In the dystopian short stories “The Lottery” by Shirley Jackson, and “Harrison Bergeron” by Kurt Vonnegut Jr. both display a society that strives to make a better system, yet the participants are blind to the moral flaws that they are constructed against. While “The Lottery” strives for population control, the means of achieving it comes at the cost of a life. However “Harrison Bergeron” is the most effective in achieving equality because it attempts to make all citizens equal , and by using the ''handicap'' approach it permits society to function on a level that allows each individual to be treated the same regardless of what other qualities they may have. To begin, in “Harrison Bergeron” the society was based on fairness because anything …show more content…
He did it in such a way that limited other people, but by using this approach he was able to put everyone on the same level. The philosophy in “Harrison Bergeron” was to to make everyone equal, however our society is corrupt and demands control over the stronger people in order to bring them down. “the minute people start cheating on laws, what do you think happens to society?”(233). This is referring to the limitations on how the society is forced to take control in order to be equal, if we disobey the law we have consequences and society falls apart. “Harrison Bergeron” methods of unfairness shows inequalities towards the control over the persons persona throughout the story. By showing how corruption in a dystopian society can be affected towards power becoming unequal and directed towards one person in a society . Having the power to do what you want makes a dystopian society suffer in unfairness towards the individual. For example, Harrison Bergeron wanted to diverge from tradition yet when he tried he was killed for his efforts. Thus, Vonnegut understands how authority and control can be a part of a dystopian society because people rebel against society to make the structure fair and to take initiative in controlling the individual …show more content…
The society was able to successfully make everyone unified not defining them by money or looks. Vonnegut's perspective was based on equality because being unique is hated throughout the story. For example, the ballerina can be seen as a reference of perfection, they use a mask to disguise their beauty to make everyone equal in their world “and their faces were masked, so that no one, seeing a free and graceful gesture or a pretty face ,would feel like something the cat drug in.”(vonnegut232). This clearly states how beautiful people have to wear hideous mask to cover their perfections because society doesn't permit taking an unfair advantage. The same goes for George even though we don't know his appearance we know he was an intellectual person because he falls into the same category of being born with a great mind. “and George, while his intelligence was way above normal, had a little mental handicap radio in his ear.”(232). His thoughts were being disrupted through a device , this is considered to be fair to the average thinkers. Vonnegut Jr. portrays his ideas towards the illusion of equality because he mentions equality at the beginning of the story, explaining the wonders of everyone being equal in their own individuality. A society based on equality is able to place people on the same pedestal, thus this method
What do going out to eat at the same restaurant every saturday at the same time, going to a specific family member’s house over the holidays every year, and always staying up to watch the ball drop on New Year’s all have in common? They are all traditions. People have many mixed opinions on traditions in general. Nowadays authors often use fictional stories to convey their opinions on traditions. There are many ancient traditions that our society practices today.
To begin with, both "Harrison Bergeron" and "The Lottery" portray blind conformities through the use of harsh methods to keep order with society. In the story "Harrison Bergeron", the character Harrison, a 14 year old child, was depicted to be better superior than others and for this reason was given hundreds of pounds of extra weight to his body in order to keep him equal to everyone else, " In the race of life, Harrison carried three hundred pounds" (Vonnegut 2). Society believed that there should be a law that suppresses Harrison as this would make it fair for everyone. Harrison, like all other members of the society, was not allowed to take off any of the handicaps given or they would pay the consequences of, "Two years in prison and two thousand
To imagine a world where everyone's intelligence is alike is quite worrisome. The character known as George is introduced as a remarkably intelligent and strong man, however he is
There are so many similarities and differences between the stories "Harrison Bergeron" and "The Lottery". But basically, in "Harrison Bergeron" everyone is equal, nobody is smarter than anybody else, nobody is better looking than anybody else, and nobody is stronger or quicker than anybody else. This is because everybody wears handicaps to make everyone equal to each other. But basically, one boy named Harrison Bergeron takes matters into his own hands and goes against the government. The government basically makes all these people wear their handicaps all the time.
"The Lottery" shows this by showing how people follow traditions without thinking about the consequences or leaving the tradition in the past and when one leaves the tradition they are viewed as a "pack of young fools" (Jackson, 32). Jackson is critiquing society and how they do not like to think for themselves till it is too late. Tessie Hutchinson did not question the lottery till it was involved in her family's life and then her life, then it was too late to think for herself. " Harrison Bergeron" depicts this in a different way, by showing what the world would be like if society did not question the government. Everyone is like everyone else, and when a person is not, the government gives them handicaps so they are not different, this causes them unable to think for themselves or take "unfair advantage to their brains" (Vonnegut, 3).
The depiction of each character and the handicaps placed on them uncovers the harsh contrast between Harrison and the citizens of his society, while simultaneously exposing the actual inequalities of the society. George Bergeron, having a higher
However, people do not have to conform to the standards set by society. In Harrison Bergeron by Kurt Vonnegut, society forced people to be alike, in every way possible. No one person better than another. However, it shows that handicapping those who have excelled in an area of life or have greater ability than another is an injustice.
Equality is a great idea that we should strive for and achieve; however, being made equal physically and mentally by the government could be very unfair. People should still have characteristics that make us different. One can be diverse but still equal to his neighbor. Kurt Vonnegut Jr.’s use of point of view, conflict, and imagery in his short story “Harrison Bergeron,” illustrates how difficult living in a world where everyone is the same would be.
Society is supposed to be a tranquil environment, instead it is portrayed as a controlling one that dictates the life of individuals in society. Individuals who have much greater potential in life are suppressed from moving on, because of the stereotypes society places on them in order to keep everything ‘equal’. In the short stories “The Lottery” by Shirley Jackson and “Harrison Bergeron” by Kurt Vonnegut, Society places stereotypes onto the characters inhibiting them from being modernly civilized. Which leads them to criticize each other and blindly follow rules. This can be shown through the different types of characters and symbolism.
The Lottery and Harrison Bergeron, both share common themes and differences in their stories. One would be that both societies claim theses “traditions give them unity and equality”. Another theme commonly shared is both stories show how people can be blind to tradition. Although these stories are similar they have their differences one being Harrison Bergeron tried dyeing like a martyr while Ms. Hutchinson died trying to save her own life. In both of theses stories society believes that their barbaric traditions bring them equality and unity.
In the short story, “Harrison Bergeron” Kurt Vonnegut, Jr. relies on the use of irony to indicate where our country will stand once we have gained total equality amongst each other. The theme in “Harrison Bergeron” is that the government cannot enforce equality within the people. The author creates a fictional visualization of the future in the year 2081, where the government controls the people and tortures them in order to maintain “equal opportunity” in their world to prove why it is impossible to achieve absolute equality in the world. Vonnegut dives into a whole other level of uniformity in Harrison Bergeron by focusing on eliminating advantages in appearance, intelligence, strength, and other unique abilities rather than focusing on
Dystopia is a made up futuristic society that is unpleasant to most citizens living there. The society can be a place where rulers dehumanize the citizens living there. A dystopia can be a place that is filled with disaster or it can be a place where everything is in such proper order that it becomes too perfect. A utopia is a picture perfect place. A utopia can become a dystopia in the blink of an eye.
What society may consider normal and moral may in fact be immoral and wrongful to humanity. The stories “Harrison Bergeron” by Kurt Vonnegut, “The Lottery” by Shirley Jackson and The Hunger Games directed by Gary Ross collectively deal with people who live in seemingly dystopian civilizations and how they deal with their situation. “Harrison Bergeron” is the story of a future United States where citizens are forced to wear handicaps to be equal or face dire consequences. “The Lottery” tells of the annual lottery in a small town where the villagers sacrifice one of their own. The Hunger Games has twelve districts send children to fight in the Capitol’s Hunger Games .The
No matter how many handicaps you put on someone they aren’t going to change. It’s kind of like trying to cover up beauty with a mask or make-up. Handicaps have no value in making anyone equal. Although equality is needed, no one in “Harrison Bergeron” is solely based on appearance and how smart you are. Equality is treating everyone one with the same amount of respect so therefore, no one in this short story is
The story “Harrison Bergeron” by Kurt Vonnegut is about a couple, Hazel and George Bergeron, in the distant future when all people must be equal. This equality is reached in the form of handicaps. Weights are placed on the strong and athletic people in society, masks are forced upon the beautiful, and loud noises are constantly blasted into the ears of the intelligent to prevent them from thinking. While most equality is often thought of as good, the story shows a much darker side, using the government’s forceful equalization of the people. “Harrison Bergeron” uses multiple perspectives to highlight the costs of equality paralleled in today’s society.