Similarities Between Quebec And Quebec's Political Culture
POG 310 - TAKE HOME ESSAY
COMPARING ALBERTA’S AND QUEBEC’S POLITICAL CULTURE
PREPARED FOR PROFESSOR C.FANELLI
BY IAN HERNANDEZ
RYERSON UNIVERSITY
DECEMBER 14TH, 2015
INTRODUCTION
Political culture in Quebec and Alberta is often seen as monolithic, the former being nationalistic and the latter conservative. This is an understandable view given the dominance of these ideologies in these provinces. However, this view is also problematic because it holds that political change is stagnant and that these ideologies will continue to dominate long into the future. It also suggests that different political ideology is not popular among the citizens of Quebec and Alberta. Nevertheless, important questions are
…show more content…
Often a struggle between Quebec's liberals and nationalists who want a sovereign Quebec- led to a dynamic and interesting political culture in Quebec. Though a battle of Federalists and Nationalists was prevalent in much of Quebec, ignoring other factors identity politics does not explain its culture adequately. However, given that Nationalism played an important role in forming the political culture of Quebec- the factors leading to this tide of nationalism must be examined. Political tension rose to an all-time high, with the assassination of a minister in 1970 by nationalist terrorists, we will examine how the political elites created and exacerbated this tension (Heintzmen, 1983). Nationalism was a prevalent ideology, as the populist Bloc Quebecois gained significant traction by promoting the idea of independent identity from the rest of Canada (Heintzmen, 1983). With the growing frustration among Quebecois of the Languages Act of 1969 and other forces, Bloc Quebecois was able to leverage this growing frustration among the public to promote their political cause (Heintzmen, 1983). Nationalism during the Quiet Revolution was rather prominent, though the liberals held power in the 1960s- Maurice Duplessis orchestrated the support of saving the French culture, which was very appealing to the rural base (Heintzmen, 1983). At the time, the social culture of “French-Canadian Nation” was characterized by Christian tradition- in other words it reflected conservative nationalism (Heintzmen, 1983). The Quiet Revolution, however, slowly emerged to end the nationalists grip on social institutions resulting in significant social and political cultural
Summary Of Polarization And Pluralism By Bibby
61 Words | 1 PagesIn Chapter 4, “Polarization and Pluralism” Bibby’s focus is on how problems may come about when extremists of different natures, some being very religious from others being not the slightest bit religious, come together in Canada. He concludes at the end of the chapter that this balance, this polarization within Canada may actually be good for our own unique country (p.97).
Lesage Quebec Capacity Case Study
203 Words | 1 PagesIn order to improve the socio-economic level of French-Canadians, Lesage’s chief aim was the modernization of Quebec (Babich & Béland, 2009, p. 264; Pious, 1973, p. 56). The Lesage government initiated many institutional reforms in the zones of education, health, and social welfare (Gossage & Little, 2012, p. 233). For instance, in 1961, Paul Gérin-Lajoie, minister for youth, revealed an increase in the age for compulsory school attendance from fourteen to fifteen and a plan to supply free textbooks to all students (Gossage & Little, 2012, p. 233). Furthermore, Quebec also took over health care from the Church, making Quebec the only province to decline the national pension plan in order to form the Quebec Pension Plan. As a result, the Lesage
Changing Anglo-Quebecer Self Consciousness Summary
738 Words | 3 PagesIn the text, “Changing Anglo-Quebecer Self Consciousness,” the author, Michael Stein, questions the transformations of political consciousness among English-speaking Quebecers, since the election of the Parti Québécois government in 1976. Early on, key concepts emerge where the author defines the terms “anglophone” and “non-francophone Quebecer” which are mutually used. However, Stein makes a clear differentiation between those who are virtually English-speaking, inclusive of Anglo-Celts, Jews, Germans and other early immigrant arrivals, and those who nevertheless generally utilize their language of origin such as the more recent Italian, Greek, and Portuguese immigrants. Furthermore, the main objective of the text is to bring attention to the often disregarded yet ongoing psychological changes of
John Diefenbaker As An Effective Leader
1132 Words | 5 PagesCountries and states all over the world have diverse groups of leaders who serve in different parties. The leaders make different political decisions that governs the citizens of the given country or state. Canada has been governed by various leaders among them being John Diefenbaker, who served in the position of prime minister. This essay will provide various information of John Diefenbaker in relation to biography, analysis of the political career and personal evaluation in relation to John Diefenbaker’s leadership. John George Diefenbaker was born on September18, 1895, in Ontario at a place called Neustadt and was a child to William.
How Did Quebec Nationalism Influence Canadian Politics
1025 Words | 5 PagesINTRO While invoking a somewhat contentious relationship with the Federal and Quebec government, Quebec nationalism has shaped the dynamics of Canadian politics. Through a discussion of several historical events, Canadian politics have been influenced by Quebec nationalism. In this paper, I will argue how various significant changes to the constitution, the restructure of the Federal government from centralized to decentralized, and influencing policies that ultimately made Quebec a distinct society in Quebec. TOPIC 1 Since Canada is a federal state, the constitution assigns separate jurisdictions to the Federal Government and to the 10 provinces. These provincial governments have constitutionally recognized authority to enact laws in their
Essay On April Accord
1182 Words | 5 PagesThe tension between provincial and federal government is a continual struggle for power in Canadian politics. On April 16th, 1981, the highly debated April Accord was signed by the Gang of 8 and proposed to Trudeau as an amending formula for the Constitution. On the surface, it appeared to demonstrate a united front within the provinces in the Gang of 8. However, there is much controversy over whether the accord was an authentic solution to the amending formula or a way to stall negotiations since Trudeau would not approve it. Thus, the April Accord represents the political tension between the Gang of 8 and Prime Minister Trudeau.
The Pros And Cons Of The Unity Of British North America
795 Words | 4 PagesThe uniting of the British colonies to form Canada was an event of great uncertainty as the opinions on the topic drastically differed. Although the settlers had similar beginnings in the lands, they now called home, the differences of culture, language and customs remained. The proximity of the lands did not translate in the people. Issues with the Canadian identity still exist which is evident in the strong views of many that live in Quebec. It can be argued that placing varying groups of people in the same nation can be cause for divide and may weaken feelings of nationalism.
Assess The Reasons Why The Conservatives Lose Power
876 Words | 4 Pages“Trudeaumania swept across Canada…for a few warm spring months in 1968 Pierre Elliot Trudeau synthesized the dreams, achievements, and illusions of the liberation era.” (Fellows and Wells, 2013). Trudeau ran under the slogan of creating “the Just Society” (Fellows and Wells, 2013) in Canada, and unlike Diefenbaker, Trudeau would manage to achieve what he promised the public. While Trudeau was in office he managed to implement reforms that expanded welfare, enabled parliament to be more efficient, and established true universal healthcare in Canada (Fellows and Wells, 2013) . All of these changes and reform were things that others had promised previous to Trudeau but constantly failed to
Essay On Quebec's Secession
1912 Words | 8 PagesQuebec’s secession from Canada has been driven by many factors such as the provinces’s belief in a distinct identity, lack of representation in politics and the isolation of Quebec’s culture and language from the rest of Canada. These beliefs are valid but, realistically a secession from Canada will cause economic destruction within the province. It has been reported that the province of Quebec has little economic backing in trade to finance a legitimate government in international politics. Also, issues concerning international trade and negotiations will become difficult to deal with as economic stability will not be immediately guaranteed. In addition to that, all the chaos from these problems will inevitably lead to Quebec’s citizens
The Quiet Revolution: A Period Of Change In Quebec's Politics And Society
982 Words | 4 PagesThe Quiet Revolution prompted Lester B. Pearson to establish the Royal Commission on Bilingualism and Biculturalism. It suggested making English and French the official languages of Canada in 1969, a colossal victory for Lesage and his allies, although they were no longer in power. The Lesage
Bloc Quebecois Argument Essay
1122 Words | 5 PagesIn many countries, conflict between different groups of people is inevitable. In Canada, the divide between English-speaking and French-speaking regions has been a prominent political and cultural topic since the birth of the nation. The most well known of these conflicts goes to Quebec. The province has sprouted several movements and parties supporting the autonomy and independence of Quebec. One of those parties is the Bloc Quebecois.
The Impact Of The Quiet Revolution
821 Words | 4 PagesTo call this era of drastic change the ‘Quiet Revolution’ is a vivid, and yet, paradoxical description. The Quiet Revolution was a time of intense socio-political and socio-cultural change in Quebec, which extended beyond Quebec’s borders because of its influence on contemporary Canadian politics. As a result of the effects of the changes that occurred during this Quiet Revolution, most Quebec provincial governments since the early 1960s have maintained political and social orientations based on the core concepts developed and implemented during the Quiet Revolution. As such, there is no doubt that the Quiet Revolution had a significant impact in Canadian History. This impact can be characterized by the prelude to the Quiet Revolution; the demographic evolution of Quebec; the social educational reforms that were put in place; the economic reforms and their impact; the rise of nationalism; and finally, the cultural changes that occurred.
Pierre Trudeau Federalism
1515 Words | 7 PagesInstitutional and historical analysis often portray the motives of governments, especially in the cases of Quebec separatism and Aboriginal mistreatment. History describes attempts at compromise to rectify the problems by altering political institutions to provide more autonomy to the provinces, witness in various accords and the methods described previously. However, in regards to Aboriginals a historical relationship of exploitation and eradication sheds on the systemic issues that Aboriginals cope with and the institutions that caused them. As scholars of Canadian politics, it is important to consider historical and institutional analyses when looking at any issue, as it reveals the underlying motives of actors in regards to the cleavages that comprise a state.
Social Welfare In Canada
835 Words | 4 PagesSocial Welfare Policy and Child Protection – Strength and Limitations Since last two decades Canada being experienced softer and harder forms of neo-liberal economic impetus (McKeen, 2006). Many of these reforms targeted social benefits and divided marginalized people into deserved and undeserved category (McKeen, 2006). At a large level, social policies are shaped by the exploration of dominant ideas about a social issue. Existing political views and the interest of the dominant policy community are predominantly influencing policy making (McKeen, 2006). The mainstream discourses for solutions of social problems and policy outcomes are increasingly underrepresented and narrow down the focus of social welfare in Canada (McKeen, 2006).
Essay On Canadian Culture
1575 Words | 7 PagesIntroduction: When we think about culture, we automatically associate it with all of the stereotypes that are known. However, many of us never actually take the effort to find out the true culture of a place, which is why when we go to other countries we are clueless as to the culture and its practices. I believe that it is important to learn about the culture and any relevant information about a country before going there, which is why I have decided to look into the culture of the country Canada and its social practices. The country of Canada is in the continent of North America and it is well known for the friendly culture and open minded citizens.
More about Similarities Between Quebec And Quebec's Political Culture
Summary Of Polarization And Pluralism By Bibby
61 Words | 1 PagesLesage Quebec Capacity Case Study
203 Words | 1 PagesChanging Anglo-Quebecer Self Consciousness Summary
738 Words | 3 PagesJohn Diefenbaker As An Effective Leader
1132 Words | 5 PagesHow Did Quebec Nationalism Influence Canadian Politics
1025 Words | 5 PagesEssay On April Accord
1182 Words | 5 PagesThe Pros And Cons Of The Unity Of British North America
795 Words | 4 PagesAssess The Reasons Why The Conservatives Lose Power
876 Words | 4 PagesEssay On Quebec's Secession
1912 Words | 8 PagesThe Quiet Revolution: A Period Of Change In Quebec's Politics And Society
982 Words | 4 PagesBloc Quebecois Argument Essay
1122 Words | 5 PagesThe Impact Of The Quiet Revolution
821 Words | 4 PagesPierre Trudeau Federalism
1515 Words | 7 PagesSocial Welfare In Canada
835 Words | 4 PagesEssay On Canadian Culture
1575 Words | 7 Pages