TITLE Jenna Stokes What makes a movie transformative? The medium of filmmaking is advantageous in many ways – from the striking capabilities of visual effects and camera work to its capacity for emotional connection with an audience. However, even the most casual moviegoer can attest the qualitative difference between movies meant simply to entertain and those seeking to reflect society on a deeper level examining elements of the human condition. Both To Kill A Mockingbird, directed by Robert Mulligan, and Do the Right Thing, directed by Spike Lee, are transformative movies that center on small American communities illustrating the damaging effects of racism in society and analyzing the moral character of America’s citizens and justice …show more content…
To Kill a Mockingbird is a coming-of-age story that mainly details Scout and Jem’s interactions and maturing perspectives on the world around them. As a result, the African American community has relatively little screen time in the story and Tom’s death is communicated to the audience through Atticus’ reaction to it. Given the movie’s broad audience and morally optimistic thematic message the decision not to include Tom’s likely graphic death is understandable. The close up of Gregory Peck’s devastated face as he hears the news is emotionally compelling and after the audience has spent 32 minutes watching Tom’s legal trial, their knowledge of its injustice serves to further intensify the scene. However, the scene is ultimately a white man reacting to a black person’s death and the storyline is rooted in Scout and Jem’s perspective as members of Maycomb’s white community. The African American community by comparison is distanced from the town through Jim Crow era policies like segregated seating and the only glimpse the audience gets of their reaction to Tom’s death is when Atticus tells Tom’s …show more content…
After Bob Ewell attacks Scout and Jem, the Sheriff plainly identifies Ewell as being responsible for Tom’s death describing it as happening for “no reason”. To Kill a Mockingbird repeatedly points to Bob Ewell as a racist and deeply unkind man yet fails to apply that same level of moral questioning to the other townspeople. Even after hearing articulate evidence proving Tom’s innocence, the people of the jury - having assumedly racist beliefs - still convict him. Preserving the movie’s optimistic outlook on the moral integrity of society, this injustice and the role of Maycomb’s residents in it is never fully addressed as the scene quickly shifts to Tom’s death. To Kill a Mockingbird wants audiences to believe in the integrity of man’s moral character highlighting the Sheriff’s condemnation of Ewell and subsequent protection of Boo Radley and Atticus’ honorable defense of Tom. However, believing this optimistic view of society requires ignoring the approximately twelve people who sentenced Tom to prison – an action which directly led to his death - and the glaringly racist actions of the mob who attempted to lynch him earlier in the
Tom Robinson is caught kissing a white woman from Maycomb named Mayella Ewell. To prevent being frowned upon by the local citizens, she instead said that Tom Robinson raped her even though that was far from the truth. He’s taken into trial with the help of Atticus, and the case is unarguably one of the factors that help further the theme of innocence in Scout’s view. Atticus is determined to help Tom, even if it means that the citizens will turn against his own family because “killing a mockingbird is a sin.” As events progress, Scout is taught that discrimination solely because someone is “different” is
Firstly, the lynch mob at the jail never tests the whites fear of revelation. Hidden throughout the scene, Tom portrays a bone over which the white people fight rather than a true character. Furthermore, Atticus’s inability to see racism as a grand problem and look at the problem outside the community of Maycomb further shows his failure of empathy. A day later, at the trial, Atticus fails to prove that blacks and whites are interconnected, instead shows how the Ewells are disconnected. Subsequently, Atticus never calls on the jurors to empathize with Tom, alternatively, asks them to empathize with himself, and sympathize with Tom.
Even when the evidence overwhelmingly supports Tom Robinson’s innocence, the jury’s bias towards blacks convicts Tom as guilty and is the reason for his eventual death. However, Atticus’s strong efforts leads to a lengthy discussion about the verdict of Tom’s case, which creates hope for a turning point in Maycomb, where whites and blacks are treated equal, because no other trial involving a black person has taken this length of time. In summary, all the occurrences of injustice in To Kill a Mockingbird such as the trial of Tom Robinson are created by a group of people with the same immoral beliefs but can be fixed with strong determination
The deeper, more meaningful plot is the accusation of Tom Robinson, a black man. Tom Robinson is accused of raping Mayella Ewell. Although Tom is wrongly convicted and sentenced to death, The Ewells were not believed. After the trial, Bob Ewell wanted revenge on Atticus for exposing the truth during the trial. Bob Ewell then tries to kill Jem and Scout.
Not an old Uncle, but a strong young Negro man. No code mattered to her before she broke it, but it came crashing down on her afterwards.”(Lee 272). Therefore, Atticus proves to the court with the evidence that Tom was not Guilty and Mayella Ewell tried to kiss Tom, and when Bob Ewell saw this he beat her and blamed it on Tom Robinson. “Our courts have their faults, as does any human institution, but in this country our courts are the great levellers, and in our courts all men are created equal” (Lee 273-274). Instead the court does not want people to hate them so they say that Tom was guilty.
Even though Tom Robinson was innocent, Bob Ewell, who was white, still won the case. This hit the Finch’s hard because even though they hated the racial discrimination occurring, there was nothing more that Atticus could do to change the ways of Maycomb. While all of this was going on, Scout’s perspective shifted more to her father's beliefs instead of joining the mainstream cowardness of her
He explains how it is not fair to Tom that just because he is black, he is unjustly accused of something. Atticus understands and tries to point out the fact that if it was a white man in Tom’s position, the jury would have a different opinion on the situation. Atticus displays a prime example of how someone should try to achieve social justice, even when the situation is unfair. Also, while saying his statements, Atticus exclaims how Tom felt sorry for a white woman, Mayella, and that he had been forced to put his own word against two white people. Here, Atticus reinforces the thought of how this jury is unfair to Tom.
As said by Atticus,” I don’t know but they did it tonight and they’ll do it again and when they do it-seems that only children weep.” (213). Because Tom is judged guilty Atticus believes that the justice system is sometimes unfair and unethical, to colored people and it may continue that way for a long time.
During the trial of Tom Robinson, Atticus is the defending lawyer. He tries to turn the jury towards Bob Ewell the father of the rape victim. Atticus shows the jury that Mr. Ewell could have easily beat his daughter. The main idea that Atticus uses is that Tom Robinson didn’t hurt Mayella Ewell it was Bob Ewell. Although, at the end of the trial, Tom is found guilty and Bob Ewell grows a personal vendetta against Atticus.
Atticus is appointed a case by Judge Taylor to defend a black man named Tom Robinson who has been accused of raping a white girl named Mayella Ewell. Because of the racism and prejudice against black people, he believes that he will not win this case and could risk the life of Tom Robinson. Because of this case, Scout gets bullied by Francis about how his dad is defending a black man, Atticus later talks to Scout about how “[Tom Robinson] lives in [a] settlement behind the town dump….there’s been some high talk around the town to the effect that I shouldn’t do much about defending this man” (Lee 86). Atticus knows that something bad can happen to him if he were to defend Tom Robinson but still does so because he has the courage to do it. After the trial had ended, Atticus was waiting for news but he did not expect something so terrible and heartbreaking, Tom Robinson, unfortunately, died after being shot several times.
With their unbeknownst number of kids the Ewell brood, specifically Bob Ewell becomes jealous and outright angry that Atticus would oppose him in the court of law by representing Tom Robinson. Although against the odds Atticus feels empathetic towards the Ewells not necessarily Bob but instead for Mayella, he understands what she is being put through, Suffering through domestic abuse, and in court Atticus even goes so far as to state that he feels sorry for Mayella. To add to this he implies that the man truly guilty of beating Mayella is in the courtroom (Bob Ewell). This did nothing to calm Bob Ewell’s seething manner instead it only escalated it, and in an attempt to get back at atticus he tries to kill his children whom are saved by an unseen and unknown force which killed Mr. Ewell. The precursor towards this however was when Bob Ewell spit on Atticus but even through this Atticus was rational, he thought about it.
This quote shows how innocent Tom is because all he wants to do is go back to his three kids and wife. He almost made it over to freedom where he could try to get back to his family, but Tom didn't make it over. The guards say that Tom Robinson would have made it over the fence if he had two good arms, but while trying to escape Tom Robinson is shot seventeen times. Everyone Tom saw said he was so kindhearted and was always there or ready to give a helping hand if need be, and that truly does represent everything a Mockingbird stands for. Tom's death has such an impact on everyone that even Aunt Alexandra has empathy for a black man and that shows something.
Even with Atticus’ strong defense Tom is found guilty. The trial resonates deep within Scout, Jem, and Dill. They get to witness the unfairness in race and prejudice. The trial sticks with them as they mature as they continue to fond over Boo
Jem also opposes the town’s racism. He instead sees the incorrectness of the town in a logical standpoint. During the trial of Tom Robinson, Atticus brings up solid evidence that the attack was not from Tom, but her father Bob Ewell. Jem believes that there is no way that Tom would be declared guilty, he still believes that the town is not racist and thinks that the jury people will think logically about the case. “I peeked at Jem: his hands were white from gripping the balcony rail, and his shoulders jerked as if each “guilty” was a separate stab between them.”
Tom was a dead man the minute Mayella Ewell opened her mouth.” Scout understands that, despite evidence of the contrary, the white jury will believe a white person instead of a black person"(Champion). Even though Tom was innocent just because he wasn 't white he was set to die the moment he stepped into the courtroom. If people saw past his skin color and actually looked at the evidence. Tom would 've been a free man and wouldn 't have had to die.