The question of whether John D. Rockefeller and Andrew Carnegie were "captains of industry" or "robber barons" is a complex one. Both John D. Rockefeller and Andrew Carnegie played significant roles in the growth and development of American industry during the late 19th and early 26th centuries. On one hand, they are often referred to as "captains of industry" because of their entrepreneurial spirit and their ability to innovate and transform entire industries. Rockefeller's Standard Oil Company revolutionized the oil industry by creating a modern, efficient integrated business model that helped to lower the cost of oil production and distribution, so he could reinvest into his company. Carnegie's steel empire not only transformed the steel
Throughout the late 1800s, many people grew tremendously in wealth. Most people started businesses or expanded railroads which required a lot of money. This start the idea of robber barons or captains of industry; while there were some people who would collect the money for themselves there were many people who gave back and did some great things for America. Therefore, industrialists of the 1860s-1900s were more rightly called Captains of Industry than robber barons. John D. Rockefeller, James Fisk, and Henry Flanger are some great examples of Captains of Industry.
Eastman, Morgan, and Carnegie were all captains of industry. They were all captains of industry because they were top innovators in their industries. For example, Carnegie became the leader in the steel business because he introduced the Bessemer process to America. Using the Bessemer process, Carnegie produced stronger steel cheaper than before. The cheaper stronger steel led to more railroads being built and skyscrapers being created.
John D Rockefeller, captain of industry or robber baron? First off, John D Rockefeller was born on july 8th, 1839 and died on May 23rd, 1937. He was very monopolistic because he bought out and destroyed all of his competitors that opposed him. He manipulated the government into not allowing alcohol to be sold so he not only monopolized the oil business he made it to where there was no other alternative to standard oil. Lastly he spied on these other oil companies to find out what kind of competition he had.
The Growth of America America’s industrialization did not just happen on its own. Many workers and business people contributed to the growth of America ,but three men made significant impacts. These three men were Cornelius Vanderbilt, John D. Rockefeller and Andrew Carnegie. Vanderbilt led to the expansion of the railroad industry. Rockefeller led the advancement of oil refining and Carnegie progressed the way steel was manufactured.
Andrew Carnegie, one of the best businessmen in all of american history. Most consider Carnegie as a robber baron but I disagree. I say that Andrew Carnegie was in the place of a captain of industry. Carnegie was a captain of industry because he was the world's richest business man that came from a poor shoemaker house in scotland and once he sold away his massive company he turned to the people and became a philanthropists.
John D Rockefeller becomes one of the most influential and notorious men of the Gilded Age through his ambitious attitude. He ushered in a new way of economics for America. He is one of the most famous robber barons because of his outstanding business strategies in oil. He is very successful and “by the early 1880s controlled some 90 percent of U.S. refineries and pipelines.” (1) John D Rockefeller becomes one of the most famous men of his time through his advancements in money and oil.
George Eastman, John Rockefeller, and Andrew Carnegie were all Captains of Industry. They were all philanthropists, which mean they donated a lot of money. George Eastman donated over 50 million dollars to dental, medical, and technology. Andrew Carnegie donated more than 475 million dollars to public education, museums, concert halls, technology, and benefactions after death. John Rockefeller donated more 410 million dollars to medical, education, and academic salaries.
Carnegie and Rockefeller: Captains of Industry Money makes the world go around. As cliché as that may sound, it's accurate. Wealth and social class are both two concepts that are built into society that surround the initial title of money. Two people that were both ranked very high socially and were both very wealthy, were Andrew Carnegie and John D. Rockefeller.
In the late 19th century, the United States of America was growing rapidly, especially with the rise of industrial businesses and corporations. Some of the most popular figures that contributed to this growth were John D. RockRockefeller, Henry Ford, JP Morgan and Andrew Carnegie. These multi-millionaire tycoons gained wealth and fame during the “Gilded Age” by contributing to industrialization and the improvement of America as a whole. Although these individuals, and many more are typically known for their support and creation of the industrial revolution, were they “Robber Barons” or were they productive managers of the emerging growth of America?
The business leaders of the Industrial Age were both robber barons and philanthropists, but were considered philanthropists because of how they positively impacted the U.S during this time. Some business leaders at times took money and treated their workers poorly which was considered being a robber baron. However, they also made large donations and invented many great things we still use today which makes the business leaders of the Industrial Age philanthropists. Andrew Carnegie was one of the business leaders of the Industrial Age. Carnegie did do things that made him a robber baron at times.
J.P. Morgan, John D. Rockefeller, and Andrew Carnegie were great inventors of their time but they did things that made them Robber Barons. One large reason why they are a robber baron is that they wanted to get more money without caring for anybody working for him or working with their companies. J.P. Morgan was criticized for manipulating the financial system in order to make more money for himself. J.P. Morgan made a successful bank that is one of the leading banks today, CHASE. John D. Rockefeller made his money by creating an oil business.
Andrew Carnegie had a significant effect on the Industrial Revolution. The Industrial Revolution is the development of factories and the mass production of consumer goods, in this case, Carnigies steel. The Industrial Revolution set the economic foundation that allowed Andrew Carnegie to construct his monopoly called Carnegie Steel. Some argue that Andrew Carnegie was a Robber Barron because he didn’t do anything about the dangerous work conditions but the evidence supports that he was a captain of industry because he was a philanthropist and rose from a rags-to-riches storyline. Andrew Carnegie had such a powerful influence on the world and his steel-making establishment is still around today.
Rockefeller has made an impact on the industrial revolution by changing and monopolizing the oil industry to bigger and better ideas. His funding to major organizations and schools, and motivation towards younger generations to push forward with his
John D. Rockefeller was the founder of the Oil company. Andrew Carnegie was the founder of the Steel company. Also, J.P. Morgan was an financier and banker of a corporation. Then Cornelius Vanderbilt was a steamship operator and then he focused in building railroads for
John D. Rockefeller and Andrew Carnegie were abundantly similar when it came to traits that made them sucessful in business endeavors. They both rose from extreme povery and disadvantage as children. Limitations did not exist when it came to their inner core of ruthlessness exhibited at times against their competitors and even their employees. They took complete control of every detail of their business and ran it with a prerogative to control a large part of the American economy.