays there as if protecting me from the sun and the soldiers. After a few minutes, my head feels cooler and my heartbeat slows''.
(Louisa 187) Lou doesn’t understand why Billy is hostile towards her. She feels that she didn’t deserve to lose her father, but realizes that it is better than having a father who won’t even feed you. Lou feels sympathy for him, and now understands why Billy is like that.
When Chou was describing Hong’s experience she described Hong’s language as if it were like spitting to show just how upsetting and angry it made her just to talk about what she witnessed. Because the soldiers made an example out of that boy, they made it
The two families that were supposed to accompany her didn’t show up. She was all alone, and the crew members even told her to get off the ship, but she didn’t listen. Charlotte was stuck on a ship with all men and she was the only passenger. She had to face some tough challenges on sea with the other crew members and the captain, and she had to work hard to get her respect on the ship. This connects to me because I was the only girl on my team, and I had to overcome challenges with the boys.
The conflict was between the narrator and herself. She knew the girl was not good for her but she did not care and wanted her anyways. She could deal with all of her annoying qualities because she loved the way she always looked. The other conflict I saw was Charlotte cheated on both the narrator and the boyfriend, Maurice.
Charlotte wasn’t the only person who took a stand against these laws, Ida Wells refused to leave a first-class train car that was for white people. Not everyone was as brave as these two though. Lynching was a huge problem during this time and many African Americans were scared to do something that might upset the whites. This created a culture of fear which stopped African Americans from trying to live normal
There are people that I run across in my everyday life and I judge them before I take the time to get to know them whether it’s what someone has told me or the way they look, speak etc…It has opened my eyes to notice my flaws and the judgements I place upon people and I don’t know them from a can of paint. Charlotte took it upon herself to accept the responsibility of coming up with a plan to save Wilbur’s life and she didn’t have to. She saw a friend in need and she wanted to help which is what real friends do. In the novel Charlotte was able to tell Wilbur to stop crying and whining so much in a way that Wilbur could accept which the other animals couldn’t.
When she says “Now that she'd captured them, she thought perhaps she might live” it means that after Loung had written her past down and got it out of her head, she could move on from those experiences and forget them. Without the weight of her memories pulling her down, she knows that life is worth living again. If Loung hadn't pushed through wanting to kill herself by
She didn't know who actually did it, but she suspected Zachariah, her friend and crew member. Charlotte thought, “I didn't dare blame Zachariah for fear that he would be killed.” Charlotte’s loyal character helped her learn important lessons and get people to trust her when they didn't do it
This shows that Loung idolized her father and these special moments between Loung and her father were things that she held onto in order to survive the atrocities that she experienced. Loung’s father not only provided provided physical protection by moving his family to places where they would not be in so much danger but he also provided emotional protection by giving Loung hope that she would survive these hardships even after he has
Those sentiments show that her husband was not a cruel man but a kind one. With that information, it is still noted that “she had loved him—sometimes. Often she had not” (Chopin) which could mean her marriage was of convenience and not a choice. Even though this relationship may have been amicable Louise still struggles with this new emotion, that of